Some friends took us here, mostly because they love "The Pink Stuff" (garlic salad dressing). While the salad is just iceberg, old school bacon bits, and a couple of slices of pepperoni, I have to say that with "The Pink Stuff" it was quite good. Our servers were very friendly. We did have to call them over a couple of times for drink refills but no biggie. I like the pizza sizes. The Prince is the smallest but you can also order the smaller lunch size (but pay a dinner price) in the evenings. I had the The Garden Supreme mini (Black olives, green pepper, mushrooms, red and white onion, artichoke hearts, roma tomatoes, feta and mozzarella). I really liked it but would have enjoyed a few more tomatoes. It did need a couple of sprinkles of red pepper. Others enjoyed The Hawaiian Jack (Canadian bacon, pineapple, green peppers, mushrooms and pepper jack cheese), and a build your own sausage and pepperoni. I loved the interior and it does feel like a neighborhood joint. read more

See all

Butcher block pizza was good, but cheese pizza and cheese bread were just ok. Decor is dated and service could have been better. Our waitress was also taking phone orders and dealing with pick up orders while it seemed like several other employees were just sitting around. It appeared that the staff wasn't sure who was responsible for which tables. read more

Came in for lunch. The food was very good and everyone working there was very friendly. We will definitely return

The pizza is so tasty and the crust is cooked just right. The original roundtable is similar to a supreme pizza but way better than most. The Alfredo slice and garlic bread is very flavorful! Service with a smile when I went into the restaurant. Delivery drivers as friendly as well. The ambiance is on old school pizza shop vibe. read more

Pizza Shoppe - Pizza Shoppe - Pizza Near Me - Bixby, Oklahoma

See all

Been going here for 10 years now and the workers are so nice and welcoming the food is amazing and the cheese is so good

Excellent tasting pizza & service! We had half Hawaiian Jack & Butcher Block. Ample toppings & cooked to perfection with a golden crust. read more

Pizza Shoppe - Half Hawaiian Jack & Butcher Block. Ample toppings & cooked to perfection with a golden crust. - Pizza Near Me - Bixby, Oklahoma

If you like the old Godfathers pizza you will love this place. Lots of toppings and cheese. Overall the best value in Bixby.

Great food , service and ambience. We call ahead and it's ready when we got there. Great prices. read more

Pizza Shoppe - Great pizza and great service - Pizza Near Me - Bixby, Oklahoma

We got the Roundtable supreme pizza with tons of toppings! Piping hot and so tasty! Just as good warmed up the next day!

The food was good service was good. They just need an adult to supervise young people running the place. Better lighting would be nice also

Had the lunch special, pizza with a salad and drink good value and love the pepperoni and sausage pizza. House salad a bit small. Friendly wait staff. I would go back. read more

We have always had a fondness for this place, it has been a favorite of ours for a long time. Whenever we find ourselves in the vicinity, we make sure to grab pizza from here. Even though we reside in Owasso, we willingly make the drive just to bring home their delicious pizza. The crust they serve is exceptional! Since my mom has celiac disease, she has to opt for the gluten-free crust. It's so good that whenever we offer to get her pizza from here, she always responds with an enthusiastic "yes". The service is consistently excellent, and all the staff members are incredibly friendly and accommodating. read more

Good deep pan pizza if you like that style. Cozy and warm with excellent service. The place could use an update as it's too dark colors read more

I'm a bit torn, the food was edible... it isn't like it used to be the crust is thinner than it used to be and the amount of cheese used seems to have been cut. If I was only rating it based on food it would probably a 3 star... but unfortunately it has a problem with service. My family had lunch there and aside from bringing use the food after taking out order we never saw our waitress again. Don't be me wrong she didn't get abducted by aliens because we could hear her and some other giggling and talking constantly in the kitchen. But it would have been nice to get a refill instead of having to get up and get it myself, yeah they had a sign that said the soda fountains weren't for customer use... but what are you going to do when the staff hides in the back? Oh and when we left we had to yell for someone to check us out because apparently they were having too much fun with their giggle fest to bother to have anyone up front... did I mention the girl working their with earbuds in? That's probably why we had to yell. Sorry but this was the most unprofessional staff I've seen in any restaurant... My kids liked to go there... but they will be finding a new place for pizza or learning to eat frozen pizza because I will not be treated like crap when it comes to service. read more

I'm giving this a 4 bc the pizza is really good. If I could rate the pizza and service/restaurant separately pizza would get a 5. Service and restaurant decor a 3. The service is literally "ok". Not good. Not bad. The decor is like something you see in a western on tv. Odd and outdated. The pizza however is possibly the best in the Tulsa area! Today we got a supreme and a Margherita pizza. Both were delicious and fresh. Super fresh ingredients on both! In summary, we enjoy it much more "to go" rather than "dine in"! read more

Pizza Shoppe - Exterior - Pizza Near Me - Bixby, Oklahoma

See all

Not my style of pizza. Pizza sauce was soupy and lacked flavor. The toppings fell off the pizza when serving and what ever toppings were left on the slice were drug of the pizza on the first bite and slapped my chin lol. Funny because it was hot AF. The best part was the crispy crust. The cheesy bread was loafed Texas toast piled with cheese. The bread was ok I guess. I'll stick with my go-to pizza place, Uncle Vinny's, in B.A. read more

Cassie is the best! She took great care of us at lunch. The Pizza Shoppe has good lunch specials with a variety of options at a reasonable price. read more

I recently got a pizza from here. My daughter is 7 years old. If I took her into our kitchen and said "Please make a pizza, sweetie", I have no doubt whatever she came up with would be better than what I bought from Pizza Shoppe. The place was staffed and run by indifferent teenagers and it showed. Don't get a pizza at/from this place. Let it die and be reborn as a better pizza place. The only way to go is up. read more

What are the thin crust Canadian bacon and pineapple. The pizza was great the service was great. I think we found our new pizza place

Good pizza. Nothing fancy, but good quality and good price. We order carry out often and it's always hot when we pick it up.

i've always loved pizza shoppe. you can customize your pizza any way that you want, which is great for me because i like less sauce and cheese with bacon on it. Service is always top notch. It's a comforting environment with soft lighting and music. Definitely suggest it! read more

This was our first visit ever to Pizza Shoppe in Bixby OK. We had heard good things from our neighbor so we wanted to try it. I walked in to get our to-go order and the first thing I noticed was how really warm it was in the P.S. Then, when I mentioned it was our first visit, the guy behind the counter said 'oh joy.' When I got home to eat, the pizza was stuck to the paper in the box (how does that happen?) so we had to 'pry' it off the bottom. Bad atmosphere. Bad service. Bad food. All of that equals adds to our first visit being our last visit. 6/1/24 read more

Pizza Shop is my husbands favorite. And he loves the pink sauce. When get pizza this has been our go to place. We like to order and pick it up. read more

Pizza was amazing, atmosphere was equally awesome. We ordered the cheese bread, the round table and pork sausage and mushroom pizza. Server was as sweet as could be and we will definitely be back! read more

Love this place. Just a little hole in the wall, but pizza is great. The crust reminds us of what saltines taste like - great on pizza. Toppings are laid down first and covered with lots of cheese. All I can say is try it and you will be hooked like my family. We've been eating here for years. read more

Pizza Shoppe - Sausage and pepperoni green pepper. - Pizza Near Me - Bixby, Oklahoma

Definitely a one-off restaurant. The food is good with a good selection of pizza and pasta dishes. Several of the servers are high-school kids, and while young are friendly and attentive. read more

We have been eating at Pizza Shoppe for over 20 years. The food is always delicious. Anytime we have delivery it is always hot and fresh. The Big Shoppe salad with Pink dressing is a must. read more

We got the Chicken Alfredo King pizza. This is our first visit and got take out. We all agreed that this is the best pizza we've eaten in years! Large amount of mozzarella which had a touch of chardonnay flavor. And a perfect blend of chicken breast, mushrooms and onions with a tasty alfredo sauce gave it an outstanding character. While we live 15-20 minutes away, the pizza was still hot when we got home. We were the major investors and owners of the best Tulsa gourmet pizza place in Tulsa County before a fire lead to its closure a few years ago. This was better than our Chicken Bacon Ranch, my previous favorite! And these prices are very competitive! We will be back! read more

The Pizza Shoppe is our family favorite. The cracker crust is really good. The melted cheese on top is stringy when you pull out a piece, and the sauce is so good. This is the best pizza for leftovers too. Put it in the toaster oven and it won't be dried out. The crust will be crispy all over again. We usually take a bottle of "Pink Stuff" home as well. read more

Pizza Shoppe - Cheezy outside, saucy in the middle. - Pizza Near Me - Bixby, Oklahoma

Love their pizza and "pink stuff " salad dressing. Service is always great! Also, it's always a bonus to support local businesses.

So glad I got to come in for a pie. Everyone was super friendly and I gotta day the pie was perfect. Big shout out to Elijah for killing it in the kitchen. Will definitely be consign back next Friday for pizza Friday. read more

I really wanted to like this place, and honestly, I've had worse. We did a call in and pick up, but unfortunately, their website links to their out of state locations and while close, is not completely accurate. The girl I spoke to on the phone was friendly enough, and the pizza was done in a timely manner, and as expected. Honestly, their crust is one that meets my personal preferences quite well. Meaning despite ample toppings, the entire crust stayed nice and crisp! Their unique style of placing the toppings under the crust was a good way to keep our toppings in place, but made it a little harder to tell which half of our pizza was which. To be fair, it isn't their fault we ordered a split pizza, so please take that just as something to keep in mind when ordering, not as a complaint by any means! Their cheesy garlic bread tasted ok, but is nothing to write home about. And their special pink garlic sauce was decent as well. Unfortunately, nothing really just blew me away, but their salad left me wanting. It's a simple iceberg salad with cheese, bacon bits, your choice of dressing, and a couple slices of pepperoni to top it off. The problem I had was finding about 1/2 cup's worth of brown pieces throughout. I picked out the pieces I didn't want, and it was fine otherwise, but that's what is keeping me to a more moderate ranking. Nothing so good I'm planing to go out of my way to get it again, but nothing so bad I'd never give them another try. To their credit, the pricing was very reasonable, and for what I paid, the food was right on the money! It was about $20 for a side salad, medium pizza, and order of cheesy garlic bread--pretty great on my wallet all things considered! read more

See all

Best pizza around for sure and some people say the price is too high but you are paying for quality and personally I really like the decor. I might be weird or a hipster or whatever but if you want amazing pizza, great service and a neat place to hang out read more

Terrible. Ordered a Hawaiian Pizza, queen size. It was $17! It had zero flavor. The customer service was so awful, too. The manager was running around the restaurant chasing her kids and employees were yelling across the restaurant at each other. Never going back. read more

sadly, this local bixby pizza place has great tasting pizza but it's way "over-priced".

I don't like any of the pizza places around Tulsa with the exception of NYC pizza. I just moved to Bixby and seen The Pizza Shoppe and thought I would give it a try. The first thing I liked was the cheese was on the top of the pizza. When I was a kid that is how they made pizza back then. By the way, I am 56 years old. It seems cheese on top is no longer the style. The crust was the next thing I noticed... nice crisp and chew. The first pizza I tried, original round top was tasty. I loved the fresh ingredients however, couldn't taste the pizza sauce much. The next day, I couldn't stop thinking about the pizza and had to go back. I ordered another one, the butcher block but this time I ordered it with marinara sauce instead of the pizza sauce. Now I could taste the sauce and it was much better. In the span of 2 weeks, I think I have visited the Pizza Shoppe 5 times lol. In summary about the best pizza around these parts but that is not saying much. read more

The exterior of the building is Modern Spanish Non-descript, but the interior screams 1967. If you are familiar with the West Coast's Round Table pizza chain, so is Pizza Shoppe. There is even a decorative suit of armor in the dining area. Awesome! The dining area is also larger than one would expect from the outside, and there is a HUGE banquet room with coin-op games. This is definitely the kind of place you go with your soccer team for the season-ender. I arrived near closing time, but the staff remained amiable and outgoing until slightly past closing time. In fact, the manager, who waited on my table, and kitchen workers were still chatty as I paid to leave. They certainly placed the customer first here. Pink sauce? The workers' uniforms advertise it; the front counter displays it for sale; and the menu has a nice blurp promoting it as well. Frankly, it tastes like French dressing, but it is a positively non-food grade of industrial, Pepto Bismol pink. My dining companion likened it to strawberry yogurt, but there is no description that would truly encapsulate pink sauce. It is a phenomenon that you just must try. As for the pies, Pizza Shoppe is generous with the cheese. You might consider a smaller pie than you are thinking. The specialty pies are slightly askew of the mainstream chains but not outlandish. They are probably the same combinations the chain has been serving for forty-five years and will continue ad infinitum. It ain't broke, folks. I was slightly disappointed with the garlic cheese bread which really is bread; it is mounds of cheese on slices of toast. I would have preferred more garlic. Mileage may vary. For the price, this place is tremendous. read more

We always enjoyed Pizza Shoppe when we lived in Kansas City, and were thrilled to discover the Bixby, OK location. This location appears to be family-run, and it feels good to support a family-run operation. The staff were tremendously friendly and attentive to all the guests that came through the door. Second, the pizza was a classic Pizza Shoppe offering! We had a large king pizza topped with pork sausage. The pizza was perfectly cooked and they did not skimp on the toppings. I suppose the only disappointment, however slight, would be the cheese bread. It appeared to be Texas toast topped with melted mozarella cheese. It is an appetizer that falls short in satisfaction compared to the top-notch pizza. It can be argued among pizza-goers that the decor is dated. While I would agree, I found it nostalgic and comforting. The decor at the Bixby location is very similar to the Kansas City location I frequented as a kid growing up. Knight's armor, midevel references, arcade games, red carpet, etc. I can just see me and my 5th grade basketball team sitting at a big table pigging out on pizza wearing our nut-hugger basketball shorts. Good times. All in all, a quality product served by a nice, hard-working family. When looking for a casual saturday lunch to satisfy a serious pizza craving, who could ask for more?. read more

I can't believe I had not reviewed sooner! I have been coming to Pizza Shoppe for at least a decade. I am not what you would call a pizza person, yeah I'll eat a slice if that's what everyone orders but I typically do not go out of my way for pizza, just not my jam. But Pizza Shoppe, well, they are exactly what I always want out of pizza and can only seem to get from them. Thin, crisp crust just the right amount of sauce and loaded with toppings. I don't think I have strayed much once I built my own pizza. I order the same thing every single time - Hamburger, Artichoke, and Black Olive pizza, house salad with the Pink Stuff, and a root beer. Every time. And I have NEVER been let down. My pizza is always fresh and flavorful. The salad, although yes, it is a simple iceberg lettuce salad with cheese, bacon bits, and pepperoni slices, hits the spot while you are waiting for you pizza to cook and when you top it off with their house dressing AKA the Pink Stuff (garlic dressing) it is awesome. I typically buy a bottle to take home so I can make it myself on those days I just can't make it to Bixby. The staff are always friendly and accommodating. I have never had a bad server. Although, primarily staffed by high school age kids, they are well trained and do a better job than I would have at that age. But hands down favorite employee would have to be Michelle. She is fantastic. Always remembers me and my mom when we visit and makes sure we feel welcomed and are taken care of. The decor is straight out of the movies. I grew up watching tv and movies that had pizza joints that looked just like this place and I was ecstatic to find this gem. I grow weary of slick and 'modern' decor. I mean how many times can you see the same type of restaurant put up the same "art" before you want to scream? I enjoy coming here whether it be on shopping trips with my mom or date nights with my husband. If you don't want good food, comfortable atmosphere, friendly service, and throwback decor then Pizza Shoppe is not the place for you. Otherwise seat yourself, enjoy the experience, and do yourself a favor... order the Pink Stuff! read more

The Pizza Shoppe is a great find for anyone who loves excellent pizza. There is something for everyone as the meat lovers, supreme, pepperoni and vegetarians all have options pleasing to your palates!!! I didn't try them but have heard from friends the salads are equally delicious. Even for the more adventurous, there is a marijuana dispensary next door so you could plan a whole evening without going far. The staff is kind and efficient and take pride in their clients happiness!!! read more