Oh, man! The pizza and deserts rock! We've been there twice, so far, and I can tell you it only gets better with each visit! The folks behind the counter are friendly, know their customers, and are always happy to see new faces and old. Isn't that everything you want from your local pizzería. We have carried out once and have eaten in once. Now that we know how friendly it is, it's our preference to eat at one of the tall tables. (They're right by the soda fountain so it's a big plus for me.) I'm so sorry we didn't discover it earlier. I think some folks were keeping a secret for themselves. read more

This is our pizza place we order from and the best tasting pizza we've been able to find in our area! The owner is so friendly and he cares so much about his business and works so hard. I see his social media posts and can tell how much he loves his pizza restaurant. Whether your ordering for dinner or just stopping by for a slice it's well worth it. read more

Not a bad slice of pizza. Service was great. It says restaurant. It isn't. It has 3 or 4 (2 person) high tops and it's pretty hot in there. read more

Amazing pizza and service each and every time! We did 1 XL cheese pizza, soda and an italiano sub. The sub and fries were HUGE! Everything was flavorful and cooked perfectly. We love the cheese to sauce ratio on the pizza. Best pizza in LOL! read more

Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Land O Lakes, Florida

Since I hail from the state of New Jersey, I was quite excited to find this small pizzeria out on route 41. I stopped in on a Sunday night about an hour before they closed and they had some slices available at the counter. Service was very fast, friendly and efficient. Prices are beyond fair. As for the pizza, I have to give it an eight out of 10. Crust has a wonderful flavor and is exactly like the Neapolitan pie. I grew up with in New Jersey. Cheese is good -- more than likely Grande. Slices are served, piping hot and with a smile. The sauce itself is very good slightly more salty than sweet. Considering that it was less than $10 for two slices and a bottle of water, I was happy considering the prices these days! It's a quiet small little place. Mostly take out business, but they do have a few small high top tables in the back. Great for a quick bite of pizza! read more

Pizza Pie - Two counter slices - Pizza Near Me - Land O Lakes, Florida

Pizza is delicious! I ask for crispy and no green peppers, add black olives, and the pizza is always perfect. Great place!

Avoid The Pizza Pie Buyer beware. Horrible experience with their new ordering app, run by Route Masters. Delivered to the wrong address. Didn't refund the delivery fee. The app service wasn't helpful and The Pizza Pie person who answered my call was rude and dismissive. Time to look for another place to spend my money. read more

ever ordered from an establishment selling "Philly Cheesesteak Pizza" or "Philly Cheesesteak subs" that didn't include green peppers and onions. Apparently, those are add ons here. Costs more for the pizza but you can add them for free on the sub. All of the photos on the menu, btw, showed them with green peppers and onions. I really don't care that their high prices don't include those, but they should at least have it in bold print that they're optional so our pizza and sub didn't suck the way they did. All that said, what we did receive was very good quality and flavor. Not sure we'll be back because of the man who answered the phone when I called to understand. He sounded like an older guy with a heavy accent. Just zero customer service sense. Very disappointing from that aspect. read more

Pie was ready as I walked in the door. Love the smells in the establishment. Very nice staff. Will be back and soon !!

The pizza was ready when I got there, and it was delicious! I will definitely go back to check out other menu options. Highly recommend!

So fortunate that this excellent pizza joint is right around the corner. The pizza is "NJ style". Full takeout menu of Italian entrees, cheesesteaks, calzones, and pizzas, pizza-by-the-slice, and desserts. Stopped by to pick up dinner for one. Owner Rosario and regular cashier (I must ask her name) are very friendly. My order was ready quickly and served with a smile. The place is clean. It was slow outside peak dinner hour, during dinner the joint and parking lot are packed. Be sure to order early on a Friday night. Took advantage of their $8 daily pasta special, which included choice of house or Caesar salad, choice of pasta entrée and sauce, and a roll. How could you beat that for eight dollars?! Ordered fettuccine alfredo and Caesar salad. Added a meatball to my order. Everything was still hot when I arrived home. Plated it up and enjoyed a homemade-tasting Italian dinner. Pizza Pie is a solid neighborhood pizzeria. It's worth a drive, too. It's by far the best pizza I've had since visiting family in Land O Lakes for the past 12 years. Thanks, Rosario. Yes, I'll be back... maybe again this week. Thanks, Rosario! read more

Pizza Pie - $8 daily pasta special: fettuccine alfredo and Caesar salad. Added a meatball. - Pizza Near Me - Land O Lakes, Florida

I don't know what happened. Loved this place tonight we placed an order for antipasto salad and pizza. Never have we had artichoke and zucchini along with smothered in balsamic vinegar. Almost like it had a Greek spin on the salad. The pizza was adequate but the wow wasn't there. I don't think we will be returning which is sad because that's our only option in the area. read more

Good variety of Italian food. Pizza was good. One of the best local pizza parlors but Tempano and Grimaldi is better.

I love this place. I tell everyone this is the best pizza in Tampa. I hope you guys expand your hours so it's available when I get a craving at 9pm... :) read more

WOW... So we decided to give the pizza pie a go and we are so glad we did. The food was absolutely perfect. We ordered the large cheese pizza and it was delicious. We ate until we couldn't move, the pizza sauce was amazing and the pizza had the perfect amount of cheese. While I waited for my pizza the owner or manager actually took the time to ask me a couple questions and was looking for feedback. The pizza took ten minutes and can't wait to eat here again. read more

Based on reviews I decided to give it a try and was not disappointed. Pretty much carry out only and packed on a Friday night. They know how to handle busy times and are totally organized for phone, online and food delivery service orders. Clean and friendly. I hung out for awhile waiting for the rain to slow. The pizza was outstanding. One of the best I've had in Tampa Bay. read more

Pizza Pie - 12" WORKS - Pizza Near Me - Land O Lakes, Florida

This is not a dining place so no reservations. Misleading if you are looking for a place to sit down with the family.

Great quality Italian food. Their pizza is amazing. Nice thin crust Jersey style pizza. Their spaghetti and meatballs is also top tier. The meatballs are very good and the tomato sauce mannnn it's good. read more

I haven't tried everything, but so far, the pasta dishes are where it's at. Quality and quantity is on par read more

Pizza Pie - Menu as of 12/2024 - Pizza Near Me - Land O Lakes, Florida

As a New Jersey Native , I close my eyes and take a bite to take a trip back home. From pizza , pasta (especially the lasagna) to the apps(wings,mozzarella sticks).and this has become my favorite place to get pizza. I would recommend to everyone read more

Best East Coast / Jersey style pizza in the area. I have tried the other local places but nothing beats Pizza Pie. Their sandwiches are great too! read more

Thank you, Pizza Pie, for being a staple in Connerton for my family to get great pizza and even better service always. We are grateful to have such a great place near us. read more

See all

We have really enjoyed our last few meals from here. Salads are great and the pasta shells are addictive. Chicken parm was awesome. So was the eggplant parm. This guy runs a local business he is proud of. read more

The food there, and the service is amazing! Definitely a Friday night delight for the family :)

Yum! I love pizza pie! I am a big lover of New York and New Jersey pizza and Pizza Pie never disappoints. Such a good place for pizza. The only thing that is a bit disappointing about this place is that the restaurant is very small and very hot inside. I never eat at the location and I always just pick up pizza but to be honest I'm not sure if you can eat inside. There are 2 very small tables that seat 2 people and I never see people eating there just waiting for their pizza pick up to be ready. Overall though, I recommend Pizza Pie for those seeking good New York/ New Jersey Pizza. read more

Being Italian from New Jersey especially a little boastful. It is very good. Referred this place very often to many friends who agree. read more

We were looking for good pizza after we moved here from the Chicago area. Deep dish pizza is for the tourist. Chicagoans eat thin crust cut into squares. Anyway, we ordered via phone a large sausage, 1/2 mushroom and onions, 1/2 pepperoni. It was a short drive so we picked it up. It was ready and hot and the staff was friendly. It smelled so good in the car, we couldn't wait to get home. The pizza did not disappoint as it was delicious. The cannolis were great too. We tried other places, but this is now our go to for pizza. read more

We ordered a large white pie with garlic sauce, a large sausage and mushroom pie, chicken cutlet Parmesan dinner and an egg plant Parmesan dinner with fresh green salad included. We all enjoyed the pizza, portions on the dinners were enough for two. Lemon cello cake . Tuesday deal extra large cheese pie $9.50. These guys are legit from New Jersey The pizza proved it to us. Glad you're here and want you to stay so we will be seeing you often. Small counter and a few tables to eat inside. read more

See all

Pizza is full of flavor and freshly made. Service is A+. But for those who must have gluten-free pizza- the cauliflower pizza is not gluten free. If it's just cooked on the same oven I never get a reaction, but digesting it I do. Anyone else...give this a try. Everyone in our group loved the freshness & flavor of the calzone and meat lovers. read more

never again! this is the second time that I have placed an order well in advance. When I arrive to pick up the pizza at the designated time my order hasn't even begun to be made. This time my husband picked up our order, when he arrived home (a 5 minute drive) the pizza was cold and very undercooked. I requested a crispy crust and what I received was the exact opposite. We have very few dining options in our area, this is why I gave Pizza Pie another chance. Very disappointed and a waste of money! read more

Best pizza around! We're from NJ & I can tell u it's definitely the best ur going to get in the area! Our community has ordered also for events at our clubhouse..from pizza, salad, pasta, eggplant parm, chicken parm & wings! Everything was hot & delicious. We certainly found a gem in our neighborhood! Thanks Rosario for bringing NJ to Florida! read more

Definitely best pizza in the area especially if you like a thinner style crust. Both the dough and sauce are very fresh. We love the pizza, calzones and Stromboli. Double check your order when you pick up as we have had a mix up where we've gotten someone else's order but food is always delicious. Love this place! read more

Killer pie! Knots were ok. Wings were pretty good. Star of the show was definitely the pie. Delicious.

Great lil pizza shop with the nicest people! The pizza and stuffed shells are yummy! Super fast as well.

I am From philly. This is the best pizza I've had since I have left Philly and even at least as good as my favorite pizza place in Philly. Everything is made with love the old fashion Italian way .Rosario, the owner, and his wife keep this a mom and Pop basic ingredient wonderful Italian joint read more

The pizza from Pizza Pie is fantastic. They advertise authentic NJ pizza and it's better than a lot of pizza from NJ. The calzones and Stromboli are also great. I'm so happy I found this place. Ordering is easy, the staff is always friendly and the pies are ready when promised. The Tuesday pizza special is a great deal. read more

Very nice people owns that joint,really good pizza and a lot more to choose from,all of it is great

Stromboli was delicious I got extra cheese, ham, and black olives. It was huge enough for two meals. I used Uber Eats arrived perfectly great pricing and value! So glad we have a decent a non chain family owned real pizza place! I will be ordering from Pizza Pie again. The sauce was amazing. read more

Pizza Pie - Stromboli with ham, black olives, and extra cheese. The sauce was perfect! - Pizza Near Me - Land O Lakes, Florida

We just ordered for the first time and couldn't be happier with the food. We gave up on good pizza once we left New Jersey 10 years ago. We are Italian and from NJ so we can appreciate a good pizza and this place is lt. The pizza crust is thin and delicious and they obviously use quality products because you can taste them in the pie. I finally found a Jersey pie in Florida!! read more

Was in the area and a customer told me about this new pizza place that opened. Went in and saw "Jersey style" and thought oh boy here's another one. But wow the pizza is really good and definitely Jersey/New York style. I got a white pizza that had spinach, diced tomatoes and garlic on it and a regular cheese slice and both were good, gonna come back here and try one of their platters. There's five high top seating and no booth seating. It's a mostly take out only and definitely worth it. read more

See all