Had another great meal! Tried pepperoni, gyro, and Philly…read morecheesesteak (you can do 1/2s). The cheesy garlic bread is ridiculous! And the fettuccini Alfredo was so good, two others were eating off my plate) Service was super friendly and fantastic and prompt. And.... Gluten Free Options Gluten free crust options; 12" regular flavor and 10" Cauliflower. Award winning gluten free Key Lime Pie! See you again soon.

Where Great Pizza Becomes Tradition…read more It's refreshing to find a restaurant that still does things the right way. Locally owned, welcoming, and focused on quality instead of shortcuts. The dough and sauces are made fresh in-house, the ingredients taste fresh, and the Wisconsin cheese really shines. Every pizza feels like it was made with care. Small-town restaurants like this deserve to be celebrated. It's locally owned, serves outstanding food, and clearly takes pride in every pizza.

By far the best pizza in the area - we've tried them all and its not close, will never get pizza…read morefrom anywhere else. The sauce is incredible, they dont skimp on their toppings, and if you order it a certain way like extra crispy, or other specific instructions, it shows up extra crispy and prepared the way you want it! Point being they care about what they do and what they send out the door. Massive kudos to the folks at Pizza Man - Please dont ever change!

The online ordering process was painful and laborious. Need to clean up your website and online…read moreordering process. Bought 2 large pizza pies and had them slice the pizza traditional cut. Some odd reason they like cut the pie up into scrabble sized pieces!

If your looking for an amazing restaurant with full rich incredible comfort food with sauce on top…read morethis is the hidden gem in Amery WI. Just down the sidewalk from a good bar and Main Street. The crunchy crust and wonderful flavor of this pizza will be historical in this town. I predict people will come from far and wide to get this pizza. Service was well, you're not getting your pizza until it's done and done correctly. The owner is a one man show. No staff. It's very efficient. You order online. You pick the time and date of your pickup then order ,and go get it. We had a party planned ordering this Monday. If you pick a time he makes sure your pizza is ready as you're coming in. I picked 6:15 and he was taking them out as I was walking in. Thank you D' Addarios Such a wonderful addition to a postcard town!

This place has unbelievable Detroit style pizza. It's definitely the best pizza I've had in Amery…read more Highly reccomend!

So I was quite excited to try this place here in my very small town. As a Yelp Elite squad member…read moreI base almost all of my decisions when trying new places on reviews. Especially during travel. I ordered takeout. Not sure if it was just a bad day or what, but when you are a bit spendy you should take extra care in maintaining good quality food in takeout as much as dining in. I ordered the New Glarus beer battered onion rings, They were soggy, if they had packaged these in brown paper bags this problem would have been greatly diminished as a former restaurant manager. For 9$ I had to come home and put them in the oven to make them crispy again. Also, being a Chicagoan I am a pizza freak. When claiming to be a brickfire pizza place, your crust should be crispy on the bottom yet still chewy. NOPE! It was boxed and sitting in a PILE of grease making my 14$ small pizza very soggy. Very disappointed and probably won't return. I'd rather drive far for good pizza for what I paid for at this establishment. ** update**. Tried to give this place another chance and what a waste of every penny. We figured instead of the pizza this time (being that it was the ONLY place open). We'd try the sandwiches. I'm a Chicagoan and so I went for the "Italian Roast Beef". Big mistake, it was dryer than a desert road and all Italian roast beef sandwiches originating from Chicago should be served "wet" or at least a little "wet". My son ordered the philly and it was just as bad after we had to sit and watch the server stand there and stare into space only to leave to come back with something to write with and STILL didn't give my son the sandwich we ordered so he had to wait. She said she would take it off the bill and she took off 4$..... NEVER again. Don't do it.

Excellent food great service and a short detour...from anywhere! Try the mushroom swiss!…read moreAlso your favorite beverage...bottle, tap, or mixed drinks available. Cheers!

Food was really good. Had a Fried fish fillet sandwich on a hoagie, came with hot chips. Others had…read morea patty melt and a hamburger. We ordered for takeout. Was hot and ready on time.

This place is great, try the rootbeer they have the best Spechers and they have a large menu they…read morealso do thin crust if you ask. Support local businesses!:)

Pizza and calzone were both excellent. The ice cream is quality as well. Will be going back again!read more

I couple days ago I went to Main Street pizza in star prairie Wisconsin. It's disgusting! When I…read morewent to the establishment was terrible. The employees looked tired and depressed, I'm pretty sure they were serving food on dirty plates, and there was multiple flys! I hate to be a "Karen" as people say now but when I worked in fast food back in the 80s and 90s it was 100x cleaner and more sanitary. If you want a clean place to eat DO NOT go to this establishment!

Great place to get Pizza and other food. The food is fresh and tastes homemade. Love the pizza…read moresauces. Ask for the special Premo sauce. I would recommend this to everyone. Don't forget your checkbook or cash. They do not take credit cards.

This place is a nice little gem in Scandia. We had two cheese pizza and tossed salad. Both were…read moregreat. The server and cashier were nice. There is some indoor seating and a picnic table outside. Many people do takeout too. It's very casual and with the takeout people coming and going it can be chaotic. If you need refined ambience, don't come here. If you want good pizza or maybe a root beer float, come on down.

We were visiting the area and stopped in at The Sawmill after a friend recommended the pizza. They…read moreare only open on Sunday afternoons to the public. The rest of the week is reset for private events. First, the venue is the perfect place to sit outside and enjoy the large property when the weather is nice. There are a couple of buildings with outdoor seating as well as indoor space for events. There is a large flat screen TV by the bar inside the main building if you would like to sit and enjoy a game, etc. They have outdoor live entertainment which was very nice to sit back and listen to the music. They also had a few yard games which people were enjoying. The website isn't quite up to date as it instructs you to bring your own picnic supplies, non alcoholic beverages, etc. as they just serve beer. However, they do provide paper plates and napkins a well as have a full bar including some wine and non alcoholic beverages for purchase. Sawmill had a set menu of a few thin crust pizza options as well as a handful of seasonal pizzas. No additional pizza toppings allowed but you can ask for a topping to be removed if you don't like it. Our group ordered a Pep Fest which is tomato sauce, pepperoni, co-jack and a Trippin' Balls which is tomato sauce, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, sausage, mozzarella. The pizza was okay. Toppings are limited. The pizzas are cooked in an outdoor wood fired pizza oven so we were expecting more of a crispy thin crust pizza. The pizza dough is not crispy but soft and doughy. Not exactly what we were expecting but the flavor was pretty good. Every employee we encountered was nice and everyone seemed to enjoy working there. It's a nice place to hang out, have a drink and enjoy the outdoors and live entertainment.

5 stars - definitely worth the stop if you're in the area!…read more I really enjoyed my first visit to Sawmill Pizza & Brew Shed. It's out in a rural area, quite a trek west of downtown Clear Lake. But they have plenty of signs directing the way. And "yes", back in the day, it used to be a real working sawmill. I was skeptical when my 2 Wisconsin friends invited me to hang out at Sawmill on a Sunday. Only open 1 day a week on Sundays? Only open from 2:30 to 7:00? Only 4 kinds of pizza? Yes, it's true! But it's great! The property is huge, many acres with tons of parking. They have multiple buildings, outdoor activities, a lake across the street, live music, pizza, beer, and soda. The whole atmosphere is like a super chill county fair - awesome! The custom pizzas are great too. They're all the same size - large. The pizza is neopolitan style & cooked in a brick fired oven. The flavor options are great. They're all, basically, giant gourmet Italian style pies. They can definitely compete with any fancy-dancy pizza joint in the Twin Cities (minus the snobbery). The beer options are excellent. They have a bunch of interesting craft beers on tap in addition to standard options in cans & bottles. Finally, this place is run like a clock. They're extremely well organized. Everyone is super friendly too. That goes for the staff as well as the guests. (No pets or outside alcohol allowed.) For those of you that may be interested, Sawmill does special events too. LOW CARB: It was a little tricky eating low carb, carnivore style at Sawmill. Basically, I picked the pizza with the most meat & the thickest toppings and I scraped all the toppings off the doughy crust. It worked fine. I ate all the toppings and none of the high carb dough. And I saved the crust for the family of noisy crows that visits me every morning. So everyone was happy...me, my buddies, and my feathered friends. A big thumbs up! -Maxx