This is a nice place to stop in for pizza. It's located on the main street in town. It's in an old…read morehouse with a deep porch for eating outside. Order at the counter and it is brought to the table. Our usual order is two 7 " pizzas and a side salad with drinks. Our pizza orders vary but all have been great. The crust is bubbly and crisp! Average cost is around 20.00

Terrible service. Waited over an hour for a 4" sandwich. Everyone else at our table had been…read morefinished eating for 20 minutes. They need to learn to balance their dine in and carry out.

The restaurant is cluttered by the front. Not very eye appealing. Otherwise it is ok looking. Our…read moresever was a grump and we even tried to joke around and cheer her up. No response. On to the food. The bread and olive oil was pretty good but it wasn't Italian bread. The olive oil blend was tasty. The worst Caesar salad I have ever had. It did not have Romaine lettuce. The chicken on it was that fake prepackaged chicken. We specifically asked if the dressing is creamy, not the vinegar type, response yes. Was it, no. And the salad came out after we got our pizza! The sever was pretty much like too bad because of the kitchen. The pizza is really good and we like the red sauce, why three stars. The cherry bourbon smash drink we got was really good. However, I would get pizza to go and that is about it.

Great waitress knowledgeable of menu items. Food was ok sauce is always a personal taste. It's a…read moresmall space that we were seating in. So it felt crowded

Nice variety of pizza. Hot and fresh. Small salad bar but very good. Reasonable priceread more

Great price for salad, soup, Italian sandwiches, pizza buffet. Salad bar is pretty small, but had…read moreitems I like, only iceberg lettuce however. Pizzas were good, not too much sauce, which I like. I really like the Italian subs they had on the buffet. They do quite a business. It was pretty busy, there were 8 of us we lucked out that 2 tables opened up as we ordered. Cashier was helpful since we'd never been. They do a large takeout business too. They have different salads and sandwiches on their menu too.

Pretty cool place and great to watch a game in with friendly staff. Cold beer! Good pizzas.read more

We got 2 pizzas to go this weekend. One was a deep dish and the other thin crust. Both were burnt…read moreto a crisp and dry. The so-called deep dish was as flat as a pancake. Never again.

What a great place. Reminds me of the pubs in Germany with the music they play…read more Drinks are great, Beer is even better. Food is awesome, the cranberry walnut salad is heaven! Highly recommended!!

It was a bit confusing how to order. Someone walked up and tried explaining it, but I opened a tab…read moreat the bar to order beer. Then I was supposed to order food at the table. I didnt know how they would link the two together. Im sure this was a newbie experience Food came out quick and hot. Some interesting options on the menu. Very delicious. The beer was limited options but very delicious. Nice they have a full bar for those that dont like beer (gasp!). I really liked this place and will return.

Wonderful place to eat!! The food was great, came out hot! The atmosphere is a quaint little…read moredinner. The staff were friendly and efficient. Would definitely recommend!

WE LOVED THIS PLACE. Hands down, my new favorite bacon. First time ever having it deep fried and I…read moresee life in a new way. :) It does not make it heavier in fat at all... it actually balances out the fat and cooks it consistently for the perfect light crisp the whole way through. Highly recommend trying it! Also, if you want to surround yourself with sweet people, go here for the staff. Miriam was our waitress twice and we absolutely adored her. Food was great every time... you'll never go wrong with authentic Amish cooking and the prices were more than reasonable, too. The interior is what you would expect for a quaint, small town diner - a little dated and cozy. We will come back here, probably multiple times, every time we visit Middlebury. Thank you!

Their Margherita DOC is right up there with the best New Haven has to offer and I have tried them…read moreall. I only wish I could be returning soon. The service was prompt and friendly but don't expect too much in decor. The food is what you are here for so don't worry about the small stuff.

Wow! What delicious pizza! Fresh and huge salad with lots of slices of fresh cheese. My truffle…read morepizza was excellent!! This spot opens at 5:00 and people were lined up to get a table. Well worth a visit!

Good pizza. Lots of ingredients! Reasonable prices too…read more Close by our cottage. Nice people there too.

The pizza might be great, but don't go here for breakfast! It was really, really bad. Everything…read morewas microwaved. The eggs were powdered and the bacon was practically raw. My gravy was from a packet and they crumbled a 1/2 of a biscuit into it and served me my " biscuit and gravy". By far the worst breakfast or meal for that matter we have EVER experienced!!

The lady that took my order was very nice. The service was fast and the pizza was very goodread more

Delivery driver maybe forgot (or maybe the people who prepped the food forgot?) but he felt…read moregenuinely sorry and comeback with my food and even gave us a free soda. Food was good but my stomach hurt a lot after, My husband not so much . It was a bit of a wait( almost two hours with my food being left behind)and had a lot of construction going on in that town that we stopped by briefly. 5 stars for delivery driver though !