Simple. Good food. Fast service. Good value. Good selection. Recommend Give it a try read more

The pizza buffet was great! Nothing groundbreaking, but so good. It's definitely better than the average Pizza Inn or Cici's. They kept the pizza bar full of great options, all of which were warm and tasted fresh. I saw staff put out several new pizzas during the maybe 30 minutes I was there. As many have mentioned, the mozzarella sticks (not like fried sticks, more like pieces of extra cheesy cheese pizza with garlic instead of marinara) are unmatched. I couldn't believe how reasonable the price was! Less than $10 for lunch is a rarity these days. The service was great as well. Very friendly. I will be returning soon! read more

Pizza Cafe - Pizza and a mozzarella stick - Pizza Near Me - Pinehurst, North Carolina

Nice little place with wine and beer. Not a favorite of buffets but the pizza was okay. The table service was a little confusing when we first arrived. Their sandwich was okay at best. Probably one and done. read more

Great pizza. Loved the crunchy thin crust. Mushroom sweet pepper onion pizza was excellent. Very flavorful. Ready when stated

We're new in town and trying to find good pizza. Vito's is fantastic and the best so far. We thought we'd try pizza cafe next. We ordered a large 'deep dish' pizza a garlic rolls with cheese. Without going into needless detail, this is Pizza Hut, papa John's kind of pizza not what we were hoping for. It was about frozen pizza quality with cheese that doesn't melt. The garlic bread with cheese was lightly toasted with no cheese and no garlic. The pictures speak for themselves. read more

Pizza Cafe - Funky, half melted cheese - Pizza Near Me - Pinehurst, North Carolina

See all

The cafe is in my neighborhood and it is very nice and clean. Love the pizza. My favorite is the Hawaiian. Service is always excellent.

Always great pizza and Leaf always takes great care of us! The buffet is a great value as well.

This place is like a hidden jewel. We've been here twice and enjoyed the Tropical Delight pizza. *just think Hawaiian Pizza* Jacqueline went above and beyond with the service she provided. Professional and down to earth doesn't even begin to cover it. I HIGHLY recommend this for lunch and dinner. read more

This pizza is super good and they deliver really fast! My favorite was the pepperoni bacon jalapeño. read more

Pizza Cafe - a pizza in a cardboard box - Pizza Near Me - Pinehurst, North Carolina

See all

It's a great place to have pizza and salad with family and friends as well as be treated like you're the only customer. It's kid friendly and has a great location. I love bringing my boys here for lunch or dinner. read more

Good pizza and decent prices. We also had some chicken wings that were great! Small but nice place. They have a buffet too.

My visit didn't start well. The manager was assisting a new employee with the credit card reader when I arrived, and proceeded to ignore me for a minute or two. Training is important in a service business, I get it, but it could be argued that customers are more important. In any event, once he made himself available, I was seated quickly and ordered a small thin crust supreme pizza and a draft Yuengling. The pizza was average; the beer was good. Service was friendly and efficient. Tab was ~$14 before tip. Not sure what the pizza scene in Pinehurst is like, but I hope there's better pizza elsewhere in town; this wasn't impressive. read more

Came in tonight with my Mom for a pizza. Ordered a medium hand tossed 3 topping pizza. We were seated and taken care of by a lovely server. She was handling the whole dining room including all COVID procedures like a pro! Our pizza came out very quickly and was absolutely delicious! They cut it properly so each piece was completely separated. I hate when my pizza is not cut well and I end up losing half my toppings. We will add Pizza Cafe to our dining routine! read more

Pizza Cafe - Pizza and beer!! - Pizza Near Me - Pinehurst, North Carolina

Great pizza, horrible delivery service. Delivery orders are not made a priority and are never on time. Was told 40 minutes and took 2hrs to get our pizza and we live 10 minutes away!!! Insane! Only doing take out from now on. read more

On our carry out rotation for years. The service is always quick and friendly, the food hot and delicious, and the prices reasonable. Hope they will be able to open the salad and pizza buffet soon. Highly recommended. Sonja & Manny read more

This is our go to Friday night pizza place. Fast delivery. Affordable prices on pizzas! Get the supreme pizza with original crust.

Stopped here after seeing this place on Yelp. It was just a few blocks from the doctors office I was at, so thought it worth a try. We did the lunch buffet, which is a great value at about $8. The staff really impressed me with their warmth and friendliness. The pizza didn't blow me away, but I would say it's great for the value. The thin crust they have is perfectly crispy. My son was also impressed that the pepperoni on the pizzas were crispy. My personal favorite thing was the pepperoni and jalapeño pizza. They also had a veggie spaghetti that was surprisingly good. They had a few school groups here while we were here and I was impressed by the attention they gave the kiddos, but no one else in the restaurant was neglected either. It's clean and has an Italian/Golf theme to the decor. It's worth a try if you're craving quick pizza. read more

Not sure I'll recommend this place. Walked in to place a take out order. I was approached and asked if I wanted to be seated. I let the young lady I wanted to place an order for take out and she walked off?? Ahhhh, ok, not to be bothered if I'm not dinning in?. Ok, Someone else approached me and I let him know I wanted to place a take out order, he didn't offer a menu or anything "what do you want?". Well, this was my first time here. I didn't know what they offered on the menu, no one offered a menu, when I asked the gentleman for a menu he pulled one out and then stood there. I asked for a minute to look over it. After a few seconds he then asked if he could 'go over the menu with me?'. I can read, thank you. I didn't order any food. I felt like I was a bother from the moment I walked in. Wait staff only wanted to help someone dinning in and guy at the register was obviously too busy. Sad this is the treatment given here. There are some really good pizza places in the area, guess this one won't make the cut read more

Been there 3 times, each progressively worse: First time for take-out: that was a good experience. Nobody else was in the restaurant. Pizza was pretty good. Second time for their buffet: so disorganized that they couldn't get the beverages to the table. Chalked-it-up to being an off-night for the waitress. Third time, even more disorganized. We stood there waiting to be seated while the host (I think the owner) ran around like a chicken with his head cut off. We left after waiting and waiting to be seated in any of the many available seats. This place is just poorly managed. My advice, get a good pizza without the pain at Vitos. read more

Super child friendly place! Awesome pizza buffet lunch--loved the Jalapeño Pepperoni Pizza :) We did a Home Delivery a few days later & they were super fast! Fresh ingredients! Definitely Top Shelf Family Joint!!! read more

Great little place to unwind. Favorite of my parents. Delicious thin crust pizza - with lost of choices and constant fresh pies coming out. Informal, no frills - but good food. read more

This locally owned restaurant is great! Even better, they deliver within a certain distance. The salads are fresh, wholesome, and not from a bag. The pasta and sauce is amazing, they will even bake it with cheese on top. To top it all off, it is quite inexpensive! I will say that I'm not a fan of the pizza and don't purchase that item, but that's personal preference. I have many friends that love the pizza and thoroughly enjoy the lunch buffet. Next time I will be trying the egg plant Parmesan which a friend raves about. Very polite staff, I have never had a bad experience the couple of times I have eaten here. read more

Great pizza place service is excellent food was really good nice pizza buffet good price

Great family place and tremendous service. Easy to get in and out and the pizza was delish!

Such a. Good price for such good clean salad + pizza. My favorite has got to be the pepperoni thin crust pizza. It's been good every time I go there. There are times I don't support local businesses but, I try my best to support local. Thanks for being part of the community! Check this place out if you haven't! It took me a long time to hear about it, definitely worth a weekly visit! Hehe read more

Best pizza in town hands down!, and the owner is a great guy. Seriously best pizza in pinehurst heck in all of Moore county

Great pizza and great service. The buffet was amazing and the desert pizzas were so good!!

I have been eating here for almost 20 years. That statement alone should say something about this place. The owner always welcomes us personally and knows exactly what we want. They have a buffet at lunch and also a few nights for dinner. There is a wide variety of pizzas, their signature baked cheese sticks, desert pizza, pasta and salad. They have THE BEST sweet tea you will ever taste. They also offer wine and beer choices. Family friendly, great value and there staff is the icing on the cake. We are fans for life in this family. read more

Pizza Cafe - Cheese sticks from Pizza Cafe!!! The BEST you will ever taste. - Pizza Near Me - Pinehurst, North Carolina

I wish I found this place earlier. Great lunch buffet and better pizza (and cheaper) than the chains. It has a family atmosphere to it. Wonderful owner and staff, and they have fast, free delivery (on two occasions it took less than 25 minutes). I will be back for sure and it's my new go-to pizza place! read more

This used to be a local fav. Good food but the atmosphere is very tired, dirty walls, everything needs to be updated and refreshed and cleaned. There are many other options in the area. read more

My favorite restaurant to go to when I'm in Pinehurst!!! So delicious hot or cold! The best pizza place I've ever been to!

Was just ehh. Not what I would call an Italian restaurant. The service was fine.

Pizza was good, veggies were fresh, but it was slightly greasy. Not bad for the price.

Strip mall pizza joint that's in great need of overhaul and do over.... We came in around 1pm on a Sunday and attempted to eat the buffet.... We each had a slice and left. Enough said. read more

Great place to take kids. Server is always so friendly and she remenbers our son. That's always a winner. Great buffet. Good variety. Owner will always accommodate special requests for the buffet selection. Good value. Great for ball teams and slumber party attendees! read more

For these prices, the amount of food you'll get here can take on an army! Variety as well as affordable. I left stuffed!

The people are extremely nice and the service is prompt. The food is really great and there are also good desserts.

We/I do like pizza cafe. The price is great and when you come in, just tell the waitress what you want, if you don't like what is on the bar. For me I don't like thin crust so I order thick pan. I have read the reviews and one I do agree with is this restaurant does need a face lift, maybe to brighten up the sitting area. I have not ordered take out so I cannot review that portion of the business. One waitress usually takes care of the entire eating area, so i can see why, if asked for take out she may not be entirely engaging, however no excuse. Remember, prices are cheap, you get a bunch of food, veggie bar is fresh with good selection, so don't push the envelope and try to make this into a Vito's pizza unless you want to start paying the Vito prices. read more

Great pizza, free delivery and right around the corner. The pan pizza crust is delicious and we are a big fan of the white pizzas. This is our family choice for pizza night. read more

I'm frequent customer for lunch buffet and always get good food and service. Sometimes they don't have my favorite pizza on buffet and add it when I tell them. I eat out most days and this is my to go pizza place. Best of those I go to. All pizza on buffet here is thin crust and this is kind I like. Make your own salad on buffet is good and fresh. read more