What a wonderful place. Has the best homemade mozzarella cheese sticks. I've gotten the Lobster…read moreBisque and salad, and their half a sandwich and soup and both had been great. Always good nice servers and very welcoming.

This place has the absolute worst customer service I've ever seen!!! Ordered a plain bacon…read morecheeseburger. They gave me lettuce, tomato, and some kind of dressing on it. I took it back and they said the bartender said she read it back to me and said I didn't say "No toppings". But clearly I said PLAIN. Horrible place. Never going back.

7/9/26 Great location in downtown Carlisle. Service was quick & friendly, prices were good. Pizza…read morewas tasty; chewy mozzarella, mild sauce, crust could've been thinner, but good flavor. Slices were on small side, but priced well. Good, but not quite great. Convenient stopover.

Mediocre is a compliment, nothing special bordered on tasteless. A Red Baron or Tony's Pizza is a…read morefar better option.

We visited Carlisle, PA to attend the annual Corvette event. We loved the location of Pitt Street…read moreStation as it was within walking distance of our Air BnB. The service was excellent both evenings! Yes! We chose to enjoy dinner two nights in a row! We were thrilled, and blessed to have Meg as our server, both visits. Meg was attentive, engaging and very knowledgeable of the menu. She was a pure delight. The first evening we ordered the Meatball Sliders as an Appetizer. What incredible flavor and texture these meatballs have! All meat! The red sauce was wonderfully bright with true authentic Italian sauce. My husband and I shared the sliders and the Cubana sandwich. What fabulous flavors in the Cubana as well. The bread had a nice crunch on the outside with soft bites inside. Delicious!! The second night we enjoyed delicious Spaghetti and those wonderful Meatballs along with the best Chicken Marsala we've ever enjoyed. We will visit the next time we are in Carlisle.

Pitt Street Station offers a number of items that would work for vegetarians and gluten free…read morepatrons. As for vegans, well, there isn't much. Thankfully the restaurant is willing to accommodate (like leaving the cheese off a pizza) so there are vegan items to be crafted. It would just be cool if there were one or two items designed with vegans in mind. So, after some hocus pocus work, I decided on The Puttanesca Pizza and a non-alcoholic Cinnamon Vanilla Mule. The Puttanesca Pizza typically features olive tapenade, house tomato sauce, shaved Romano and rosemary gremolata. The waitress said it would be no problem to leave off the Romano. The Cinnamon Vanilla Mule contains cinnamon-vanilla syrup and ginger beer. Thankfully no substitutions needed here. The pizza at Pitt Street Station is bar style. A thin, chewy crust with the toppings layered on top. I found the crust to be pretty good. I like the combo of tapenade and house tomato sauce but did find it a tad salty. Can't imagine what it is like with the Romano added in. The Cinnamon Vanilla Mule was very good. I liked the balance of all the components. It was cool to see some non alcoholic cocktails on the menu and to have them be really good. I would return to Pitt Street Station if meeting up with someone because the place is accommodating to dietary needs but until some actual vegan items are on the menu it won't be somewhere I seek out on my own.

First time. had a fish sandwich & fries. they forgot the extra cheese but put it on when i…read morementioned it. it was a little done as well as the fries. $15.95 seemed a little pricey. It was a very thin piece of cod. BUT, Apple. my host & waitstaff was amazing. So friendly & welcoming! I would go back. They have a bar & serve breakfast...wondering if they are from NJ! IYKYK!

Located across from the Carlisle Fairgrounds 1st visit. Looks very clean and the Staff are really…read morefriendly. Quiet off season day! My wife ordered their Cream Chip Beef over Home fries and I ordered their Country Fried Steak with 2 eggs over med. Home fries & toast. The food came out hot & delicious. Looking forward to returning to try their dinner menu.

The best place for reasonably priced Italian food in Carlisle. The service is always excellent. The…read morestaff are knowledgeable and friendly. Their entree portions are huge so we share one dinner.

We've been here a few times when we've been in Carlisle. Staff is always friendly. Casual and…read moreclean. Portions are huge! We've never finished our meals and have plenty of leftovers. I love the seafood pasta and my family loves the calzones and sandwiches.

Carlisle has lots of great food options. I'm not a coffee drinker but I needed some sweet treats to…read moreshare with a friend. And these cookies did not disappoint! All 3 were delicious!

Looking to treat myself a little on a cold, gray Wednesday afternoon, I decided to finally stop…read moreinto Denim Coffee in Carlisle. I've walked and driven past it many times but had somehow never made it inside. Since Denim was also participating in the 2026 Cumberland Valley Coffee & Chocolate Trail, it felt like the perfect excuse to check it out and grab a quick late-afternoon pick-me-up. I walked in around 4pm and found a handful of people inside -- some chatting quietly, others working on laptops. The space was clean, calm, and welcoming, with soft music playing overhead. The woman at the counter was an absolute sunbeam on an otherwise dreary afternoon, greeting me warmly and happily taking my order. I went with an iced coffee with sugar-free vanilla syrup (extra sweet, please!) and oat milk. Total came to $5.25. While she prepared my drink, I took a moment to look around and realized what a great view Denim offers from their bar seating area. Full glass windows with stools looking out over the square in Carlisle make it a fantastic people-watching spot. That afternoon, the Farmers Market was set up across the square, and it was fun watching people dash between stands while dodging raindrops to grab their weekly goodies. It struck me as a perfect place to meet a friend, spend a few hours working on a laptop, or just decompress with a coffee and watch the world go by. Denim also had a small sweet treat case with snacks that would pair nicely with coffee. I stuck with just the drink this time, but everything looked tempting enough that I'd definitely consider adding a pastry next visit. A few minutes later my name was called and my drink was waiting at the end of the counter. One interesting touch: they placed the container of oat milk beside my coffee so I could add exactly as much as I wanted. It's a small detail, but not something you see at many coffee shops, and I appreciated the flexibility. The iced coffee itself was excellent. Unlike some places where iced coffee tastes like watered-down brown liquid, Denim's actually tasted like coffee -- strong, smooth, and delivering a solid caffeine boost. Overall: great service, really good coffee, reasonable prices, and a cozy spot right in the heart of town. The only real challenge is parking since it's so close to the square. Street parking is available nearby, but depending on the time of day you may need to circle a bit. All in all, a great little coffee stop and I'm glad I finally walked through the door.

We ordered take out and they had it ready right on time. I say this is classic style pizza on a…read morethinner style crust. Less cheese than other places which I appreciate because I can actually taste the rest of the toppings! Not greasy at all and so much flavor.

The cheeseburger wrap was tasty and exactly what you expect something with that name to taste like…read more Their pizza is quite good too. Our server was attentive and did a pretty good job of taking care of us. The only 'ding' that I will give this place is that the restaurant owner and some of his staff members and friends were very loud while working on their beer vats. They showed no consideration for their customers and, instead, seemed to be oblivious to the fact that most people eating in their restaurant wouldn't want to spend their lunchtime raising their voices just so that the person they were dining with could hear them. These guys were so loud and boisterous that, a few times, we just gave up on trying to chat with one another because there was zero chance that we could comfortably speak loudly enough to hear each other.

Firehouse Subs is one of my frequent sub haunts and on the menu today was the Fire House Chicken…read moreBacon Ranch. The FHCBR if you will, had a pepper next to it on the menu I assumed that means spicy so I asked the guy if it was spicy to which he replied "it's not that spicy" so I had an image in my head of a piss poor mild hum, to which I say the counter-man's description did not do the "not too spicy justice". Now this was not a flaming hot hurt your mouth kinda spice but it was a leave some heat lingering great flavor kind of spice, and I've got to add idd consider myself to have a pretty high heat tolerance so idd probably think most normal people are probably gonna think this thing is actually pretty spicy. So I gotta ask, since when are there spicy subs? Like not just sweet peppers, pepper relish or jalops I mean since when do they slather a bad boy down with some capsaicin infused chipotle mayo? My brain doesn't logically go to subs should be spicy, but apparently the chefs over at the Fire Company thought it did and let me tell you I commend them for that. They gave me something I didn't know I needed Fire fighters are supposed to put fires out not start fires and let me tell you Firehouse Subs lit a fire in my mouth and my heart today. Get yourself FHCBR especially if you ain't afraid of the fire, you may get a little burnt 10/5

Service was good. Guys working we're nice enough. Food, yikes, our smokehouse brisket which is…read moresupposed to be cooked for 16 hours was rare. Not a good sandwich.

Great local butcher shop with a real butcher on site . I have been going here for years and we…read morenormally get their hamburger which is outstanding. Great staff , quality meat and more .

Great customer service with great products. The meat was extremely fresh and cut to order with…read moreprecut options available as well. The butcher stepped out of the back to talk about what I wanted and made sure I left happy.

This is exactly where you want to have lunch. Thoughtful & kind staff plus healthy & delicious…read morefood. Menu combination choices that are unique. I am a traveling musician who is tired of North American garbage food. I found this place by chance after going to a great bookstore across the street. So happy to find it. I loved it so much I returned a second day. I rarely get to do that on the road. Thanks for doing good work. Very refreshing.

We were there this past weekend and it was steady. Got seated right away and placed our drink…read moreorder. We both ordered the pick 2 (half sandwich and soup) I didn't care for the lentil soup so I swapped it for the other. I'd definitely go back the food was very tasty and the staff was excellent.