Great neighborhood bagel spot! It's a weekend tradition for my family to stop in there to grab bagels and breakfast sandwiches. Bacon, Egg, and cheese is my go to. I've never had a bad experience there in all the times going there. They even bailed me out one time with a 6 foot hero for a party when my caterer canceled. This place is more than just bagels! That should be their slogan. read more

Their bagels are HUGE & absolutely delicious. I think I have finally found my newest spot for a good, quick breakfast! read more

Pio Hot Bagels - French toast bagel with strawberry cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Ok, so updating on my last review. Though they don't cut individual bagels, I just have someone cut them for me at home. But they are massive, delicious, and fresh. read more

Very hit or miss if you order on Doordash. Perfect when you're in person. Have ordered delivery from them twice and both times order was messed up as though they don't read the Doordash info at all. In person service is quick and food is always great. Recommend going earlier than later. read more

A-OK. Decent little bagel shop. Typical kind of bagel you'd find on Staten Island. Big, fluffy, but lacks that Brooklyn crust/chew. Try it out! read more

I've obkt has emdelivery and tbh it's not far from where i was and it's taken well longer than expected to actually be completed and given to a delivery platform. I don't know. I didn't like the BEc sandwiches. I didn't love the bagel or flavored cream cheese and it left me wondering what they hype is all about. In the warmer months I'll give it a 3rd try and not be lazy and update my review of tien to prep and enjoyment. read more

Great bagels , bacon, and eggs with cheese and excellent coffee , what else can you ask for? ..

I got the Grilled Chicken broccoli Robe wrap it is Great they are very accommodating

Not enough raisins in their cinnamon raisin bagel. There's maybe 2-3 in each bagel. Unacceptable & cheap...... Won't return because it's happened a few times. Makes you think what else do they cheap out on? Their dairy? Their flour? read more

I really like their bagels! It's the only place in the neighborhood I go to for bagels. The only down side is the prices - I got two sandwiches on rolls - one was literally just american cheese and ham, no lettuce or condiments, and one soda and it cost $17. The south shore is generally expensive and overpriced but for a standard sandwich it was definitely pricy. Will simply just come here for what their best at: bagels! read more

Great place for a bagel in SI. BEC and Egg and Cheese on an everything bagel is great. Lines begin early in the morning but move fast. Great variety of beverages and last minute items like eggs, milk and juice are sold. I would have given five stars but once there flavors of bagels run out you are out of luck. read more

Quick & Delicious Breakfast Bagels! Coffee is always fresh & the staff is great. Line gets long but that's because the food & service is good. read more

The bagels are good, large size. The only issue I have consistently is that their plain bagels have other stuff attached to them like poppy seeds, onion, sesame seeds. I guess they don't clean the oven when they put the bagels in after making their other seeded bagels, I can't have seeds (medical condition) and I'm constantly scraping stuff off the bottom of their plain bagels. The other problem is that their is no distinct way of forming a line in the store so they are serving customers out of order. I go there regularly to buy bagels, and only bagels and I always get stuck behind the customer that's ordering 4 prepared sandwiches with special requirements. Come on...put up a sign where the line forms and serve the BAGEL only customer a little faster. Clean those ovens. SMH read more

I have been going there for years. I spent at least $30 a week buying sandwiches and bagels. One day I went in I was my usual sandwiches. I also wanted to add a toasted bagel to my order and they told me they can't touch the bagel without me, putting anything on, I'm not sure why they know me as a good customer when I told them they just lost me as a customer. Plenty of bagel stores around in our neighborhood. I spoke to the owner about it and he seem not to care read more

On site made bagels ... you can't beat that ... the large flavor assortment of Bagels & flavored cream cheese are great tasting ... I find the catering is inexpensive for the large amount of food they give you ...try the chicken cutlet Wheel .. wow read more

Ok Bagels with rude staff, on a recent visit I was the only customer and waited while the 3 workers behind the counter watched the soccer game on the TV. Also they advertise that they use butter on there bagels but they actually use margarine the cheaper alternative. Better options elsewhere!! read more

I like bagels that are fat and doughy and Pio does 'em like that...the kind of bagels you don't want toasted because they're still soft and warm until early afternoon. That works for me. Creative homemade cream cheese flavors: scallion (delish) and olive (my fave). For all the years I've been going to Pio, though, I've never had the stomach to try anything else. It's not exactly the cleanest looking place. It might be very clean as breakfast grills go for all I know but a whole bunch of different oily ingredients cooking on one small grill next to a 3 ft high stack of bacon isn't my style. I'll stick with a simple everything bagel with scallion or olive cream cheese. Simple. They do simple well enough for me. I've been to better, cleaner, more modernized, trendier, and bigger shoes with more variety throughout the city and NJ but for a simple bagel in Woodrow, this'll do. read more

Bagels are precisely what you'd expect from a fine NYC bagel establishment: big, fluffy, delicious, and served with a very thick New York accent. I've tried the "pump" (aka, pumpernickel) bagel, egg, egg everything, and French toast. Be aware that the French toast bagels are limited in quantity. If you get to Pio Hot Bagels after around 11am, there will be no more French toast bagels. Sad! Pio nails it with consistency and taste. You can't go wrong. It just gets a little bit crowded in there in the mornings. There are only two tables to seat yourself, with two chairs each. The ambiance is the furthest thing from fine dining, but that's not what you go there for. Come here for your perfect grab-and-go NY bagel. You'll be very happy with your choice. read more

This deli has great Boar's Head cold cuts. They have Boar's Head ham $9/lb at least $2/lb less than neighboring stores. I like to get cold cuts here. Their bagels and rolls are not the best. They are not always fresh and the bagels sometimes give you heartburn. If you like the taste of the bagels, they are huge. I can only eat a half. It's a small space that's crowded on weekends so it is well liked by neighbors. They have two small tables with two chairs each if you prefer to take your order to stayz read more

Best bagels and sandwiches hands down! I drive 30min to this location and it's worth every minute- no one comes close IMO. Their bagels were such a hit at my local team meetings that myself and a coworker now take a CARRY ON filled with their bagels whenever we travel to Chicago or Rhode Island for work. The French toast ones were my bosses favorite!! First place I bring family when they visit and are looking for a NYC bagel. My parents also ordered from them this summer a few times- the sandwiches were huge, fresh, and delicious. We had American, Italian, and chicken cutlet w roasted peppers. I actually tried to hide a few slices so I could take home left overs . Oh and I'm also a potato salad snob and they knocked that outta the park too. Now if only they made pizza bagels . read more

Not sure why it has a 3 star average. I'm new to the Staten Island bagel game but this place was on point with the French toast, 8.8 outta 10. Delicious. Bagels are big so no need for 2 for breakfast. Great spot. read more

Was in the area and stopped in to get bagels. Never again. $18 for two bagels with tuna salad. Highway robbery. And they looked at me like I was crazy. read more

Bagels are very good and always fresh. Two very good bagel stores in the area with Heartland Bagels being the other. Lines are a bit more manageable at Pios as heartland is regularly out the door with slow help. That being said, both are very good but heartland gets the thumbs up here with Pio very close behind. Wont go wrong with either read more

This place has great tasting bagels, they just have to get people that pay attention to detail. They have their own specialty cream cheese mixtures, so I asked for bacon cream cheese which is a bacon cheddar cream cheese. I get home and they literally placed a few full strips of bacon on top of regular cream cheese... Really? was that a compromise, did you run out? Why didnt anyone say something if thats the case? or maybe the moron who made it thought that was normal? read more

My favorite spot for bagels and sandwiches! The staff is super friendly too. Going to miss this place when we move, wish they had other locations! read more

Hands down best bagels ever. i will be a PIO's bagel advocate in any bagel debate :) Also, the best sun dried tomato cream cheese!

Gave this place another try. What a mistake! One star is too much. Food still overpriced and nothing great. Owner was rude to another customer who pointed out their order was wrong. Disappointing for a local business to be rushing the orders and lack customer service. read more

Bagels are a mess! they wrap in tin foil 4 times then when you go to eat it ,it falls everywhere. The bosses talk to much bs with the guys. I was there today and asked for three chicken cutlet wraps and the girl gave me one then took an extra 20 minutes to wait for the other 2. Then the boss asked me what i was waiting for then just said okat Didn't say sorry or offer anything. Girls are very nice on the other hand the men workers are rude. read more

I'm giving it a 2 star only because the bagels are delicious. The customer service here is absolutely the worst !!!!!!! my husband and I always give them the benefit of the doubt and continue to come here. after today, never again. I never ever write a bad review. they are continuously nasty. They close at 2 o'clock but when you come in at 12:30 they tell you that they can't make you any more eggs. My family has owned a restaurant for over 20 years and my mother would never ever turn away somebody an hour and a half before closing because they don't want to make eggs so they don't have to clean the grill. I even try calling ahead of time sometimes to give them enough time and even on the phone they are so rude and they tell you to just come in. I will never come back here again. it's sad because the bagels are so good but the way that they treat us and the way that they are put such a bad taste in our mouth that it's not even worth it. read more

Terrible. The employees including the owner don't use gloves when taking bagels out of display or use same contaminated glove that they handle money and preparing food. Reuse tissue paper occasionally when owners father is working to remove bagels from display. No hair restraint worn by workers. Very poor process and cleanliness standards, Dept of health should investigate. read more

Good bagels. Staff is rude. The high glass makes it hard to hear when ordering. When you walk in you see a mess of people and there's no real system. Getting back to the staff. People are rude and seem annoyed you are there. The one guy is always chewing food with his mouth open while talking and preparing your order, pretty gross. I would go here because the bagels are good and they are close by. But now I go elsewhere. read more

Best bagels- they taste good and they're fat. The service is fast & friendly. However the parking terrible.

So far the best bagel I've found on the island. Well priced. Coffee is good too! I have seen that bacon and eggs are sitting on the grill from earlier like other reviews mentioned. read more

I get my Sunday morning bagel here alllllll the time health wrap & a bagel. All day if I could get it every day I would. Best deal on the island. Bagel are just great & a good size too. Not to to big & not small I am sooooooo happy w/ my local bagel store read more

There bagels are delicious. They are huge and soft. The pumpernickel was my favorite. I can't wait to come back and try more flavors. I'm surprised this place doesn't have more reviews. read more

Very small bagel store but very good ! The bagels from here on weekends are so extremely soft. It can he very crowded here Sunday mornings so prepare for that. They have great lunch specials as well during the work week. read more

Pio Hot Bagels - Yummy bagel with cold cuts. - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Bagels ? More like a Kaiser roll too doughy but that's the way they are in Staten Island.

My go to spot for bagels. Delicious, big, fluffy bagels that are hard to beat. Even better when used to make a bacon egg and cheese sandwich! Definitely recommend Pio Bagels read more

Amazing bagels! They're huge and always delicious! Love the service and how quick they are no matter how busy it gets in there!

I made the mistake of going there this morning actually wanting something specific. I asked for scrambled eggs and sausage and for the god only knows how many time, I didn't get what I asked for. I also asked for toast with butter. I got toast no butter. I know they know how to use butter because the bagel I got for my kid was basically in butter soup. Instead of trying to act like the cool kid on the block focus on what is a very simple job. I'm done there. read more