Went to do laundry and stumbled upon this pizza place, it was nice and clean with decent amount of…read moreseating. I'm a bit particular with pizza, mainly don't want it burnt and this was the complete opposite. The pizza although just a regular cheese, it was packed with flavor and the marinara was so yummy. The pizza stuck out for me with this kind of breading like crust, not the typical slice! As I just relocated this is now close to me and will be making this my regular go to joint. If the cheese is this good the specialty slices and food must be out of this world! Friendly service and me and my family were satisfied. Happy we stopped in today!

The food is always good. The owners are very, very friendly. I did have a slightly unhappy…read moreexperience when the owners weren't there and the young kids were filling the orders and they forgot something in my order so I had to wait there for them to to make it but 90% of the time when I go there, everything is perfect so they just need to know step it up when when the owner isn't there

Fantastic food and customer service. It's my go to lunch spot. Excellent grandma slice, vodka…read moreslice, meatballs and more. Only thing I'd change--the vodka slice has too much cheese on it. A little is good but lately they've been adding more and more. Their buffalo slice is also something I'd love to try but I can't stand blue cheese or ranch. They put it on by default. I wish it would be optional, something they could add on the spot for customers that like it. Other than that--it's fantastic. Great flavor, great crust, great sauce. Everything you look for in a pizza place.

Good food, great service, with a spacious dining area. The calamari was really good. The penne was…read morereally good too, so much, I ended up with leftovers for work. Definitely is now my go-to spot.

Stopped by La Supreme Pizza for dinner with family a few weeks ago and had a great time all around…read more It was a first time visit for most of us, but we came based on a recommendation that they had one of the best Sicilian pepperoni slices in the area. If you're wondering, yes, it totally lived up to the hype. What else went well? The service and really all of the other food we ordered. Just a positive experience overall. La Supreme Pizza is a small pizza shop located in a strip of businesses. There's plenty of free parking shared among the other shops. The inside does have a few tables if you want to enjoy your food on site. We were a party of seven people and took up almost half of the seating area. The staff was really accommodating and helpful as we tried to organize the order for so many people. All of the food was great. Some standout items for me included the Sicilian Pepperoni slices, stuffed garlic knots, and the plain slice. Highly recommend any of these items. My first visit to La Supreme Pizza was a hit. My family and I would definitely return in the future the next time we're in Oakdale.

Being in this area, they have a pretty good buffalo chicken slice. Normally I review places after…read moretrying it multiple times but this deserves a good review. Very friendly service, ambiance is cool it's a small local pizza shop. I got a buffalo chicken slice well done with a side of bleu cheese. Now the slice was good I do wish it had been spicier and the chicken was crispier. Their bleu cheese seems to be home made with thick chunks of the bleu cheese. Decently priced pretty good pizza. I want to try more of their menu options however their buffalo chicken is pretty good. And that says a lot from someone who lives in Nassau county and has had the best pizza ever all around queens and the city. This is a spot I want to try more of and decently and fairly priced. I'll definitely be back.

4.5 Stars (I rounded up)…read more We ordered a large deep dish pepperoni pie with hot honey, garlic knots and a salad for delivery during the dinner rush. The guy who took the order was very pleasant, polite & well organized. After speaking with him, I was confident that the order would be executed correctly. Kudos as well to the delivery guy, who had the pizza to us in 20 minutes, piping hot. The pizza was delicious, like rock star status. The pie had a delicious (plentiful) sauce, and they use the little pepperoni which gets crispy and curls up with a little pool of oil (LOVE THIS). The hot honey that was drizzled on the light/buttery crust was a nice finish to each slice. How do they coax so much flavor into that dough? This will now be a weekly routine except we're going to rotate the deep dish offering and try the meatball burrata. Garlic knots were cold, hard and lacking Parm and EVOO?? Caesar salad was run of the mill with a micro-portion of dressing. We will be back.

Hands down, the best pizza around. Never had any less than 5 star. Everything about it is…read moreperfection. Our absolutely favorite is a well done Margarita pizza. Only con is that everyone else knows about it too, so can get busy. If ordering from delivery, take note of the day and time. There can sometimes be a wait, but it's TOTALLY worth it. You know that "can't wait until morning when I can have a cold slice for breakfast" feeling? Not gonna happen because there is never anything left!

We ordered food to be delivered. Food was very good. The gentleman who delivered the food was…read morefriendly and professional. He made a very good impression. Prices are excellent for the amount of food that we purchased.

I've only heard good things about Sal's so I decided to grab a couple of pies. We got a couple…read moredifferent chicken pies and they were stacked with meat. The staff was friendly as well

As someone who probably takes pizza a little more seriously than any reasonable adult should, I can…read moreconfidently say this place deserves all five stars. I've tried pizza from Montauk to Manhattan it's nothing short of amazing. The New Haven-style pizza was fantastic. Thin, crisp, beautifully charred, and with just the right amount of chew. That slightly blistered crust brought exactly the flavor you want from this style of pizza. No flop here, just crunch and crisp all the way through. I think Dave Portnoy would be impressed. Then came the Sicilian, and somehow they managed to crush that too. Thick, light, and airy on the inside with that perfectly crisp bottom that makes a great Sicilian so satisfying. What impressed me most was how well they executed two completely different styles of pizza. Plenty of places can make one good pie. Doing New Haven-style AND Sicilian this well? That's when you know the kitchen knows what it's doing. Great ingredients=Great pizza Five stars all the way!

Furci's Pizzeria - Bayport…read more First impression when pulling up -- this place is massive. Then you realize it's a market along with a pizza spot. The pizzeria itself is actually pretty small, with just a few tables and a small counter area. There's a good variety of pizza and specialty items, and the staff was attentive even though they were pretty busy. We came specifically because of all the recent buzz about their New Haven-style pizza. We've been to New Haven many, many times, and unfortunately, while the attempt is definitely there, New Haven it is not. If you've never had the real thing in New Haven, you might think, "Okay, I get it," but the South Shore of Long Island is still a long way from New Haven, Connecticut. The Bambinos were tasty, but the best thing we had was the Chicken Alla Vodka with fresh mozzarella. Thin-cut breaded and fried chicken with fresh mozz -- really good. Unfortunately, the vodka sauce itself was a little bit of a letdown. Overall, we weren't disappointed. There were some good bites, the staff was solid, and there's plenty to choose from. Definitely worth stopping in if you're passing through Bayport, but I wouldn't make the trip expecting a true New Haven pizza experience.

Love the crispy thin crust on these pies especially mikes hot honey, eggplant and meatball ricotta…read morepies. Fast and friendly service.

We went on a Sunday after picking my mom up at the airport across the street at 12:30pm. We weren't…read moresure it was open as there was only one car in front and it was very dark inside. There was one other table of people. The food at Anthony's is always reliably good. We ordered the large salad, wings and a pizza with 1/2 mushrooms. The service and food were both good. The bathrooms however were horribly dirty. I'm assuming we were the second group of guests for the day and the sink was so grimy it looked like it hadn't been cleaned in a month and it smelled that way. When I mentioned it to the waitress she apologized and said she didn't notice because she never goes in there, and she would let someone know. There was no manager around, which surprised me because the manager at the Commack store is always there asking how everything was, and it's always clean. On the way out I noticed the door was so covered with hand prints you could barely see through the glass. We love the Commack location, but won't be going back to this one.

Stopped by Metros on Main in Sayville and tried both the regular slice and the grandma slice. The…read moregrandma slice was really great- flavorful, and something I'd definitely come back for. Next time, I'll be grabbing a whole grandma pie to share with family. I had a quick chat with Danny, who was super welcoming and friendly--great energy. What makes this place really unique is the setup: the front is a full-service sit-down restaurant, and in the back, there's a dedicated pizza counter where you can grab a slice to stay or take out. It's a smart and convenient concept. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the area or passing through!

This review is also for Sayville Pizza that shares the space. Now that that's out of the way…read more.. I was in the area doing some volunteering and hunger struck. This is where I found myself. Upon entering it's a very nice looking restaurant with a full bar. They are also decorated for Halloween! I opted to sit at the bar as I didn't want a table being by myself. Teri was the bartender today/this evening and she was great! Very friendly and welcoming. After looking at the menu I was a bit overwhelmed and wanted something small. I opted for two slices of pizza. I had a BBQ chicken slice and a slice with sausage and pepperoni. They are a bit bigger than your average slice. They were very filling too! I asked for the slices to be made well done, and they were cooked to perfection! So good! There was so much flavor in each slice...it was a party in my mouth. I also had some garlic knots that were yummy and fresh! Everything about my experience was great! I would absolutely drive the extra few minutes to dine here vs other places...it's worth it!

The crust is the best it's always light and crisp, the sauce is never too salty or greasy. Very…read morepleasant counter help.

I'm really disappointed with the customer service I received here. I came in simply trying to…read morepurchase an item, but I was not acknowledged or helped for over 10 minutes. The employee was doing several other things instead of assisting me, and I felt completely ignored. I politely asked if she could help me when she had a chance, and instead of acknowledging me or explaining that she would be with me shortly, she put her finger up and shushed me. I found that extremely rude and unnecessary. I understand that businesses can get busy and that employees may have to answer the phone or handle other tasks, but customers who are standing right in front of you should at least be acknowledged and treated respectfully. In my experience, the customer in front of you should be assisted before moving on to a phone call when possible. I wasn't asking for anything unreasonable--I was simply trying to make a purchase. Unfortunately, the way I was treated made me feel unwelcome, and it left a very bad impression of the business.

We recently came to Satellite to try an old classic. We got the stuffed penne slice, chicken and…read morebacon ranch, mozzarella + basil + red pepper, plain and grandma alla vodka. My expectations were blown out of the water! Everything was delicious and cooked perfectly. The wait time was pretty long but the guy at the counter said it was the busiest they'd ever been since he started. After a couple of zeppoles, I forgot about the wait and enjoyed an amazing meal.

We gave Satelite a try for dinner this evening, it's a 30 minute ride for us but our friend wanted…read moreus to try it. First the restaurant dinning area is set real nice and they have a very nice little bar area if you don't want to eat in the restaurant area. Our food was delicious and plenty of food. Everything we had was very good, we all had chicken dishes and eggplant dishes. Everyone was full and we all had take home bags. Our waitress was excellent and always was checking to make sure we all were happy. Wine by the bottle is priced fairly depending what you like.