The name says it all, this place is absolute pie heaven. Tucked away in Atlantic Beach, Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe is quite possibly the cutest, most charming little pie shop you will ever walk into. The staff is warm, genuinely delightful, and makes you feel like a regular from the moment you walk through the door. Now let's talk pie. The coconut cream pie was incredible. The chocolate crème pie was incredible. But the key lime pie, has to be the best key lime pie in all of Florida. It was perfectly balanced, fresh, and exactly what a key lime pie should be. We tried several pies and there wasn't a single miss in the bunch. Every single slice was excellent! If you are anywhere near Atlantic Beach and you love pie, or even if you think you're just a casual pie person, get yourself to Pie Heaven. You will leave happier than you arrived, with a very full stomach and zero regrets. read more

See all

Pie Heaven Bakery has been on my list to try for a long time. I finally made it! There was not much parking beside the small building. But fortunately I found a spot. There was a small patio with two tables in the front. I checked out the boards inside to see what pies were still available. I stopped by at roughly 1 PM. I wanted the coconut pie but that was gone and the employee suggested the coconut custard as she said it was her favorite. So I ordered one slice of coconut custard and a small chicken pot pie. I jumped into the pie after dinner later that evening. Oh my the pie was fabulous! Creamy and sweet with tons of coconut. But not overly sweet. The crust was flaky and delish also. Highly recommend the coconut custard! I waited a few days to heat the chicken pot pie in the oven. She added an instruction sheet in my bag which was helpful. The sheet explained how to heat up the pie as well as how long both the savory and sweet pies last once you take them home. The chicken pot pie was yummy! It was filled with lots of vegetables and plenty of chicken. The inside wasn't runny like most store-bought chicken pot pies but the filling was good! I wish the crust had gotten a little crunchier on the top. But maybe that's because I didn't bake it for three days. You can purchase slices of savory or sweet pies or whole pies. They are no longer taking orders for Thanksgiving but suggested you come by and grab one and freeze it. read more

See all

This is my go to place for nights I don't want to cook or when I need to take a friend, not feeling well, a meal. All the pies are amazing and taste homemade! The shop is quaint and the staff are all so sweet and helpful. I usually get the chicken pot pie but the quiche and sweet pies are delicious too! I highly recommend Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe! read more

Very nice customer service and that is so important nowadays. Everything is clean, fresh and wonderful ingredients. Appreciate a company locally and woman owned!! Slices could bigger, but I'm always going to say that about GREAT Food! Go and get a bunch of different slices and take to a friend's house for Sunday dinner!! Get someone a chicken pot pie if they just had a baby or moved!! Yummiest gift ever!! read more

I was in the area and really craving some coconut cream pie so my fiancée and I drove over to this little pie shop near Neptune beach. I wish I could say I had a great experience and that this was my new go-to pie shop, but that couldn't be further from the truth. The vibes here are rancid. Despite the uncomfortable experience (which I'll explain below), I would have still given two stars if I had liked the pie I purchased from here, but I did not. The woman running the shop told me that they were known for their pie crust and so I was hopeful, but ultimately disappointed in the flavor of the crust. The filling was fine. It tasted like your run-of-the-mill coconut cream pie, not unlike what you can purchase from a grocery store. The crust is genuinely where I had the biggest issue. It had an unpleasant aftertaste. I'm assuming that the shop uses either shortening or a cheap butter because it was all I could taste while eating my pie. And for the prices they charge here, $8 per slice and $14 for a small pie, was expecting more. To explain our uncomfortable experience here: My fiancée and I are a bit more on the alternative looking side and we were made very aware of it by the stares and weird looks from two of the three staff members that were working here. The only person who wasn't standoffish seemed to be the woman running the store. She said that she wasn't the owner, but that she had worked there for a long time and explained the shop's mission to me while my fiancé looked around. Though I'm disappointed in myself for not leaving right then, I was really craving some pie and as we were the only ones in the shop, I felt kind of obligated to get something. On our way out, I noticed the anti-abortion signs they had hanging in the shop and was again kicking myself for not leaving without purchase. In this day and age, you vote with your dollar; small and large businesses alike. It's obvious that my fiancée and I are not the target demographic for this shop, but perhaps someone reading this is. I just didn't appreciate how aware we were made of it during what will surely be our first and only visit here. read more

See all

Wonderful place!! The crust is to die for!! I've had their pecan, coconut custard, hersey's/reese pie, shepards & chicken pot pie- all very good! I want to try the quiches next! My favorite pie I would say is the pecan!! read more

This is one of the best places in Mayport/Jacksonville to buy a pie, quiche or other. The small pies already made up are $7.00 and it goes up to quiche and pies up to $39.00. Why so much? Because they only bake with the finest and best ingredients. Pros-great baked items and staff. Cons:parking is small Order your holiday pies early! read more

See all

Tried Pie Heaven for the first time over Thanksgiving. The Apple pie was delicious! That said, I will never go there again. What possessed me in the first place to pay $45.00 for their 'large pie' (not that large...just a regular pie plate size) still escapes me. I must have been on drugs. But, for them to charge that much to begin with (yeah yeah...I know they don't use hydrogenated oils, High fructose, etc) seems like Highway robbery to me. Again, I must have been under the influence of something strong to pay that anyway. Dumb dumb dumb! Who's the fool here? read more

It is everything everyone else has already raved about. The Pot Pie is famous for good reason with the perfect crust to filling ratio. The Cornbread and Chili is another winner. The chili is mildly seasoned and the cornbread is thinly lined around the pan giving every bite a crispy crunch of slight sweet bread. And with the Pecan Pie the pecans are large and toasty and the filling is just the right amount of sweet without being cloying. Another perfect filling to crust ratio. Definitely worth the drive to Mayport. Enjoy the growing Arts District while you are there. read more

What an adorable little shop! With the sweetest staff members! They had pies by the slice as well as full pies and little 6 inch pies! I was craving a chocolate cream one so I went with the 6 inch Triple chocolate cream pie so I could bring it home to share with my husband! It had a lot of chocolate cream flavor and I loved the pie crust! Perfect dessert! Can't wait to try more in the future! read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Walking into the store I was greeted with a hello and a smile. Was shown the menu of the pies for the day, so many pies to choose from a slice or a whole pie. The feeling in this store is love for making pies as for their customers. Highly recommend this store and the PIES!!!! read more

Great service, delicious pies!! friendly people. All food is made fresh daily. Limited seating.

I've driven past this tooo many time to have never stopped in. I'm so glad I finally did bc I was soooooo satisfied with all my treats! Ordered a slice of margarita key lime and triple berry. A small 6in lemon meringue and key lime and everything was fresh and flavorful. The slices are plenty big and their selections are amazing! Everyone working was professional, inviting, and friendly! Can't wait to come and try more!! Thank you for a first great experience! read more

See all

Have purchased several several years ago. Good pies at high prices. I am accustomed to great pie from Hoosier Mamma in Evanston, IL.

We've passed this little pie shop every time we go to the Mayport Ferry & decided to stop in this time & get some pies for Easter. We were greeted by an adorable older lady who gave us the lowdown on all their pies that were listed on a board. We could see pies cooling on racks in the back where 2 ladies were busily making pies. It was late in the day & they were out of a few types of pies I would have liked to try like the corn bread, and chicken pot pie. The nice lady said they don't use any preservatives & everything is fresh baked. Their large pies are $42 which I think is a little steep but since I haven't tried them yet I can't be sure it's not worth it. I ended up purchasing 2 small pies which are $15 ea. one was an organic cherry & the other an apple with raisins and frosting. I'm saving them to bring to Easter dinner at a friend's. I was told they would keep in the fridge for a few days since they were so fresh. I will update on the taste. Upon paying the lady put my pies in a bag & added a pamphlet about Jesus. I guess there's nothing wrong with having some pie with the Lord. read more

Best pies and a kind, good-hearted owner! Thank you for all you do for our community.

These ladies put a lot of love in their pies. Fresh ingredients, home made everything, you will not be disappointed!

The staff was extremely friendly and the pie was amazing!!! Will definitely be back for more.

The pies here are just about as great as the lady's making them! Definitely a staple to the area!

I went today to to receive free pot pie that was offered to military families due to the government shut down. The staff was amazing and so sweet, literally one of the best pot pies I've had in years. I highly recommend trying their food. read more

I have heard from word of mouth I need to get here but just never seemed to be in the area until recently. I stopped by on a Friday evening and picked up some pies for 2 events the next day. My first was the Chicken pot pie. It was huge and weighty. We warmed it up in the oven as instructions stated until the homemade crust was browning and when it was cut you could see it was a truly a filled pie. It contained a gravy with vegetables like peas and organic chicken. It was delicious. My second choice was a coconut custard for my friends birthday and it was sooooo good, I may need to drive back a hour and get another soon. mmmmm Lots of choices and worth the stop.Look for the blue building! read more

See all

Lovely little shop making great pies! Very happy with the chicken pot pie; it's clear why it's a best seller. The chocolate bourbon pecan pie was fantastic as well. Great, flaky crust! read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Chicken Pot Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Great pie & very friendly staff. Best pie we found in the Jacksonville area. We'll be back!

All pies are so out of this world delicious that once consumed, one feels they have died and gone to Heaven. This truly is Pie Heaven. I am excited about going to Pie Heaven again and again. We truly can get a taste of Heaven while here on earth! Pie Heaven is Simply The Best!! read more

OMGawd! The smells rolling out the door overwhelm your senses! You want one of everything! Hahaha! Although, that could be expensive! This is their 8th anniversary and awesome incentives all week! I stopped in today for two chicken pot pies, along with a Quiche and a Coconut Custard for dessert! I have frozen the quiche for later and one of the chicken pot pies is going to a sick friend ... but this one is all mine! Filled with organic veggies and chunks of chicken - this is a fabulous meal! Run, don't walk to this cute little bldg along Mayport Rd. read more

See all

Not sure why I waited so long to check them out. This place is delicious! When NYE rolled around I figured this was the perfect time to get some pie. Located right off Mayport Road in a stand alone building. There is some parking to the side of the building. This is more of a pick up and take home type place however there were a few spots to sit in and eat if you choose. Service was excellent. The ladies at the front of the shop were so kind and patient. They helped me pick a variety of slices and instructed me on the proper way to reheat. Slices and whole pie choices rotate but honestly every single thing we got was beyond delicious. The chocolate pie was probably my fav! I will def be back for more goodies! read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

The peach pie I ordered was absolutely delicious! The peaches were not mushy but had texture to them. Not skimpy on the filling...there was at least 2 lbs of peaches in it. Everyone raved about it. Will definitely order from Pie Heaven...the pie was heavenly!!! read more

Ohhh the food is so good, I love pie so maybe I'm biased but wow. The service was amazing think she was the owner but little old lady so nice and thoughtful telling me about all their pies and such. Building was a little old but just what you'd expect for a family owned spot that been there for years. read more

Heh. No, the big one is not "family size". That is the proper size and the small one is a snack. A while back, I remarked that I'd hit every restaurant on Mayport road. This was definitely one of the last ones, even though I see it while driving past. It's local, delicious and convenient for the pandemic since I can take a pie and pop it in the oven at home. I do wish it wasn't quite so generic. Meat pies have incredible potential for umami and traditional American pies don't tap into it far enough in my humble opinion. One day I'll find a restaurant with a mutton curry pie or something more ridiculous, and it'll be my favorite. Until that day, I'm happy eating this. Ack, that's a lie; after that day, I'll still be happy eating this. Next visit is reserved for the quiche though. read more

See all

There isn't much room in the cafe. And by not much, I mean 3 small tables with little room to move BUT the key lime pie and chicken pot pie were delicious! Very hearty. The price however is also very hearty. Be prepared to shell out $$. read more

This was a dangerous stop... but I'm so glad I made it! They have so many option sweet and savory! I bought the berry pie and I was so happy with my purchase. I know what to expect now, and I will be sure to come back soon! read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Strawberry Rhubarb 6 inch pie - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Fantastic pies for every occasion! We've been super impressed with the sweet and savory pies we've sampled from Pie Heaven. Each pie has the most flaky, buttery crust and the savory pies are just as delightful as the sweet ones. Next time you need to bring a dish or you have a family and friend that needs a meal I suggest you stop at Pie Heaven! The chicken pot pie hot out of the oven has been my favorite savory pie for sure. This is a hidden little gem of a place that I'm so thankful we stubbled upon! read more

Happy pie day!! No doubt about it, these pies are delicious. Come out on 3/14 and get the best deals on their pies at $3.14 a slice (limit 4). If you come any other day of the year, ya, you'll probably pay more but the tender loving baking care that goes into each pie delivers some yummy bites. Don't let the run down little building prevent you from placing a pie order. There's space for about 9 seats inside... and on pie day, they set up an outside tent to hold another 8 seats. Eat dessert first. read more

See all

OMG, I've died and went to Pie Heaven! Located in a cute converted house, this place is simply amazing. The ladies that work there are friendly and sweet and the pies are just freaking fantastic. Seriously! My absolute fave is the chocolate bourbon pecan. They have about 15-20 on "tap" daily, which are available by the slice or whole. They also have savory pies (chicken pot pie, chili cornbread pie) and quiches. Do yourself a favor and get here ASAP :) read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Chocolate bourbon pecan pie - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

As you walk around the grocery store a lot of products say 'homemade' on them. Of course they are light years away from being homemade. As long time pie makers we can testify that Pie Heaven pies are about as close to homemade as you will ever find outside your own kitchen, and for those not familiar with the intricacies and mysteries of pie crust Pie Heaven pies are probably a lot better than 'homemade'. We have never been disappointed with a pie from Pie Heaven, and part of your enjoyment is knowing that you not only got to eat a great pie but you contributed to worthwhile charities. The folks at Pie Heaven are friendly, funny and committed to making great pies and to service. Pie Heaven is located in a small wooden building that looks like someone's home, and eating there is like eating in Grandma's kitchen. read more

Everything is amazing. I ordered the holiday pie and we all loved it so much 2 of our guests licked the plate. Quiche was to die for. A bit pricey and lady in the back is cranky but other than that I absolutely will be going back. read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Holiday pie was amazing - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Stopped in for their famous chocolate pie to bring to a friend's birthday dinner. Unfortunately (for us), they were sold out! Luckily for us, there were so many more options to choose from. Because I wasn't sure what to choose, I chose a lot. Haha Irish Cream pie (baileys on chocolate crust), chocolate bourbon pecan, key lime, and classic apple pie. I know these will be winners as well! Always a pleasure dealing with the beautiful ladies in this bakery! They were even sweet enough to give me cool packs to keep the cream pie cool while making a long drive. Thank you, ladies! read more

See all

The heavenly Tomato Souffle Pie will soon disappear. Do not pass go, do not collect 100$. Drive to PIe Heaven as soon as possible but call first! read more

After having this place bookmarked for a while, I decided to head over there for their new creation - a pineapple cream pie - that I'd seen in one of their advertisements. I happened to go on a great day as the whole pies were going for $22 instead of $33, as per a Facebook post. And, I went in the middle of happy hour which has a buy one, get one pie slice special. It really was wonderful timing! Given that it was hot outside, I thought that a pineapple cream pie would be great for a sweet and cool treat. The owner told me that she created a pineapple pudding with whipped cream folded in and she added whipped cream and pineapples on top. As they only had one left for the afternoon, I had called in to put the pie on hold. When I arrived, it was ready for me. I also decided to get the country chocolate and apple pie slices. While I waited for my pies to be boxed up, I tried a sample of the coconut custard pie and a pinwheel made from their crust. The pies were all good but the country chocolate was my favorite. The filling was rich and creamy and it was the sweetest of the three pies. The unsweetened crust balanced the whole thing out well. I enjoyed the pineapple cream pie but the filling needed a little more punch as it was pretty "one note" and the apple pie could've used some more cinnamon and sugar and less crust. I look forward to coming back to try their savory pies and perhaps more of their dessert pies. read more

See all

I'd leave 10 stars if I could. Nice people, incredible pies made from good ingredients, no preservatives or unpronounceable items. Blessed with love by the ladies in the kitchen. You must try their Strawberry Rhubarb pie, best I've had since my grandma's homemade pies. The Pecan Bourbon pie was to die for. Visit this place, you won't regret it. read more