They're open until 3am and deliver faster than freaky fast, forget your cold Jimmy John's sandwich and head to Pickleman's. This is the original location and has always been the best, usually less crowded that the one downtown on Broadway. The buffalo chicken is a favorite and asiago chicken is darn delicious, too. The also have soups, salads and pizzas, but a warm toasted sandwich is always the best pick. read more

Horrible customer service with the man working on September 4 at around 1 am. He messed up my two numbers 1# twice. He first did it with adding tomato and then leaving out the mayo and then said to leave after I told him that they forgot the mayo after I check the second time and said I was causing problems. I have never had any customer this horrible and I have work a bigger rush then the 10 customer that they had. The lady working with him was trying to soften the mess up and it wasn't her fault at at it was the dudes fault. And they didn't offer and compensation even after doing it twice I will never eat at this restaurant again. How is it on the customer when you mess up the order twice after the customer tells you what's supposed to be ok the sandwiches . read more

Great service and wonderful food always. Our favorite quick stop when we come in to town before a basketball game. The gentleman working, gave my son a chocolate chip cookie at the end of our dinner. Such a kind gesture. We promise to pay it forward. Thank you! read more

Ty for the amazing food and service. I don't get anyone's names unfortunately, however start to finis this is the best Picklemans ever! They never ever let us down. read more

Very rude employees, trying to close the store early. Wouldn't let us sit down or use the bathroom. And when I said what I didn't want on the sandwich they had a attitude read more

Delicious quick lunch to grab to go, enjoyed my sandwich more than expected and had to go back after work to get something for my husband because I just had to have him try their bread. Would definitely pick this place over any chain restaurant serving similar food. read more

They would not take my order. They were very rude, and had friends hanging out in the store. It was a very hostile environment!

Good food for decent price. Staff is friendly. I liked the smokehouse and the Cuban. Late hours are always a plus.

The staff working at this location from 8pm to 10pm could benefit from retraining in the areas of customer service and food handling. The Black male working the food service counter this evening that identified himself as the manager and refused to provide me with his name or the name of the store/general manager, smushed the bread of the sandwich he was attempting to make for me into the counter as he verbally berated me for inquiring about additional charges to my sub: Overall the staff looked like they were forced to be there against their will and it was clear that 8:30 pm they were either attempting to close early or deter current and potential customers from ordering so that they would not have to work and could continue to close early. I asked one of the female workers if they were closing early since it was only 8:30 pm and they'd already emptied the self-service strawberry and classic lemonades as if it were no longer available for purchase. I walked into the downtown Broadway location at 9 pm this evening and not only was there classic and strawberry lemonades STILL available for purchase AND self-service, they informed me that their lemonade would be available for purchase and service until their doors lock and their lobby empties out. I called the Old 63 location TWICE and asked to speak with a manager and was informed by the late evening/night staff (once by a female workers, and the second time by a male worker) that "it is against the HIPAA laws" to provide a customer with the name of a manager. The jokes literally write themselves! read more

This is just another Subway with a little better seating. Sandwiches aren't notable. It's OK if there isn't a Sonic or McDonald's nearby.

The guy behind the counter aus jus you in a clear ramekin with a non-matching white lid that did not stay on it (because it OBVIOUSLY wasn't made for it, not rocket science: it's colored to match, supposedly idiot-proof). I noticed once I was down the road and the whole car started smelling like aus jus. And I looked and realized it had all leaked out of the bag all over my seat and into every crack imaginable. Now my new car smells like beef and will probably forever. I brought it back in and asked them to explain, pointing at the matching lid that would've been the obvious choice. Rather than an apology I got a bunch of attitude. Unbelievable. The manager there is worthless. No apology, barely even gave me enough aus jus (this time in a proper container) to suffice. read more

Awesome as always, great food, friendly faces, fair prices and quick service!! Thank you! read more

I absolutely love Pickelman's. This place has the potential to become a super chain. The location on 9th street is known to me and all my friends for their excellent customer service! We try to go once a week. If you want a good rainy day soup and sandwich, this place is your place read more

Love the food from here! Anything in the menu is super awesome and pricing is fair as well

Just ordered my first Pickleman's pizza last week. Awesome! So I ordered another one this week. Same pizza had a $4 price increase! The Hog is now over $20!! Guess I'll just go elsewhere next time. Pappo's and even overpriced Shakespeare's is cheaper! Ouch! read more

While Pickleman's may be a bit pricey for a sandwich shop, you definitely get what you pay for. The food they serve is top-notch. I am pretty picky when it comes to the way I like my sandwiches made, and at Pickleman's they are always willing to make your sandwich however you like, with no eye-rolling or grunting. In addition to being delicious, the facility is absolutely spotless. Floors, counters, and tables are always clean. The staff is extremely friendly and quick, too! Delivery never takes too long at all. The only complaint I have with the business is that they used to forget items when delivering. They always corrected the mistake, and recently I haven't had any problems at all. If you haven't tried Pickleman's yet and you live in Columbia, it is DEFINITELY worth it. You won't be disappointed. read more

I placed an online order late at night around 1:15am when the place closes at 2am. I was surprised to see they were open that late on a Sunday (since most other food places were closed) but thankful as I had just finished my bartending shift at a local restaurant and was starving. My friend went inside to pick up the order and was informed they were out of meatballs for the sandwich but offered to replace it for any other item and the additional sandwich chosen was made promptly. The staff was kind and helpful and the food tasted amazing. Thank you! read more

This is the worst place customer service wise. Manager Brett Sheen was absolutely rude and unhelpful when I called to talk about driver Jamie Templeton. Jamie Templeton refused to give me change when I paid and after yelling at me over the phone, he rudely handed me my sandwich. I heard about how awful this location is but I never thought it would be this bad! Pickleman's need to re-train all of its employees at this location! read more

I order a pizza and they just give me in a box something completely different with onions when I'm allergic to onions When I call to replace my order they just want me to pay again for a new order when I even touch that pizza that they give me read more

I had the veggie pizza with no cheese, or parmesan cheese. Which was really good! The thin crust was perfect. Not to hard or soft. It was perfectly crisp to my liking! Delivery service was quick as well. They gave me a time and kept their promise. read more

This is usually one of my favorite places to go for a quick meal. Their food is solid as I enjoy both their pizzas and sandwiches. In my last visit the experience was ruined by terrible service. The workers seemed stressed to the max and I could tell they didn't want to be there. What resulted was 2 messed up orders out of 3. The pizza we ordered was very under cooked and the workers asked us what the standard toppings were for our sandwiches because they didn't know what goes on them. As well as it taking nearly 10 minutes to get our food when it is usually less than a 5 minute process. Very disappointed in this visit. read more

We ordered salads for delivery. One Avo Cobb and cranberry walnut. We would order them again. Love the idea that you can add what you want.

Like location. Grand daughters favorite place. I had Southwest Salad and found it fresh and satisfying. Staff very nice too

Best darn service I've ever had at a place. I walked in and they gave me a hug and asked how my day was going before taking my order. The best part about it all was when I was short 5 cents, the cashier took a nickel out of his pocket for me to use. What a great place to eat! read more

The Asiago Chicken sandwich is fantastic and worth ordering while the Asiago Chicken pizza is tasty but greasy. The sweet tea is also top notch and the touch screen soda machine makes it possible to create an Arnold Palmer. Pickleman's is better than Jimmy John's but a tad expensive. I would recommend it to anyone willing to pay a little extra for better food. read more

Over priced basic sandwiches. Cookies are good. I've had nothing but bad experiences with trying to get my meal delivered from them. Please replace all Pickleman's in Columbia with something better. read more

The sandwiches are really good... I've gone here more times than i care to count. It's been one of my favorites. So picklemans, i say this with love, but this place has the worst delivery service. Every single time i've ordered delivery, i've either waited an obscene amount of time or my order has been screwed up. I waited over 2 hours for a sandwich once. Also, they dont have those sleeves to put the pizza in while they deliver it to keep it warm, so pizza shows up at room temperature. Also, they recently changed up what toppings go in their salads, but didn't update them online or in the store, so the salad you order will have different toppings. read more

This is a good place to venture to for a quick meal. They have a variety of sandwiches and pizza. Their service is usually pretty good. However, Jimmy Johns, Potbelly's, and Subway are better in terms of price and quality. Pickleman's is a nice and quick eat but is just too similar and has to compete with all the other better sandwich places in town. read more

I have been ordering from pickleman's for the past 4 years and would recommend to all if you are looking for a good sandwich or thin crust pizza. Their delivery time is always between 35-45 minutes and will be longer towards the end of the night when people are getting out of the bars. it is very comparable to potbelly. I suggest getting the grilled cheese and tomato soup combo...it is a great price and is amazing. read more

Open late and food is always good, but late night worker absolutely sucks. Incredibly rude. Puts up closed sign so he can stand outside. We pulled up at 1 and asked if they were open and he told "technically until 2" with the rudest tone and gestures and then proceeded to make up wait inside until he decided he was done with his break. Don't sign up for late night shifts if you're going to get mad when people actually come in. read more

Excellent service and excellent food. I enjoy eating here and look forward to trying more of the sandwiches. Thanks Jaime.

Great toasted sandwiches but not very filling for the price, friendly service and good atmosphere read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - BBQ chicken sandwich with tomato - Pizza Near Me - Columbia, Missouri

Sandwiches are pretty good. Smaller than expected but that's ok for the price. Salads are awesome. Broccoli cheese soup is great. Ordered delivery & an item was missing ( something small ). We were unpacking so I was too tired & busy to worry about it. We will order again because of the salads. read more

The only reason I go here is because it's open late and it taste good but when I called to order my food the man who answered the phone was incredibly rude and when I got home the pizza wasn't even cut at all. read more

Looked on Yelp for some local flavor and skip the national chains and discovered this establishment. Good food and service- think Jimmy Johns or Potbelly. Nothing over the top, but solid choice. The map on Yelp was way off, just saying. read more

This is a really solid sub shop. I've gone here about once a year every year since 2010 and the quality, flavor, service, and atmosphere has remained constant throughout. Their ingredients were fresh, love the toasted subs, the bread is good, and I never leave going, "Man, I wish ____ was different." read more

I work literally a few blocks from this location and have utilized online ordering twice. And both times my order took about an hour and 10 minutes to get to me. My order was placed at 11:02am. The receipt was printed at 11:50am. Delivered at 12:10am. Their food would probably be great if it hadn't been sitting out that whole time. Today was grilled cheese and tomato soup. Soup was luke warm and the grilled cheese was cold. Nasty. I will give anyone a second chance. Never again. read more

Not a bad place to eat. On par with Jimmy John's. A step above subway. They have won some "best of Columbia awards"

One of my favorite sandwich shops in town. They have high quality, delicious sandwiches. I love the bread and their pickles, my favorite is the Turkey Bacon club and I get it with shredded cheddar instead of provolone. They always remember me and start my order as I walk in the door. read more

I absolutely love Pickleman's food but this location's customer service is horrendous. In my last visit, they ruined my sandwich order. The employees and manager were also rude to one another and to the customers! When I was checking out, I tried scanning my loyalty app and it didn't work. After multiple attempts, the employees and manager had no idea how to fix it. This isn't my first terrible experience at this location. I would rather drive out of my way than go to this Pickleman's again. read more