We achieved our first pregnancy (and child) with Dr. Chenette's help, so I should be giving him 5 stars no matter what. But I have some misgivings. Mostly, I don't feel that he listened to me or trusted that I understood my body.
1. When I first talked to another doctor at the PFC, she said she didn't want her patients to chart their cycles; she didn't want to work with me that way. I was then assigned Dr. Chenette, who, I was told, was amenable to his patients charting. And so he became my doctor. But it wasn't true; he refused to discuss my charting results or listen to any knowledge I had to offer about my body.
2. Even though my tests were normal, he still insisted it must be an ovulation problem (I believe that is all they really know how to treat). He therefore pushed me to take Clomid the month of the IUI and to give myself the hCG shot the day before the IUI to ensure ovulation (even though my body functioned like clockwork). I obeyed, and the IUI worked, so I never thought back on it, until we were ready for our second child. With my second pregnancy, I felt less desperate and was more assertive with how I wanted to run the show. I insisted on a natural-cycle IUI (no Clomid, no hCG), and, as I knew it would, it worked.
3. When I came in for an ultrasound for my 2nd pregnancy, it was a Friday. Dr. Chenette said the follicles didn't look big enough and that he was sure I wouldn't ovulate over the weekend, so I wouldn't need the IUI until Monday. I insisted I was going to ovulate on the weekend; I knew my own signs. I was trying to understand their hours and how it worked if you found out you were ovulating on a Sunday--who was in the office and at what time? Dr. Chenette skimmed over my question and told me that if it made me feel better, I could take an Ovulation Predictor Kit test on Saturday morning and if it was negative, I could wait until Monday to come into the office. But I knew better, so I took one test on Saturday morning (negative) and then one again at night (ovulating!). I started calling the office at 6am on Sunday and they told me to waste no time coming in. The IUI I had that morning (administered by Dr. Givens, whom I found infinitely more confident, warm, and nurturing) was successful, and that afternoon I felt my final ovulation cramp--I was done ovulating. Monday would have been too late.
So, my ultimate opinion of Dr. Chenette is: use him as a tool, but trust yourself first. I guess I the same is true about most doctors, but once in a while you find a doctor in whose hands you feel completely at ease, and let yourself check out while s/he does all the thinking. IMO, Dr. Chenette is not that doctor. (But the baby we got from the IUI he administered is such an AWESOME kid, I almost gave Chenette 5 stars.) read more