I consider myself a pizza connoisseur. I've tried it from New York to California and everything in between. This...this majestic pizza is fantastic. You can tell from the first bite it's different. The sauce, a little sweet, a little saucy, a little bit of love, is probably one of the best marinaras I've ever had. My wife and I got a Large with the Garlic Butter Parmesan crust, pepperoni, pineapple (i don't care what you say, pineapple is good on pizza), and mushrooms. Garlic Knots. And the cinnamon bites for desert. The smell emanating from the box made our mouths water the whole way home. And they did not disappoint. Everything was amazing. To top it off, Steve who I'm guessing is the owner, was so personable he made us feel like we've been part of the family for years. Just a genuinely good human, which is hard to find these days. To say I'll be back is an understatement. This is my forever go to as long as Steve is running the show. New customers, don't hesitate to order this pizza. Top notch. If I could give it 12 stars I would. I don't leave many reviews, but my wife Michelle and I had to leave one here. This place needs to be known. Dave Portnoy would definitely give this a super high rating. Thanks again for an amazing meal. We WILL be back. And soon. No pictures....we demolished it. read more

This is our second time eating here and I've enjoyed each time very friendly owners And staff! They even have video games that are free while you wait for your pizza, small eat in dining area. Pizza was excellent love the homemade sausage. read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Sorry we ate it before we took a picture sausage and pepperoni pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

Wow. I was craving pizza and felt like trying a local spot I hadn't had yet, didn't expect to find my new go-to. I can't believe I hadn't heard of them before. Came on here to show some love and apparently I'm not alone! There's plenty of good local pizza around but sometimes it's out of my price range so I divert to a chain location. Petey's somehow offers chain prices with incredibly tasty homemade pizza. I will be back, many times. Especially to try their salads which look delicious. 5 stars Petey. read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Greek Pizza with Tomato Garlic Mix - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

See all

First time trying Petey's pizzeria and I am completely satisfied, Best antipasto salad I've ever had made with such love & such fresh ingredients....mozzarella balls, deliciously seasoned and with all the fixings. AMAZING!!!! The pizza was delicious as well, perfectly cooked with a delicious sauce to complement the perfectly crispy crust, Great cheese blend and delicious pepperonis to set it all off... before we left the store he opened the salad and the pizza to show us which I appreciate as well.... Not to mention this pizzeria is 10 minutes plus from my house and still was perfect by the time I got it home... I will most definitely be back thanks for caring about your product!! #supportlocalbusinesses read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza made perfect! - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

See all

I've been looking for some good pizza and saw the reviews for Petey's so I headed on over to Warren. We were running errands and were excited to find they have two booths. We ordered and chatted with the owner a bit. This place does mostly takeout since there's limited seating, so keep that in mind. Our garlic knots and pizza were everything I was looking for. There are also classic arcade games that you can play for free while you want. The owner is a great guy and has a ton of repeat regulars. I'm looking forward to going back and checking out more from the menu. Oh, get the ranch!! It's made in house and is top tier. read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

See all

Wow. This place is legit. I tried it today and got the Thin round pie. It was fantastic. They definitely know what they're doing.

Friendly staff! Excellent pizza and bread ! 10/10 ! Love what Steve has done with the place ! read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

If you're looking for another blah pizza place keep looking because peteys is the opposite of that! The chicken parm pizza and calzone are the quintessential foods for any mouth. The way Steve and his crew CARE shows in every single thing they craft. If you love amazing food crafted with care using ONLY the very BEST ingredients then peteys is your place!!! Love Ray! Best customer EVER! read more

Peter is doing everything right! Garlic knots have fresh crushed garlic and fresh herbs. The care he puts into a salad is unreal. Those aren't canned beets. The lettuce is fresh and crunchy. The pizza is sooo good. This dude cares and he is there every night. read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Large pizza with pep and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

See all

Wife and I have been looking for a good pizza place for a while now. Jet's is nothing like it used to be and Buddy's has gone down hill in my opinion too. Saw the reviews for Petey's and decided to give it a try. When we walked in Steve, the owner, was cordial and friendly. Talked to him about the pizza and he explained everything that I needed to know. Ordered a Meat Lover's with green peppers and mushrooms. It was very good! Pizza had lots of toppings on it, just as it shows in the pictures online. All in all, we were very happy with the taste of the pizza. It was really, really good. The owner, Steve seems to be a dedicated, and hardworking person. He takes pride in the food he serves and makes sure that it is up to his standards, as well as the customer. Will gladly make this our "go to" pizza place from now on. read more

We tried the square Veggie pizza and it was delicious. Awesome Veggie Pizza with great customer service for very reasonable prices. Definitely must try!!! read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

From placing my order via phone to pick up, customer service was top notch! I ordered the family deal- 2 pizzas one round and one square, bread sticks, meatballs and spaghetti. Food was great! My son enjoyed playing free video games while we waited for our order! Definitely will be back! read more

Petey's is so conveniently close to my home. All the staff, & owner, are super friendly & helpful. And, best tasting local pizza, of all-time! You must try Petey's Pizza! read more

The salad was amazing ! The staff was great! I was a little disappointed in the pizza as the underside of the crust was a bit scorched.

Great pizza, everyone that has tried it with me has loved it also. My son's friends say it slaps.

Welcome to the neighborhood! We ordered two pies tonight to try our favorite toppings. They knocked it out of the park. A good looking pizza that was delicious. They have remodeled the space to include seating and a few nice video games. I can't wait to work my way through the menu to try their other offerings. read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Menu Sept. 2021 - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

This place is back!!! From Salvatores to Petey's - finally a good Italian pie. Stopped in on my birthday for a pie and cheese bread. Played some arcade games as we waited. The staff was super friendly and the food was amazing. Back to being one of the best pies in Detroit. Pizza the way I was raised. I will be back many times for the amazing taste and supreme service. Just looking to see if they can do a BLT :) read more

Hands down, jets pizza has tough competition when it comes to this place! The customer service is top notch and their pizza and bread was absolutely mouthwatering delicious! I have to admit, I have my only go to pizza place now and no longer jets! Their food is handcrafted with love and you can see it in the result. You've got to give this a try and support local business!! read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Small Cheese Bread - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

See all

Ordered a salad, meatballs, garlic knots and wings. Wings - amazing. But the wings are not tossed in sauce but uou dip them, they are plain. FYI. The meatballs looked good but were way too salty for my wife and I. She ate one and I had to eat the rest with rice. It's better with rice. Salad meat also very salty, but that's just probably due to brand of deli meat. Haven't tried the pizza yet so I might update when I do. read more

See all

Peteys Pizzeria makes a great pizza. The crust has a nice crisp, the sauce is flavorful without overpowering, and the cheese is melted just right. Simple, fresh, and exactly what you want from a local spot. read more

I went to Petey's Pizzeria for the first time today. The guy who waited on me was super nice. I ordered a medium Hawaiian Pizza with pepperoni added to half. I wasn't really a fan of the sauce. The crust was excellent. My husband liked it. I also ordered the garlic knots but didn't care for them. I would say definitely give them a try. I'm gonna try their salads next. I'm pretty hard to please when it comes to pizza. It wasn't that bad, I just didn't care for the sauce that much. They have daily specials too! Looking forward to trying other things. read more

We were in the Detroit area for a baseball tournament and discovered this place on our next to the last night. After our last game my son couldn't wait to stop here again. We ate almost all of the garlic knots in the car. And the antipasto salad was the as pretty as it was delicious! And both nights our order was ready before the expected time. Will definitely stop again next time we are in the area! read more

While I haven't had a chance to try their pizza, I have to give all the stars to this place for their communication and helpfulness. We were scheduled to come into Warren with a large group. I called ahead to find out if they could accommodate our order and I have to say I have never had a more helpful experience than I did speaking with Petey's. They talked through our needs, suggested some things, gave clear information on when to order by, were willing to deliver a large order and helped us making decisions. In the end, weather canceled our visit, but because of the helpfulness, kindness, and excellent communication I would absolutely order here and encourage others to do so! This place is run very well and is customer focused. read more

The Greek salad was really good and very fresh. The pizza was just okay. I was disappointed in the mushrooms on the pizza as they were very tiny pieces and there were hardly any of them. I don't think they were fresh either. Service was good. The place is really cool inside and would be a fun place to take your kid! read more

Ordered some food for the second time from Peteys and it didn't disappoint! Garlic Knots, Antipasta Salad, boneless chicken, Italian BMT sub and calzone. Boneless chicken was very flavorful and so were the sauces! Antipasta was a true Antipasta with olives and seasoning, very flavorful. Calzone and Sub were both hot, fresh. Support local, support Peteys - you won't be disappointed! read more

Me and my coworkers recently started checking this place out even though it's a little outside our normal pizza-pickup zone. Now, this is the only place we get pizza. They have garlic knots. Petey's way crust is the best thing ever. There's arcade games. Everyone is super friendly. I only wish it was closer to my house. read more

We aren't from the area and we went based on the reviews and we do not regret it! We were welcomed warmly given plenty of time and answers to our questions about the menu. Steve talked with us about the stores origin story and how it came to be. Very inspiring local providing quality food and service to the community! The food was amazing! We got a large pizza, garlic knots, and the pepperoni chips all 10/10! We played a few rounds of the arcade games and took in the beautiful renovations. This is the pizzeria you need to visit in Warren. I will be traveling back from Ann Arbor again. Can't recommend enough! read more

See all

We had an excellent experience here. Steve went above and beyond to make our takeout order a reality. Pizza was excellent, service was outstanding, cannot recommend enough! We will definitely be back every time we are in the area! read more

Very delicious pizza, and what compliments this place even more is the people who run it. 10/10 recommend. Best pizza in the Area by far

One of the best pizza places in metro Detroit. We had the Hawaiian, a pepperoni and mushroom, and garlic knots. Everything was amazing. The building was cool too, with arcade games to play while you wait for your pizza. Will be ordering again soon. read more

Petey's is our favorite pizza place! The service is great and you can't beat their garlic knots! Everything is delicious but we highly recommend the barbecue chicken pizza. We've been loyal customers since it opened in 2021 and it comes highly recommended from our whole family! read more

Wow this pizza place tastes Ike authentic pizza from Italy!! Beyond amazing! You will truly enjoy the food! Highly reccomend.

This is my favorite pizza place. Very cozy and welcoming. The food is always fresh and delicious. The wings are juicy yet crispy best in town. The staff is so sweet and accommodating. My kids love the free arcade games in the store. I recommend everyone trying this place it's awesome. read more

Looking for a late night snack and I came across Peteys. I had never heard of them but after seeing all the excellent reviews I decided it would be worth trying. We ordered a small pizza , steak sub and BMT sub. Even though doordash gave me a snail of a delivery driver and my food was luke warm upon arrival the pizza was still excellent with a very tasty sauce and freah ingredients. The steak sub was one of the best I have had. You could easy the sautéed onions and the sub bun alothough crisp k the out side was nice and soft on the inside making this sandwich a home run. One thing I noticed with my order was the top quality of the products they use. There is no skimping here. My suggestions are ordering direct skipping door dash and trying the pizza and steak sub. Two picks you cant go wrong with. My son ended up having the BMT incase you are asking yourself what we thought of that. He too raved about how good the meat was and that he liked how they layed the meat and cheese. read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Salami , Pepperoni, provalone sub yummy - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

Husband and I ordered a large supreme pizza and an "anti pasta" salad. The salad was hand cut, not "bag 'o salad" and had fresh mozzarella. The pizza was outstanding with fresh ingredients. Will definitely order again. read more

I didn't know about this gem until I scavenged for Pizzeria's nearby. I live so close, yet I had never noticed it! 10/10 service, and the food is sososo good. They took care of us immediately, and were so welcoming. Definitely will be visiting again read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Monday Special: 2 Medium 2 Topping, and Garlic Bread for 24.99 - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan

Fantastic Pizza and salad. Delivery was quick the food was hot and fresh. I can't wait to order more

My office is nearby and I tried every restaurant in this area. The postman delivered a flyer for Petey's. I wanted to try something new. I didn't know they existed. OMgosh. It was not a mistake!! I had the rigatoni with alfredo...they make it fresh. I ordered a small veggie pizza with alfredo instead of the regular pizza sauce. Great all around. Garlic knots were great also. I go there almost every week. read more

Newer place. Found them on yelp. Have only tried the pizza here, but it's great. Looking to try some of their other items soon!

This is my boyfriend and I's go to pizza pace since we just moved to the area! The butter garlic parm crust is to DIE FOR! I ordered from them the first time and literally had dreams about the pizza that night because it was so fantastic. I most recently ordered this past Friday, May 6th around 9pm and it was amazing yet again. Whoever the gentlemen is that was working that shift, thank you!! The pizza was fantastic and he was so nice! The only small beef I have with this place is that they are somewhat inconsistent. Sometimes they forget the garlic butter parm crust (which is my fav part). But other than that, you've gained a loyal customer! read more

Petey’s Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Warren, Michigan