My husband and I were at the Brunswick County Botanical Garden for a bit. We were hungry for lunch, so I googled and found this place. It had a 4.5 star rating. The interior is tiny with 4-5 small tables. There is outside dining at picnic tables but there were no umbrellas. We ordered the margarita pizza and added sausage and mushrooms, a large one. We always like left over pizza. We were given a basked of garlic knots. They were delicious but were swimming in butter and olive oil. The pizza was very good and I always like a thin crust. The sauce was tasty but I thought the sausage was flavorless. My husband disagreed with me. The girls behind the counter were very nice and friendly. If we are in the area, we'll definitely go back. There are other items on the menu that sound great. read more

See all

I thought the name of this place was funny but the pizza is legit ! We ordered 4 different kinds of pizzas and they all were great. Definitely try the Margherita, was my absolute favorite! read more

Lived in BSL for a while, now in Winnabow and we still go here because it's good, fresh and consistent. The team is always friendly and we've never had a delivery or pickup order missing anything. We've probably had pizza on about 15 different occasions here and it's always good, always perfectly cooked, always the same amount of ingredients. The crust has a good flavor and the right amount of chew. The sauce tastes pretty good to me. My absolute favorite is the double double which is double cheese and double pepperoni. Super good! Also tried a few of the different hot and cold subs which were all good and they make a really good loaded salad too. Tried the chicken parm and although decent, rhe chicken seemed to be previously frozen or the Tyson precooked variety. The garlic knots, wings and fried apps are all pretty good although standard frozen US foods type stuff. I read these negative reviews complaining about the quality, taste and price... I'm sorry but I just don't get it. This place is legitimately good. The price? Sorry but this ain't little Caesars or Domino's with a coupon and it's still cheaper than Bambinis, Pizzettes, Mo's woodfired, Sebbys etc. The quality is good, it's what you would expect from a small pizzaria. Definitely better than Dry street and blows away the chains. The taste? Look it's not the best pizza in the world but it's good. Good enough to hit that pizza craving spot and good enough to want again. Give this place a shot and see what you think. read more

See all

Lasagna was delicious!! We just moved to BSL and was recommended to try them. Friday night is the only time for lasagna. Friendly southern servic read more

Being a local I know this place all too well. They make sure to charge you the absolute most while providing you with the least amount of food as possible. The subs are these tiny short little subs with 3 slices of meat. Steak and cheese? Forget about it, Both ends are all bread, with a tiny little scoop of meat in the middle . Chicken Calzones? Only 2 chicken tenders in the entire thing, but they charge you $18. For $18 I can make a calzone at home to feed my entire neighborhood using the portions this restaurant uses. Mozzarella Sticks? 6 little sticks for $10 after tax. Once you look at them you'll think to yourself, $10 for these tiny things? Rip off. Pizza? Expensive and very inconsistent as it's always undercooked. Saying well done means nothing. The first time I said well done, the pizza somehow came out more undercooked than the last pizza we ordered. It's a disaster. And guess what? They have one of those stand and look at you while you fill out the tip slip even though they're only providing counter service. It's awkward. So not only do they provide you with portions that highly favor the business, they also want you to pay their employees wages for a service they don't even provide. Theres no pizza/sub place in all Brunswick county I'd recommend less than this place. read more

Have tried this place several times and they just can't get it right. I'm not the only one who seems to ask for a well done pie and it comes out undercooked. How how is it to leave it in the oven just a few more minute. read more

Again today stopped in to order the special. Wet, soggy and disgusting is how I personally describe the mess they handed me. Of course it was too late because I took it home to eat. The crust was nothing but thin crap. No texture nor taste. Wet soggy crap. Hate it when Joe is not there. read more

I've tried them three or four times now. Pretty good, high-quality ingredients super friendly staff with an average amount of wait time for your food. My brother says the salads are amazing. read more

Today's special was a large one topping pizza, and an order of garlic knots. ($16.02 total) Pizza was delicious, and the garlic knots were great as well. Glad I came here instead of going to a chain pizza place in Southport. read more

Stopped by for a large pie and a Greek salad. Explained that my son has a deadly allergy to peppers and to keep any off the salad. Returned home to find the salad covered with peppers. When I called to let the restaurant know, I explained that I wasn't interested in a refund and that I only wanted to let them know for training purposes due to the severity of my sons allergy. I was sorely disappointed with the response. Argumentative, hostile and flippant to say the least. This place has great food, but our experience today was awful. read more

Great food great service. Cheap lunch. Will add toppings and heat your lunch. Cheap fast and easy

Great food great service! One of the only places that can deliver where I love and they're always fast.

Pizza was very good. Staff is very nice. Garlic knots were good. We will surely try again.

Pretty good pizza spot. I tried some pepperoni pizza, a piece of the BBQ chicken Stromboli, and the Greek salad. This was a great restaurant to pick up lunch from, and I am happy with my experience there. read more

Pepperoni Grill - Greek salad - Italian Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

Wings cold and not cooked all the way! Stromboli was nothing special. Not worth it for the expensive price! read more

Fantastic pizza, subs, garlic knots and lasagna. If you want the lasagna make sure you get it early. Check the website for the day.

Good pizza and sandwiches- especially for delivery or take out. Dining in is an option but they are so popular it's hit or miss to get a seat. read more

I got a large pizza from here. There were so many huge bubbles in the pizza and it came burnt. The crust was extremely thin so the topping just kept sliding right off the pizza including the cheese and all. The delivery service was good and in came in good timing. I have never eaten in at this place so I can't speak on the atmosphere. read more

They have a sign on one of the roads and it sure did grab our attention. We had a large pepperoni pizza and cheese calzone. We kept it simple and truly enjoyed the meal. The staff were also very friendly. Great little local spot. read more

Consistently good pizza, wings, salads, subs, pasta, etc. Always fresh and hot. Love the Veggie pizza and Friday Night Lasagna. My kids always ask for the Garlic Knots. The Buddha Sub from the "Hidden Menu" is my favorite sandwich. Free Local Delivery, though we're close enough I've never used it. A BSL Institution. read more

Always friendly and super fast delivery. The food is ALWAYS amazing even if you're just getting a salad. Highly recommend.

First time eating here. What a find !!! 2 pieces of pizza and a drink with garlic knots for $6.00 during lunch. It's a no brained. I wish I had known about this years ago. read more

Beware ordering take out. Use paper bags which are stapled. Got home to find sauce and garlic butter from knots soaked into the passenger seat. I called to complain. Molly the manager said she knows how to package food, laughed and hung up on me. Food is good, but I don't want my car ruined. read more

Best pizza around BSL. Molly and Joe are the best. If you see them working , you know it's going to be great. Ian's a D-bag but you just have to get past that. read more

Very good and close to home. They also deliver which is wonderful! So glad to have them in the neighborhood!

Amazing pizza and service! Sometimes can be little slow due to being the only pizza place in Boiling Springs but the Oak Island restraunt is beautiful right on the water! Always a great meal from here! Try the chicken parm. sub! read more

Everything about Pepperoni Grill is amazing. Local, fresh and delicious. We order just about every Friday. The Mac n cheese bites are a hit in our house hold not to mention the garlic knots! read more

I love pizza. And I live in a large city where we have lots of pizza options. But the Pepperoni Grill could give just about any of my local pizzerias a run for their money. It's a pizzeria so don't expect anything fancy inside. And they don't serve alcohol so plan on carry-out if you just have to have a beer or wine with your pizza. They make their own crust. You can get thin crust or hand tossed. We had a vegetable garden thin crust and a hand tossed carnelicious- sausage, pepperoni, and sliced meatballs. Both were excellent. I kept tasting little bits of roasted garlic on my pizza- it was fabulous. This place is well worth the drive if you live in Southport or near one of the beaches. read more

Pretty good pizza and wings. Pizza is a little light on topping, but dough,sauce and cheese are very good. Either location BSL or OKI food is consistent. read more

Staff and pie are in total sync here! Great staff. Tasty pie. The little garlic knots are hot bundles of finger licking fun. Best of Southern hospitality--nice, courteous, will serve you at the table. Make you feel welcomed without feeling "fake". Unless you're traveling along this road, you probably wouldn't go out of your way to visit PG. That would be sad. read more

Let me start by saying I like their food, and they are close to where I live, so I order from them fairly often. That being said, I am very disappointed, in fact angry about their policy for using the coupons they send me in my email. I participate in a points program. Occasionally I get an offer for some discount. Tonight it was buy a pizza, get a second 50% off. I call them for delivery, place my order and tell them I have a coupon. They tell me that I can only use it if I come in the store. I ask why, and get several lame excuses about people lying about the coupon, or using them more than once etc. Expressing my disappointment makes no difference. It is a "management decision." It makes no sense. Why have the stupid points program if it only serves to piss off the customer? I'm hungry and tired and don't feel like arguing to no avail, so I placed the order anyway. That is how they get away with the lame policy. It will absolutely affect my future decisions to buy from them. I am now going to cancel my involvement with the point program so as not to be tempted to buy from them again. Fair Warning if you think that coupon is any good. It's not. In addition the few bucks I would have saved is no exchange for my time and frustration. I absolutely hate stupidity. read more

Who closes at 8:30 on Saturday 2-3-2018? Have 20 people at my house trying to order all kinds of pizza. Probably a 100$ order at least. Dissapointing read more

Absolutely delicious! It's worth a special trip to BSL. Love this place, the food and people! I always get the calzone, everything is always fresh and superb. Best pizza in town by the way, don't pass it up! :) read more

Pepperoni Grill - Best pizza in town!! - Italian Near Me - Southport, North Carolina

A must try Pizza place. Their warm welcoming attitude made our experience excellent. The pizza was fabulous and the taste just unique. The price...very reasonable. Definitely a 5 star... read more

This is the only pizza that I can still eat because of acid reflux. Their sauce is sweeter and their pizza isn't filled with grease. I love the thin crust and the price is great!! read more

Everything I have tried there I have liked. Everything is delicious, especially the eggplant parm, the wings, calzones and lasagna on Fridays! I highly recommend it for a casual, family friendly, lunch or dinner. read more

We live in Southport and twice in four weeks we have paid them a visit only for them to tell us that they were serving guests in their facility first, then handling to go orders. So tonight we were told a 90 min wait for a takeout. Worst service in town by far. read more

Great place. Wish it was around years ago. Great pizza, staff and beer. It was a pleasant surprise to find a place that appreciates fresh ingredients in BSL. Best in Brunswick county. read more

Great pizza, calzones and subs. Awesome staff. Give them your number and be signed up for reward points toward free food.

Yummy food! Staff is very nice. They messed up one of my orders and fixed it before I even knew it was messed up.