As far as those I know from the plays I attend, local theater-enthusiasts feel naked without their weekly email from Funsavers (aka phillyfunguide). Every Thursday I peruse my Funsavers email for all the 1/2 price theater tickets that week, and check the website for what's going on around town. While I have heard People's Light advertised on WRTI (which targets a limited local audience, pretty much identical to those who already attend), I have NEVER seen People's Light on Funsavers' weekly list, which tells me they aren't interested in arriving on the greater theater scene, and prefer the bubble in which they currently exist.
I guess this is because they are fat and lazy with their local patrons, and can't be bothered to draw from the same crowd that every other theater in the greater Philly/Wilmington/S-NJ area does. Maybe if diverse people from all over came to see what People's Light is like, they might give smarter reviews, based on comparisons to better experiences, and word would get out that People's Light is not so great after all. What I am trying to say is, I find it really lame that this theater is like FUBU (for us by us) for Malvern and nearby Mainline, and nothing else. The plays are all about stuffy bourgeois white people, and the playgoers are all stuffy bourgeois white people. Any treatment of non-whites is performed in the uber-PC patronizing fashion, which equates more to masked racism, rather than to any actual empathy and genuine equality/respect.
Sometimes locals get hung up on a place and think it's better than it is because it's their own home-grown venue. In consideration of all the Greater Philadelphia Area has to offer in terms of theater, and after years of research (i.e. theater experiences all over) I have come to the conclusion that Malvern and its local ilk, is full of itself to give this place a 4+ star rating.
My mother was one of the first to subscribe to People's Light, and through her, I've seen more than my fair share of performances there.
Having experienced a lot of theater throughout my life, and with the analytic background of English degrees, I really want to get to the grit/meat/heart of a play, and to hear and see the playwrites' words explored within an inch of their meaning. I am not impressed by how chic the building is, or if they have a trendy adjacent cafe, nor do I care to mingle and people-watch during intermission. If that is all theater is to you (like my mother), then People's Light is the place for you. Theater is a lot more than that for me, and People's Light is NOT the place for me.
I was lucky enough to attend U-Penn's summer-in-London course, filled with 15+ outings to theater throughout London and its environs. That fabulous experience inspired me. Since then I've sought theater relentlessly locally, as well as experiences everywhere I go. Costumed dramas on stage in Viet Nam, theater in New Zealand, D.C., Boston, NYC, and Blackfriars in Staunton, VA (the equivalent of a World Heritage Site for Bard fans).
Of all the theater I've seen, I am offended by the soap operatic acting and distractingly opulent sets at People's Light. It seems that if this place has the kind of endowment to fund sets with more decorating and detail than most people's actual homes, they might want to allocate some of that toward better direction or actors.
The predominately Baby-Boomer crowd of patrons didn't seem to notice that the acting and play selection was lame compared to less-endowed playhouses. If they are anything like my mother's friends, they are too doped on Paxil and wine to notice. And THAT is the kind of crowd this place seems to cater to. Dunno, good theater is just my taste, maybe it's not for everyone.
----------------------------------------------------------
If you too have been disappointed by People's Light, or would like to branch out and compare, here are some suburban venues where you will find better theater than People's Light:
Players Club of Swarthmore (2nd stage productions), Swarthmore, PA
Old Academy Players, Mannayunk, PA
Hedgerow Theater, Media, PA
Footlighter's Theater, Berwyn
Spotlight Theater, Swarthmore, PA read more