We found Penny Jo's in the summer of 2024. Since then, we visited numerous times. It is located in Washington Heights, a nice bar with lots of counter seats, and a handful of tables as well. We had many different types of cocktails and food. The atmosphere, their offerings, and the people keep us coming back again and again. They have weekly specials for both food and drinks, on top of their regular menu. All the drinks we've had there has always been strong and high quality. From the food menu, we had Bavarian Pretzel, French Onion Grilled Cheese, Muffuletta Sandwich, Baked Mac & Cheese, and many more. One of our favorite is the Pretzel, and it is HUGE! You can see how big it is when we put it in front of my hubby's face! We got to talk to one of the managers, Seth. He was super friendly, helpful, and fun to talk to. The other staffs were really welcoming too. They do lots of live music there as well, although we never go during the live music hours. We really enjoyed all the food and drinks we've tried here. Always a good time, and aways feeling wanting to come back again for more. Such a great neighborhood spot. read more

See all

The manager, Seth, has made me feel welcome and happy on many visits to this bar with excellent food and drinks. First thing, look at the chalk board for the specials on food and drink. There is an interesting groups of people that come here. There are people from the local hospital or university and the local neighborhood. I love a salty jumbo pretzel with a cocktail. The sandwiches and other food are consistently excellent. They also have live music and a full calendar. I am grateful to have such a solid local bar with proprietor such as Seth and his staff. read more

Penny Jo's - Bars Near Me - New York, New York

This is one of the bars local to the Washington Heights community. It's frequented by people who work and are students of Columbia medical center such as myself. It's a small unassuming place with a limited menu of snacks and drinks, but it's enough to serve its purpose as a fun place to gather with friends/colleagues after work. The meat and cheese board was cool and had a good variety of things. The pretzel was freshly baked, but while the salt was very pretty, it was a bit too much so me and my other friend kept shaking off the extra salt before eating lol. The whiskey brownie contained ACTUAL whiskey in it to my surprise lol, a little too much for me but I'm sure alcohol lovers would like this dessert. There's also some games that you can borrow from the restaurant to play with your friends, we played uno! I wouldn't go out of my way to make a special trip here but if you're looking for a place to meet in a casual setting in Washington Heights, this is a good spot for that. read more

See all

If you want a nice smooth vibe this is your place. Super chill and lowkey They have live music up until about 8pm It was a Saturday and the kitchen closed at 10 A bit disappointing nonetheless the mixologist was a delight The drinks did not disappoint . read more

I had the best time at Penny Jo's. Shout out to my friend Justin for putting me on. Solid cocktails at reasonable prices and staff that is friendly, funny and accommodating. The bartenders were amazing people and I would hang out with them whenever. The drinks were very high quality and at a point they were being made just for me- I was off the menu. If I didn't like something,the servers were happy to make adjustments, with no fuss. The bites are also good. I had the French onion grilled cheese. My onion wish was that the grilled cheese had more French onion flavor and actual onions. But it was delicious. This is a great place for drinks and bites. Will definitely be back read more

Penny Jo's - French onion grilled cheese - Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Great bar in Washington heights. Pop in here once in a while before class or after work and they never disappoint. Can't beat a pint and a pour ($10) and service is top notch. Get the muffuletta if you're hungry, because it's as close to getting one in Nola. Vibes are great, and I would tell anyone in the area it's a must go, especially for whiskey pours. So happy to have someplace like this in the community. read more

Loved it! Stopped in after work with some friends. While they don't have happy hour, there cocktails are $11 and soooo delicious! I got the El Diabolo which was tequila based. All of my friends loved their cocktails too. They have a small food menu where everything is reasonably priced! I loved the turkey cran sandwich I got, also $11. Joseph was our bartender and he was great! Super patient with our large group! Definitely can't wait to go back! read more

See all

This place is such a gem! We had nil expectations for a bar up in Washington Heights, but wow, we fell in love. We went on a Saturday with some lovely live jazz, warm cozy Christmas lights, and really solid cocktails for 2 rounds for four. The only thing missing was the gently falling snow flurries outside. read more

Wow. New favorite bar!!!! Absolutely sensational service, exquisite and incredibly crafted cocktails and just delicious food. Most important to me--the vibe here is really amazing! Everybody is very chill and welcoming. Ordered the tomato soup&grilled cheese per our wonderful bartender Joseph's recommendation and it was NEXT LEVEL delicious. Joseph is soo cool and sweet-feels like a new friend rather than someone just serving us drinks. He loves what he does and is KILLER at it!! Love him! They host live music Saturday nights as well as burlesque shows throughout the week. If i could give this spot two words to describe it I would say: "elevated chill". Will absolutely be back! read more

Penny Jo's - Bars Near Me - New York, New York

This was a sweet little petite bar I visited while in the heights. The bartender was very attentive and sweet. I met some awesome people in here just on the mere whim to stop in and have a beer. Very clean and small. I am definitely going to revisit this bar when I make my final move to NY. read more

Penny Jo's - Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped here with my wife and friends. The decor is creative post-industrial with exposed brick. The vibe was chill, youthful, and local. Creative cocktails and a curated beer list with good service. The chips mornay and charcuterie board were well-made. Definitely recommend. read more

Nice dimly lit bar in Washington Heights. Tried a few good cocktails. Liked their burning sage the most. Happy hour is from 4PM to 7PM everyday. Although they have food the place is more for drinking..All seats and tables are high. Haven't tried their food yet but i saw other people ordering food so I'll probably try it if and when I'm around there again! read more

See all

Found this place unintentionally, after looking for a place to sit and have a meal . The service was amazing , loved the snacks , I had the Mac and Cheese , several glasses of Rose .will definitely pop back in . read more

Not a single Latino or Hispanic as part of the staff. I came here with mother and sister and although we are all bilingual - we grew up on this street. I am highly disturbed by the fact that this place decided to occupy and gentrify this neighborhood with no positive impact to the community. No wonder it's always empty! read more

Had the best bartender to serve me. Explained the drinks menu and also communicated with me. On a friend level, not just as a customer. Highly recommend coming back here, when you want chill vibes read more

Stopped in for a drink and an in-between snack. Bartender Seth had a good vibe and was attentive, conversing with everyone at the bar. Good music and atmosphere. Had a Tito's and soda and the meatball soup. Hit the spot. read more

Beautiful place with beautiful drinks made by beautiful people! Come here for a wonderful time! You will love it!

Tried this place out after work one evening and had a great time! I had the El Diablo cocktail which was super tasty. The prices are decent and the service was wonderful. I'll definitely be returning! read more

I love this spot besides being 2 blocks away, for many reasons!! Great locals bar with live music, amazing cocktails, and the food is fire! Andrew is awesome! read more

Great hole in the wall bar. Met some cool people and the bartenders are rad! Happy hour specials are decent and really enjoyed the music (reggae.some soca) great vibes read more

This is a great local bar to enjoy great food, friendly ambience, and fantastic drinks. The bartender Joseph will take care of you needs. Highly recommend to try this bar. If you go once you will be back. read more

From the moment we walked in, the wait staff was really friendly and attentive! They greeted us as we walked in, and then brought over a complimentary amuse bouche - a small plate with mini pickles, hummus, and a piece of cheese on it. It definitely wasn't a lot of food or super fancy, but it had us feeling welcome and comfortable immediately! They have a fairly limited menu, but you can also order standard drinks that aren't on the menu! My friend ordered the Tia Maria from the menu, while I ordered a mint mojito (not on the menu). Both drinks were very well made- decently strong without tasting like it. Cocktails are also $11, which is pretty standard for this area. They also have a happy hour on beers and wine every day, and a live jazz performance once a week. I'm planning to come back, and I'll definitely be recommending this place to my friends as well. Excited to have this place in the neighborhood! read more

See all

This is a great, homey bar, with some yummy food, nestled in lower Washington Heights. The brick wall and good cocktails only add the atmosphere. I've only been here for drinks during a quiet weeknight, and the drinks and sandwich I had were ace! Looking forward to returning for some live jazz. Opened by same owners as Uptown Bourbon in Hamilton Heights. Good happy hour, live jazz, and I hear, free tapas on some nights! What's not to love! read more

Visited our son and he suggested this place. Fabulous lite bites, fantastic dessert, great staff, and very clean! All in one place! Highly recommend and looking forward to our return! read more

Love this bar! The drinks are great and the bartenders are so friendly. I hope they'll be able to reopen after COVID

This is probably my favorite bar in the city. Guaranteed great service and drinks. They make you feel so welcome and I defiantly don't mind staying a while, it's that kind of place. read more