I am totally not an ice cream sandwich type of person but these were excellent. The ice cream sandwiches are hand made with each having an interesting outer cookie and unique ice cream and a pie filling layer inside. What a great concoction! Many combinations to choose from. All sold from a cute little hippie-ish hut. Check out the pictures and salivate! read more

Brightest take on an ice cream sandwich ever, this place is so good, and the flavors are amazing. They have a high quality, small batch feel. Not like the mass produced ice cream sandwiches we have all had. The cookies are light and crisp. read more

See all

Me and my sister really liked the place. It is a small gem with potential. I had the cookies and cream and my sister had the cookie dough. The only problem is that they are pretty big for me. read more

This place has such great curb appeal you can't help but stop in for something. They were open later in the evening of one of the nights my boyfriend and I were staying in the area. They had many great selections of ice cream sandwiches, it was hard to choose just one. They are $6 each so I was only getting one... I decided on the peanut butter chiffon which was an excellent choice. It was super fresh and the ice cream was very rich and creamy. There was no skimping on the peanut butter either (a big pet peeve of mine)! My boyfriend had some sort of brownie sandwich which also looked good and he seemed to enjoy it. The employee was really nice and helpful even though we walked in 5 minutes to closing time. I would love to see this place come to the Philly area as I would frequent more often! Definitely recommend it and yes it is worth the $6! *Let it sit a few minutes before eating to let the cookie soften (my Peace Pie wisdom) . read more

Peace Pie - Peanut butter Chiffon - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Lots of fun flavors. I had the key lime peace pie- Amazing cookie crust and key lime ice cream that had the perfect balance of tartness and sweetness! read more

We wanted ice cream and everywhere else was closed. They're open until 10 in the off season. Decided to try it. Very disappointed. We got 6 of them, all different flavors, and they were ALL freezer burned. If you're going to sell something like this at $5 each they should be freshly scooped. Pulled them right out of a freezer case in wax paper not even in a closed container. So lord knows how long they were just sitting in the freezer like that. I couldn't even tell you if any of them were good because we couldn't taste them over the freezer burn. BEWARE! read more

Holy. Crap. These are amazing. After enjoying hundreds of ice cream cones on the mall over the years, we came across this new shop yesterday and thought it sounded interesting. My husband and I tried the salted caramel brownie and coffee toffee, respectively, and were blown away. The salted caramel filling (in both sandwiches) is really something special. And the crunchy salty toffee pieces in the coffee toffee was perfect. The cookies are crunchy and a little salty (in a good way) and firm enough to stand up to the ice cream without crumbling to pieces. We cannot wait to go back to try the others! Seriously, my stomach is growling. read more

Peace Pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

This is such a unique take on an ice cream sandwich! My dad and I ordered the pumpkin spice ice cream sandwich and the salted caramel apple ice cream sandwich. You can view all the available flavors through the glass in the front and then order through the window on the side of the store. The ice cream was delicious and a great portion size (held us over until our next meal!). There are benches right across the street (or down the next block along the main street mall area) where you can sit and enjoy the sandwiches. read more

Fantastic ice cream treat! This was an interesting take on an ice cream sandwich that tasted just like a slice of pie a la mode. The order/pick up window was perfect for a quick, safe dessert during the pandemic read more

Awful experience. The teenage girl that was working the evening of 8/15/19 was more interested in her cell phone than her customers. We waited about 2 minutes for her to finish her text messages before she barely lifted her head and said hello (and the shop was empty). I had to prompt her to tell us about the product and she offered a few abbreviated sentences before returning to her cell phone. Again, I had to prompt her when we were ready to order. She was rude and lacked any knowledge of customer service. The "peace pies" were ok. There is no "pie" about it. They are basically an overpriced ice cream sandwich. Nothing great and certainly underwhelming after all the reviews we read in advance. We will not be returning to this establishment. read more

2nd trip back from Atlantic City...Quick treat before next stop Wildwood. What a delicious find!!! read more

Peace Pie - When in Jersey! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

This quick service Cape May ice cream cookie shop was incredible! The brightly colored walk up to stand is adorable on its own. There are so many flavors to choose from; we got peanut butter brownie, cookies n cream, and coconut cream pie. The ice cream was perfect in between the thin pie crust like cookies. The serving size was perfect and every bite was delicious! Definitely check this place out. read more

Peace Pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Different is a good thing. Thin crunchy cookies filled with different flavored ice cream and fillings. I got the turtle cookie sandwich - chocolate cookie stuffed with a thick layer of caramel, nuts and chocolate ice cream. A miniature version for kids (and those with smaller appetites) might be a good idea. read more

See all

Honestly not impressed. The cookies were not that good (mine even still had tiny foil pieces on it) and too frozen. The ice cream was too hard and not that flavorful. Overall I was very disappointed. On top of that, the person working inside was also doing landscaping outside, maskless. When he saw us at the ordering window, he came inside, and then put on a mask and gloves. I'm not sure if he washed his hands, but if he did, it was brief. We definitely won't be back. read more

Peace Pie - Triple vanilla - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Who would have expected that I would willingly go back to eat ice cream sandwiches in 50-60 degree weather? I stumbled upon this place because it its cute decorated exterior at night and was surprised to see a line in November. There is a screen at the window and the shopkeeper wore mask and gloves when they were getting our items as well! They have a lot of different flavors but we got the raspberry chocolate, key lime, and strawberry chocolate and they were all so good! The cookies were firm and crispy and the ice cream was delish! I wasn't expecting chocolate chips in the raspberry and strawberry ones but they just made it better! Overall, if you're like me and visiting Cape May for the first time in the winter season don't pass on Peace Pie (at least you won't have to worry about it melting if you decide to grab it on your way walking back to your place like we did) read more

Amazing spot . The employees were really nice and explained about there making of the company. The ice cream peace pie cookie was really good. I gotten the apple vanilla ice cream and my fiance gotten the vanilla brownies carmal one . They were out if this world. The prices was just right as well. Definitely have to come here and try it out. read more

Amazing selection of flavors, and great ice cream sandwiches. I had the salted caramel brownie, which was good but hard to chew because it's so cold and a bit hard because of the coldness. Friends had the creme brûlée and the Jersey Devil. All delicious and highly recommended, but that Jersey Devil was something special. Enjoy! read more

I had the Orange Creamsicle Sandwich and it was super yummy! You had to wait for the ice cream to soften a little but it was really delicious! I wish the cookie had a bit more flavor though. The staff was really nice and helpful and the outside if the store is so colorful and great to take cute pictures! read more

Peace Pie - Orange Creamsicle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

An innovative take on the ice cream sandwich is what this business promises to offer & that they do. I had the cookie dough sandwich. It was tasty & hit the spot. The cookie is more crunchy than soft and chewy. I'm more partial to the soft and chewy cookie. Not sure if all their cookies are on the crunchy side. read more

When it's 1 degree feels like and 25 mph winds in February and the only ice cream in town is peace pie, you have to swallow your pride and get the goods. That's the cynical review. You don't need to swallow anything except ice cream packed inside delicious cookies. And you don't need to wait until mid winter! Strawberry with chocolate chips inside chocolate butter cookies really hit the spot. Many choices. read more

These are ice cream sandwiches with a layer of PIE FILLING! They are 100% deliciousness. The ice cream is so creamy, the pie filling layer so delicious, and the sandwich cookie part tastes like pie crust! read more

Peace Pie - Salted Caramel Apple - The Elvis - Jersey Devil - Caramel Coffee Toffee - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

They have two windows on opposite sides of the building and plexiglass for covid. Ice cream was amazing!

Delish!! Saw this cute place right as I was leaving and couldn't resist grabbing a quick cookies n cream sandwich. So very good!

Just Wow!! So yummy. Awesome selection of Ice cream sandwiches. Had the peanut butter cookie dough which was bomb!! Jerry the owner runs the shop and is super nice. Be sure to ask him the story behind the name :) enjoy read more

Peace Pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Wow, where have I been? This ice cream sandwich is amazing. We ordered 4 different flavors and all were equally good. I would definitely come back over and over. It's worth that 30min ride on the peloton afterwards. If they offer overnight shipping I would order!! It's that good!! read more

Peace Pie - two ice cream sandwiches in wrappers - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

I love Peace Pie. An amazing variety of ice cream treats! A must visit location for every trip to Cape May!

Ice cream sammy + pie filling. What's not to love? So many flavors for everyone, but the banana cream is worth trying first. read more

Peace Pie - Banana cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

what a cute place!! it's right off the main street and they have window ordering. I got the salted caramel brownie and it was SOO good. definitely recommend!!! read more

Peace Pie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Absolutely lovely establishment. Owners are great...so friendly. Sprinkled my ice cream because I was craving it!!!

Delicious!!!!! Worth the wait if there is a line! The s'mores sandwich was perfection, as was the salted caramel brownie.

Tasty with a ton of sandwiches to choose from. The dude who works there is as cool as a cucumber

Delicious. A bit over-priced, but worth it for a vacation stop. A welcome and unique alternative to just another ice cream cone. Our family got the Orange Cream, Strawberry Shortcake, and Smores. All of them received rave reviews. The shortbread cookie had the perfect crunch and thickness and the ice creams / fillings were very flavorful. Glad we stumbled upon it. Only negative is that at $6 the sandwich seems a bit over-priced, but since we were on vacation we splurged and it was worth it for a one-time thing. read more

Decided to try it out since it was a new place this summer... finally found the little shack close to the Japanese place by congress hall. All of the cookie sandwiches are premade. They all have the same shortbread cookie and are all different fillings. I had the Carmel brownie, it was delicious and would definitely get it again. Dad had the coconut cream.. couldn't really taste the coconut but it was still very good. Not much you can do wrong with an ice cream sandwich!! I can't wait to go back and try all of the flavors!! read more

Peace Pie - Chocolate Carmel Brownie!!! Yum! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

OMG!!! You definitely must go to Peace Pie and enjoy the best ice cream sandwiches ever!! Don't forget to take some hone too. My favorite is the coconut read more

Delicious. Unsure how you can choose which ice cream sandwich to order because all the combos are outrageously tasty but I had the pb brownie and it did not disappoint. The outer cookie was sturdy and perfectly crisp. And there was even a surprising caramel drizzle that was a really nice touch. I'd love to go back to try other flavors read more

Peace Pie - Peanut butter brownie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Yum! Adorable little shop with mouth watering ice cream sandwiches. I tried the salted caramel with brownies...and they even cut it so I could share easily. read more

So happy we finally got to try Peace Pie in cape May! We went on a Sunday night and the line was pretty long, out the door but went super fast. There are so many flavors it was overwhelming at first to figure out which I wanted. I think you have to see them in the case first before you can decide. We went with the Pecan Pie and am sooooo happy we did. It was amazing. $6 not bad. We split it because I don't think I could've eaten one on my own.. lots of ice cream, def big. If you're in the cape May mall area I would def go for this compared to a regular ice cream cone. Much better. read more

Five star! Not the typical dessert place and always a treat to have. Will be back soon!

I was skeptical. In fact, I love Uncle Charley's so much that I didn't want to find another ice cream place in Cape May. However, I was hooked at the first bite of my salted caramel brownie ice cream sandwich. I'm not a fan of shortbread, so I didn't expect to like the cookie. I'm a brownie snob, so I didn't expect to be impressed by the brownie. Boy, was I wrong! Peace Pie nailed each component; the chocolate cookie, the vanilla ice cream, the salted caramel, and the brownies were all fantastic. The woman behind the counter told me everything (including the brownies) was homemade. I could tell by the taste that they were quality ingredients. I also appreciated the fact that the ice cream was deep frozen so that it could be savored longer. Needless to say, I'll be back. I plan on trying as many different flavors as possible! read more

Peace Pie - The current top-seller: Salted Caramel Brownie! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Extremely good but they are way to frozen like harder than a rock frozen like mount Vesuvius hard like harder than a god damn Diamond