This is a tough review to write. It's clear from the previous reviews that a lot of people love this boat and the crew. I have to say that In general, I agree with these reviewers. However, they have a couple of practices on their boats, specifically their non-charter free-dive trips for spearfishing, that are questionable.
I recently participated in one of their free-dive trips to Santa Barbara Island, a three night trip that included a ton of amazing dives, and a lot of beautiful fish caught by nearly every participant. Honestly, if it was not for the success of the ensuing trip, I probably would have asked for a refund of my fee based on what happened the first night of the trip.
I'll detail what happened. On the night that I boarded, I arrived at around 7:30 PM, since the Peace Boat website stated that the boat would begin boarding at 8:00 PM. When I got to the boat, it was about 7:55 PM, and there were perhaps 4 people milling around the back deck, which was piled high with gear, clearly dropped off earlier by other passengers. The doors to the galley were closed, and a note was taped on the door stating "Doors Open at 8:00." I returned to my car to grab a bag, and then walked down to the boat again. When I got to the back deck, the doors were open. I went inside and found the sign-in sheet, where people mark down their name and the bunk that they want to claim for the trip. To my surprise, I found that there were already 15 or so names on the list, and that every bunk other than the smallest ones were claimed. I found this odd, since the website clearly stated that boarding started at 8:00, which I assumed meant that claiming of bunks also started at 8:00. The fact that there was no gear on any of the bunks when I checked below confirmed my suspicion that the bunks had been claimed before the doors actually opened.
At this point you (the reader) are probably thinking that I'm just being a pain in the butt. But the fundamental unfairness of this practice of letting passengers claim bunks before the designated boarding time, combined with the fact that I am 6 foot 4 inches tall, and simply don't fit in the smallest bunks (about 6 feet long), made me really angry. In the spirit of full disclosure, I did confront two passengers about how they were able to claim bunks before boarding time. In fact, the situation nearly precipitated a physical fight between me and two other passengers. In the end, the very nice passengers helped me to find an unclaimed bunk that was actually 7 feet long, which was perfect for me. Once settled in the bunk and trying to rest, I got to listen to another passenger have the exact same experience as me, including another verbal altercation. By this time a crew member had finally arrived, and helped smooth things over. After this problem, the trip went off without a hitch, all thanks to the careful planning of the crew and captain.
In the end, I feel pretty sure that the crew and captain are aware of what happened, but I was never asked about it, and I did not have the energy to pursue it with them. After all, in retrospect it's a pretty dumb thing to get mad about. Several weeks after the trip, though, I feel compelled to write about this for a couple of reasons:
1) I don't want anyone else to have the same experience I had. This is to say, if you want to have your choice of bunk, especially if you are tall and don't want to spend three nights sleeping in the fetal position having your butt and feet bumped by other passing passengers, then show up very early. Some passengers told me that they showed up as early as the morning of the departure day (more than 12 hours before departure) to claim a bunk. Obviously, they had prior knowledge that I was not privy to. But hey, now you are privy to it as well. Good luck!
2) I don't think that the Peace Boat folks care about the unfairness of this bunk choice practice. In general, it fits with the preferential treatment that they show to passengers who have gone on a lot of their trips. I don't think that this is right. If this was a charter trip, that would be another matter. But this was a trip that was open to the general public, and the crew and captain have an obligation to ensure that everyone who signs up and pays the required fee has equal access to all of the resources on the boat. For example, the ability to take ice from the boat's supply of ice (no one told me we could do that), or the right to jump in the water and let myself drift for a half a mile, counting on the crew to come pick me up in the skiff. That was a long swim back for me. Haha.
With any luck, this review will help other passengers to have a better experience by tipping them off to a couple of "secret rules" that are not stated on the company's website. Perhaps it will also inspire the Peace Boat to upgrade their website so that it clearly states that bunk choice depends on arriving very, very early.
Oh, and in case you are wondering, I did leave a tip. read more