I want to love PW Gym. I really do. I've gone here religiously for the past 4 years during college but now that I've graduated, it's numerous flaws are more than just inconveniences.
Let me preface by saying that if you're a varsity or club-level athlete at Yale, PW will treat you well and cater to you. If, however, you happen to be like 90%+ of the gym's membership and are not a varsity athlete, then you will be sorely disappointed. This is the biggest issue with PW -- it is a gym catered to the wants and needs of Yale's athletic programs. It sees its commitment to its other members as secondary and it shows.
On paper, PW has many attractive amenities that would make it an excellent gym. If you ever try to use many of these amenities, however, you'll be incredibly frustrated.
Want to swim in our beautiful indoor swimming pool? Sorry, it's only open 2 hours a day. Also, it isn't open in the morning or evening when people could use it before or after work, it's open 1-3pm. Why? Because the varsity swim team wants to practice. Are they practicing for 15 hours a day? No, PW just doesn't care enough to provide accommodating hours. It is absolutely mind-boggling.
Want to run on our air conditioned indoor running track? Well sorry, that too is going to be closed 4 hours every afternoon so the basketball team can practice. I'm sorry, can someone please explain how my running on the track 2 stories above the basketball court interferes with their practice? I pay a significant amount of money to use these amenities. Why is it that I can seemingly never use them?
And in all the 13 stories of space that PW has to its name, you, the member, are provided with about 5000 square feet of space to exercise to your hearts desire (which, to no one's surprise, gets incredibly crowded). On their website, they'll proudly boast of the fitness center's 20,000 square feet of space available. What they don't tell you is that fully half of that space is the realm of varsity athletes only. It's literally behind a wall. You can't even look at it.
Parking is practically nonexistent. There's parking available for Yale employees and metered street parking. That's it. If you have to commute to PW like I do, this is not a small issue.
I have tried to ask multiple times about all of these problems and why they won't fix them and the collective response can be most aptly summarized as "F#*$ you, that's why."
To top it all off, the area in the fitness center that PW deigns to allow its members to use is incredibly unorganized. Weights are haphazardly places wherever. Despite the gym closing 3 weeks out of the year for "cleaning," I've never seen this area cleaned or organized at all. There's plenty of cardio equipment though.
Most of the positive reviews seem to be "look at the architecture! It's so pretty!" and things of that nature. Look, if all you care about in a gym is how cool the exterior looks then god bless. Take all the pictures you want. But if you're someone that is looking for a real gym that is committed to providing the best it can for its members, then this place is not for you. read more