Was visiting Plainfield for a wedding this weekend from…read moreChicago and stopped by after checking out after a friend recommended this shop. We grabbed ribeyes, filets, Italian sausage and wagyu burgers to try. Made the ribeyes and filets tonight and they were so freaking good. Such a difference between a Jewel or Mariano's bought product of the same and this shops'. We put the steaks on the smoker and they melted in our mouths like butter. So amazing. We're trying the rest out later this week. Too bad we don't live closer here!! We'd be broke haha.

Small shop with an awesome lady working behind the counter. Super nice! Cant wait to try out the…read moreburgers I got!

Great poor boys and garlic butter. They're a great resource for meat here in town. Good service.read more

Service great! Cuts of meats are done by the owner on the spot. Quality of meat is tremendous…read more Great marbling on the steaks. Prices are high, but worth every penny. Great experience there, always. Family owned business. If this isnt a Mom & Pop shop, thats so American, I dont know what is! They are so friendly! They go out of their way to ensure you get what you came for.

Nice small butcher shop in a strip mall off 159th Street ... the same mall that Mayan Palace is in…read more This was a nice stop for those special events when you want to serve beef ... high quality with prices to match, but the quality justifies the price. This is not a general store with a wide selection of items. It is more of a specialty house where you'll find typical butcher products. If you are looking for beef ... you've come to the right place. Relatively limited offerings of other items, but the main thing they do is done right. Sometimes they can be closed when you'd expect them to be open, but that probably comes with being a small business without a huge staff. We suspect they also supply some restaurants in the area and that may be their biggest customer. Good place for those special occasions.

Great service and great meat! We went there for prime rib and walked out with flank steak too…read more Definitely will be our go to butcher!

I'm a sucker for getting my food from local sources so I was happy that I found out about this…read moreplace. Its an actual farm that just started selling meat from their cattle to customers. I'm more of a burger guy than steak, so I just got a couple pounds of their ground beef. Really enjoyed the burgers that I grilled up later that night. You can't go wrong with locally-raised, hormone-free meat. Its better to call first if planning to make a purchase.

We have bought beef from the Wheeler family for a long time! It's absolutely amazing! The taste of…read morethe meat is crazy good! Needs absolutely no seasoning! And you don't need to drain a ton of fat off of it! So tasty!! I recommend anyone to buy their beef from Wheeler Beef!

Little old fashioned deli butcher shop. Totally recommend them. The selection and prices are very…read morecomparable. Great service, excellent products

Online ordering apparently has errors. Ordered 6 3packs of sandwich ribeye and when picked up it…read moredidn't seem right I asked clerk is this 18 and was told should be got to my tailgate and had 6 steaks. I had 18 people so it was frustrating. I will say gave me a full refund but would have preferred the steaks.

Fresh locally owned- great quality and variety. Convenient hours. Would definitely recommend!read more

Excellent meat selections & very helpful staff with lots of complimentary products tooread more

Excellent, friendly service!!! Linda is amazing and offers great beef bundles. She offers…read morescheduling for pick up to accommodate my full work so I could pick up a standing rib roast fresh vs a frozen one. I highly recommend Kaminski Farm Meat and bonus that's a quaint beautiful setting. Ask for Linda!!!

Ah...I finally found a real a source for my meat...with friendly knowledgeable service…read more Picked up some Amish cheese that was very tasty.

This is long -but it is that special. Please help me spread the word…read more This place is so understated and deceiving -in a good way! It looks like a meat packing house from the out-side. But when you step in, it's a homage to the art of meat preparation. The owner Steve is a gem. You can tell this is not only a quality business but also a passion project that he has continued from his father. My daughter is a recent Purdue graduate from '25 class. We are not local, but from NJ. She found this place as part of a local walk and stopped by to pick up a gift certificate to give as a thank you gift.. She noticed they do catering- and thank goodness!. We rented an Airbnb for her graduation so family can stay with us and had planned to have a caterer. But the caterer I booked 4 months prior to graduation cancelled on me one week prior to the event! I was left high and dry. My daughter remembered that Beutlers caters! Steve literally saved us when all others could not or would not. He was not only empathetic to our situation, but he made sure we had an amazing feast and thought of everything to ensure we had the celebration we envisioned. The food was so incredibly good. My family was raving about it all weekend long. Truly THE best pulled Pork and Beef brisket we've ever had. And for a family that doesn't even like beans, they couldn't stop eating it! So good, it should be illegal. We had leftovers for days. Best of all, Steve told me he prepped all the food himself. His TLC was evident. He made sure we had everything needed, even lovely serving baskets and lighters for sternos! My only regret is that my daughter graduated, and I have no known future opportunities to call on Steve again to work his magic. I hope this review gains traction. I'm on a mission to ensure that word gets out about this rare gem of a place and the incredible owner behind it all, Steve Beutler. Heartfelt thank you Steve.

Awesome service. Really nice people. Don't forget the cookies. From liver to steaks. Fat, bones…read moreand tenderloins. Lots of yummy meat must haves. Feed you and your pets. I love the decor also. Tin shed vibes.

Shocking! Not the Polancic's I use to know. Sanitation is a big issue with me…read more Bare hands in raw meat does not mix.

Breaded pork tenderloin is incredible. Made my second trip to buy 20. I'll have to buy a case next…read moretime.

Come for the meat and cheese counter, stay for the nook in the back of the store where all of the…read moregorgeous bottles of wine live. Actually, in my case, I came for the wine nook. I read that this is a good place to find a great bottle of wine, and it's true. Old World Market will satisfy the indulgent, bougie food lover in you -- the food lover who likes pretty charcuterie boards made from thinly sliced prosciutto shaped into flowers. And it will indulge the wine lover in you -- the one who likes a good glass of wine. It's a small store. Surprisingly small, actually! But along with wine and meats and cheeses, you'll find specialty food items like Swedish Pippi Longstocking candy (what?), pasta in all shapes and sizes, cookies, teas, oils and lots of imported goodies. You'll mostly find food imported from Europe: Italy and Nordic countries, specifically. They offer readymade sandwiches and small charcuterie boxes to go, for those of us who want to live deliciously but also have stuff to do elsewhere. Basically, this is a great place to visit to find something delectable to eat or drink in Valparaiso.

Great selection of meats and cheeses! Gem of a find. Will definitely be going back soonread more