Wow. I am truly speechless because my mouth is full of Savory decadence I had a coupon local flavor. Wasn't expecting much. I'm from Westchester and eat in Bronx /City or Jersey . Most pizza places in Rockland suck. Let's be honest. They are good. But not ya know Anyway got a individual Taco pizza. It was an actual dough pizza not Pizzete which is just a big tortilla. That make that around here and charge a lot. All sides were there in box. Tasted yummy. Also personal Bronx meat pizza. Very nice size and excellent meat to cheese ratio. Delicious. Chef Salad Was Banging!! Best of all ....... Def must order Stuffed mushroom. Hands down one of the BEST I have ever had Also prices were awesome !!! Just try Also never been there and know no one Had a local flavor coupon. read more

See all

I have ordered from Papa's several times and I'm surprised at all the bad reviews on here. I will say that I always go to pick up my pizza though, so I don't have delivery problems, I guess. The pizza is really good! I have a picky family and everyone in my house likes their pizza. It's always done by the time I get there and it's hot and fresh. I've also ordered salad from here and been happy with it, it was nice and fresh and the salad dressing was good too. One of these days we'll order wings and I'll update my review. We'll keep ordering from here. read more

The food at Papa's used to be good. I ordered a Barbecue chicken wing meal. The chicken was not only unseasoned but the barbecue sauce had been watered down, to stretch it I imagined. This is the 3rd time I've received substandard food. I won't order from Papa's West Haverstraw again. read more

This place has decent Pizza with some tasty latin foods. Good prices and the staff are good people. read more

This place changed owners so I decided to try. They offered a special, 2 slices & a medium drink for $5 bucks. The cheese was stretchy chewy and the crust had a nice crisp crunch to it. On my second visit I had a Jamaican beef patty which is always a old school treat. I would come again for the pizza. The 4 stars is for Rockland County. read more

Papas Pizza - Nice-ah Slice-ah! - Pizza Near Me - West Haverstraw, New York

Since we moved to Rockland County (20 years ago) we searched high and low for a pizzeria that at least came close to Bronx pizza. We just moved to Thiells from Chestnut Ridge 2 years ago in May... Received a coupon flyer in the mail and felt $9.99 for a large pie - what the heck - why not... Well let me say...after 20 years, we FINALLY found pizza close enough to Bronx pizza!!! We order EVERY Friday a large pie with extra cheese or the family package 2 pies and 10 wings!! If you order enough you gain points towards something free or discounted! LOVE THIS PLACE!!! We're HOOKED!!! BEST Pizza in Rockland! Gave it 4 stars only because we've never ordered anything else except pizza or been to the location. They say 45 min for delivery and ALWAYS deliver in less then that! read more

Papa's is just OK. If there is a special, fine, but I wouldn't pay full price for this. My friends had us over and ordered a special which included a large pepperoni pie, garlic knots, and buffalo wings. I'm from Buffalo so the wings didn't do it for me but did actually get somewhat close. They were crispy and cooked well but much too small and didn't pack any heat at all. I didn't hate them though. The pizza was super greasy. Like, dripping. The cheese itself was good but the pizza was undercooked and greasy so it was hard to eat. You practically had to use a fork and knife. Because of that, I was not a fan. The pizza I would give 2 stars, the wings 4 so that's how I got to 3. Can't comment on delivery since we picked it up, nor the garlic knots since I didn't have them. All in all, wouldn't be my first choice but I wouldn't be opposed if someone else is paying. read more

See all

Great food and even greater prices! Authentic Italian tasting food not your typical Dominoes or Pizza Hut prepackaged crap. One of the top three pizza spots in the area. The heavy traffic in and out of the place is a testament of their food. Where else can you get the family feast which includes a large 18" pie, 2 Liter Pepsi and a large order of garlic knots or zeppoles for $15? read more

See all

We've ordered from Papa's many times in the past, and they are usually very good. This time, we ordered a pie, a sandwich, and a calzone. We were told it would be delivered in 30-35 minutes. Our food did not come until an hour and a half later and instead of a calzone, we got a box with two slices in it. We called to make them aware of the mistake and they said they would send the correct item. Forty minutes later, we called again because we still didn't have our food, and they said the driver was out with our food. It is now over an hour since we called for our calzone and we still do not have it. The pizza that we did get was only slightly warm and nothing tasted the way it usually does. Update: It has now been over 3 hours since we ordered and an hour and 45 minutes since the driver supposedly came back out to deliver our calzone. So we called again and they gave us a credit for our next order. However, there will not be a next order for a very long time. read more

I really wanted to like the food here but each time I've ordered I was disappointed. The pizza is just terrible. French fries are either soggy or over cooked. Pasta undercooked and not seasoned. Chicken noodle soup not impressed. Fettuccine sauce is so bland no salt at all. Wings are good and salads have been good. Each time I've ordered I've taken a few bites and my food goes straight to the trash. Disappointing. read more

Chicken Cesar wrap BBQ chicken wings SO YUMMMMY The chicken was breaded chicken and it tasted amazing. read more

Papas Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Haverstraw, New York

I should have read the reviews before ordering. Big mistake! We are 1st time customers. We ordered : Nachos Grande not meat instead guacamole -ice cold thick gooppie fake cheese. Guacamole was frozen and the size of 2 ketchup packets. Huge chunks of tomatoes lettuce and gross old jalapeño slices. I could barely eat it and threw most of it in the garbage. Garlic Knots . - very dry Buffalo Calamari - she said spicy and I said yes buffalo sauce. OK no problem. They arrived with out the "buffalo" Calamari was decent Chicken Buffalo 10 inch -bland We won't be 2nd customers. read more

There are plenty of other places to order food from around here. Don't waste your money or time on this place. Today I ordered two heroes and two salads, totaling $45 with a kind tip. The food was delivered over an hour after I called in. The driver did call to say his gps had sent him in the wrong direction. I got an excuse but no apology. It was as if delivering my food was an inconvenience to the delivery driver. Not only did the food come late, one of the sandwiches was made wrong. This is the second time I've ordered from here. The first time was an online order that also got delivered wrong. Unfortunately their menu is awesome and the food is really good even when made wrong. read more

Pizza is good but customer service is HORRIBLE! This place ripped me off twice. Two times after speaking with the owner to apply a coupon that was never applied. First time, I disregarded the inconvenience and spoke with their Manager that you ensure me the coupon would be honored for the next order. The next order came and the coupon wasn't honored. No big deal, it was only $5 off. Third time my pizza was delivered with half its toppings on the side of the box. Called to speak to the owner, Papa and they attempted to deliver the pizza and insisted on ringing the bottom apt bell even though their computer system receipt shows the 2nd floor. Called to ask where my pizza was and I was told that they were too busy to attend to my complaint. Perhaps if they made a point to contact their customer, they would have realized that something wasn't quite right but instead they chose to wait for me to contact them. Two and a half hours later their delivery person shows up and I am angry. Not even an apology to show good faith. Delivery charges of $1.50 go towards their tip in addition to an extra tip I gave because we share the same industry. Nice to see where there sense of urgency for their customers are. If I reacted the same way they did to me with my own guests at the restaurant I work, I would be fired! I'm cancelling my charges for this order, which is something I NEVER do! Future customers: Make sure you open your pizza boxes and check your order. Customer Service make the biggest difference. A shame I will no longer be doing business with them because of this. There food is good but their sense of urgency is HORRIBLE! read more

Papas Pizza - Check your pizza first before receiving it via delivery. - Pizza Near Me - West Haverstraw, New York

Papa's Pizza. The take out food is very good. Large portions. But the service is atrocious. They were late on a delivery because they hadn't even started the order until we called looking for a delivery. Then it was wrong when delivered. Second time delivery issues. I think we'll go elsewhere in the future. It isn't worth the aggravation. read more

Everytime I come here I tell myself maybe the pizza will taste better, but no. The pizza always looks and taste terrible. They really need to change everything, from the sauce to the crust. As a pizza fanatic, i'm very disappointed. Don't waste your money coming here read more

I go to this place a lot the pizza is good but the best deal is half sandwich With fries and a soda you can get chicken parm or wraps and they are delicious the wings are good too is a good idea to call first it will take 15 min to get your order the pick up is a little challenging because the parking is small and there are a lot of businesses there owners are friendly read more

Papas Pizza - Chicken roll - Pizza Near Me - West Haverstraw, New York

Excellent food - best selection in North Rockland. The ONLY complaint is that they charge an additional $2.00 to place an order over the phone. Strange practice... read more

Co-worker told me about this place. He also said that it was owned by two brothers, one nice and one not so nice. First time there ordered a good specialty pie. Guy at the counter was friendly (must have been the nice brother). I also signed up for Papa's Rewards Program where you get points redeemable for food based on the money you spend. Just went there for second time. Ordered X-Large Cheese Pie and 16" Chicken Parm Hero. I had to ask the guy on the phone to take my phone number so I could get credited the points for the order. Went to pick up the order. The guy was a prick (must be not so nice brother). Couldn't be bothered to even utter a word to me. I asked if points had been given to me. He grunted that they had. Then a young girl working there checked. She said that the points had not been given to me but she had corrected it. I don't really give a crap about Papa's stupid Rewards Program. But why institute a customer loyalty program if you are obviously so unwilling to give the customers what you promised them. Bad way to do business. Anyway, the pizza and hero sucked. So now Papa's doesn't have to worry about me racking up the Rewards Points because I won't be going back. read more

6 Reasons this pizzeria is great 1.Their food is great, don't listen to these bad reviews they have. 2. Online Ordering- just in case you don't want them to mess up your order. I mean come on we all make mistakes 3.Fresh everything- Don't get me started on their home made bread. To my eyes everything is freshly made not like any other pizzeria around here. 4.FREE DELIVERY 5.You get paid for ordering- what other pizzeria gives you money towards food? Its called papas rewards, look it up. 6. J-U-M-B-O wings 5 stars are not enough to describe the quality of food this pizzeria has Just think if every customer they had would of reviewed, how many good comments would of been left. Don't let some bad reviews stop you from ordering. read more

I am worked with Louis for 10 years at the original Papa's Pizza I taught him everything I know. And now when his son is there or one of the other managers you don't get what you ordered every week we try to get something from there every time I do there's a problem from doughy bread , burnt pizza and today we ordered a philly cheese steak with just onion n extra cheese, repeated it three times. And a chicken parm hero also... now the cheesesteak was with peppers n onions which was wrong and bread hard as a rock!! Same thing with chicken parm... hard as a rock. So I called back and told them there mistake. Now if Louie was there he would of did right thing made sandwich right.. and we would of been good with that .. but the Manager stated no that's the way we ordered it said he repeated it three times which he didn't!!! Now all I have to say is that the customer is always right... he argued with us so I said I'll stop bye when Louie's there n tell him!!! Wouldn't make New sandwich n basically called us liars !! What a shame the place is on point most of the time.. but from now on I'll only order when Louis is there.... don't get twist it is usually great when Louis is there but if his son or other mangers there call someplace else...... read more

DON'T EAT HERE & STAY AWAY FROM THIS PIZZA PLACE!!! This pizza place is DISGUSTING!! Leftover pizza sitting on the counter is from someone else's pizza pie that they didn't want!! This place should be shut down!! read more

I love their pizza!!! It is my new favorite. I have become a regular. I do pick up or eat-in. The crust is crisp, the cheese and sauce is just the way I like it. I recently tried their Dinner for 4 special and it was delicious. The portions were ample and the chicken marsala was yummy. The quality is great and the prices are affordable. read more

Save your money, delivery takes forever and when you go in person they leave bins in a public area where you can get hurt. My husband hurt his leg really bad by tripping and falling over what should have been stored BEHIND the counter. No regard for public safety! Go to 3 Boys from Italy instead, lesson learned read more

Good prices and pizza but staff is horrible. And God forbid you leave the coupon at home....

DO NOT ORDER FROM THIS PLACE. Ordered at 5:30 8-13-11 - told 35-45 minutes. Called at 6:30 told it delivery was almost there. Called again at 7:00 and they are not answering the phone! Unbelievable! Even the worst pizza place makes their deliveries! Can't comment on the pizza cause they didn't bring it! read more

I never right a bad review, but upon having gone to and ordering from this place multiple times I have consistently received bad customer service and excessively long wait times for subpar food. if placing a delivery order, do not expect your food for at least an hour minimum, in warm condition at best. The food quality is ok at best, comparable to some places in the neighborhood depending on preference, but nothing that stands out and certainly not worth the unwelcoming atmosphere and long wait times. Strongly advise against going here. Avoid if possible. read more