I called at 8 o'clock on a weeknight and they weren't very busy and instead of just pushing out a regular pizza they went above and beyond and I was blessed with one of the best pizzas I've had in years. Awesome product and awesome service. 10/10 would recommend for local pizza. Great job guys!! read more

Papa Everett's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Clear Lake, Iowa

It's a small hole on the wall that reminds me of the mom and pop pizza shops I grew up with in the northeast. If you want to stay and eat, fine but it's not really date night material. The pizza, however, is wedding day material! The crust is chewy and flavorful while the sauce is nearly perfect. I had a pepperoni and it was an absolute delight to munch on driving home to Rochester. If I'm going by Clear Lake, IA, I try to be hungry so I can order from here! read more

Papa Everett's Pizza - 12" Pepperoni - Za Heaven - Pizza Near Me - Clear Lake, Iowa

Friendly staff, probably great for take out, I wouldn't eat in as zero ambience. Pizza was good, not great

I recommend the pizza with the crust on top and bottom. It's delicious. They are always friendly and fast.

Dessert pizza with cherries was the start of our order. Delivery time was prompt and guy delivering was great. Skip the wings seemed to be frozen wings with breading in them. We got the everything pizza and it was pretty good. read more

I like and recommend this place....nothing flashy, but has good pizza at reasonable prices. An organization I belong to has had these guys cater many events and there has never been a disappointment of any kind. Solid, solid business and pizza joint. read more

Shared a small pepperoni pizza(10.99 without tip) with my girlfriend. Best pizza I've had in a long time. Service was quick and pizza was out in less than 10 minutes. I would frequent this place if I lived in the area. read more

We enjoyed our large Super Combo pizza which was very good as usual. We picked it up at the prescribed time and it was ready to go. It was a easy dinner read more

I'm from New York and take my pizza seriously, so I wasn't expecting much from some place in Iowa named "Papa Everett's." (I mean, come on - at least be named Tony's or Vinnie's, right?) But there was nothing else nearby at the end of a long day of driving except fast food and a Chinese restaurant closed for vacation, so I said to myself "ah, just deal with it" and prepared to scarf down one more pale imitation of genuine pizza. Damn, was I wrong. This nondescript joint gave me a mushroom pie that was one of the best I've tasted this side of the Hudson. Great crust, fresh mushrooms, plenty of cheese, decent sauce-- what else are you looking for? Nice, friendly lady behind the counter, too. Crowded with noisy young families, so if that 's not your thing, go back to your motel room like I did and eat your pizza with a brewski or two. Maybe you could find a Mets game on TV. Signore Everett, I owe you an apology about the name business. You're a paisan, aren't you? read more

I purchased a pizza coupon through Stebens Childrens Theatre for a free, two topping large pizza. I called for delivery and in order for them to deliver, I needed to have an order for at least $8 so I ordered a small pizza as well. Pizza was delivered on time and the delivery man took my coupon. Upon looking at my bank account online, I realized they charged me the full price for BOTH pizzas without honoring the coupon. Yesterday I called to speak to a manager. The manager was not available and the woman was very polite and assured me that I would get a call back. I have yet to get a call back. I will call them again today. I will update my Yelp review accordingly. This is very disappointing as we have been ordering pizza here for years. I am very hopeful that Papa Everett's will rectify this situation in a timely manner. UPDATE: I called again today and the manager called me back within 15 minutes. She did not work yesterday, but after getting the message regarding the problem, had already called the credit card company. The situation was rectified yesterday and it was an honest mistake. Mistakes will be made, but if a business does whatever it can to fix it, I am pleased!! Great customer service and yummy pizza!! Give Papa Everett's a try! read more

We were looking for someplace local to stop and eat while driving from St Paul to Des Moines. We decided on pizza and looked up what may be good. Went inside and not sure if allow eat in for now it looked mostly for takeout and delivery. Luckily they do. They were super nice, quick as they could be with the number of take out before us. We started with bread sticks while we waited, spot on with the snack and sauce. Then onto the meatavore pizza, delicious! I just now wish we lived closer. I heard they are keeping the prices reasonable even though the cost of ingredients is not. Go help local! read more

Very friendly atmosphere. The owner took our order and even served us. Pizza and breadsticks were homemade and tasted like it! Very fresh ingredients. We were on vacation and stopped at Clear Lake to see the Buddy Holly memorial. Wanted some pizza and we hit the right spot. They are now actually called Papa Everett's Pizza. Lost the old name to keep the fresh ingredients. Worth the stop. read more

Papa Everett's Pizza - Awesome homemade style breadsticks! - Pizza Near Me - Clear Lake, Iowa

See all

Went in there not expecting much, but found that you can order for the family or just for 1 and the quality stays the same. I tried their cheeseburger Pizza (just because I wanted to try something different) and it was everything I expected and then more. Was so impressed that i went back the next day and bought another. One cashier/prep guy and One Pizza Chef is all they need. I will be back next time I'm in the area read more

This address seems to be invalid. We asked a local if there was a pizza place nearby and she looked at us like we wanted directions to Mars. Not sure if it exists but figured I'd warn people that no GPS of mine took me to the right place if this address is correct read more

I purchased a pizza coupon through Stebens Childrens Theatre for a free, two topping large pizza. I called for delivery and in order for them to deliver, I needed to have an order for at least $8 so I ordered a small pizza as well. Pizza was delivered on time and the delivery man took my coupon. Upon looking at my bank account online, I realized they charged me the full price for BOTH pizzas without honoring the coupon. Yesterday I called to speak to a manager. The manager was not available and the woman was very polite and assured me that I would get a call back. I have yet to get a call back. I will call them again today. I will update my Yelp review accordingly. This is very disappointing as we have been ordering pizza here for years. I am very hopeful that Papa Everett's will rectify this situation in a timely manner. read more

Our go-to pizza in Clear Lake! Their unique sauce is delicious. We love a classic pepperoni/mild sausage or the amazing bacon cheeseburger pizza! Try the breadsticks or cheesy breadsticks! Plus they deliver which is rare in CL. read more

Awesome pizza. Very friendly staff. I was in town for a concert and saved my appetite for their pizza. I was NOT disappointed. Fresh all the way down the line. Great salad, too! read more

Papa Everett's Pizza - the menu and prices - Pizza Near Me - Clear Lake, Iowa

See all

One of the best, flaky and buttery crust pizzas I've ever had. Great local spot, definitely a favorite.

Really good pizza. The owner, Sandy, was so pleasant to talk with. They have delivery service, too. We just took our pizza back to our hotel. read more

If you really want some good pizza that is more like homemade this is the place you really need to try it

Thanks Clear Lake Breadeaux for bringing me back to fond childhood memories of delicious pizza parties. Even more so, thanks for creating a new adult tradition to stop and feast on a scrumptious plate of pepperoni with buttery crust and rich tomato sauce. Yum^3!! (Or yum yum yum!) read more

I'm going to begin with the good; the pizza was delicious, didn't take too long, the guy working the counter was nice, and the food was reasonably priced. How ever the reason this was a 3 star experience was due to one employee who doesn't understand health codes. My first impression of her was already an unprofessional appearance, as someone who has worked in food service I know you are supposed to maintain a clean and presentable appearance but she didn't even look hygienic. Then after wiping down a table she proceeded to put her bare, filthy, hand into the black olives container and eat them like snack. This is the olive container that they use to make the pizzas by the way. This was disgusting and makes me feel sorry for the next people who get black olives on their pizza. Management should review health code practices with their employees. And if you are stopping by, I'd avoid the black olives. read more

Owner is a moron lost in time. Pays $8 to employees and expects them to work like a dog. Quality of pizza is not even close to good. This place requires a pay raise and a true pizza chef to make it. Other than that it is a joint to hear silly drama and poor poor quality pizza served not on time. read more

Their pizza is nothing to go out of your way for. And the owner's attitude toward customers is shameful. I can't support their business.

This is not breadeaux pizza, it is now papa everetts. They still have the website linked to a breadeaux website and menu. I assure you nothing is the same. They advertise delivery options but fail to let you know till you call, that they do NOT deliver till 4 pm. What a joke. read more

I have ordered pizza since my first review for delivery and have been impressed- delivery was on time, pizza was delicious! I love their breadsticks! I have noticed that pizza is sometimes a bit too greasy though. read more