Papa Rony's is a very unassuming pizza place attached to the Algonquin motel. It had be recommended by a friend and I was skeptical when we picked up our takeout pizza but I am happy to report that the hype was real.
Papa Rony's makes excellent old-school pizza. The cheese is intentionally browned, not burnt which is just the way I like it. The large pizza is closer to a medium at some places so keep that in mind when you order. The thick crust makes up for that though.
My only complaint is that our pickup took a bit longer than we were quoted so we were left waiting for a bit but otherwise I would definitely order from them again. read more