Great first time experience. We were able to call ahead for…read morea table. Servers greeted us upon checkin aand seated us right away. Cheese bread- great texture, cheese was pulling apart, crust had a flavorful parmesan/italian seasoning dusting. Meatball hoagie- sauce was zesty, meatballs were full of italian spices and the bread was fall apart goodness. Calzone- was the so - so- not enough meat - at most 2 slices which was underwhelming with the cheese ratio.

Review Update: Updated 2/2/2026: I'm back to officially eat…read moremy words--along with a lot of pizza. If you saw my first review, you know I wasn't a big fan. But after two follow-up visits, I've realized my first experience was just a fluke. I'm now a total convert. The Game Changer: I asked for my pizza well-done this time, and it was perfect for me. I was with a group who ordered the Vegetable Pizza which was loaded with fresh, vibrant veggies...so good! The "Don't Sleep On These" Items: * The Reuben: I'm calling it now--it's outstanding. Perfectly balanced and definitely the sleeper hit of the menu. * Fresh Baked Bread: This stuff is basically a religious experience. Get it. * House Salad: Surprisingly fresh and the perfect. Big salad to share! I'm so glad I gave this place a second (and third) look. It's officially earned its spot as one of my favorite local spots

To begin the story of my experience I should first start with how amazing the beer cheese is. Made…read morein house and it is absolutely amazing. The service was friendly. The food arrived and my pizza was as ordered. It was customized to be an imposter margarita pizza. They absolutely nailed it. My girlfriend got her sandwich and ended up taking some home to save it for later! And for, what I think is the best root-beer know to mankind itself, just blew me away. I bought a growler (64oz) to take home! Thank you new NABC for making a new choice for dinner into a restaurant that will have my business forever!

What a disappointment. I've been before and had delicious food. I would even say it was my favorite…read morepizza. But how the mighty have fallen. They were out of several NA beverages. They cannot produce hot water without running it through their coffee machine, which makes it taste like coffee. The Kase (similar to queso) is basically yellow water. Devoid of flavor; it does not cling well to the stale chips or pretzel bites. The 10 topping pizza we ordered had all 10 toppings, but only one or two of each. The crust on the deep dish cannot hold up to the weight of the pizza. The service was fine. The restaurant furniture needs an upgrade. Everything feels icky. Even the soap in the wash room appeared watered down. I do not recommend. I will not be back.

My family and I stopped in here on a Friday for lunch. We are greeted the door by a man and he was…read morebehind the counter and he also made the pizza. The pizza we got was a large cheese and I got the eight dollar giant, slice and fountain soda. The girls cheese pizza was $16. The pizza was ready in about 11 minutes. We see it ourselves, and he brought it to us. Eat the pizza in the back corner. It's a very small area to eat and died in. But it was comfortable and we enjoyed our food.

On our way back from a trip to Rough River Dam State Park (see my review), I called 8th Street…read morePizza to order for dine in. We were about 10 or so miles away. When we arrived, the pizza was ready and it was as good as previous reviews stated. There were 3 very friendly and professional female staff members. The restaurant isn't very large, but it is clean and stylishly decorated. See photos.

I eat low carb so I cannot attest to the pizza. The wings on the other hand were amazing. They are…read morealmost as good without any sauce as they are with. The salad was fresh. We sat inside with all the garage doors open so it was like there was no outside wall. It was very pleasant. The waiter was very patient and quick. Would definitely go again.

We previously had lunch at Parlour and had an enjoyable time. Food was good as was the service…read more Today we returned for another lunch hoping for another enjoyable experience. Unfortunately, this visit the only positive was the food. It was as good as our first visit. This time, service was slow and not near as attentive as our previous visit. I ordered a beer and it was out. I asked for a "taste" of an alternate beer. Our server disappeared for quite sometime. When he finally came back, he had forgotten my beer. We then ordered and it took forever for our food to arrive. Once our food arrived everything started to smooth out. We were about half way through our meal and they opened a whole wall of overhead doors. It's 11:45 in the morning, temperature in the upper 60's and wind blowing at about 20 mph straight in the doors. ONE table asked to open the doors totally disregarding the numerous other patrons. Keep in mind the patio was open, these customers could have eaten on the patio. The wind was extremely chilly and our napkins were blowing off the table. I mentioned to our server we didn't want the doors open and we were uncomfortable. He just grinned and said "It is a little cold" and kept walking on by. About 15 minutes later he came back to our table to see if we needed anything. I once again protested the door being opened made us quite uncomfortable. This time he spoke to someone and they closed the door on our end. By this time we were about to leave. One person in our party said had they opened the door before we got our food she would have gotten up and left. A real shame they totally changed our opinion from the previous positive to a real negative this time.

Any thin crust fans out there? If so, this could be the best pizza in the whole wide world!…read moreThe menu is mostly normal, not a lot of adventure in the ways of pizza making. The place was busy and I saw more carry out than I've seen anywhere else. The popularity is for good reason.

So traveling fout of town and checked out this place seemed interesting. Locally owned…read more Doing a little day trip to help out some friends to get to an orthodontist appointment and I thought might as well check out a family owned business that's been around since 1991 while they were at their appointment. Great service and generous portions-of veggies on the house salad . The pizza is really good. I ordered pepperoni and green pepper with hot Nashville Drizzle. Very unique crust very thin, but flavorful and generous amount of portions of cheese and toppings on the pizza. Service has been good and the atmosphere is great and lotd of tvs for games to watch. If you're ever in the area, you should check them out.

Had a great meal here tonight at Mazerella's. I had the Buffalo Chicken (Crustless Style), my…read morecompanions had the: Grilled Chicken Alfredo - He said the chicken was so incredibly tender and delicious and the garlic bread was also tasty And the Maz Combo Pizza - She said it was "super good" And my crustless was wonderful. The flavors were are balanced, the cheese has awesome pull and it was a great portion size. You order at the window and take a seat. They will bring your food out to you. They have soft drinks in a cooler in bottles and cans and a soda fountain. Our food was delivered hot and delicious in less than 15 mins. We will be back!

Hands down, best pizza around. Always fresh, always FULL of toppings, always hot, crust is perfect!…read moreWhen we order extra cheese, it's a LOT of cheese. If you're a cheese lover, you won't be disappointed. I can't say enough about this pizza. Finally, someone who does it right and doesn't skimp on toppings. Prices are fair, staff is friendly.

Kinda stuck in the middle on to what to really put for Arni's review wise. I would give 4 stars…read morefor the pizza and breadsticks and 3 stars for service and location. I was browsing for locally owned pizza place options in New Albany and saw this place pop up. I phoned in an order and first time line was busy, 2nd time I got through. Ordering went ok, not great. It would be half hour before food was ready. I arrived literally on time however, never being here before I didn't know what to expect. It's a small building and it does look pretty old, it has been around 60 years and is an Indiana staple. The parking lot is pretty small as well with additional parking in the back. I go inside and there is a line of people waiting. It didn't take me long to be waited on though. It was around $21 and some change for pizza and breadsticks. Pretty reasonable if you ask me honestly. I got a 14 inch pepperoni and breadsticks. I was supposed to get marinara sauce but got cheese sauce instead. Now the pizza, I like that the pepperoni is shredded instead of round, Pizza King is the only other place I know that does their pepperoni like this. The pizza itself was absolutely delicious and the breadsticks did pair well with the cheese sauce. I would like to try their other foods as well. Reason for 3 stars, location is small and dated but, I'm very into nostalgia. Parking can also be scarce. Inside seemed small and not much room for dining in, I ate some of the pizza in my vehicle. I give 4 stars to the pizza and breadsticks. I would return here.

They really went end to end with the sauce and toppings. Generous! But I really love crust so I was…read moreactually a little sad. Anyway nice crispy za. I forgot to take a pic of the pepperoni but it was a unique shape: Twas crumbles instead of cups :O Cajun chicken (also not pictured) did not taste Cajun in any respect but did have chicken. The square cuts were cute but also confused me - I didn't know how many to eat so I accidentally ate too many me thinks

I am a pizza snob. I love this place. Everything I have ever had from here is awesome.read more

Had a very interesting experience. I thought the food was good but the dinner as a whole left a lot…read moreto be desired. Firstly, we went on Valentine's Day. I was excited to choose from the options I saw online here, until I found out they had a limited menu. And when I say limited, there were literally four options for entrees. I get doing a limited menu but surely there can be more options. If you didn't want pizza or chicken dishes, then you were out of luck The service was below par. If they are going to charge a decent amount for food (bill was 67 for two people, with one beer) then I feel like the service should meet that. One of the servers that was not ours was loud and annoying during service. Our server mentioned to us that he was sorry for the service because they were busy, when half the tables in the place were open. I'd hate to see what a full place would have been like! I hate sounding negative on a local place but if you are going to charger higher end prices then the experience should also be a bit better. I feel like Martini's in Louisville (a similar cuisine I've visited recently) had cheaper prices than this place, and was a much better experience. Not sure if I'll be in a rush to be back here

The pizza is New York all the way & the chicken wings are to die for.. bite through skin again &…read moreagain

This place does pizza right in one of the coolest places around. The service is always top notch…read moretoo. This time I got the small meat pizza that was divine. In my opinion the only thing I wish they had were bread sticks. It was a perfect spring day and most of their patrons took advantage of eating outside on the side patio tables. The red and black exterior is a positive vibe. This place bat a 1000 percent every time!

We first learned of Marco's Pizza being huge fans of the now extinct joyful experience of walking…read morethrough a movie store like Family Video to pick out our movies for the weekend. That little window to the pizza side allowing the wafting smells of glorious food to come in was genius and irresistible. While the movie rental experience, and the lofty late fees we always seemed to accrue are now long gone, we still love the occasional delivery order from our local Marco's Pizza. Marco's offers a great menu that is consistent and a good value. We are never disappointed in the quality, flavor or service.

Really good pizza at a fair price. My favorite is thin crust pepperoni, Italian sausage…read more Every Tuesday buy one pizza get one free you can't beat that deal.