Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Papa Johns Pizza

    1.6 (13 reviews)
    Closed 9:30 am - 12:00 AM (Next day)

    Order Papa Johns Pizza Takeout or Delivery

    Papa Johns Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Papa Johns Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Never order from this location. So poorly run, should be closed. Hour and a half waits after time said was ready

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Lu S.
    0
    12
    5

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Michael S.
    182
    225
    419

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Papa Johns Pizza

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 9,320 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Water Street Pub and Grill

    Water Street Pub and Grill

    4.3
    (60 reviews)
    1.6 mi

    Came here for dinner and unfortunately left pretty underwhelmed overall…read more The restaurant itself was clean, and service initially started off fine. When we first arrived, the restaurant was not busy. Only a couple other tables occupied, so expectations were fairly high for a smooth experience. Unfortunately, things quickly went downhill. The food took quite a while to come out despite how slow it was. When it finally did, it was first delivered to the wrong table before eventually making its way to us. The food runner then randomly grabbed a ranch from our table and brought it to another table. He seemed potentially new, but overall the service felt very disorganized and clueless, especially considering the restaurant wasn't busy. We ordered the cheese curds to start, and they were disappointing. The breading was mushy and extremely greasy, and the cheese itself tasted low quality rather than the fresh curds you'd expect at a Wisconsin pub. We also ordered several wing flavors since they were on special: garlic parm, buffalo, bourbon BBQ, and lemon pepper. One issue right away was the lack of flavor variety overall on the menu. The wings themselves were inconsistent. Sizes varied dramatically, which clearly affected the cook quality. Some were fried so hard they were like chewing leather, while others had soggy, undercooked skin. Flavor wise the buffalo were almost completely flavorless. The lemon pepper was extremely mild. The garlic parm was probably the best of the group, though still just average. The bourbon BBQ was rough. The sauce tasted like an overly sweet, overly salty cheap jarred glaze rather than an actual house-made BBQ sauce. My wife ordered the Mary Mac burger without a bun and was told extra lettuce leaves could be substituted to make it a lettuce wrap. Instead, it came out with just shredded lettuce. The burger itself was overcooked and lacking flavor. The fries were decent enough, but nothing memorable. Overall, this felt like a place with potential that just missed the mark on both execution and consistency during our visit.

    Hubby is always up for a good burger, so we stopped here on our way out of town on a Wednesday…read morenight. Signage outside indicated that they have fish fry on Wednesday night so that was a plus for me. He had a water street melt with chips and fried cheese sticks. He asked for his burger to be cooked medium. The menu indicated his burger had onion spread on it. His burger was not cooked medium but well done. The onion spread was a "sauce overload" and not a pleasant addition to the melt. The cheese sticks were wrapped in a won ton wrap and deep fried. They were served with a marinara. The cheese sticks could have used some type of seasoning to give them flavor. Very bland. I had the fish fry special of fried perch. Mild fishy flavor and definitely frozen. Thin crumb breading that had some type of seasoning. I choose fries, coleslaw, and rye toast. The fries and toast were the best parts. I wanted tartar sauce for my fish but it was so sweet that it wasn't good with the fish. Service was fine. She needed to leave before us and asked if we wanted to close our ticket. We didn't plan on staying as we're traveling so we closed it out. Location was easy to find. Bar area was clean.

    Photos
    Bar area
    Bar area
    Beef brisket quesadilla
    Beef brisket quesadilla
    Water Street Pub and Grill

    See all

    IVR Bar

    IVR Bar

    4.3
    (51 reviews)
    2.8 mi
    $$

    IVR Bar | Milwaukee…read more Started off with a Piña Colada from the mocktail menu (they can add liquor too ) and it was the PERFECT drink for a hot summer day. So refreshing and sooo good! Honey Garlic Wings - SO filling and the sauce was incredible Honey Garlic Jumbo Shrimp - perfectly cooked and packed with flavor... might be my new favorite shrimp Arancini Butter Chicken Pizza - absolutely delicious! Chicken Tikka Tacos with Mexican biryani rice - such a fun combo and SO good! Lamb Chops - my first time ever trying them and OMG... I was seriously impressed!! 5/5 The presentation was beautiful, every single dish was flavorful, and the portions were HUGE. The staff was so welcoming and made the whole experience even better. If you stop by, definitely ask for Tabby!! She was amazing and such a pleasure to have. They also have: A patio TONS of parking (Milwaukee people know how rare that is ) A huge bar with TVs everywhere A beer wall Happy hour specials A rewards program you can sign up for with your phone number! Definitely adding this one to my Milwaukee favorites! Check out the full review on Instagram: @ratedbyaleena

    I've visited IVR Bar several times and realized I never submitted the review I wrote. I'm happy…read morethough because after several visits I have more qualities to cover. Warning this will be a long review as a result. My review does have a few recommendations based upon my experience and one negative in #5. 1. Food The food here has consistently been very good. One of our favorites is their butter chicken pizza served on naan bread. It comes with extra butter sauce for dipping, and the flavor and consistency is so good. The pizza is full of chicken and a nice amount of cheese. The only thing I'd recommend is serving the side of butter sauce hotter. It's always much cooler than the pizza, which I've experienced more than once. Their naan bread is always soft and fresh. We've tried both the garlic naan and cheesy naan and both are so good. Buffalo wings and birria tacos served on naan were all delicious. The meat was seasoned and the rice was very good as well. The honey garlic cauliflower appetizer is tasty but the portion is quite small for $14. You'll see the serving spoon in the photo for scale it shows how small the serving is. I think lowering the price could encourage more people to order it. For $14 you might as well get some wings or a 1 topping pizza! 2. Drinks They make excellent drinks. I've had multiple martinis here and have never been disappointed. My husband ordered a Hennessy sidecar that was also very good. I went for their Thursday ladies happy hour where martinis are $5. The only drawback is that only a few specific flavors are included: blueberry, apple, cosmopolitan, and dirty martinis. I had a pineapple lemon drop martini there and hoped to get it again for the happy hour price, but it wasn't included. I think it would help if they advertised which martinis are included in the happy hour promotion so customers know what to expect. 3. Service Service has always been good during my visits. I've never had a bad experience with the staff. The dark skinned host has seated my family several times and is always friendly and welcoming. We're always seated immediately because they're never busy when we go. 4. Atmosphere & Entertainment There's usually about 2-3 other parties in the dinning room and a few patrons at the bar when I've visited. The lighting is dim and the vibe is relaxed. They have plenty televisions throughout the dining room and bar. The dining room has a 4 way TV in the center. If you're into sports they don't miss. They also have a few slot machines near the bar. 5. Cleanliness Overall cleanliness has been acceptable, but there are a few things that could be improved. I have noticed gnats on multiple visits. It's not a swarm but they are noticeable. More so this time with multiple sweet martinis at our table. With them using fresh fruit and syrups for cocktails, I imagine that isn't helping. The bathrooms appear to have been updated and look nice. There wasn't any odor, but the trash can could have been emptied or pushed down. 6. Menu & Communication One area where they could improve is marketing. Their website and social media advertise events or specials without explaining the details. For example, the flyer in my photos show tacos and tequilas night. With flight of tequila samples and tacos for $65/person. How many tacos and tequila samples does one get? How much tequila per sample? What would I be paying for? More social media presence, photos of their food in the happy hour posts and more details of specials would bring in more customers. I'm a Yelp and social media lady! I do a little research before deciding on new spots. I'm not scrolling through 20 posts a restaurant shares to get to food videos or images. I expect the to grab my attention immediately. It's so close to many big offices, factories, and various businesses. They should be busy always. I've seen multiple restaurants come and go in this same building over the last 12 years. I'm hopeful they'll be more present to increase their customer base. Another improvement would be adding more vegan options. When I was avoiding meat and dairy earlier this year, I noticed they listed the Garlic honey cauliflower online as vegan but it was labeled vegetarian on the menu on the table, which could be confusing for someone strictly following a vegan diet. 7. Loyalty Program One thing they do very well is their rewards system. They track points through your credit card, and we've received $5 off simply from returning. That's a great feature that more locally owned restaurants could learn from. So you're wondering if I would go back? Yes, I plan on it. Although I'm hopeful they consider my recommendations. Would I recommend it? Yes the food is good! The service is good! I've never had to wait! If you've never tried Indian food before this is a great place to start. They serve familiar foods with Indian flavors which may be helpful with easing in.

    Photos
    Bar view.
    Bar view.
    Coconut Korma Enchiladas
    Coconut Korma Enchiladas
    Pineapple lemon drop

    See all

    Pineapple lemon drop
    Evie’s Vietnamese Kitchen

    Evie’s Vietnamese Kitchen

    4.1
    (178 reviews)
    1.7 mi
    $$

    Evie's is my local go to for Vietnamese Bondi sandwiches and Pho. But the other food on their menu…read moreis also equally delicious. I especially like their Vietnamese tacos with chicken. It's also nice that they offer Boba tea options either for dinner or lunch or to go. Easy parking with a lot right out in front on Appleton makes it an easy choice for a date lunch with my wife.

    First time here. Came with two other people for a Friday lunch…read more Food: Excellent selection of food. Plenty of choices for appetizers, street food, and entrees. They also have lunch specials if you're short on time or trying to stay within a budget. For an appetizer, we got the Red Bean Sesame Balls. You get six of these delightful little hot and sweet balls with a red bean center. Probably more of a dessert than an appetizer, but that didn't stop us. Two of us ordered the Pho. I got the Seafood Pho, and the other person got the Beef Pho. Both came out plenty hot, with very generous portions even though we ordered the small size. There were lots of delicious ingredients and a flavorful broth. Both were excellent. The third person ordered the Pad Thai, which was also delicious. The meat was tender, the noodles were cooked just right, and once again, it was a generous portion. Service: We were seated right away and given menus and waters. The server did a good job helping us navigate the menu and was friendly and efficient. The only issue was the timing of the food. Two of us received our Pho while the third person had to wait for her Pad Thai. It would have been better if all three meals had arrived closer together. Instead, we had that slightly awkward round of, "You eat," "No, I'll wait," "No, it'll get cold," and "Do you want some of mine?" Atmosphere: It's a well-designed space with plenty of seating, including spots at a counter and throughout the dining room. The acoustics are a bit loud because of all the hard surfaces, and the volume of the music added to the overall noise level. At times, it was difficult to hear someone across the table without leaning in. Overall, an excellent meal. I would definitely stop in again, either to order the exact same thing or to try something new.

    Photos
    Evie’s Vietnamese Kitchen
    Spring rolls
    Spring rolls
    Evie’s Vietnamese Kitchen

    See all

    Marko's Pizza

    Marko's Pizza

    2.9
    (40 reviews)
    2.0 mi
    $$

    ((So gross and disgusting I had to froce myself to eat 2 slices ) save ur 25$ and go somewhere else…read moreI'm so mad the pizza was inedible Was driving home and I seen a pizza place never been before i like pizza so thought I would give it a try I order a large pepperoni sausage mushroom pizza It was horrible 1.it was super salty like so salty gave me a headache 2. The bottom of the crust was burnt grey so it was dry Could only finished 2 pieces after that my mouth tasted like I been eating burnt salty luchable pizza For a frist time ever ording pizza will be my last Felt sick after eating 2 pieces might be food poisoning I don't even think the sausage was cooked it was we still raw inside

    My wife and I like to drive around while the weather is nice and hit all different kinds of food…read moreestablishments. We recently decided to explore Germantown and we stopped at Mario's Pizza for a cheese, mushroom, and sausage pizza. We've heard about this place for many years and decided to finally give it a try. My wife went in to order the pizza and two drinks and was told that it will be ready in 20 minutes. 37 minutes later we got our pizza and two drinks. I was extremely hungry and decided to try it in the car, rather than waiting to go to a park or another place to park. The pizza was awful. I have actually invested in a New York pizza restaurant and know good pizza. This is not that. To pick it apart for you, understanding that taste varies among eaters, I will tell you that the crust is dry, flavorless, and essentially becomes a cracker when cooked. I like thin crust, pizza, and I've had many crisp crusts that were good and excellent (Zaffiros on Farwell being a benchmark). This is really not good. The sauce was extremely bland. I like playing sauce, but this was flavorless as if there were no spices in it of any kind. The cheese is good. It's a stringy mozzarella. that is the saving grace of the pizza itself. The mushrooms were flavorless, unseasoned, and dry. The sausage was abysmal. So salty, so inconsistent in size of pieces, and way over spiced. I'm afraid this one is a miss. My wife thinks it was a sold a couple years ago. Not exactly the pizza place I've heard so much about over the years.

    Photos
    A horrible pizza
    A horrible pizza
    New ownership and a nice renovation.  Good pizza and good prices.
    New ownership and a nice renovation. Good pizza and good prices.
    Marko's Pizza

    See all

    Papa Johns Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...