My wife doesn't even like pizza and she loved this place. We had the Voyager's Pizza, which was the chef's special that day, and it was seriously good. It had locally grown mushrooms and you could really tell the ingredients were fresh and high quality. The best part was that it was filling without being heavy. We left completely satisfied but didn't have that sluggish, weighed-down feeling you sometimes get after eating pizza. One of our favorite food stops while visiting Evansville. Would definitely come back! read more

This was our first visit to Pangea. We'd love to return to try the other half of the restaurant for ramen. Service was a little slow to get seated, drinks refilled, and get our checks. But we loved our pizza! We got four different slices so we could try a variety. My husband wasn't a fan of the hot honey, but that's personal preference. We also got an Italian salad to share and it was a delicious addition. The restaurant itself is very clean and nicely decorated. read more

First, this is two restaurants- one is pizza and the other is Asian. I'll review the pizza joint. When you walk in you are greeted with an open kitchen and friendly smiles! I inquired about the menu and they explained you could order either cuisine and then decided on pizza. The menu is simple but unique, and the vibe reminiscent of a college dive joint but cleaner - very cool on my book! The cupperoni was topped with hot honey, which accentuated the saltiness. The pistachio had a nut butter base and crumbled spicy sausage, which was unique. No tap beer but if you really want one they will bring it over from the other restaurant. read more

See all

I can see why Pangea Pizza makes so many "top pizza restaurant" lists! You can order a 14 or 18 inch of any pizza on the menu, or there are special pizzas available by the slice every day - check out the website to see what flavors are available each day! I love that they have multiple vegetarian pizza options, not just a cheese and a veggie! I got the Really Fun Guy, which was absolutely delicious! Generous mushroom toppings. The crust has a lot of flavor and has the perfect crisp texture. Ordering online for pick-up was easy! On a busy weekend, they get a little backed up with orders, but I only had to wait an extra 5-10 mins. There are a few tables inside the small space but lots of takeout orders going out the door. Plenty of street parking and a gravel lot across the street! Can't wait to go back to try some gelato! read more

Pangea Pizzeria - Really Fun Guy - Gelato Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

It's a really great place food is fast but not too fast to where you're concerned I got kids pizza which was $12 but to be honest as an adult I'm a five six a hundred and 75 lb woman and it filled me up hopefully that gave you enough information on what you can do and I like to eat the people were really nice they took their time with you and they seem like they have fun as far as making the food and you can see them make the food too read more

Pangea Pizzeria - Italian sausage pizza kids size $12 - Gelato Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

If you want a delicious salad that tastes as good as it looks, this is the place to go. I was heading to a concert and needed a fast place to eat without a long wait. Oh my. I ordered the pizza and just wanted a half a salad. I should have ordered a whole salad. I like salad, but this salad was just so yummy. I literally was sad when I was done. The lettuce was so fresh. The blue cheese chunks were huge and the cherry tomatoes, absolutely the best. The fresh ingredients make this place different from any other place. Highly recommend. I wish i lived closer to eat there every week. read more

Pangea Pizzeria is a place I think about often when I want pizza. I love that they have a rotating menu where you can walk in and order pizza by the slice. The inside has a cool vibe, but there is not much seating, especially if you have a larger group. With that being said, I also love getting carry out. The pistachio pizza is my favorite, and I love their thin crispy crust with all the fresh ingredients for toppings. read more

Pangea Pizzeria - Pistachio pizza - Gelato Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Ordered their specialty margherita pizza to go on the night of 10/18 so I pick it up and take a peak and see just a basic plan cheese pizza in the box. No fresh mozzarella, no basil, nothing like the picture on their website. I walk back in (should've just got my $30+ back) and I ask if they had any extra basil. The girl was very nice about it and said she didn't know why it looks like that and why the kitchen did it that way but she went back and cut some more basil for the pizza which helped a little but to be honest, nothing could've made this what it actually should've been for that price. The worst part is that it wasn't even good for basic cheese pizza. Maybe it was an off night or made incorrectly, idk but never again. read more

Pangea Pizzeria - Supposedly this is their $30 Margarita pizza (in reality just a plain cheese pizza) - Gelato Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Guy making the pizzas is very nice and hardworking, running the place himself. We got the chicken bacon ranch pizza. It's all hand tossed and you can see it. Delicious af. I wanna to try some more authentic pizza flavors here next time. Pizza came out fast too. Nice chill ambiance . read more

If you're looking for high-quality delicious pizza, you have to try Pangea! I ordered a cupperoni pizza slice to go and it was so tasty. Their pizza slices were pretty big but one slice was definitely not enough for me. I also got a cup of their lemon sorbetto and it was so light and fluffy. The only downside was that I waited probably over 20 minutes just for my one slice of pizza, which I wasn't expecting. read more

Pangea Pizzeria - Lemon sorbetto (to-go) - Gelato Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

My partner and I stopped in for an early lunch. Having dined at the ramen shop on the second floor, we were exited to sample Pangaea pizza offerings. There is ample parking in a semi-private lot across the street. When we arrived, promptly at 11:00, we overheard somebody say, "Is it THAT time already?", alluding to the fact that they were open to customers. We ordered at the counter, and were told they would bring our pizzas out when ready. 34 minutes later, still no pizza. I walked to the counter, and noted several pizzas already prepared. Great!! One of them must be ours!!! About 5 minutes later, we were ( finally) served. It makes me sad to have to say the pizza just wasn't that good. Yes, the toppings were delicious, but the crust.... The base of all pizza was not crispy and delicate, more akin to a cardboard box. It was difficult to chew, and more so after our pizza (quickly) got cold. After a couple pieces, my jaws got tired from chewing the overly glutenous crust. I was disappointed after spending $52.00 for 2 pizzas and 2 sodas. read more

Pangea Pizzeria - Cupparoni pizza - Gelato Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

Okay so the food was pretty good but PLEASE JUST PLEASE DON'T ADD BASIL LEAVES! They are disgusting. Their dessert is didn't try but Dang the prices were expensive. It was 2.50 for 1 macaron and $26 for a dozen! It should be $12 for a dozen. I can eat a macaroon in 2 bites and I'm not charging a $1 and 25 cents per bite and not charging the $26 for 24 bites. Now let's get on to the service. They put our. Food out in record time which was very sus but luckily wasn't bad and poisoned. The place was nice on the inside. Now if Pangea is reading this, ask if they want basil leaves and bring your prices down! Especially on macaroons! read more

Looks like this is going to be another winner for the Pangea chain. Attended the soft opening and they seem to be pretty organized. This restaurant is small but actually has enough seating for the lunch crowd with the counter and outdoor seating. The pizza was good. Had the Cacio e Pepe. Very tasty with a crispy crust. They have single slices if you don't want a whole pie. Great lunch place downtown read more

See all

I have to say I was very disappointed in this pizza. I ordered the knuckleball pizza. This was my first time ordering with this pizzeria. I had it delivered. It was around $25 for a 14 inch pizza.. The pizza definitely wasn't worth $10. The red Pizza sauce tasted like Chef Boyardee sauce. I kept biting into something overcooked, and I had to spit it out because I couldn't chew it. Some places I would give a second chance, but I definitely will not be ordering from this place again. read more

I love this place. One of my favorites in Evansville. The drunken noodles and spring roll are my go to. Recently had the monthly special meal and drink-duck tacos with the farm stand cocktail, fantastic. Melt in your mouth and so flavorful! read more

I hated this place. The pizza took forever, and it wasn't busy. The workers were snobby and rude. The pizza wasn't good. The atmosphere sucked. Seating is EXTREMELY limited. I will never return. read more

Pangea Pizzeria has quickly become one of my favorites. The pizza tastes great and is unlike anything else I've had in Evansville. My personal favorite is the Cupperoni. Service is good - I frequently order carry out and it's an easy process and always fresh and tasty. read more

My wife and I were going to the ramen place after a three hour drive, but they lied about how long the wait usually is. So we stopped here at Pangea. I'm usually very picky about pizza and almost never eat it out anymore. However, the pizza here was very good. Much better than we expected! We had the Far Oasis. Great crust, tasty roasted tomatoes, not too much cheese, good sauce, and nice veggies. Only the olives were a tad too salty. Fresh garlic and spinach and maybe some tarragon and feta would make it more interesting. But again, I'm very picky. I recommend eating here. Screw the ramen place. Great pizza. Good atmosphere with friendly staff and cool music. Would come here again if we ever stop in Evansville. read more

Great pizza, great service. Next to our favorite ramen place, 2nd Language (same owner/business group). read more

Pangea Pizzeria - GFam^5 - Gelato Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

The pizza was great, the staff went above and beyond in customer service, and the building is pretty.

Large variety of pizza options. Fresh and delicious. Self service (order and then pick a table). Food is brought fast to your table. Great selection of desserts (gelato and cakes) read more