I have gone to the Original Palumbo's a few times before in Stroudsburg and wanted to check out this one in the Bartonsville area as well. Went early on around when they opened for the day. The man working inside was friendly and the slice was just over $2 or so which is standard for the area. The slice was good. Minimal flop and a nice little char on the bottom. Sauce to cheese ratio was solid and the sauce had good flavor. Couldn't speak to the rest of the menu as I just grabbed a slice to go, but the cheese slice was solid. read more

Palumbo's II - single slice - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

[1154] 2/2021 We were staying a nearby hotel so decided to check this place out. There is no indoor dining due to Covid but that was fine with me since were taking it out. The staff was nice The single slice I ordered was tasty. Kid didn't like his nuggets read more

See all

My first stop when I come to PA, the pizza is almost to the one they sell in NYC, two brothers cooking up an Italian storm of delicious authentic Italian pizza, sausage roll, calzones and so much more!!! A must stop!!! So make you way to delicious food in Stroudsburg PA lots to do in the area, river rafting, snow tubing, swimming and fishing all near bye! See you here at the best pizza in PA read more

See all

Great FOOD! Very pleasant people. 1 of the best pizzas I have had anywhere! Chicken roll pepperoni rolls garlic knots all fantastic! read more

Yummm! Our family was on vacation to the POCONOS and needed a pizza night in and it was YUMMY!!! It was also ready so quickly! Definitely recommend. read more

NOT WEARING MASKS!!!! I walked in today, noticed all patrons were wearing masks, but NOT ONE EMPLOYEE was wearing one!!! Lost a customer forever. If you cannot respect me or your community you do not deserve my dollars. read more

I went to Palumbos to try out some local pizza. As I entered a woman had walked in before me. She politely asked the guy if she could use the restroom. He started going off about mom and pop restaurants never letting people use the bathroom. The lady asked if there was anywhere local and he said buy a water and you can. She ran outside and came right back with money for a water. Apparently she had grabbed $2 and he wanted $2.12. She said she'd run out and grab the $0.12 but the guy just started going on a rant to the point the lady cried. I left, screw that restaurant! read more

Without question, this place has one of the best pepperoni pizzas I've eaten in a long time. The dudes that run this establishment are absolutely awesome. This is an old school New York style pizza joint at its finest. read more

Pizza was very good, I would definitely order from them again just don't do delivery it's almost $10 extra...

ignorant phone service and staff wanting to fight me when I said so. food is Ok but cancelled my order once I was talked down to on the phone. I am disabled and shouldn't need to drive down to the storefront to cancel my order for poor service. again the food is ok but the guy answering the phone was ignoran. take that attitude back to your city and welcome to the country.t read more

After a healthy amount of shooting at the nearby gun range, nothing screams like hittin' the spot like some pizza by the slice. Coming into this place, super casual, strip mall pizzeria. Nothing too fancy, but the fragrance from the pizza just draws you in. I appreciate this place for the fact that they are all about business. They want to get your order right and get you what you want. If you want, a sub or a mod, they will try to help you. The ingredients are fresh and the thin crust is perfectly baked. These are medium-large size slices; basically normal sized. This was a pretty amazing way to fuel up for the white water rafting the next day. I highly recommend trying some of their other options, like the subs, calzones, etc. They have a lot to try. read more

Great food and service. Enjoyed the steak sandwich w/ the works , plus Antipasto. Enough for two meals . Less that $20. Will definitely return. read more

Needed food for my break, and their food was hot and ready. Tasted amazing, they also have a lot of choices and they even do delivery

Excellent Sicilian style pizza! We were staying at a nearby hotel & opted to try this pizza and I'm so glad we did. The pizza is huge (very very heavy and filling- almost like Chicago Style Deep Dish) we ordered two & should have only ordered one because we couldn't even finish the one pizza! My 16 year old son who normally eats a whole large pizza himself could only eat three squares. I would definitely order from here again & wish they had a restaurant in our hometown. read more

Palumbo's II - Sicilian Style! One pizza is more than enough for a family of 4 - two of whom happen to be big eating teenage boys! I highly recommend!! - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Their Pizza is the BEST in the entire Stroudsburg area! I moved to PA from NJ and tried a lot of different Pizza Restaurants and couldn't find one that was really good until I found Palumbo's II !!! Their pizza is delicious and every other item I have tried has also been delicious! Their delivery service is outstanding! The food is always hot and they are very prompt! In addition, their employees are always very POLITE and professional! Bottom line, I love Palumbo's II read more

Had the pizza and the cheese steak sandwich. Pizza was terrific, crispy crust, plenty of cheese and sauce. Very tasty cold the next day. Some pizzas are just terrible the next day cold. Just one solid mass of artery-clogging cheese flavored cement. The next day pizza from here, still had it's flavor. Cheese steak, was terrific. My wife ordered "Deluxe cheese steak" don't recall what it was named, but had peppers and onions and stuff. My son ordered the same. I tried a bite and was very impressed. The gentleman that took our order was one step ahead of my son giving our address. He knew where our community was located and how to get to it. Delivery driver was very friendly and professional at the same time. Pulled up to our parking area and seeing our cars were from out of state, introduced himself. Prices were average to a little below. Just moved into the area, so have not had exposure to local prices. Most definitely less than Jersey prices. Would recommend to friends, family and all. read more

Jason and Jimmy are awesome! Real Margherita pizza, delicious garlic knots, and excellent service! Highly recommended!

This place is Great!!! If you miss that good old Fashioned elementary school cafeteria style pizza. Or the pegresso soup served in a bowl that looked like their Chinese take out came in. Best of all the tables had that good old just cleaned with a pork chop look. read more

I'm out here for a little vacation and I'm staying at the Fairfield inn In stroudsburg and me my girlfriend her cousin and his fiancé were looking for a place to eat breakfast. We basically accidentally stumble upon. A little gem of pizza place and they were serving breakfast! First of all we all are from New York and we are just blown away by Palumbo's II breakfast menu! We don't even have this pizza there! We had the bacon egg and cheese calzone and we had the peppers and onions pizza both were phenomenal. The guy behind the counter and his wife making the pizzas is a very personal couple and proud of the food they make and what they sell and you can definitely taste the passion in what they are doing! New York is definitely missing out because they have definitely struck gold! It's a diamond in the ruff but let me tell you you will not be disappointed eating here! read more

Breakfast sandwich was spot on! We are from NYC and feel like this place would be a hit there. Staff was nice and personable. Highly recommend! After all, why wait on the Dunkin' drive-thru line when you can just grab some delicious breakfast pizza two doors down! read more

I am a truck driver that stays at a hotel in Bartonsville almost every week. I have been used to eating at the hotel bar but last night I wanted something different. I browsed through a bunch of area restaurant menus and settled on Palumbo's because of the great reviews. I can understand why they get such good reviews! I ordered the Chicken Francese which was served over linguini. This dish was just like it came out of an Italian Nonna's kitchen!! The food came right to my hotel room in a very timely manner and was piping hot. This is my new Thursday night go to restaurant! Keep up the great work!!! read more

Palumbo's II - Chicken Francese - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Always get our order right. Food never disappoints! Highly recommend if you're in the area, so many options to choose from even for vegetarians like me :-) read more

Don't order slices. The last two times I was there instead of getting the fresh pizza displayed in the cases I was given what looked and tasted like day-old slices from under the counter that were inedible. Gave them the benefit of the doubt the first time because I have been going there for years. But it just happened again when I brought a friend there. She wondered why I would recommend a place that served food like that. Definite bait and switch. Never again read more

Awesome, hot, out of the oven , thin crust, pizza. Ran into this pizzeria on my way to NYC just a mile out of I81. I prefer this place 1000x times more than anything in the highway service centers. I ordered a medium cheese pizza, 14", more than enough for 3 people with 2 slices each. Price is good and they have specials everyday. Super Tuesday is two large pie for 16.75! Recommend! read more

Been ordering from here the past few years and love it. There pizza (which I consider "real pizza") is great and reminds me of where I grew up in Jersey. The prices are awesome and the rest of the food is great too! It's what you expect from a pizzeria, totally recommended. read more

Tried it twice just to be fair and both times the pizza was a disgrace. Two slices needed 6 paper towels to remove the grease. A tasteless mess. Worst part is that those handling the food are the same handling the money. No thanks, I'll pass on the bacteria. This place is not long for this world. read more

Awesome rice balls !!!! Staff is really nice ... Pizza is good ! Very clean and neat staff is very friendly ... wish they would deliver! read more

The pizza here was good. Although my family and I do prefer the original Palumbo's. Great deal on the large pizza and pitcher/2 liter bottle of soda for $12.50. The place is clean and the service was good. read more

In a time when local businesses are hurting, Palumbos decided my order was too small and too far to deliver. In the past they have always accommodated me, but today the guy on the phone was rude and showed zero customer service, even though he said it was slow. I guess people that live alone don't deserve delivery! They just lost a loyal customer read more

Uh-huh! Palumbo's has expanded and moved towards the Rt. 80/33 side of town! Yee-HAW! As usual, thin crust pizza that is made well, and best of all TASTES GREAT! The new locations is a bit of a pain to get into, and work your way around. However, when inside it's alittle overwhelmingly beige! The seating is comfortable and clean. The staff has been quick to acknowledge and serve you. Prices are not out of line. I have yet to try one of the entrees. Great spaghetti and meatballs. Stroudsburg's BEST pizza joint has a cousin... Give 'em a try. read more

Pizza was good - large was definitely large. Can't say we tried anything crazy, although the specialty by the slice pieces looked fantastic. We were traveling with our young nephews, so we limited our selection to "basic" 8-) Would 100% go back. Service was great - the staff at the counter were all nice, friendly, and attentive. Simple decor with big screens mounted, playing the various games that were on (+ for the guys). read more

Fast friendly and very efficient staff. Please give them a try and plenty of food. You will not be disappointed!

Called in for curbside delivery. When I got there they came out with no mask. That means they are making your pizza with going without CDC guidelines. read more

I stopped in one night to grab a quick slice on my way home, huge disappointment. First of all, the pizza was literally dripping with so much grease the bag was soaked! I when to eat the plain cheese pizza slice, completely tasteless. To top it all off, they charged me almost 5$ for ONLY 2 slices and nothing else. Complete letdown unfortunately. read more

Got a pie that was smashed and attached to the top lid of the box. I called to explain and the woman that answered was nasty. Thanks for the amazing service! I will not be ordering from them again read more

Palumbo's II - Thanks,this is great! Can you tell how much care they put into a pie? Plus when I called to explain what I had just got, the woman was nasty - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Being a full blooded Italian, rooted from Staten Island, family all from Brooklyn...we know good pizza. All my Italian friends in the area from the old neighborhood, we all know good pizza. We all agree that Palumbos beats out all these other pizza places in town, best pizza best Italian food around by far. I use the spot off 3rd street here to grab a slice alone, and when I wanna take family out we go to the other spot up 611 with better seating. Sicilian slice is great, try a chicken parmigiana sandwich or if you like those exotic pies with the chicken bacon ranch and things like that they do that sort of thing. True testament to a good plain slice here. read more

Best pizza in the poconos. I hated almost every slice I ever had, till I found this place. They have delicious frozen desserts and cookies from NY brought in on the regular the florentine lace are my favorite. The tomato basil pie is excellent, so is the white, stuffed philly cheese and plain. The rolls are great, so are the entrées and sandwiches. The guys that work there are all top notch, and gentlemen. Love this place.... read more

Don't make the mistake of ordering the large stromboli, unless you are sharing or are good with leftovers. It is huuuuge. I was staying in the Hampton Inn across the street, so I ended up wasting over half. Really good food, fresh ingredients and very well priced. I wouldn't hesitate to go back. read more

So, we went on yelp to help us find a nice pizza place and chose Palumbo's ll because the reviews were so great. Ummmm, no thank you. The minestrone soup was watery, the tossed salad was given to us with a plastic package of dressing on top of it! The spaghetti and meatballs plate was ok. The chicken parm was average. My family's been to plenty of small places where the decor is dated and everything is well worn, but the food was delicious. Sadly, this is not the case. We will not come back the next time we stay in the Hampton Inn. read more

This is by far my favorite pizza in the Poconos. I have never been disappointed anytime I have ordered anything from these people and I strongly recommend them. As they say about good pizza, it's all in the crust! read more