Their items are spectacular. Everything there is of excellent quality. The staff is terrific

The owners and their merchandise is simply wonderful! I've read the bad reviews and my feeling is you can't please everybody! The prices of gems and gold these days makes it out of reach for many. I've witnessed the owner helping people who don't have a lot to spend getting something because the owner gave it to them below cost!! Can't stay in business doing that a lot! This is not Kay jewelers with poor quality stones or man made stones. This is high quality gems with individualized made to order pieces. Everything we have gotten has been magnificent and of the highest quality! I've trusted them with stones and work costing thousands of dollars!! You won't found a better place to get work done or buy. If your looking for a cheap quick fix, this isn't your store. Just call them and you'll get an individual appointment!! read more

Overman Designs - New diamond ring custom! - Jewelry Near Me - Payson, Arizona

My original wedding set was stolen, it was stolen fr a nurses aide at one of the hospitals in the valley. It wasn't worth much because that's what we could afford at the time, We have now been married over 35 years and can afford more. I still would like to have had the original set back. The owner of Overmans charged us over $5000 for the set of ring, which included saudering them together, and if I had needed it to be size, that would have been included to. Mr Overman said "Since we had purchased the rings from him, he wouldn't char us the usual $2000 to sauder them together. But, they kept all the diamonds that went around the entire back side of the rings!!! I have not been able to get ahold of him since!! I would not recommend Overmans to anyone!!! They will rip you off!!! read more

Where are you? Store closed. No signs explaining why. Mailbox full when I called. Website shows you are open. You have lost my business. Do you even care? read more

Two years ago I posted my negative experience with an engagement ring. Overmans decided to post another comment regarding my experience and trying to refute my claims. Why are they still posting incorrect information? I will never set foot in there again and after my review I received ugly phone calls and lessons on how and when to wear an engagement ring. Their 30 day WARRANTY should say it all. Buy local with this business is a joke. read more

I have a lot of very high end jewelry inherited as well as that which I have purchased myself. From the moment I walked into Overman's I knew I had found my final jeweler. They treat their clients like trusted friends, provide exemplary service, celebrate your special days, and provide products of high quality and imaginative design. I have come to trust them implicitly. My adult children have also become clients, having their engagement and wedding rings made by Overmans as well as gifts for special occasions. When I lost one of the earrings my husband gave me for our wedding, 43 years ago, I was heartbroken. Chad and Melissa calmed my concerns and went to work hand crafting a replacement so that I could still have that feeling I had when I first received them. This is the only jewelry store you will ever need. I feel so fortunate to have them in our little town. read more

Top notch service and stunning jewelry. I highly recommend going here above any other location in Arizona.

I have never felt comfortable in a jewelry store until I found Overman Designs. They really took the time to get to know us and make recommendations on what they thought we would like. They've done everything from repairs to new jewelry to custom designs. I have a ring I have had since I was a child that was completely worn. They tried so hard to find a setting similar to the original, but because of an unusual size it was impossible. They helped me find a setting to complement the stone. I am 100% satisfied with both the design and the quality. Even though the stone wasn't expensive it has great sentimental value to me. Chad and Melissa really understood that and created a ring that means even more. I feel like they cared as much as I did about my ring. read more

Had a great experience today at Overman Design. I needed a battery replaced in my watch and the closure latch tightened. They were wonderful! Quick, efficient and courteous. Thank you for the great service. read more

I was looking for a place that does plating for my wedding rings. I was so happy when I walked into Overman 's Design in Payson. The staff there were so friendly and helpful. I would definitely recommend them to everyone. read more

This place is hands-down the best jewelry store in Arizona. Amazing people, amazing designs, at a wholesale price. This place is a must stop if you're in Payson. They have tons of jewelry and do custom designs as well. I'll never go anywhere else. read more

A great place to find amazing one of a kind jewelry! The customer service is outstanding! They have beautiful things:). They can even custom make things! read more