My efforts to embrace this Pub were sincere, having visited it five times in search of a better experience, but each visit left me more disappointed than the last. I'd give 0 stars if I could.
Let's dissect the experiences:
Atmosphere:
Although they brand themselves as an Irish Pub, O'Neil's lacks the distinctive features that define an authentic Irish pub. I spent a bit of time in the midwest and I encountered a bar owned by Germans claiming to be an Irish Pub, which felt more authentically Irish than O'Neil's. And they admitted to knowing nothing about Irish pubs. That's telling.
While O'Neil's offer ample space, the crowd and vibe lean more toward a spot for quick connections than an authentic Irish Pub experience. There is nothing Irish about O'Neil's. It's a fancier looking dive bar.
Drinks and Bar Service:
Opting for a beer over a mixed drink seems advisable here. On two out of four visits, ordering a Jim Coke resulted in an overpowering quantity of Jim Beam. While I appreciate strong drinks, this was excessive. For a strong drink, I go to the Witch City VFW. Just 2 visits proved these were stronger. If Jon Taffer visited the bar, I'm positive he'd recommend Partender. Lastly, attracting the bartender's attention can be quite challenging. It consistently took over 10 minutes to get noticed and at least another 5 to receive our drinks. Wether or not it was busy.
Food:
The food tastes great. Really great, actually. I thought it was slightly redeeming and I edited another review to state that. However, shortly after my update I became violently ill.
Entertainment:
I had high hopes for their Karaoke nights, being a Karaoke enthusiast with years of experience running Karaoke events myself. Regrettably, all four times I attended, the Karaoke was more than subpar. It's not the singers. Some are good. Some are bad. You still cheer them on. That's how it works. However, the DJ (who I'm told his name is named Nick?) seemed incredilby inexperienced. Maybe this is not his day job? But maybe he should focus on that. The dude would not shut up and, on more than one occasion, insulted patrons. Someone should tell him it isn't all about him and he's there for the patrons. This was one of the worst Karaoke hosts I've witnessed. He does not have the talent or demeanor for that role. Maybe O'Neil's should have live music. Karaoke is not working for them. That, alone, has driven myself and from conversations I've had, many others, away.
In conclusion, O'Neil's Pub and Restaurant is a place I'd advise avoiding unless you're solely seeking a one-night stand. Unfortunately, that's how they made me feel on my five traight visits.
Avoid this place at all costs. Not worth your time. read more