Came in this morning since I was in a rush and needed something quick to go. I was craving a Pan…read morecon Bistec. Ordered it and they prepare it right in front of you. The staff were really polite and attentive. The sandwich it self was ok, not the best. The steak was a little bit thinner then usual and tough to chew. I usually ask with everything, but I guess they add lettuce at this location. So future reference if this is my last resort then I would ask without the lettuce, but make sure you ask for salt also, because it does lack seasoning. It's doable just not great.

Friendly people, the most authentic Cuban sandwiches in the Naples area, at a better price.read more

Amazingly fresh selection of meats! Our first time here but will be back…read more$88 spent and got all this: 2 thick filets 3 lbs ground beef 2 lbs bacon 2 large chicken breasts Steaks were the BEST I've ever had!!

The quality of the meat is fantastic. Everything is cut to order, and the prices are great--far…read morebetter than what you'll find at typical grocery stores. The bacon is especially impressive, sliced thick and fresh just the way it should be. I'll definitely be buying all my meat from here from now on. The service is outstanding as well, from the butcher to the cashier--everyone is friendly and helpful."

If you like good food with an Italian touch. This is your place. Gorgeous desserts. Fabulous…read moreprepared foods. I got the eggplant parm- delish. They have an authentic butcher shop there. Meat is fresh and high quality. Can't wait to go back. Crowded but fast service.

This place is more like a grocery store, meat market, and deli. It has very good fresh bread. Just…read morea warning, if you are going to get a cold sandwich from the deli, the white/ Italian bread is so so so hard and crusty. And I'm not saying that's bad, but if you don't have great teeth, forget it. Again, the bread is delicious and the cheese and meats are top-notch. I had the Italian sub but needed to heat it up in the microwave to soften the bread a bit. The wait times are absolutely ridiculous. Today they told us they were to shorthanded 4 people behind the deli counter and the wait was 45+ minutes. Some of the items are very very overpriced. The sub was not. It was about 10 bucks for the Italian sub. We bought the mozzarella with the tomato for $9.99 a pound. It was absolutely flavorless! I understand the mozzarella is fresh made, but the tomato was rockhard and ridiculous. SO disappointing. We paid way too much for that. Try it but good luck on wait times. Parking in back is better than waiting for a spot in the front of the store off 41.

We stopped to pick up a couple of items for dinner, so the review is only for the deli, not for the…read morerestaurant. We got smoked andouille sausage, which was very tasty. But pastrami was simply spectacular, juicy and very, very delicious. If you are craving nice pastrami sandwich, this is where you should get your pastrami from.

Dining at Jimmy P's is a masterclass in culinary geometry: the marbling on their Wagyu follows a…read moreperfect exponential growth curve, and the flavor intensity is a vertical asymptote--constantly approaching perfection

My mother-in-law, my wife, and I dined at your restaurant on December 27, 2025, and had an…read moreexcellent experience. We started with the calamari appetizer, which was very well prepared. For our entrées, my mother-in-law and wife both ordered the Wagyu burger with truffle fries, while I chose the pork chops with mashed potatoes. All of the meats were exceptionally tender, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. For dessert, I had the chocolate ganache cake, which was rich and satisfying. We were not disappointed at any point during our visit. The ambiance was great and added to the overall enjoyment of our evening. The staff was also very accommodating and helpful with my mother-in-law, who uses a walker, which we truly appreciated. Our server, Matt, was polite, attentive, and very knowledgeable about the menu, further enhancing our dining experience.

I am so disappointed to have to say that our dining experience last night was horrible at Jimmy Ps…read morecharred. Since we moved here in 2009, it has been our favorite restaurant. Perfectly cooked steaks with just the right amount t of flavoring. Salads, entrees and deserts always perfect. Last night it was a mess. Me, my husband and 32 year old daughter went out to dinner for the Xmas season. We always go to Jimmy Ps and we go an average of once a month and our dinner bill is usually $375 to $450 every time. Last night we ordered 2 filet mignon and a Rib eye steaks with a potatoe side and grilled asparagus. My daughter ordered her steak medium and a side of mashed potatoes. Her steak was horrible. No salt and pepper and no seasoning. Her steak was cooked well done. The server came over and we showed him and he did provide my daughter with a fresh perfectly cooked steaks. I had the rib eye, Pittsburgh medium rare. I have this steak every time i come here and have eaten this probably 50 times.last night whatever seasoning was used has the char taste like it was cooked on a dirty grill and tasted absolutely rancid. We noticed that the asparagus side that was also grilled had the same rancid taste. I didn't send it back since they already cooked a replacement steak for my daughter. I tried to explain to server but I didn't demand a new steak. Paid $80 for a steak I couldn't eat. The service is always great and last night no exception. I think we will be taking a break from there for a bit