We went here for the first time recently. It was for my birthday. I'm usually skeptical about hotel restaurants, but this one blew us away! I had the New Orleans eggplant pasta. The portions were great. We both left full and happy! Our waitress was very sweet and accommodating. The view out the window was spectacular, especially at sunset. read more

Oliver's Rooftop - View from the window! - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

I reviewed food elsewhere just after their opening. a few nights ago we visited only the bar. this is unique for erie and rather special. the view is spectacular and expansive. the staff behind the bar were attentive and fun - even at a late hour. good stuff. read more

See all

I was there in April for a conference. We stayed at the Hampton Inn. We ate there the first night and went back for a second night to try some of the other items on the menu. Service on both nights (as a couple and with a couple of friends the second evening) was great. Food quality was superb. Will go back when the opportunity arises for me! read more

We liked it so much we went back for dinner to celebrate our anniversary! Manager stopped by to check on us and even cleared our soup dishes - now that is teamwork! Had Hailee again as our server. View were stunning- in fact we got to see the sunset and 7 different fireworks displays while we're were there! Can't wait to get back to Erie to eat there again! read more

Oliver's Rooftop - Anniversary celebration! - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Worst place ever. We got sat I. A dark corner I. A almost empty restaurant and than no one even greeted us at 15 min we left. Would not recommend read more

Oliver's Rooftop - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

The initial feel of the ambience was really cool, however the food was disjointed. The banana pepper appetizer with beef and chorizo was fairly interesting and well prepared, but all the prices were way too expensive for how they're presented and indicated on the menu. Restaurant "favorite" off the menu, which was Walleye with a "butter white wine sauce" was not prepared as said on the menu, which ultimately translated to a thick buerre blanc weird consistency, and the dish had a cold, bland, broccoli to accompany it. The sauce that was on the dish tasted funky and strange and did not give flavor to the fish, which was shamefully dry. There also was an occasional bite of fish that did not taste fresh... Super scant amount of fish, some rice, and some cold broccoli which weren't seasoned for 38 dollars. Come ON. read more

We usually love Oliver's and the food is always great! However I'm not sure what was up with our waiter during our most recent visit. He was commenting on how fast we drank our first drink and also called us "kiddos". My husband and I are in our 30's and 40's? I'm not sure why how fast I drink a drink (which wasn't fast actually), and being called kiddo at an "upscale" restaurant is appropriate. I feel like he was talking just to talk most of the time. We had a mom and dad night out for the first time in a while and couldn't even have a conversation without being interrupted literally every 10 minutes by either the waiter, the manager, or the person bringing our food. Like I said, the food was so good but I would literally request NOT to have our waiter ever again. read more

Oliver's Rooftop - Don't Don't Give up The Shrimp - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

The food here is usually fine. I have gone about 3-4 times this year, one of them being during the solar eclipse. Was told with our reservation they would have a brunch. Upon arrival we found that they only had lunch. Some of the dishes were less than amazing, especially for the price. read more

What a let down. You know I should have know better with this place. To be honest, the food reminded me of a vamped up Bonefish Grill menu or something. The fact that you look the place up and it says it's $50-100 per person is so not worth it. The food was so mid, I actually wished we went somewhere else. We got some apps, lobster deviled eggs, which had like 6 pieces of lobster shells in them that we couldn't even finish them. How can you can it fine dining and then have people choking at the table; tempura cauliflower, nice soggy cauliflower that's now drenched in a sauce and has zero crisp, ew. The lobster and shrimp bisque that I asked for to be hot, not surprisingly came out nice and cold as the room itself. The waitress even dropped it off saying be careful it's hot! I just didn't say anything because of my level of disappointment and ate about half of it anyway, the flavor was great, but it was honestly thick and cold. My husband got a Greek salad with chicken that was brought out without two ingredients, which the waitress informed us of and then had to bring those out as she looked at the dish and said, "oh they definitely didn't put everything on there." Okay? I got a rubbery Cajun chicken parpadelle pasta with a sauce that had zero kick to it. Overall just disappointing, especially with having to be there for 2 hours waiting and waiting for everything. Maybe a lack of communication in the kitchen? Not really sure. All I can say is save your money and go to one of the other places nearby and get better quality food. read more

Oliver's Rooftop - Tempura Asian Cauliflower - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Food was interesting and great. Service was attentive but not overly friendly. The views are fabulous! A Bit pricey, but worth it. read more

Though I didn't visit the actual rooftop establishment I did visit their newer establishment just outside the building which I will do this review on. First is first, this place is gorgeous! It's probably the hottest spot on the strip besides waiting to go on the boardwalk and ships. This place is well lit, it's got great music on the weekend, great food, dog friendly, great people. It does get really busy so be forewarn! Seating is open and is hard to find. read more

Oliver's Rooftop - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

My husband and I stayed in Erie for about 5 days, our last evening there we decided to go to Oliver's Rooftop. Let's just cut to the chase. It was horrible. Both of our meals were way overcooked. I had the salmon, which was so overcooked it was inedible, you couldn't chew it. The rice that come with it was lumpy, very stuck together and very dry. My husbands meal, had shrimp in it which was so over cooked he could hardly bite into it. It was busy and by the time the waitress got back to our table, there was no way I was going to wait for them to cook another. $100 dollars later of an inedible meal!! Sure it was nice there, is that what I paid for? The rooftop view? So overpriced and so not good. read more

Rooftop views were exactly what we hoped for. Seating in the corner gave us great views. We were there on a holiday evening and service was a little slow but always friendly Food was delicious and plentiful. Great for a special night out read more

Oliver's Rooftop - View from our table overlooking Oliver's Beer Garden - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Oliver's rooftop was a pleasant surprise. We stopped in on the way to Pittsburgh from Cleveland. (The food in Cleveland was mediocre so we were ready for a good meal.) the restaurant was relatively empty so we receded right away. We were given a high top table with a perfect view of the lake. I was server was attentive throughout the meal. I had lobster with pasta. My wife had a kale salad with chicken. The muse were cooked well and delicious. The only complaint would be the long wait for our appetizers, but the view of the lake made it very bearable. We definitely intend to return here. read more

Greeted and seated immediately. We chose a dessert before heading in for the night. It was suggested by our bartender. She said if I didn't like it, she'd buy it. Pretty impressive to make that guarantee. She knows her stuff because the sweet potato cheesecake was outstanding!!! Our space was perfectly lit. Not too dark but not too bright. A nice view of the beautifully lit from the full length windows. Thank you for a wonderful experience as we pass through town! read more

Oliver's Rooftop - Sweet potato cheesecake with salted caramel ice cream - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

I went up to get desert and the employees were so nice And the waffle covered in chocolate and fruit was delicious . read more

The ambience of the restaurant was lovely and we were seated at a fabulous corner table with views of Lake Erie from 2 vantage points. However, the service was giving off "Denny's vibes". Our server threw a bunch of paper beverage napkins on the table and said something to the effect of "Here ya go!" While not otherwise rude, she was quite loud. We did not like being shown the specials on the "laptop-like device". It is just not something I'd expect to see at a "fine dining" restaurant. She brought out the salads just moments after the appetizer. We definitely felt she was trying to rush us out. At the end of the night, there were 2 errors on the bill. The food was good. Although we did not care for the salads, the appetizers were great and I enjoyed my salmon entree. I am aware how difficult it is to find great help so I will not let the service we received on this visit stop us from giving this place a second try. read more

Oliver's has a great view, good food, and great service. It is a bit overpriced. I would have hoped for a basic breakfast after oversleeping the free one that ends at 10 am. read more

OMG! Is the best way I can describe everything! The lobster deviled eggs had a lot of lobster and was awesome! My favorite appetizer was the hot banana pepper I had the lobster pasta my mom had the Cajun chicken and my aunt had the eggplant all of them were so delicious and seasoned to perfection. I had the peanut butter kup drink it was awesome! I also had the trio crème brûlée OMG! Raspberry, chocolate, and regular. All I can say I highly recommend this place! read more

Oliver's Rooftop - Pumpernickel bread - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

You're paying for the view at Oliver's Rooftop. As long as you're prepared for that, you'll walk away less disappointed about the food. Be sure you call up and specifically reserve a window-side table. I was stuck at a table with no view (about 70% of the restaurant) and wondered why I was even there paying those prices. I wouldn't even bother dining there if you can't enjoy the view. Service was polite and efficient. My old fashioned was good but the waiter didn't know what kinds of bourbon they stock, a skill I'd expect at a 3-dollar-sign establishment. My wife ordered a J. Lohr cabernet but whatever she got was definitely not that. The waiter will give you a photo slide show of their daily specials on an iPad. A cute idea, but she didn't describe any of them so you only have a photo for consideration. I ordered their "famous" Parmesan Crusted Walleye for $38. Walleye is a mild delicate fish and it was smothered it in a thick creamy sauce which of course ends up being all you can taste. It tasted good but it's a very odd choice on the chef's part. Accompanying the fish was a small pile of plain white rice and broccoli. The broccoli and rice were perfectly cooked but also perfectly plain. Not even a drizzle of EVOO on the broccoli to amp things up. I walked away wondering what I just paid $38 for? A nice piece of fish which I can't taste, plain rice and broccoli which I can make at home, and a ladle-full of parmesan cream sauce which was yummy but was the only item with taste on the expensive plate. I would love to understand the chef's thought process on this dish and why they say it's "famous"? I wouldn't recommend Oliver's for the food, but if you're looking for a nicer dining experience with polite service, good drinks, and a very nice view give it a shot! read more

We're gonna push to 4 stars and avoid any fractions. Here's the thing with Olivers, which is on the 8th floor of the Hampton Inn on the Bay. The Lobster bisque (which I think was a special) was very tasty, as were the Firecracker shrimp (dubbed "Do't give up the Shrimp!" for a local reference reason) and our cocktails. Over our meal, had the Smokito and my fiancee had one of the manhattans and the Peanut Butter Kup. We loved all of them. She really enjoyed her sesame crusted tuna (an appetizer she got as her main) as well. The view is lovely. That and the great appetizers and lovely service push the place to 4 stars However, my Walleye sandwich was just okay and honestly needed to just have the coleslaw and aioli on the bread. That or just make the sandwich with a stronger fish. I wasn't really a fan. Also, the desert profiteroles, which having great pistachio ice cream inside, had were incredibly dry. read more

The food was excellent, our server Sarah was fantastic and the view of Lake Erie was amazing (even though it was frozen) Look forward to returning in the summer. read more

Oliver's Rooftop - N.Y. Strip & Shrimp topped with Lobster sauce. Rice, baby carrots and asparagus. - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

The atmosphere and ambience was amazing and the view wonderful. In Erie Pennsylvania for a work trip and had to check out the local restaurant of choice. While the manahattan was made to perfection the lobster pasta left a lot to be desired Kelsey my waiter was phenomenal and provided great service however the pasta needed truffle oil and a little salt and pepper to bring out its flavor. The service was amazing and the staff is friendly I would come back if in town again the Walleye fish was great read more

See all

We had an excellent experience with the General Manager Todd and our server John. They both went above and beyond to make it an excellent experience for us. Of course the food was delicious as always. Would highly recommend this restaurant. The whole staff was excellent!!!!!!! read more

We were not all seated on time for Sunday Brunch yer they still served our party of 7. The food and cocktails were amazing. We have now found our new favorite Brunch spot. With a view even in the winter to captivate you. I had crabcakes Benedict with tomatoes instead of muffin as I requested, plain fantastic, Greek scramble my one son's had they said it was something they will definitely come back for. Bananas Foster French toast, over the top and don't forget the creme Brule medley, you will be sorry if you do no matter if you take it with you. ENJOY read more

Beautiful. Nice ambiance. Was greet and seated next to the window for a spectacular view. read more

See all

Awesome views of the harbor and Presque Isle (5/5) I recommend this place if only for the amazing views. Lobster pasta - underwhelming and overpriced for the amount of actual lobster. The cheesesteak was delicious. The overpriced ipad menu upsells by the waitress felt awkward. read more

Oliver's Rooftop - View - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Lovely smooth spiced rum and orange juice with ginger beer. Great with Asian chicken wings. read more

Oliver's Rooftop - Altered orange mule: smooth and refreshing - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

See all

Pros: We had the asian cauliflower and it was delicious. MY wife had salmon and said it was great. I had the surf and turf. The Lobster and filet were cooked perfectly. The drawn butter with the lobster was great. The beer selection is not great. They don't have a good IPA. Cons: We made reservations 4 months ahead of time for our 38th anniversary. We drove 2 hours to this place and then they sat us at a tall, little round bar table! It was not comfortable. It ruined the atmosphere and I'll never go back. I get better seating at McDonalds. read more

Nice thing about this place is you can order a $40 steak or a $16 hamburger. So great place for any budget. read more

This restaurant has amazing ambience and view. The service was outstanding. However, they weren't busy when we went at 11 AM. The food we ate was quite tasty and well presented. The prices are a little on the high side but some of the items are extravagant. You don't have to eat for too expensive if you get a burger here but if you want deviled lobster eggs or the seared Aji tuna, it's going to cost you a little more. The bar looked amazing, but I didn't get any drinks at that hour so I can't attest to how the drinks are. It looks like they had a good amount of wine choices. Many of the tables are unique and fun. I took some photos. They offer a very easy to read allergy menu. I attached a photo of it. I'm gluten-free and try to do dairy free so this restaurant made that extremely easy. Their allergy menu also includes people looking for vegan or vegetarian options. I would definitely come back to this restaurant to enjoy the food and awesome view. read more

See all

The food was worth the wait, the prices were very reasonable, the fries had great flavor, the cheesesteak sandwich was robust and very filling. Our server Stephanie on point and very helpful and quick and good at her job. Definitely go back again. The view is also awesome, I'm sure it's better at night. But kudos to setting, food and service. read more

See all

First time here at this fairly new restaurant. The view was good, but with the rain not as spectacular as it could be. The Don't Give Up the Shrimp appetizer was spectacular. We had the souvlaki salad and lobster pasta dishes. Both very good. We came at lunch...service was good and seating was available. It is t large though...so reservations are recommended. Great bar too. There were no toothpicks at this restaurant. read more

Oliver's Rooftop - Don't Give Up the Shrimp - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

Love Oliver's Rooftop. The food and service is fabulous thus the reason for the meals being higher priced. Usually my husband and I go to Oliver's for a special occasion as to me it's not an everyday eating establishment but for special events. Everyone is so friendly and most of the customers are happy as they are celebrating a special event as well. I don't mind paying a little more for great food and service making me as a customer feeling very special read more

Oliver's Rooftop - Church where my granddaughter had her first holy communion - New American Near Me - Erie, Pennsylvania

My husband and I dined here on Christmas Eve. It was our first time visiting Oliver's Rooftop. Our meal was delicious. The staff, from the host to the waitress to the bus staff, were wonderful, welcoming, friendly, and informative. The restaurant was decorated for the holidays and made for a very festive atmosphere. It was the perfect choice for the holidays. We plan on a return visits no matter what the season. We highly recommend Oliver's Rooftop. read more

Date night with my husband. Food was delicious. Loved our entrees as well as the appetizer sticky wings and tiramisu dessert! Been Wanting to come here to celebrate a few things and finally made it. Good choice, will be back and definitely recommend this place. Our waitress Jo was very pleasant! Only took picture of one entree the lobster pasta, and also tiramisu and sticky wings. read more

See all

Ok this place was very nice. The view of the lake is so amazing. It get busy around happy hour. Drinks are $2 off. Zack was awesome! He knew the menu and yoi can tell he wasn't just trying to sell me. The eggplant pasta was delicious. Zac also was right on with the desert choice. Whenever I'm back in town I will definitely come back. Been to couple restaurants on that are in my 2day stay and this hits the nail. However no one had on masks. That's why. I didn't give a 5. read more

See all

Always a good place to visit, menu selection was good, and staff always polite. Plan to visit again when in town.

Food was great. They were able to accommodate our large party. The staff was nice and the restaurant is beautiful and overlooks the water.

What a beautiful birthday luncheon with my best friends. The service was amazing and the food absolutely mouth watering delicious!!! My favorite restaurant in Erie. read more

See all