Ordered a pizza with extra sauce and extra cheese . Got home and there is zero sauce .. NONE !! I called and let them know he says let me pull the ticket.. yup you ordered extra sauce extra cheese let me ask in the back. Come back and said well we're sorry . I said well I want another pizza well we're closing , I said well then I want a credit for another pizza for the next time. He says well we can't credit you for a whole pizza but we won't charge you for the extra sauce next time ... are you serious !!! I said no way I want credit for another pizza ! I'll bring this one back . He said do you w Ant to talk to the manager . I said yes . He goes in the back and then says sorry he's not available. Call tomorrow if you want . Unbelievable!!! Who ever was making pizzas tonight Monday evening 9/9/24 needs a new profession . read more

See all

I love this place. IDK why people expect to get the highest quality when the price is typically $10-$15 per item. If you're expecting flawless then go spend $200 and leave this hidden gem to the rest of us read more

Great food and great employees and clean bathrooms and great delivery drivers and great location and great prices I would recommend this place to all my friends. read more

Cute storefront at this takeout/eat in pizza place. Being from Buffalo, I'm quite bias for our pizza so we decided to get the "Old School Stromboli" The large was filled with ham, salami, pepperoni, mushrooms, mozzarella, and sweet peppers. It came with their pizza sauce for dipping - which is a semi sweet sauce, the kind I like. I can't attest to the pizza but I was a fan of the stromboli and would come back for that! read more

Old School Pizza - Old School Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Last night we got our regular order large pizza and chef salad. Usually they are very good. Her salad was big leaves of lettuce, some cucumbers and rolls of meat. Missing were onions, tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, black olives and another kind of cheese. She called and told him and the guy said just a minute and hung up on her. I called this morning hoping to talk to a manager. They took my number and said they would call me back. Of course that didn't happen. I called in later and they told me that the manager was in but came back on and said they weren't available. Not a good way to deal with a repeat customer. They have a problem in their kitchen and they don't want to deal with it. It's a shame because the pizza is usually good and the delivery guy is very efficient but we are done with them. Managers do your job. read more

amazing food. some of the cheapest and best service in town. can get a slice of pizza for a $1 which you dont see elsewhere anymore

Amazing prices the pizza is always finished fast and super fresh highly recommend this place

This is great pizza for $1 a slice. They also have the cheapest pizza in the downtown area. The pizza taste great for the price.

I have been coming to this place since August 2017, there are some pros and cons about this place. They are very busy and I understand there can be minor errors, but I was so disappointed during this last experience. Every time I order their pizza, I always buy a box of pizza but the amount they put on the pizza is NOT WORTH IT! Maybe I expected too much from this place lol In my last experience, I ordered over the phone I clearly told this woman "please make sure to use a clean knife when cutting my pizza because I don't eat pork or anything that contains pig." I know I always state this every time I eat out bc its not a normal customer request for most places but I don't know why every time I order their pizza I am always so disappointed but in the past I always thought it's fine maybe they were busy but this time I was like yup thats it I won't order their pizza no more. I ordered a mushroom pizza and they barely gave me any. Also I found a pepperoni on my PIZZA! I called them as soon as I saw it and someone basically told me they cant do anything about it. Welp... okay well I guess the best I can do is give them a review. I am not the type to complain like this because I came from a restaurant business family back in LA but in this case I was so disrespected since I stated it twice when I ordered. I wanted to give them a 1/5 BUTT I gave an extra star because they have a fast pace service. the place is clean and it is a better choice to go to late night. I really love their philly cheesesteak sandwich and that is probably MY MOST FAV ITEM from their menu. If I ever want to order from their place, it would def be that or their wings other than that, there's not much to say. It is just not my favorite place in the town, it is just convenient when I want quick food. It honestly can be better especially with the amount of traffic they have. Overall, it's a cheap place so to be honest you basically get what you paid for. I recommend to really change up the customer service, if a customer is not satisfied, DO something about it but if they complain after eating the entire thing or couple days later it makes sense why you cant do anything about it other than taking in the critique. Also, minor errors is understandable but EVERYTIME cmon now this just shows that the employees doesn't care. read more

Old School Pizza - THIS IS A MUSHROOM PIZZA? lol okay. - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

See all

By far one of the best, cheap pizzas around! As a college student, this place comes in handy after a large night of studying! read more

bought a pizza and Mac and cheese bites I did not get my Mac and cheese bites and the pizza was not good

There in no better pizza than Old School. Perfect crispy non greasy slices everytime. Everything is priced very fair. You can get two slices and a coke for under $4.00. A large cheese pizza is only $8.00. The shop is a nice and clean atmosphere. Staff is very friendly too. Once you start eating here you will never be able to go anywhere else. read more

See all

I just ordered a pizza and I can't wait for it to get here!! We order weekly and it's always great! We work late and Old School is the only place still open when we get home. Awesome staff, awesome food! Fast delivery too. We only order the delivery but I've been to the building once during Covid. It looked like any other restaurant during Covid so I can't describe what it's like now. I bet it's awesome inside. I bet the ambiance is super chill and fun!!! 10 stars!!! read more

Ordered a regular hoagie, 1/4 the way into eating it I bite into a staple , stuck in my tongue had to pull it out , was bleeding , the girl working said she would have her manager call and make it right but never got a call , long time customer , but I don't feel safe eating their food again, not with pieces of metal in my food and I feel like they don't care about fixing their mistake , it's a shame because I love the food but won't order there again read more

Old School is the best fucking restaurant in the city. If you're looking for a real pizza, come here. New York-style thin and yummy. Their three-cheese cosmos lit have me faded right now. This is where you want to be after a night of bar-hopping in downtown Wilpo. This is also just a cool hangout--this is where you want to be. I love this place b/c it doesn't try to be anything fancy. Just a bomb-ass pizza joint. If you wanna feel Williamsport, come to Old School. read more

Old School Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

I can't say enough good things about old school pizza!! We love this place so much! They are the only place that will deliver to our home until midnight Any night of the week! Amazing! Especially when everything else closes at 9 pm and you work til 10. All of the staff is friendly, fun, and down to earth, like people you want to just hang out with. Their pizza and hoagies always taste wonderful and are reasonably priced to say the least. We have yet to have a bad experience with Old school and we order from them every other week! Thanks for being Awesome read more

I used to order from here very frequently until they would forget parts of my order every single time. Decided to give it a try a few years later thinking things may have changed but NOPE. Two times in a row my order was incomplete. Called to complain but no one ever came back. It's interesting how restaurants with workers who speak English as a fourth or fifth language are capable of bringing what you order but this place couldn't if their lives depended on it. The hours are great, food is okay, but the service is astonishingly awful. read more

Last night i ordered pizza to home at 10:50 pm. And some guy on the phone told me it will be 45 minutes. I told okay and was waiting. And I was 12:00 sleep. Morning i saw 2 missed call 12:38 am. And i called back delivered guy told me i didn't answer his call, it was pizza. I called back to shop some asshole woman told me we charged your pizza money and we don't care you have to don't sleep and wait it. It is not responsibile it is so late and they didn't pay my pizza money back. Other delivered guys didn't knocks door. Because my roommate friends slepts 2:00 am they told me there is last night nobody came and knocked our door. If you wanted something here. Remember this. They are asshole. Big asshole. Large asshole read more

I've ordered from them many times. Every time they about 45 mins and it'll take well over a hour and a half. They always mess up at least part of my order are never nice when I call to order. Food is good. read more

Unfortunately. Dissatisfied and disappointed is the only words I can find after receiving tonight's order. Not only was the order well over an hour wait time on a Sunday evening, the food showed up cold. But the kicker.... it wasn't even close to what was ordered. After calling and addressing the issue I was told that they got busy and they were sorry. They offered to remake the order. Another hour later we have yet to see if it is properly made. read more

Horrible! I waited an hour for delivery to get cold pizza that was charred on the bottom it was inedible. I mean it was almost completely black and hard. heck out the pic. Avoid this place! read more

Old School Pizza - Burned and cold pizza from Old School - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Had one unpleasant experience at my former favorite pizza place in Williamsport. First, they over charged me for a large pizza. Once I actually opened the pizza to eat it, I noticed a piece of gum cooked onto the pizza. I called to explain the situation and they told me they don't do refunds but I could bring the pizza back in and they'd make me a new one. Once I brought the pizza back to the store I stated that I wanted my money back and didn't even want a new pizza, and the cashier literally laughed at me and gave me a dirty look. I have never seen something so disgusting ever ordering food, and will never be coming back to this place. You'd think a shop who messed up so badly would be offering compensation or anything to make up for their mistake, but all they did was give me a hard time. read more

Old School Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsport, Pennsylvania

Used to be very good thin crust pizza with flavorful sauce. They must have changed their dough recipe or cooking time/temp. The pizza is now doughy almost raw dough under the toppings. Not a very palatable thin crust style. The sauce has slightly changed as well not sure if it is the taste or quantity on the pizza but something is different. I used to recommend this as one of the two best places for pizza in the city and now I wouldn't recommend it as I probably won't return for some time because of the last two pizzas I have had there. The wings were pretty good and the blue cheese had big chunks of cheese in it so that was a bright side. read more

This place is terrible. The pizza and subs have no flavor and are very skimpy. They also do not provide bathrooms, napkins, cutlery, or condiments. This Is the worst pizza I have ever had. read more

Yummy pizza for dirt cheap. For a quick fix, I actually prefer this hole-in-the-wall to the more highly regarded pizza places in the area (Long Island Pizza, Crazy Tomato, etc.) The slices are large, but also thin and crisp so you can eat a few without feeling satiated. The way pizza should be. read more

Glad we didn't stop along our road trip route for a chain and went a little past the turn onto I-180 and into town for some pizza by the slice. And CHEAP pizza, too! $1.50 for a pepperoni slice and they are wide, thin crust slices. Would have been fine with 1 slice, but I'm a glutton and went for 2 with a side of ranch for dipping. Took me back to my college days... Altogether, the hubs and I had 4 slices with toppings, 2 dipping sauces and a diet coke all for under $10. Can't beat that even off a fast food dollar menu. read more

Delicious takeout at a reasonable price! We ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza and it was delivered within an hour. The crust is thin, the toppings are perfectly proportioned, and the leftovers are equally delicious. This is bound to be a Sunday tradition (when most restaurants in Williamsport are closed)! read more

This is a Williamsport Gem! Best place for pizza, cheese steaks, and subs! The prices are great too! Laid back atmosphere. Staff is so nice and friendly, and I love the jam music they typically have playing. They sell Peace Tea here too! I can quickly grab lunch here and eat in or take away, it's all good. read more

Here from Seattle visiting family. We were coming back to our hotel after a late night bible study. Not many places open especially dine in. We found Old school Pizza. It was the best food. Everything we ordered was perfect and I'm a bit picky when it comes to wanting good food/flavor for my $. I'm back home still craving the food from this place. You wont be disappointed eating from here. read more

They really have no consistency. When we first moved here it was excellent. Crust was able to maintain toppings and was crisp not soggy...extra cheese meant extra cheese.....last time ordered I could see the sauce through the cheese...etc. Last time ordered it was disgusting... Returned it. Manager...female is an absolute NIGHTMARE to deal with if u have a complaint. Could hear her cussing while phone laid on counter thinking I couldn't hear her call me a bitch. read more

This is the BEST pizza I have ever had. I am from the Philly area, and eat a lot of pizza. I went to school in Williamsport and miss this place all the time. They are cheap but I promise you there is nothing better than this pizza. read more

If I could leave 0 stars, I would. Have bought from for years, had great experiences prior to today. They made mistakes, refused to fix the problem; and are very rude. Now left with a cold, burned pizza. Never going to ever be a paying customer again! read more

Took forever, cold. Tasted like rubber. Very disappointed. Old school used to be my favorite. However, I've been wasting money on trash lately. Get your act together. read more

Delivery driver was rude. I told the girl I placed the order with the address and what hotel it was. She said it would be 45 mins to 1 hour. After 15 minutes I got two calls that I ignored because it was a Colorado number and I wasn't expecting the delivery that quick. I received a text from the driver "answer your phone if you want your food". I called back and he stated "you said this hotel but there's 3 here so where are you" I told him I provided the address with the hotel name. He was nice when he arrived but the text and attitude on the phone were unnecessary. Kindness goes a long way. read more

Waited 45 minutes for a small pizza to go. The pizza it's self I would give a 4.2..... Just not good pizza even with a buzz after drinking.

Fuck this place a bunch of stoners making the pizza, consistency is non existent in this place. I just take it the worst the pizza means the higher the employee was who made it. Last time I ordered and ever will I order delivery and idk if the driver was drifting on the way to my home but my pizza was shoved to one side of the box. I was livid and instead of calling and cursing them out I wrote them on their fb page they read it and didn't reply! Yea real nice way to treat a paying customer. I hope this place burns down read more

Cheap prices, you get what you pay for. If you order anything more than a cheese pizza, you can be sure they will screw up your order. Also, depending on the person who takes your order, they will argue with you when you tell them they got it wrong. read more

Having this food delivered was a real nail biter. Literally! Got about halfway through my wrap and came across something crunchy. Spit it out to find a thumb nail. About threw up and couldn't finish. Will never order again. I wish I could give no stars. read more

This used to be one of my favorite places to order from and dine in. However, it has gone down hill. The food delivered is cold and the bread sticks are literally pizza dough flattened and sprinkled with garlic salt. Disgusting. The pizza was cold and the fries were barely cooked. Will not be ordering again. It's sad to see this place fall apart. read more

Maybe they were busy, or maybe they were having a bad day. Order delivery and when the driver came the price was higher than when I placed the order, the food arrived cold, and one of the pizzas had the wrong topping! read more