We picked up a pizza Sat evening after a 10 hr drive home from NC. Usually their pizza is excellent - our favorite. Not this time: Barely cooked, hardly any sauce, raw onion thrown on in big hunks. We threw it out, it was that bad. I called Sunday & left msg, including my complaint, with a human to have mgr/owner call me back. Still waiting. read more

Can't go wrong with pizza town! What makes it better is that they support the local community. Prices are better than some other regional pizzerias. read more

Pizza Town - Menu as of July 13 2024 - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

See all

This was the worst Pizza I have ever had in 3 countries and 38 states! The Dough was Raw inside, the Cheese was so thick and Chewy it almost made you choke, I can almost Gag just thinking about it. They should call it Pizza Choke and puke. Never Ever Again! read more

Pizza Town - This is all we ate out of 3 of us and it looked like it was tossed around in a Clothes Dryer for a Day or so! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

Just stopped here with my girlfriend and 4 year old daughter mid-day during the week. When we came into the restaurant there was a customer who was clearly drinking and tried to dance with my daughter. We asked him to stop and the staff kept feeding this man drink after drink. He kept cursing at us and was using F Bomb repeatily causing us to leave the restaurant immediately. Would never come back again and wouldn't recommend this to anyone - especially those with kids. read more

Grab a second slice and it was very tasty and would get it again. The reheat was pretty perfect and great crisp

I really love this little place. We popped in when we were in town and I wasn't sure what to expect but the pizza is good and an excellent price. Don't waste your money on the big guys - it's better here and probably cheaper. ($10-11 for a large cheese.) I also think this place is WONDERFUL because they made it incredibly easy for me to order 10 pizzas for after a really devastating family funeral. It's almost as if they knew that we needed extra love that day because my family raved about the pizzas. They were hot, fresh and ready right when I requested and the woman who helped me place the order was so kind. I really appreciated this kindness and the food quality on such a hard day for us. I'll def be back! read more

Stopped by for a couple of slices. Food already prepared, lying on counter. Slices came out with sides of crust blacked and hard as wood. Cheese was thick and slimy. Unable to eat anything but the closest to the center. "Chef" had a flippant attitude! I've been eating there for many years, so I'll probably go back again. read more

An American classic. Best pizza in the Susquehanna Valley. Call ahead on weekends because they're busy! And deservedly so. Solid subs, wings, strombolis, and pizzas. Pasta dishes are good too but I have less experience with them. read more

Nice small town pizza shop with incredible price and quick service. Come here for lunch, and can get two slices of pizza (one topping each), along with a medium fountain drink for less than $4.50! that deal is hard to beat! plus, the pizza is really good-just the right mix of crusty/soft dough, firmness to hold up the toppings, and a nice sauce. Private parking lot, TV for entertainment while you eat. Tables for about 20, and it usually gets crowded around lunch time. Selection of beers for drink in or take out. read more

Pizza Town - Bacon and pepperoni slices - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

See all

Great pizza, fianceé loved the sub too. Always my go to for good pizza. I'm very picky on pizza and this ones the best read more

See all

Always an easy 'go-to' when you are hungry and have no desire to prepare food at home. They seem to always be busy as a local favorite. They offer pick-up with food that is always ready before I arrive. They have a few tables to eat in and offer delivery. A local favorite where there is a dozen orders being picked up, it seems, every time I stop in. They sell 6-packs or singles of soda, tea, and beer. So many times I just stop in for that because of the convenience. A great choice for when last minute visitors shop up. Quick, inexpensive, and great selections that are generous in portions. read more

The pizza and Stromboli were fantastic. The customer service also great. If I'm ever in the area again, I'll definitely be back

This place use to be a Gucci (good/ high quality) pizza place but they aren't very good anymore. They pizza doesn't taste the same. I also use to love their hot wings but they don't taste the same anymore. They have a weird taste. It taste like cheapness I think they went cheaper on their supplies because the chicken just taste dirty or like they fry it in nasty oil. Half the time they don't even cut my pizza and they always forget my ranch I ask for and I know dang well they be charging me for them cups of ranch that never show up. read more

Was recommended this restaurant by a friend so of course I tried it. The pizza we got was very good although we had to pick some of the toppings off. We didn't know ordering with some onions meant a whole chopping raw onion would be on the pizza. Other than that it was great. Service was amazing and the people were friendly. read more

Well it taste alright and it was good the pizza was amazing felt like when I was a kid in my old town eating the Pizza from there and this place has great service you should try it if u didnt read more

We were headed east on 80. It's 3 pm and we didn't have lunch. We wandered into Pizza Town and boy are we glad we did. Owner Nick is Italian. He and his daughter - I think it was his daughter- were so welcoming and helpful. I got a meatball parm sandwich. Wow. Sauce so flavorful and not too drippy with fat meatballs on a perfect Italian bum that Nick gets from a nearby Italian bakery. Darling Husband got the Super Sub. We both got the "small" size and they were so huge Nick had to wrap them up for us. Also this place is next to a gas station so you can make both stops at once. The place was clean and there was a TV with ESPN so that was nice too. Place full of regulars all of whom know Nick. Loved it. read more

See all

Really good pizza . best pizza in town !!. fair prices Chicken tenders and fries are just great giant helping read more

Best Pizza Shop in Milton! I go here every other Sunday with my brother! I love this shop so much that I always leave a nice tip, and I always order it to go! The staff is great and are very kind! They never get your order wrong either. Everything is always in point and great quality of food! I highly recommend Pizza Town, you won't be disappointed! Try a wedgie, they are my favorite!!!!! read more

I ordered a large ham and pepperoni pizza and had it delivered I was thinking that it was going to be an actual Pizza however very little sauce and pizza over done read more

Pizza Town - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

I think I'm being quite fair by saying that Pizza Town in Milton, PA may just have the best food for your dollar in NEPA. Pizza Town has fresh great tasting pizzas. Their subs are gigantic and everything is priced just right. They also sell beer and usually have sports on the monitor. The owners and crew are very laid back and helpful whenever possible. I can't say enough about their sausage subs. They compete with the Bloomsburg fairs vendors, if not better. 5 stars easily deserved by this legendary establishment. It will be a sad day if Pizza Town ever closes its doors. read more

Very casual but great pizza and fast. Very kind, quaint place. A lot of regulars stop in, the wait staff seemed to know all of their orders on sight read more

Pizza Town is without exaggeration one of the finest establishments in Central PA. I have and will again travel across many state lines to get to Milton and pick up a meatball sub. HEAVEN. read more

Pizza Town - a restaurant with a green roof - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

Personally, I was not impressed. My finances family seems to love this place. If I had a choice between pizza town and dominoes, dominoes wins. We ordered delivery. Well, first off I'll state that pizza town does not deliver before 5pm. We ordered a couple pizzas. Cheese and pepperoni. We received them and opened them. They weren't even cut! Large pizzas are not all that cheap. But, for the price you expect them to be cut. The pizza was cardboard tasting to me. Cheese was horrible. The pepperoni was minimal and thrown on the middle area and that was about it. Delivery took 50 ish minutes and this was not on a Friday or weekend. read more

Ordered delivery while staying at a nearby hotel.. It was great! Fast delivery, and yummy food. The Antipasto salad was delic. And so full of meat!! read more

Pizza was actually really good. 5 stars for the pizza. 2 stars for the antipasto. The saying "too much of a good thing is a bad thing" holds true to the antipasto. I couldn't find any lettuce and the toppings on the antipast were all pizza toppings. It was like handfuls and handfuls of stuff. Thing had to weigh at least 5 pounds. But again, the pizza was pretty good. read more

Oh Yeah Good Old Pizza Town Now This One Is From The Past Of My Life But I'm Telling You The Pizza Is Fantastic And The Subs,Grinders,Hero Or Whatever You Wanna Call Them Are Off The Chain HEY LOCAL BOYS YOU REMEBER THE DAYS Don't Let One More Day Past To Taste One Of The Greats Ones AGAIN.......Ehi nick continuate la grande opera buddie read more

Stopped here on a drive from New York to Cleveland. We called on the way and they had our yummy order ready. Pizza was fresh and hot and salad was lovely. A simple place but a perfect quick stop for our family. Admittedly, we were a little suspect when we saw the outside of the place but it is a great alternative to stopping at a fast food chain. We'd come again. read more

I've ordered from Pizza Town maybe 50+ times in the past 3 years. I've ordered sandwiches, cosmos', pizza, wings, fries, hoagies (subs), and Stromboli throughout the years. I found the best pizza is ordered well done to ensure you don't get any soggy floppy slices. I usually always order extra cheese and pepperoni. I have attempted to order sausage on my pizza just to find out I hate whatever kind of sausage they use. It has a very odd taste that comes across as expired to my tastebuds. The wings are breaded and they don't offer and sauce but if you like plain breaded wings they're pretty good! The hoagies are mediocre as well as the Stromboli. They're good but nothing out of this world in regards to taste. Normally I have my items delivered and the delivery service could be quicker but my food has always been mostly hot and still fresh so no big complaints there. Customer service could use some work as most often when I call I get a "what's your order" instead of a simple "hello." At times I've eaten inside, it's relatively small and basic. Nothing pleasing to look at just simple a table to eat on. It can get very crowed with 2-3 groups of people dining in. I would suggest delivery or takeout. Overall, I still order pizza here because I do enjoy the food. I suggest improving some of the things mentioned to increase business. read more

Get the meatball parm... you will not be disappointed. I have since moved away from central PA to NYC and still to this day I have not found a meatball parm in the same class as pizzatown's. Their pizza is also fantastic. All bread and dough is made on premises with that sweet water from the Susquehanna run off. I recommend washing the Meatballs down with a 2 liter of mountain dew or a 40 of old english... whatever you do... don't bring your woman here... this is a man's establishment. read more

Excellent pizza. It was late, we were hungry. Drive from the hotel was short and the help was great and service was great. The medium pizza was as big as some other pizza shops large pizza. read more

Used to be an excellent place but the prices go up and the customer services goes down! We ordered delivery one night and after an hours wait, our order came incorrect. When we called to have it fixed, they had the audacity to question each other while we were on the phone, over if it was correct or not. Of course the sub makers claimed it was. However, "they would bring us one anyways." An hour and half later we had a very rude delivery driver requesting the incorrect sub back, which we gladly gave to him along with showing him why it was incorrect (honestly inedible,, ever ate a dry tuna sub??) No apologies at all. Open up the new sub and find it was a small when we had ordered and paid for a large! Called to point out that it was totally rude and unacceptable for them to swap the sizes at their will. Pointed how questioning on the phone was rude and the manager argued that they just needed to ask the person who made it... Not on the phone, bud. That's really bad customer service. They did bring our money back for that one sub, but by then our dinner was ruined, and the lack of an apology has solidified our decision to not patronize them again. When you routinely place $40-$80 orders, a little customer service shouldn't be too much to expect. read more