Nicely decorated, attentive staff, huge menu, lightning fast kitchen, what's not to like? It's a great place squirreled away in Suamico, Wisconsin. I've ever been disappointed. read more

When Old Mexico opened several years ago, I thought it was the best. Every time I go back I'm a little more disappointed. The last time I was there will be the last time. The Margaritas were so bad we actually sent them back. The waiter apologized and said he would bring us good ones. The good ones tasted like water with lime juice. Nothing good about it. The food was so unremarkable. I can barely remember what I had but, I know it was tasteless and lukewarm. They need a manager that will go in and shake that place up because it has really fallen. read more

Yuck. I don't really know where to start, service was not great. Granted we had a large party, but it took forever to get our orders taken. The only time we had great service was when the lady came to see if we wanted table side guacamole. The atmosphere wasn't great, several of the chairs at our table, and all around the restaurant were so worn and cracked you were afraid to sit down. Our table was sticky, as was the floor in the dining room and the bathroom, it was just dirty and worn down looking, shabby. Onto the food, the chips were awful, bland and with a weird kind of chemical aftertaste. The salsa tasted like watered down ketchup. The menu is large and while there are a lot of options, it is pricey. Three people in our group had the shrimp tacos and surprise all three of them had food poisoning, definitely will not be going back. read more

Great food and very friendly and accommodating staff. I'm often skeptical of Mexican restaurants after years of being disappointed at many restaurants. However they did a great job with spices and freshness. I'm looking forward to my next visit to Green Bay so I can go there again. read more

Best Mexican restaurant in Green Bay! The ambiance is just so darn cute! They have a ton of great Mexican themed decor - very nice decor and accents to create a great space. We are always greeted with hello's when we walk in the door. The food. Oh the food. Everything is outstanding! Highly recommend getting the table side guac. It is SO good. We have tried so many different menu items, and they always hit the mark! Highly recommend their choripollo (chorizo + chicken) meal, tacos.... And everything. My only complaint?! The food comes out SUPER quick. So if you want to take your time, wait to order. It comes in less than 5 minutes. The drinks. Oh the drinks! LOVE them. Cannot recommend the Cantarito enough! It's Tequila, orange juice, grapefruit juice and lime juice served in a clay pot glass. So good. Service. Everyone is so friendly! We just love coming here! read more

Second time coming! Their quesabirria tacos are really the best I've had! Three giant tacos! Never can finish the portion! Service is great! Prices are good and is a clean inviting place! read more

Old Mexico - Quesabirria - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Some of the best Mexican food I've had in Wisconsin! The table side guacamole was delicious. The service was great too. Had the quesabirria lunch special and it was enough for dinner too. The pickled carrots and onions that came with it and the salsas were all great accompaniments to a really good lunch. Can't wait to go back and try something else! read more

Old Mexico - a mexican sandwich with tortillas and guacamole - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

4 star. Can't give a 5 as all Mexican food tastes alike in these "fit them in and feed them" restaurants. Was clean, fair priced, and staff was friendly. Would go again to get out of house once and a while. Enjoy. read more

Atmosphere was good, salsa was great. Service was rude and the chicken fajita burrito smelled/tasted awful. Very disappointing

Food and service measured up well. The usual generous portions sent us home with leftovers. The restaurant is a cacophony of conversations which makes it tough to hear the people in our group. We sat at a table; a booth may have been better. Overall, a pleasant experience read more

Ordered the street tacos this week to go just after their lunch rush was finished. The gentleman that took my order was extremely friendly and helpful and the street tacos were phenomenal. He also saw me waiting outside and delivered them within minutes of my order hot and fresh. I can't wait to go back and try other things. read more

With out a doubt, this is the best Mexican restaurant in our area. Everything we have ever ordered has been fantastic. The servers are amazing and fast. The decor in the building is very festive and fun to look at. read more

The server was super friendly and checked in on us frequently! The food was amazing -- 100% recommend, especially the raspberry margarita read more

Old Mexico - Chimichanga, Raspberry Margarita - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Great Mexican-American food with healthy portion sizes. Seemed busy and service was still fast for takeout.

Cheery dining room with plenty of space. Decorated with themed painted chairs, statutory, and music. Servers were quick and friendly. Complimentary chips and salsa. Food arrives from the kitchen quickly so there's not a lot of down time between ordering and receiving so hit those chips quickly. Food was decent, but nothing to stand apart from most of the other Mexican restaurants in the area. read more

Food was absolutely delicious! Super flavorful and juicy. The complimentary chips and salsa was very good, I really enjoyed their salsa. New favorite Mexican restaurant and definitely will be going back! read more

Authentic Mexican me as long and friendly experience everytime Everyone in our group was happy. Most have been here many times read more

Howard Suamicos newest restaurant is a nice place to check out. The inside is bright, comfortable, and clean. It was a much bigger place than I was originally expecting. The service is great and they are eager to help you. As they train new staff (it is a new restaurant) you can tell that they are training to provide great service. The table side guacamole is very good and the best part to me is you can ask for it the way you want it. I didn't want cilantro so it was a great option for me. It could have used a little less lime/lemon and more jalapeño for my liking but next time I'll just mention that. The food is good with a lot of meat. I got a combo with a quesadilla and a burrito. The quesadilla was very good and I think that would be my go to with a guacamole. I think I will try the fajitas too though as they looked very good. read more

See all

Today we decided to try out a new location for an old favorite of ours, Old Mexico's new location in Green Bay, WI. The new location seemed to compare favorably with the original location in name and menu only. The restaurant was clean (helped by being a brand new building). The menus were the same as the original location (including the prices as best we could tell). That is where the favorable comparison ends. The restaurant was very, very noisy, taking away from the overall dining experience. The service was fast and furious. It appeared the server was rushed. The food was average. it seems the portion sizes have gotten smaller at the new location. They changed the serving plates to a grey color with spots on it. were they trying to hide anything? There appeared to be something missing from the food at the new location. Not sure what. Then, they got the bill wrong. I don't think they pay as much attention to details as the do at the Sturgeon Bay location. The best I can do at this time is 3 stars. read more

See all

The food amazing!! Ambiance just brings me back to Mexico on my honeymoon! And service is just great and don't get started on the table side guacamole!!! read more

Old Mexico - Piña colada yum!! - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Costly for the food you ordered and not a friendly staff My sons chair was broke Waiter was rude

I'm the first to admit that I don't care for Mexican food...however I will be adding Old Mexico to my list of places to eat after going there! The table side fresh guacamole is amazing! I could make a meal just out of that! We brought a couple friends here after the Packers game on Sunday and this place got 2 thumbs up from all of us!! My margarita was enormous and delicious as were my steak tacos. The sauce that came with was a lovely surprise and oh so tasty!! Great rice as well....I declined the refried beans so I can't comment on them. Our group also got chicken tacos that had huge strips of chicken on them, a chimichanga and a burrito. We all left stuffed to the gills and happy with our new found restaurant - bonus it's close to home! read more

Very fast take out service. Delicious meal. Even sent chips and salsa with the order!

Wow. From the service to the margarita to the salsa to the entrées to the guac, everything about this place was incredible. My husband who hates anything avocado absolutely loved the table-side guacamole. Our waiter was so friendly and accommodating. We'll for sure be back again. And soon. read more

See all

This was our third try at this place. First 2 times was not impressed. Won't go back. We ordered a golden Margarita. Worst Margarita I have ever had. Couldn't drink it, neither could my husband. The chips were stale. Our meal was ok. Three strikes your out! read more

Pros: Table side guacamole is phenomenal (make sure to bring dollars to tip the cute young employee making it), some of the best refried beans I've ever had, very cool atmosphere, good selection of drinks, and not very loud in there. Cons: meat was a little dry (but well seasoned) Overall, we would return. read more

Chicken burrito was A+. Quick and delicious and open on Christmas Eve. will definitely be back. read more

Old Mexico - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

I mean just YES! Walking in it looks like any other Mexican restaurant you may find in the area but then once at your table it just gets better and better. First off the salsa came with individual containers for each guest to enjoy salsa. This helped me not make a mess I loved it. They then come around and ask you if you want table side guacamole made in small or large. It is well worth the money! Not only is it fun to watch them make it the guac itself is really tasty. The chips served with both were well fried and seasoned. I ordered a spotted cow beer which paired well with my meal and was on tap. I am always on the look out for good mole and this place did not disappoint. The mole enchiladas were really yummy. I love the richness and almost bitterness of their mole here. The rice was excellent and the beans just okay. I would order more of that rice in the future. Portion sizes are huge and we were stuffed to capacity after our meal. I would come back for that guacamole alone! read more

See all

I absolutely love this place! The burrito del mar is my favorite, but I've yet to have anything there that wasn't delicious. This, in my opinion, is the best Mexican restaurant in Green Bay. read more

The food is good. Beware that they may charge more than their menu lists. Ask before you purchase. Menu price at their desk states $2.75/taco (al a cart). Was charged $4/taco. When asked about discrepancy, was told prices went up. read more

Old Mexico - a chair in the middle of the room - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

See all

This was a surprising find on a late Friday night, especially considering we live out that way. For the most part it's pretty standard local Mexican fare, but the table side guacamole is really fantastic! The guacamole by itself is worth coming in for, not to mention the very good (and very large!) margaritas. My wife had the parillada, which was very good. Well seasoned, and a ton of food. I had my go to dish of carne asada, which was pretty good, but not seasoned quite as well as I like. The standard rice and beans were quite nice, but the beans far outstripped the rice - the rice itself was okay, but the beans were very good. Come for the margaritas and the table side guacamole, and everything else is just a bonus. read more

It's in a little strip mall off of lineville, but once you go in you'll be shocked. Huge ceiling and large space, excellent decor that makes you feel like your in Mexico. The service was great and the food was fantastic. My wife had a al scatter make your own and I had steak fajitas, which were all very flavorful. The rice and beans are some of the best I've ever had (most places it's dry and over cooked...not here). Best Mexican in Green Bay. Table side guacamole puts the added touch to put this place over the edge. read more

Old Mexico - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

LOVE!!! Great food! I love all Mexican food but this is my go to restaurant. Great staff and cool building.

Great place to eat, love the food and service is awesome. My wife and I go there as much as we can.

My friend and I came in last night to celebrate National Margarita Day. We arrived around 7 pm and ordered our margaritas and food. We are only able to see each other around once a month due to schedules. The website and location themselves stated they were opened until 9 pm. The service was okay, he checked on us once or twice but wasn't very friendly. The young man making table side guacamole seemed absolutely exhausted but opened up with a smile when we started messing with him. We got our food which was pretty decent shortly after. But my friends food that came was not even close to what she ordered. She is non-confrentational so she did not say anything and ate it anyways... At 8:20 they shut off half the dining room lights and shut all the music off. We were kinda taken back with the awkward silence if we were talking but we were like whatever. At 8:40 they shut off the TV right next to us and the employees stared at us from their "waiting area" with their jackets on making it very obvious they wanted to leave. Someone from the kitchen area screamed "Go home!". We found this so incredibly rude... We felt super uncomfortable as we were still munching on our food. We packed up quickly and left... We will not return as this is not a way to treat your customers... Don't get me wrong, I waitressed for a long time myself before coming into my career and there was times I was just ready to go home myself. But I would never make a guest feel like we did where we were practically pushed out the door. When we left the were on our tails, even pulling the door shut and locking it as we stepped out. All lights shutting off right after that. We will not return and will definitely be letting our family and friends know... read more

Old Mexico - Chimichanga meal, table side guacamole and the #18 - Mexican Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

See all

This is the first Mexican restaurant I decided to try since moving to Green Bay. I ordered fajitas through a meal delivery app, and they were amazing! The meat was cooked thoroughly, the guacamole tasted incredibly fresh, and the rice was booming with flavor. They also gave sizable proportions. If you're in the area and have a craving for some Mexican food, Old Mexico Restaurant is the place to try! read more

Very nice authentic Mexican decor. I liked how the restaurant was properly spaced. I hate when tables are too close together. Luis was our waiter and was friendly and very helpful. Our food came out fast and hot and everyone had a great meal. The portions were pretty big. We will return. read more

Great food, great service and excellent margaritas. If you like Mexican food, stop in and taste for yourself. You will not be disappointed.

Husband and I went for the first time last night. Really enjoyed it. The service was great. Sandra was our waitress and she was spot on. She was a pleasure. The food was above average for price. I like to review food by taste and price vs. quantity. In my opinion the portion sizes were good and more than the average adult should eat. Both of us brought home leftovers. My only observation on the atmosphere was it was too bright in the restaurant. Lighting felt more like a cafeteria vs. evening date/dining experience. read more

We decided to stop in here for a bite after the work day and we were very delighted! The restaurant itself is awesome. Great lighting and lovely colors. The guacamole and salsa were both delicious - as well as our margaritas. Our food came out fast and it was SO tasty. We are not from the area, but we will definitely be back! read more