This was my second time into Zep's and I was very pleased with the pizza. I think it was top…read morenotch tbh. Service was very friendly and responsive. Yes when staff is short, it can delay things but that's the world we live in now, when help is limited. Overall I would definitely stop in, it's a friendly atmosphere, good beer list, and very good pizza

It genuinely saddens me to write this, but my partner and I were very let down by both the food and…read morethe service at Zep's. We are truly not the type to complain, but this experience was upsetting enough that we feel it is necessary to share. The food was undercooked and raw, and the service felt cold and unwelcoming, which was not what I expected from a small, cozy establishment. This was especially disappointing because we had been looking forward to trying Zep's for over a year. We pass it daily when traveling between each other's homes and always commented on how charming and cozy it looks, like something out of a Hallmark holiday movie. On a cold night, we were genuinely excited to finally stop in for hot delicious food. Unfortunately, that excitement quickly faded. My veggie pizza was piled high with raw, uncooked toppings that wouldn't stick, and my partner's pizza was also undercooked & wet with raw onions, barely any sauce, and bland, unseasoned dough. The battered cauliflower bites were gooey and undercooked. The fried pickles were the only thing we liked. We tried to enjoy the meal because of how much we had looked forward to it and because neither of us wanted to cause a scene. We reluctantly took the food home but as we talked it through on the drive, our disappointment grew. Before leaving a review, I felt it was only fair to call to speak with management. Maybe they could make it right? Shanda was kind and listened, and said the owner would call the next day regarding a refund. Unfortunately, no one did. When I called and spoke with the owner later, I was blamed for ordering my pizza without cheese, despite this never being an issue elsewhere, and also blamed for not speaking up sooner. While I acknowledge we should have said something in person, the response lacked empathy. There was no apology, only attitude, and we were told nothing could be done. We will not be returning and do not want vouchers or credits. We genuinely tried to resolve this privately before leaving a review. The final response we received on the phone was simply "Alrighty!" before they hung up the call, which honestly says everything. Alrighty.

An update to my last 4 star review. The breadsticks now come with homemade sauce!…read more The pizza was great as usual and they've added a number of offerings such as Mac and cheese pizza and Chicago Deep Dish. Can't wait to go back!

Got pizza here after the football game. It was my first time in years , I had moved and been back…read moreabout 5 years now. WOW! This pizza was excellent. Got just the right amount of spice to it and great crust. I think I found my new favorite pizza place. Can't wait to go and get some more tonight. Great job guys. Keep up the excellent work.

We ordered takeout from here a few weeks ago after seeing a Facebook post. We have driven by here a…read morefew times and decided to try. We ordered a tray and a Buffalo chicken canzone. The pizza was good I would know for next time to order extra cheese and ppepperoni. The crust was light. The calzone was good but needed more filling and to have a side of ranch with it but good flavor.

Great pizza, the amount of sauce and cheese is just right and both have good flavor…read more The wings are great too. There are a variety of flavors and you can ask to get the wings plain then dip them in the sauces you want. Don't forget to try the potato wedges with cheese and bacon, they're good dipped in ranch dressing.

Food and service was great! We had the works pizza and it was one of the best I've had in a while…read more Super kind staff which you don't see often!

I've driven past Maries many times over the years. Idecided to try it one day last fall. I should…read morehave just kept driving by. :-( I had a pizza and it was the worst one that I had had since moving to Columbiana. Sorry Maries, but you get a thumbs down.

I have been a customer of this shop since it was open, when I moved away from the area for a while…read morewe craved a pizza or a hot Italian sub to the point we thought of having some sent to us frozen over night. Well I am back in the area now and enjoy Marie's Pizza all of the time. Not only does this Pizza shop have good pizza they have many other other things on their menu that are good and they are an Icon in Columbiana, having been around for over 40 years, they must be doing something right, the previous poster can move back where they came from. The rest of us are from here.

Pizza is top notch and I love picking up pizza with the top cheese added after it's out of oven…read more Crust is flavorful and sauce is classic and phenomenal . Service always great.

I've never had any complaints with my food. Pizza is too sweet for me but still good pizza…read more Calzones are great. Been getting the buffalo chicken calzone for years and it's always the same.

Good pizza! I'm not from the Ohio Valley, but quickly realized the locals are adamant about their…read moreDiCarlo's pizza. But I grew up in SW Philly- so I have a little broader perspective on pizza. That's all I'm saying, so as not to start a feud!

I've been ordering here every Monday for well over a year for the tray special. Order today and…read morethey tell me the total as usual. They call back and tell me it's literally two times the amount. Ok just thinking maybe they no longer do the special but my orders already placed so I don't wanna be that person. Pull up and it stills says the special on the side of the building. Walk in and they show me my receipt and they explain why. Ok that's fine but why have I never been charged like this before ? What is usually $28 now costs me $43. All because of some extra cheese ? I could've went and bought a bag of mozzarella cheese myself for $4 and heated it on there myself. Will never go back. I don't mind paying the extra but as I said for over a year it's been one price now all of a sudden it was almost double the price. Your pizza really isn't that good anyways.

Met some out of town friends here for a dinner before we attended a show in Midland, ,PA…read more All six ordered different entries including ravioli, chicken parmigiana, spaghetti and fish. Everyone totally enjoyed our meals and the attentive service. The best part was the bill was much less than a typical evening out at a nice restaurant. All six of us gave the place a thumbs up. If is well worth a visit.

OMG. No better antipasto salad, lasagna or garlic bread on the planet! This restaurant has a long…read morehistory of fine food, excellent service, low prices, and being a hidden gem. After 50 years, the food taste just as good as it did back then. Don't miss this place if you are in the area!