This was the first pizza place i visited when moving to the area . The pizza here is like eating…read morecardboard with ketchup on it . The shop was not that clean . The only reason im giving 2 stars instead of one is that the staff was friendly,li don't recommend this place and i wont eat here again

I've never had a bad pizza here ever. I drive from PA to get it and get a whole pan and put some…read morein the freezer. Better than any frozen pizza in the grocery stores. Price is very reasonable and the staff are nice and friendly.

Food is as good as I've had around here. Chili was solid and the Rueben was pretty good. Portions…read moreare good size. Sat at the bar. Bartender was nice and I didn't wait for anything. Owner/manager stopped by and asked how the chili was. Friendly and nice. Can't speak to the restaurant service, but didn't see anything to criticize. I am deducting a star for ambiance (would only be a half star if I could). The bar is nice, but the place still has a bit of a commercial building feel. Not sure if it was the lighting. Still, in an area with not a lot to offer in terms of eateries, this is a beacon of hope. I will eat here again.

I can't believe this place doesn't have a higher rating! We went yesterday for dinner and we were…read moreso impressed with the ambiance, service, and food. We took a tour of the restaurant while we waited for our food.. it was so fun to walk through the vault and check out the back patio area. We ordered drinks, nachos, wood fired pizza, and a burger-- all delicious!

For this area Mary Janes is above average, they use quality cheese…read more 'Grande ' and good tomato sauce. The pizza is a round thin crust . The staff is super friendly and every time i have ordered around 6 times the service and food have been great . The only negative thing about Mary Janes is the prices , they are high . I understand grande cheese is not cheap but $2.75 per toppings is a little steep especially for this area . I don't mind paying for quality but $2.75 for .20 cents of mushrooms is not reasonable. The hoagies are small and nothing special but overpriced also . My order of a large 16" 2 topping pizza & a 10" Italian hoagie plus two 1pint cartons of Turners iced tea was $48 no delivery i picked up . I hope people try this place the pizza is good but not worth the price in my opinion

I wanted a quick bite to eat and I stop in. All they had was pizza pies and I just was 3 slices. so…read moreI look to the hoagie and order one. the lady ask if I want italian dressing or mayo on the side. I ask you dont put it on the sandwich. She said no cause people says it makes the bread soggy. I told her that makes the sandwich better. I asked if she cant put it on as they make the said.. she doubled check with me and she puts the order in... OH MY GAWD!!! that sandwich was great. I hate places thwe condiments of a sandwich on side. you have to deconstruct the sandwich to put it on yourself. even if you are dining in. I never go back to those palces.. I will come back her cause that was a great italitian hoagie.

Glad I tried this place. Tired of the big name chain joints, and square pizzas. Ordered take out…read moreand picked it up hot and tasty pie. Delicious sauce and not under sauced like many places. Will be back.

Ordered 2 Calzones, large pizza, cheese sticks and a chicken salad with ranch. Order showed up,…read morepizza was burnt, cheese sticks were also burnt with marinara sauce spilled all over them, and salad did not get delivered. After a phone call, they said they would bring the salad and asked what dressing we wanted. A little later salad arrived without dressing. Will definitely not be eating here again.

Place has good pizza but never answers the phone. I have called 3 separate dates (during their…read morehours) and no one answered the phone. I just have to get pizza elsewhere

Local joint since 1954 serving pizza by the slice, w/very affordable prices…read more The sauce was good, crust was good w/a little bit of crunch to it. Not too spicy but had a great flavor. Take out and cash or check only. This was my first try & it was worth stopping for. My fam is from Wellsville & they love it!

I got a couple pieces to try Sauce not so great tasted more…read morelike spaghetti sauce 1* light on the toppings couldn't even taste the cheese 1* Crispie crustust the best part of the pizza excellent 5* Value pretty small for the price and amount of toppings 2* The crust is the only reason it gets a 3*overall doubt I will be going back with so many other choices

I ordered pizza here for the first time and it didn't take long at all! Everyone was very nice and…read moreit was such a cute establishment! It is cash only but they have an ATM. The pizza was good but not the best square pizza I've ever had but I will go back!

I ate everything so fast, it was so good!!! Highly recommend the Big Fish Dinner! Large piece of…read morebattered fish served with applesauce and thick cut fries. The pleasant surprise was the homemade soft yeasty roll!!!! Wow! I'll probably be in a food coma in 15 min.... The ladies who took my orders and served them were super friendly and welcoming. I would definitely come back again

The pizza was good and the wings were good as well. Not the best I've ever had, probably going to…read moregive it another shot. If it's better I'll change my rating.