Definitely a new favorite. Some of the best pizza in the county. The stone baked pizza is…read moreamazing. The crust is light and fluffy, and their sauce is perfection. We ordered a Deluxe, a pepperoni, and tried their white. The Deluxe was absolutely covered with toppings. The only downside was attempting to keep the toppings on the pizza. The white pizza was, sadly, just average. It lacked the garlicky kick we are used to, but the fresh tomatoes and amazing crust made up for it. The bread sticks appear to be legendary, and our neighbors claimed that they were better than Pizza Hut's (!). The wedges also looked good, crispy and filled with sandwichey goodness. This is our new go-to pizza joint, and I can't wait to try the other specialties and subs.

For this area Mary Janes is above average, they use quality cheese…read more 'Grande ' and good tomato sauce. The pizza is a round thin crust . The staff is super friendly and every time i have ordered around 6 times the service and food have been great . The only negative thing about Mary Janes is the prices , they are high . I understand grande cheese is not cheap but $2.75 per toppings is a little steep especially for this area . I don't mind paying for quality but $2.75 for .20 cents of mushrooms is not reasonable. The hoagies are small and nothing special but overpriced also . My order of a large 16" 2 topping pizza & a 10" Italian hoagie plus two 1pint cartons of Turners iced tea was $48 no delivery i picked up . I hope people try this place the pizza is good but not worth the price in my opinion

Better than the Bruno's in Calcutta, I think. Wish there was one close to Pittsburgh. Pittsburgh…read morehas no idea how to make pizza.

This was the first pizza place i visited when moving to the area . The pizza here is like eating…read morecardboard with ketchup on it . The shop was not that clean . The only reason im giving 2 stars instead of one is that the staff was friendly,li don't recommend this place and i wont eat here again

Since I grew up around this area it was interesting to see the large photos they have displayed of…read morewhat East Liverpool years ago. Being able to go in the vault of the old bank was also interesting. The service was really good and our food was very good. I had the steak salad and it was superb.

I can't believe this place doesn't have a higher rating! We went yesterday for dinner and we were…read moreso impressed with the ambiance, service, and food. We took a tour of the restaurant while we waited for our food.. it was so fun to walk through the vault and check out the back patio area. We ordered drinks, nachos, wood fired pizza, and a burger-- all delicious!

Very poor customer service, extremely poor management. The place needs to be cleaned up all the way…read morearound!

I got a couple pieces to try Sauce not so great tasted more…read morelike spaghetti sauce 1* light on the toppings couldn't even taste the cheese 1* Crispie crustust the best part of the pizza excellent 5* Value pretty small for the price and amount of toppings 2* The crust is the only reason it gets a 3*overall doubt I will be going back with so many other choices

I ate everything so fast, it was so good!!! Highly recommend the Big Fish Dinner! Large piece of…read morebattered fish served with applesauce and thick cut fries. The pleasant surprise was the homemade soft yeasty roll!!!! Wow! I'll probably be in a food coma in 15 min.... The ladies who took my orders and served them were super friendly and welcoming. I would definitely come back again

The pizza was good and the wings were good as well. Not the best I've ever had, probably going to…read moregive it another shot. If it's better I'll change my rating.

Usually this is a go to when in the area. Not sure why but last night's order was horrible and was…read morenot able to eat it. First, the box was heavy, I ordered a tray..I reached in for the ride home slice, and it was not cut. There was way to much cheese on it and the dough was so thin and tough, you couldn't chew it. The crust was high and dense and chewy around the edges. Not sure why a business would of let this out the door, but it will take a lot for me to stop again.

Used to love it. 3 out of last 6 times the dough was flat and barely cooked. Today the cheese was…read moretwice as thick as the barely cooked crust to cover for it. Strike 3. Such a shame because everyone is so nice there

Awful wait time of 21/2 hrs! My sub was missing toppings and 2 inches of bread at the end! Called…read moremultiple times just to get it delivered and was lied to every time! So done! I usually support local businesses, but not this one!

4 stars for the food. 2 stars for the performance = 3 overall…read more Note they only take cash and check. Decent pizza. Had wings too. Wings delicious. Pizza had good toppings. Crust a bit soft. Could've been crispier. Not 5 star, but good. That being said, placed the order at 9:37. Not delivered till 11:10. Need to do better.