Usually great pizza and chicken/ jo jo's. One of our favorites. We visit quite often.

The old owners had it down, but since new ownership has taken over, the customer service is so terrible. You can simply go in to get the pizza you waited on the phone forever to order and get yelled at by the people behind the counter. The pizza also tastes terrible now!! It's so over priced and soggy with grease while the center of the pizza is doughy. Never going back. read more

This is the 5th time we've got something raw/undercooked from this restaurant. Used to be amazing eating here. It's gone so far down hill. You pay $10 for a calzone I expect it to actually be cooked. Both calzones were undercooked and tasted like straight Flour read more

Italo's Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Lisbon, Ohio

I ordered the family chicken, Jo Jo's and coleslaw. It was gross, soggy, and over done. Like was fried in old oil. Also ordered a specialty pizza. I paid $27.99 for a horrible pre fab pizza. Worst food ever. Only posted one star because didn't have a lower rating. Never again will I order from here read more

Ordered 2 large pizzas with pepperoni and a pan of salad to go. Everything was delicious! The pizza had a perfect amount of sauce, great amount of cheese all the way to the edge, and plenty of pepperoni. The salad was the specialty! At first I thought it was too much money, but it fed 6 of us, with second helpings, and still had at least 2 more servings left! It was amazing! Good, crisp lettuce, banana pepper, onions, black olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, and cheese! Yum! I would recommend this place to anyone! read more

Jim is the only one who's ever given me a Correct order .. If you're looking to get what you ordered I'd recommend NOT going to Italos in Lisbon. The calzones are my favorite ... sadly They mess up constantly the last 7 times I've gone I've either been missing items from my order, no PIZZA sauce on the side for my calzone been handed the wrong order, or showed up for pick up and and was informed they didn't have an ingredient to complete my order... Such a HUGE disappointment and waste of time especially considering my family frequents this establishment. Had to copy part of someone else's review because it definitely fit why would anyone want that nasty marinara on the side when the calzones are mad with pizza sauce , you'd want the same sauce ... read more

My fiancee dad went here and ordered their chicken when they brought it out it was raw inside. When he told they to re cook it they sent back another piece of raw chicken. The workers tried to fight about it being undercooked. Worst service. read more

Pizza is usually not done enough. Personals are great but Large have raw dough in center. Chicken is tasty but inconsistent size in pieces from one day to another. Jojo's are so small you cant even find them in the box. On a good point.....at least I dont have to cook or clean up. read more

Pretty good food. I have tried pizza, Jojo's, chicken,salad, calzones and Stromboli. I only have two complaints. The mushrooms are canned ( which I think should never happen) and the Stromboli could have more flavor by far. a bit more sauce would make it perfect. besides that this place is great and you cant beat the prices! it even has a drive up window!!!!! read more

The pizza isn't my cup of tea and the food is rather mediocre in general, however, if you are looking for middle of the road pizza, chicken, and potatoes for a weekend night or rainy day, this might suffice. The fried chicken is pretty good. read more

Ordered an appetizer and it took forever to arrive then the waitress didn't bring us plates. We had to wait another 15 minutes for her to come back to our table. It took about 45 minutes for our dinner to come to the table. I ordered a burger and fries. They were out of pickles, the burger was cold and dry it crumbled and they served it on two thick slices bread and the fries were cold. read more

Delicious pizza! Great salad bar, even better wedding soup!! A great place for a quick lunch. Love the prices too.

There pizza is awesome, also they offer a wide selection of Italian food including spaghetti with meatballs, salads. They also have a wide selection of fried foods including chicken and Jo Jos. We often order breadsticks with cheese which is a large pizza crust with garlic sauce and covered and provolone cheese. They offer dine in and carry out, and we have never had any trouble with their service. I just wish you were closer to our home. read more

Prices aren't TOO bad but I can get 2 large pepperoni pizzas from Georgios in Calcutta for $10 less. Food is decent. On a scale 1-10 I'd rate the food a 6. Not the best but Ive had worse. I live in Salineville so the pizza around here is worse than frozen pizza. Staff is friendly. read more

We had chicken and jo jo's from here and it was absolutely delicious! The potatoes are very large, large juicy pieces of chicken, and it came with bread, butter, and coleslaw. I heard that they have recent new ownership, would definitely recommend....we've had it twice in the past week! read more

The only reason they get two stars (and not half!) is because the pizza actually tastes pretty good. We've eaten here before but don't remember having this much trouble. They offer pizzas with up to three toppings but if you just want extra cheese they charge an additional $3 (on a large) because "extra cheese isn't considered a topping, but it's an extra topping". Then, when we were considering regular toppings and asked for ground beef they told us they don't have that. Then, as a last resort, we were about to order personal pizzas for our daughter and myself and my husband would get a calzone the server blatantly informed us that they would charge me more for the exact same thing because an adult was eating it!! I would think small mom and pop establishments would make an effort to retain the few customers they still have but apparently Italo's only wants as much as they can get out of each person the one and only time they go. read more

we had them cater our wedding and the food was outstanding we had chicken rigatonis and meatballs, salad ,bread, jojo's and the staff we're very helpful professional and very friendly read more