Cancel

Open app

Search

Odd Fellows Ice Cream

3.9 (15 reviews)
Closed • 1:00 pm - 10:00 PM

Order Odd Fellows Ice Cream Takeout or Delivery

Odd Fellows Ice Cream Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Odd Fellows Ice Cream

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Flight
Kate C.

Love the options for flavors! Many, many flavors. We also loved the ice cream flight and size. The Brooklyn Blackout was the star of the show for me. Very rich and yummy! They were out of soft serve sadly (one of my kids love it). Luckily they found another good option. The Strawberry jam was really good too, very flavorful. The Hummingbird was okay, just had an odd aftertaste. Customer service was okay, the place was cute and freshly decorated. Overall, we look forward to coming back and trying more.

Some flavors you can zoom in
Rachel M.

Odd Fellows just opened yesterday, Friday, Oct. 3, 2025. I was already a fan from their Hyde Park Village Tampa location. They can be found by the restaurants at Wiregrass Mall. Specifically next to The Living Room and Tmobile and across from Azteca. The area in the middle is currently on construction. The Grand Opening was fun with a balloon maker present. He also did card tricks and magic show tricks. They did the ribbon cutting ceremony and everyone stood in line for their ice cream. Everyone there was super friendly, welcoming, and helpful. I had the mango sticky rice ice cream and exotic fruit sorbet. They were def what I love, tropical. They also have Ube and Pandan coconut which are unique for the area. Excited for them bc they are the only ice cream in the wiregrass mall area. Check them out! They have inside and outside seating and they have a vibrant circus theme even with a cute little monkey mascot!

Boon C.

This newly open store definitely a hit in Wesley Chapel. The new ice cream store is next to Living Room Restaurant. The unique of this ice cream store is their odd flavors. I got the coconut pandan which is flavor only here can get. They do have vegan ice cream that my flavor is one of them. Seating is limited inside but they do have outdoor seating. We like the monkey picture on the wall.

Felipe P.

Odd Fellow Ice Cream Co. WireGrass/ Wesley Chapel 2001 Piazza Ave. Wesley Chapel, FL 34543 Listen up Wesley Chapel!!! There is an Ice Cream stote that is waiting to bring you smiles and hapiness. Located in the Shops at Wirgrass in Wesley Chapel, come with your family and friends and make your day am unforgettable experience. Had the pleasure of visiting them and they were very welcoming. Ian and his staff brought the energy and good service while serving classic and creative ice cream flavors with a nostalgic twist. Come and enjoy Classic flavors as well as Seasonal flavors in a cone, waffle cone, or a customize scoop tray. I had their Hazel Cherry Fudge along with their Chocolare Rasberry Delight on a Sprinkle Waffle Cone. Delish!

Ali T.

Stopped into Odd Fellows on a Thursday night around 6:40 and was happy to see only one person ahead of us in line. Tons of ice cream flavors were available, which made choosing a fun challenge. I ended up going with the peanut butter s'mores milkshake. It was very good -- not the best milkshake I've ever had, but definitely a solid and satisfying choice! The staff were terrific. Everyone we interacted with was friendly, helpful, and quick, which made the experience even better. Overall, a great stop for a sweet treat!

The restaurant

Came to Odd Fellows Ice Cream at Wiregrass before closing time and the doors were already locked with the closed sign up several minutes early. If your posted hours say you close at a certain time, customers should still be able to enter until that time. Closing procedures are supposed to happen after closing, not before. Super frustrating experience, especially when I made the trip specifically to come here. Businesses wonder why customers get irritated when basic professionalism like honoring posted hours isn't happening.

Cookies and cream
Brittany R.

An ice cream shop is a welcome addition to the shops at Wiregrass! Located right next to The Living Room, this spot is perfect for grabbing a scoop after dinner or shopping and walking around the beautiful shops. The prices were steep considering the small serving sizes. Most ice cream shops say "single scoop" but really give you about 1.5-2 scoops. This place is truly the smallest single scoop I've ever seen. It was nearly $14 for these two small scoops. The flavors are very unique but unfortunately we didn't enjoy many of the flavors we tried. We sampled ube marshmallow (which we typically enjoy ube flavored items), coconut pandan, and strawberry jam flavors and we didn't like any of them! The raspberry rocky road was a hit! My husband ended up landing on the cookies and cream which was decent. The service provided was not anything of note. We also noted an inconsistency between this location and the Hyde Park one. I'm not sure if they've changed what they carry, but my husband used to enjoy an ice cream float with sprite and they did not carry sprite or any lemon lime soda at this location, when they did previously in Hyde Park. Overall, while I'm very happy there's an ice cream shop in this plaza, I'm upset it had to be Oddfellows.

See all

13 days ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 10
Thanks 4
Love this 8
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Sky B.
0
30
7

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Mike J.
34
15
26

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

This place is awesome! The staff is very friendly and super nice. They also have great dairy free and vegan options.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Nice spot and good service, but $16 for two of the smallest ice creams I've ever seen felt a bit outrageous.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Odd Fellows Ice Cream

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 808 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Paleta Mia Ice Pops - Strawberry shake with strawberry paleta

Paleta Mia Ice Pops

4.8(6 reviews)
3.8 mi

Nice ice pops for a hot day…read more I really didn't know what to expect, we were walking by and my son wanted to try it. I thought it would be like Hyppo popsicles, so the ice cream consistency threw me off. I got a matcha coconut one and he got a strawberry. I liked that there was an actual strawberry piece in his. I wish mine had a stronger taste of matcha. I think it was lessened to appeal to the masses. Inside is cute, they have two tables and a bench along the wall. We sat inside to eat our ice cream. There were two tables outside that were taken. You can add toppings to your popsicle, which I wasn't expecting, so we didn't do. I think next time I'd be more prepared and try a topping.

I love that their ice pops are made with natural ingredients. The Mango Chamoy paleta tasted like a…read morefresh and ripe mango. I could even see and taste the bits of chili pepper in the frozen swirl of chamoy sauce, but not in a spicy hot way. It was a perfect mix of sweet & savory! Paleta Mia has many different flavors. They have Oreo, Ferrero Rocher, and many more flavors and combinations. You can get a plain ice pop, or you can dip it in chocolate and/or add a topping. They also have waffle sticks, shakes, aqua frescas, and pup-sicles. There are vegan and sugar free options available as well. I was looking for something cool and refreshing. The paleta was perfect on a hot summer day. What made it even better was that it stayed completely intact while walking to the parking lot. I was fully expecting it to melt, since I had parked the car farther away to keep it shaded under a huge oak tree. I was able to savor it without it dripping all over the place. The service was great. They have a small sitting area inside with bright green cushion seating. The décor is bright and colorful. There's a loyalty card. You get the 8th ice pop free. Yay! I can't wait to try the Ferrero Rocher ice pop dipped in chocolate.

Photos
Paleta Mia Ice Pops - Outside shot of store

Outside shot of store

Paleta Mia Ice Pops - Mango kiwi paleta (left) & mango dragon fruit paleta (right)

Mango kiwi paleta (left) & mango dragon fruit paleta (right)

Paleta Mia Ice Pops - Pup-sicles!

See all

Pup-sicles!

Bruster's Real Ice Cream

Bruster's Real Ice Cream

3.6(84 reviews)
1.7 mi
•$

It was a split second decision because it was a hot day and the ice cream shop I was thinking of…read morewas over 30 minutes from where we were at, but oh- what a happy accidental find! The ice cream here was SO good, I was pretty surprised. They have a lot of great unique combinations and we liked everything we tried. The service was alright but not very trained on information. When asked about flavors or the company in general, the girl didn't really have much information. The outdoor seating really needs some revamping. It's all very worn and wasn't the cleanest and if this was updated, it'd be an incredible spot to stop and stay and enjoy your amazing ice cream!

The menu looks nice but I ordered a small ice cream waffle cone and that comes with 2 scoops of…read morewhatever you'd like, I got chocolate and it was genuinely the worst ice cream I've had so far. The service was okay, you also order through a window outside. I think they might've been understaffed but the lady at the front was efficient and had our dessert out quick. The ice cream tasted like freezer burn, the cone was stale. I did see another review that said the same thing about the freezer burn and that was years ago, but I guess it's still a problem. My friend got a cookie sundae which was supposed to have a warm cookie and hot fudge but everything was either cold or stale. If you wanna go here I suggest you look at the other reviews or try it for yourself. I definitely would not recommend coming here.

Photos
Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Outside

Outside

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Birthday cake in waffle bowl

Birthday cake in waffle bowl

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Flavors in June

See all

Flavors in June

Odd Fellows Ice Cream - icecream - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...