I think most burger joints taste the same, but I really enjoyed the burgers here. I got the Steakhouse burger and it was very well-seasoned. My friends also really enjoyed their burgers. I have to say, Odd Fellas is definitely one of the better burger joints I've been to. The "Little fella" size is a slider. Their "Regular fella" size is a regular burger size. The "Big fella" is larger than the regular size. I've been told that they switch out their menu every once in a while. Right now, they have a burger called "Hello, Newman". I know you just read it in *that* tone. Haha. Anyways, great burger spot to stop by. read more

Food was great. Service was excellent. Solid ambiance. Seemed like it was new because the kitchen staff was also the wait staff. Silverware, napkins and ketchup on the tables was not a given, but they were attentive to our needs. read more

Odd Fellas - Interior of Odd Fellows. - Burgers Near Me - Lock Haven, Pennsylvania

You order at the counter, pay and they bring the food which is fine. I got a hanks orange soda in the bottle. I ordered the "hello Newman " burger - burger, bacon, cheddar, fried egg. Instead of fries I got the onion rings. Sadly nothing had any flavor. Basic battered onion rings, and I thought the burger patty would be the star bc it seemed fresh but nothing! Mayne the fries are better? The pics look good but I wanted a change. Maybe a little salt and pepper would have helped? Just visiting LHaven so I probably will never be back anyway. read more

Odd Fellas - Hello, Newman - Regular Onion rings - Burgers Near Me - Lock Haven, Pennsylvania

Great food, always still hot by the time we get home. and the customizable milkshake options? LOVE this. Definitely check this place out if you haven't already. read more

Great spot! The burger was the best I've had in a long time. Great service. Friendly staff working. Definitely will be back.

I have always had really good food when I ate here. I get the build your own burger and they always make it right. Only thing I would not recommend is takeout- we are on time to pick the food up but it is always cold. read more

Meh, I guess good for the middle of no where. Nearly 5 Guys costs but a thicker blander burger. If lack of flavor is your thing then the these burgers and fries are for you. Large portions but left more than one half on the plate, definitely not calorie worthy. Wanted to like it given the interesting vibe of the place but could not get past the quality of the offerings. read more

Basic burger joint. Nice helpful staff, decent food (very good French fries, average pulled pork sandwich, burger, milk shake), good semi rustic interior (w/bulletin board posted menu items where you order/pay at counter). Nothing too special or exciting but always a spot to rely on for this type of fun cuisine. read more

Odd Fellas - Some fun menu item names - Burgers Near Me - Lock Haven, Pennsylvania

9/20/2024 1:30 PM. My wife and I ordered the pulled pork sandwiches. They were absolutely awful! There's no way we're going back there!

Great burger selection and flavor profiles. We had a group of seven, and all loved it.

I ordered food for pickup (wild burger and fries) and the burger was not very good. The "Cajun" didn't taste anything like regular Cajun. It was very dry. The fries were fine. read more

This place was well worth driving a couple miles off of I80 for dinner. The burgers were cooked perfectly medium, juicy, flavorful. Service was great too! read more

Odd Fellas is a cute little hipster burger and shake joint in the small college town of Lock Haven. I go here once in awhile. I really like their malt milk shakes they use Hershey's ice cream and are very tasty! You can also get ice cream cones. The Burgers have a really good grill flavor and use a brioche bun. The fries are good and I really like the aioli mayo dip that comes with the meal platter. Thumbs up! Service is quick too. read more

See all

Husband had burger and fries . He said it was good. He asked for water, he was told they only have bottled water...really? They would not give him a glass of water. I had a coke, it was good....of course, also pulled pork with their special herb seasoning and signature sauce. I tasted no seasoning and sure didn't see or taste sauce. We were not impressed. Any restaurant that only wants to sell bottled water instead of providing a glass of water for their customers doesn't deserve customers. We never had that experience before. My husband did not buy water or anything else to drink in that place. We won't be returning. read more

The smell of a sizzling grill and a curiously refined window drew us in to this local joint. What a wise decision, the burgers are all unique and they even substitute turkey. One proportion fed a family of three, and it was scrumcious. The interior was quaint yet modern and interesting enough to hold a toddlers attention. read more

Odd Fellas - Burgers Near Me - Lock Haven, Pennsylvania

The shakes and fries are amazing and the atmosphere is perfect! Update: we went again to try their burgers, It's perfect portions for the kids and they loved the burgers read more

They have a fabulous menu of burgers that look amazing and taste even better than they look!

I was looking for somewhere new to take my dad & mom, as they really tend to be creatures of habit when it comes to restaurants. So we passed by Odd Fellas, and I hit the brakes to venture in with them. New businesses don't often spring up in Lock Haven. Just the nice, modern interior alone makes it one of the best spots to open up in years for the downtown. It's a rather large space, with cool wooden tables - perfect to bring a big crew of folks for a great time out! I know this was the former meeting place of the Odd Fellas membership, but Dad mentioned that this may also have been the old Five-and-Dime store. Odd Fellas has a really nice variety of fresh (not frozen) burgers in which to choose; many varieties that the locals aren't used to having. Mom and I got the "Verona", because we love pizza burgers; while dad got the "Wild" which has a delicious spicy kick to it! You also have the option to "Build-a-burger": select the type of meat, select the type of cheese, select your desired toppings, then top of it off condiments. The burgers were fried, but they were delicious enough for me to plan a return trip to try one of their other options. The fries are tasty, and the soda fountain is something different that you won't find many of in the area - it serves up craft sodas made by Appalachian Brewing Company - drink to your heart's content! It's fast-casual, so you order at the register and bring it back to your table when you called. Fast-casual is great, of course, so you don't have to worry about putting out extra dollars in tips. Odd Fellas is just a great place that certainly plays a part in the rejuvenation of downtown Lock Haven! read more

Great food and friendly staff. The menu is simple but the food food boasts bold flavors that really get your tastebuds excited. This place is highly recommended for a great lunch. read more

I usually have a good experience here. The burger was black, way overcooked. Not sure what was going on. Asked for extra odd sauce, it was on my receipt but I didn't any. I'm not sure if I'll be back for awhile read more

Out of three burgers, two were actually bleeding. I don't send food back but my wife did. Said hers was fine the second time around. Fries were good and staff friendly. read more

Doesn't get much better than this place for a gourmet burger and handmade milkshakes.

Fries are amazing and the sauce they have for the fries is even better! Burgers are always a go and never disappoint.

Fantastic burger spot. None of those prefab burgers here. This is a chopped steak burger. Amazing. And the best sweet potato fries and onion rings. read more

Alway delicious. Great food and great service. Nice place to eat in or use the easy, online ordering and pick up at the curb.

This place has many delicious burger combos or you can create your own. I had the "Wild" burger (bacon, grilled onions, cheddar, jalapeño and BBQ sauce) Either way your going to get a great burger with crispy regular or sweet potato fries. The restaurant is located in what was formerly the meeting place for the Order of Odd Fellow's. I can't complain about the price. It surely would have cost more in NJ. read more

Odd Fellas - The Wild Burger - Burgers Near Me - Lock Haven, Pennsylvania

While passing through town on a work trip, I stopped here for a late lunch. The guy working the register was extemely friendly and a big help with my questions before I placed my order. I did a "build your own burger" with cheddar cheese, lettuce, pickles and ketchup. Added a small order of fries and a strawberry milkshake. Everything was very good, my only compliant being that the burger was extremely greasy and dripped constantly into a huge puddle on my plate. The bun wasnt soggy from the amount of grease, thankfully. I would definitely come back to give it another try! read more

See all

Odd fellows was an awesome find on our way home from NYC to Pittsburgh. It has a great relaxed atmosphere. Friendly helpful staff. The food was delicious. I would highly recommend the home made black bean burger read more

Yummy burgers. Can be a bit pricey if you go wild with toppings, but they have a good topping selection!

I love a good burger and the Wild burger is fantastic! Perfect set of flavors, well considered spice and toppings, with the heat perfectly calibrated. Wow! Easily on par with super fancy burger places you might find in a major city at half again the price or more and easily in my top 10 burgers ever. My spouse loved the humongous fungus burger as well. Fries were good but the burgers are the outstanding item here. Definitely going back for more. I called in my order and they were able to easily accommodate a curbside pickup and the person who brought out my burgers was masked, which I appreciated. Yum! read more

They have great food, friendly staff and a cool business name! It's very clean and a nice atmosphere with artistic qualities to their design and ambiance. read more

Happened upon Odd Fellas on my last trip to visit family. I was pleasantly surprised. The restaurant is super cute and perfect for groups. When you get there you have a choice to build your own or a preselected options. The day that we were there the special of the day was a salmon burger and it sounded really good. You can also choose between a beef, turkey, or veggie patty. You order up front and then they call your name when it's ready. Now to the important part: the food! The burgers were cooked well and it was perfectly juicy. I opted to build my own with French fries. The fries came with odd sauce, which was really delicious. My burger was topped with super fresh ingredients and I really liked it. My only issue was that I couldn't get the burger cooked to the temp that I prefer. It wasn't bad at all, I just personally like medium rare. One fun addition was that the soda in the fountain was Allegheny Brewing company craft soda. I had a white Birch beer that was super amazing. The prices here are really reasonable. The hubby and I both had lunch for $20 and the food was amazing. I will definitely be back to try again. They have sweet potato fries and I will for sure be trying them. read more

Odd Fellas - Burgers Near Me - Lock Haven, Pennsylvania

Expensive for the salad options due to size. But the service and quality of the food is really great!

Our first date was burgers at Odd Fellas... now we're getting married! They are the perfect, quick bite.

I absolutely love Odd Fellas. The burgers are delicious and the onion rings are truly my favorite. The odd sauce is my favorite staple and I eat it on my burger and with my onion rings. I always request extra!! read more

The drinks suck and sometimes the food is also not good but service is ok I got a milkshake last time I was there and it made me shit myself

Oddfellas have seen some changes since opening and honestly all positive. Before they added something to the burger meat that tasted off to me but now it is completely gone. I love the idea of a new burger or option evey month or even bringing back older options for a limited time. The French fries are probably some of the best you can get in the area hands down. My only gripe and it is not even big is maybe they could give the option of upgrading your fries to loaded so you can add toppings to it. The Appalachian soda they offer is just okay. I would say an acquired taste for those who definitely never had it. The staff is very friendly and place is always clean. The price is more than what you would pay at a fast food place but you can't the quality of good food. read more

I've heard mixed reviews, it is a little pricey for the type of food. Not a fan of the smash patty.

The food was pretty decent and the milkshakes are amassing. It is a little pricey though.

Stopped here for a late lunch. Delicious food. The husband reports his "wild burger" is one of the top 5 best burgers he has ever had. And the man is no spring chicken so that says a lot!! And no he cannot have a second burger no matter how much he asks. Goodness!! Fries were hot and fresh. Environmental very welcoming. I ordered a BLT on a pretzel roll and it was quite enjoyable. Perhaps they used a bit too much bacon but I know most would appreciate that!! Just a note- they serve Appalachian craft sodas but they were good and there was a variety. Be here or be square!!! read more