When they said lines go down the block? Yup they weren't kidding! Came twice and the first time? We arrived 1:45pm and there were a few people already waiting. Second time? Arrived at 2pm and there was a good amount of people there. Yet the lines moved quickly, CASH ONLY spot, in and out, easy. Dude the ice cream?! It's soooo freaken GOOD! You can taste how fresh the ingredients are like they just made it in the back room! Def a spot you don't want to miss if you're in this small quiet town! Ohh did I mention I got the flurry, boys got 2 scoops each and total was like $12.50!!! That's just insanely cheap! A scoop of ice by me is easily $4-5 alone! read more

See all

This is easily one of the best ice cream shops I have ever been too. Between us, we got 4 flavors, all amazing. Great milkshake. Great sundae. Great prices. read more

Nutter's Ice Cream - Sundae. Was prettier before we started eating. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sharpsburg, Maryland

See all

Love love this place. There's a line out the door for a reason. Their portions are HUGE there is a lot of places to sit outside. They serve turkey hill ice cream at the best prices around. I believe they do cash only though. I hate carrying cash but I will suck it up for them! They make amazing Sundays. They have all kinds of ice cream and dessert options. I think they could probably even benefit from selling some baked goods too. read more

Thursday 5/2/2024 Just a heads up: This ice cream spot takes cash only, doesn't do ice cream samples, and is strictly takeout for ice cream. I got a 4 scoop cup (vanilla, chocolate, and 2 cookies n cream) $3.82. One thing I immediately noticed was that the portions are HUGE and the prices are amazing. On the other hand, The ice cream taste was pretty mid and it reminded me of store bought ice cream. And I wouldn't be surprised if that store bought ice cream was turkey hill due to it being on their website and the taste being similar. Overall, this ice cream spot has amazing prices and even better portions but the ice cream itself is mid and average to me. read more

See all

Go back in time to an amazing old fashioned ice cream shop. This place is truly magical. So many flavors and you can choose from hand scooped or soft serve. Delicious' They are open all year round and remember to bring cash for this amazing treat. read more

We stopped here for ice cream and the line was out the door and almost around the building. They only allow 10 people in there at a time. What they call a small isn't small at all and it's only $2!! The servings are very generous, I see why people wait in line. Beware, they are cash only, but so worth it! read more

Best ice cream and prices frozen in time! $2+ for two scoops? Amazing!! If you're in the area drive by and get some ice cream!!!

When you step into this store, it's like rewinding the (cassette) tape to a time before WW2 or Vietnam. This is a small-town ice cream shop from back in the day. Maybe back before your day, definitely before mine. The decor was quirky and homey, I was charmed. Yeah, but what about the ice cream, you say. Was super on-point. They had a wide variety of flavors, but we went with pistachio-almond, cookies and cream and chocolate chip (we're boring like that). They were all bursting with flavor and struck that hard-to-hit note between too little and too much heavy cream. Smooth, silky texture with just enough body. The other retro thing about Nutters? The prices. I haven't seem prices like that since long before the pandemic. The same ice cream in Georgetown, DC or Cambridge MA will run you three times as much. Not saying you should drive out to this little corner of MD. But if you do, you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

Very delicious ice cream served in large portions at discount prices. Certainly the best ice cream deal I've experienced in decades!

This place is a blast from the past. The line says it all, and sometimes wraps around the neighborhood! Huge servings and cheap prices! You can't believe how big those ice cream cones are and don't even get me started with the banana splits. Family owned and operated this place is a rare find in America today! No matter where you're coming from it's worth the drive, but bring your cash cause they don't accept credit cards. read more

Nutter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sharpsburg, Maryland

The ice cream was FANTASTIC, their service was top notch and it was better than skibidi Ohio for all the kids out there.5 STARS

If you like ice cream - and lots of it - this place is for you! The "small" was ENORMOUS and the ice cream was both creamy and flavorful read more

Nutter's Ice Cream - Sign - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sharpsburg, Maryland

Good local go to. Ice cream is good and lines are crazy long. Old fashioned ice cream parlor aesthetic

They deserves more than 5 stars! The BEST ice cream in the nation! We love going there. So delicious especially for their peanut butter ripple & birthday cake!! Make sure go there earlier in the day to grab these!! The workers are very friendly & good prices with huge scoops! My favorite ice cream parlor. We always bring quarts home! Will always go there when I'm in town. Located in cute small town. read more

They always are so friendly in helping to please you everytime l have been there keep up the great work love your ice cream

Absolutely fantastic! The portions are huge and has a great small town feel to it. Would definitely come back in the future! read more

Nutter's Ice Cream - Peanut butter ripple - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sharpsburg, Maryland

Delicious and creamy ice cream! Huge variety of flavors and large servings - a small was two big scoops for just $2.50. Our groups favorite flavor was party cake! read more

Best ice cream around, and at priceds that can't be beat. Worth the wait in the around-the-block lines every weekend!

Outstanding service. Great ice cream. Large portions at a fair price. Stop in and enjoy. The wait is worth it as the lines often go around the corner. . read more

We were staying nearby for a few days touring the Antietam battlefield in September. The weather was warm and some ice cream was called for. Nutter's was one of the highlights of our 2 month trip! The line moved quickly, the ice cream was some of the best we've ever had and the portion size was huge. We ordered 2 "small" cups. The Mrs. had "Apple Pie" with chunks of pie crust, apple and cinnamon. I had the peach with luscious chunks of fresh peaches. Both were amazingly delicious...and the price was $4.70 TOTAL! read more

Nutter's Ice Cream - Apple Pie (L) and Peach (R) $2.35 each - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sharpsburg, Maryland

This is a popular destination! Sometimes the line can be out the door and down the sidewalk. I think they give a bit better value the buck than other Icecream shops in the area. read more

We have go to Nutter's when our adult kids come home or when we have time for the drive. We took the kids for ice cream there for over 20 years. Sharpsburg is a cute little town and it is a beautiful trip over South Mountain to get there. Good memories and nice people read more

Stopped to take a break in our travels home. Great hand dipped and soft serve ice cream. Incredible actually. Large portions and economically priced. Wished we lived closer as it would be the only place I would patronize. It fantastic! read more

Went there after seeing so many reviews and was not disappointed. Loved the strawberry shake! read more

I suspect that they're running a longitudinal study to determine how much ice cream a person will eat in a single sitting if you give it to them. I asked for a kiddie-size cup. What I got was a serving the size of an actual kiddie. Seriously, it was just shy of a pint and it cost like $.32. Okay, I'm exaggerating on the low price (but it was crazy cheap) but I am NOT using hyperbole about the size. Honestly, I think if I'd ordered a regular, they'd have just pulled the whole delicious bin out of the cooler and handed it to me with a spoon. And charged me $1.56. I am not complaining. I was gobsmacked by the generous (ludicrous) portions and nostalgic prices. And make no mistake, the ice cream itself was wonderful! (I mean, who wants a ton of something bad, no matter how cheap it is?). The blueberries and cream flavor had nice little Maine blueberries in it (and they were not frozen pebbles of blue tooth-smashing pain). And the cream flavor was actually a lovely ribbon of sweet cream swirling through the purply blue. read more

Great place with friendly service. Ice cream was delicious and portions are generous.

Everytime we go to visit our so. In shepherdstown WV we all like I. The car and he's over to Nutters. Great ice cream and very generous servings! read more

Incredibly good ice cream at great prices! We came all the way from PA for some Nutters Ice Cream! read more

Nutter's Ice Cream - Great ice cream! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sharpsburg, Maryland

See all

Yummy in my tummy. Park across the street and stop by. You will love it. Great variety of flavors and the price- wow! read more

Nutter's Ice Cream - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sharpsburg, Maryland

See all

I've been coming to Nutters over many years, every time I visit the area, because it is the best bang for your buck. I rave about the ice cream place to all my friends back in CA. It has been one of my favorites. You get a ton of ice cream, it's delicious and it's a great value. However, I've noticed the customer service has become awful. The ladies working were beyond rude to me. I asked for a sample and she practically yelled at me "We don't do samples!" Well, they used to a few years ago, so how was I to know. They didn't appreciate at all that I was there. It was like they wanted me to get out of the store. When I was looking at the flavors, the lady kept pushing me to order asking if I am ready and it was clear I wasn't and there was no one else in the store. On both occasions when I went this week, the different people working never said thank you or hello. They were unpleasant to be around. We even left a tip for the older lady who was so rude, and she didn't even acknowledge the tip or say thank you or goodbye when we left the store. She was just constantly annoyed and there wasn't anyone else in the store except us. So rude. If the price weren't so good, I'd never come back because the staff was so mean to us. It's sad because I have been a loyal and loving customer for so many years. I wish I could have a joyful time there again. read more

Yummy ice cream, interesting things to look at while waiting in line. Lots of good ice cream flavors. Cash only.

This place is a CLASSIC!!! You totally MUST go there! It's a whole experience! And the ice cream is awesome too! The prices are low, the portions are large. The lines are long but it moves fast! The staff is organized and know how to hustle. read more

Bring cash or atm across the street. Amazing ice cream that you can't get anywhere else. My favorite is the white chocolate raspberry truffle, with gram cracker ice cream. I could go on for hours. Staff is always polite and prices are reasonable. read more

What a sweet little hidden gem. Massive portions or delicious hand scooped ice cream. Their small is a large everywhere else. What's better is how affordable it is. For 8 people it only cost us $16 and we couldn't even eat all the ice cream! Highly recommend. Only thing I wish is they had more friendly(longer) hours of operation read more

This is a tiny mom and pop shop in a small town. While looking for a dessert place after dinner, my friends and I stumbled upon this place and decided it was worth a try after seeing a line out the door. The line, though long, moved pretty quickly. They offer a massive selection of ice cream flavors and a variety of different treats. They have both hand dipped and soft serve ice cream. I got a small, which has 2 scoops, of the java chip and the peanut butter cup. The portion was HUGE and it was so cheap! I'm very picky with my ice cream but this place has definitely made it into my top ten. I can't wait to go back and try out other flavors! read more

Nutter's Ice Cream - Java chip on top and peanut butter cup on the bottom - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sharpsburg, Maryland

I've cream is locally sourced/made & the ambiance is Depression Era Shabby Chic...Enjoy an Ice Cream treat which takes one back in time !

After touring Antietam National Battlefield, we ended up in Sharpsburg and found Nutter's Ice Cream. What a delight! There was a line but Nutter's is definitely worth the wait. They are generous with their scoops of ice cream and the line moves quickly. I would definitely suggest adding a trip to Nutter's to your plans! read more

Awesome treats at great pricing. The servings are huge. You better love ice cream, and who doesn't?

Pricing is good for the amount of ice cream you get, but service was awful. I let my friends go ahead of me because they medically couldn't be in the sun. When I slipped in behind them, a rude worker quipped "Some of you all need to wait outside. There's a sign that says 10 people inside at a time, but I guess you didn't read that." Admittedly, I did not read that sign but it didn't merit the demeaning response either. There's actually quite a few signs outside about the line, waiting, no sitting inside, and a demeaning sign about where to park bikes and lots of signs inside about not touching all their items on display. Apparently there is a limit on how many can wait inside of Nutter's due to their air conditioner not cooling the inside well enough to keep the freezers running properly that hold the ice cream. Even when my family got to the counter to order I was rushed the whole time and didn't feel welcome. Every time people came in while I was inside, the workers were trained to tell them "only ten inside at a time!". That has got to be exhausting. Why not just fix the obvious problem of the air not working good enough? Then at least you wouldn't have to feel like a broken record repeating yourself about your rules and you wouldn't physically be overheated from scooping ice cream in a hot establishment. But, who am I? I can't even READ! Lol Overall, Nutter's ice cream is not worth the wait nor the visit. read more

Had the best time at Nutters this weekend. The prices are super inexpensive and the sizes and flavor range are huge!! Definitely a must visit read more