3 weeks under new ownership and we think they are on the right track -we drive over from…read moreShelbyville a few times a yr and stopped in today for dinner. Lisa was still there from previous ownership, she does a great job and is attentive and friendly. The new owner came out and spent about 5 min with us discussing other Gatti locations and his vision for improvements here in Martinsville. On our way out the owners wife spoke out from the kitchen. thanking us for coming in. Food was good as always and per request of my wife they put in a fresh BBQ Chicken Pizza. Salad bar was fresh and well stocked. We will for sure make the effort to visit again before the summer is over ! Good luck to the new owner and effort to make Gattis an even better better place to eat!

Well Mr. Gatti's is again under new management. Not Good! They are more concerned about cutting…read moretheir cost of making the Pizza than the quality (Cutting back the ingredients 'it takes to producing a quality Pizza, told your staff to use less sauce on the pizza. ) The BBQ Pizza is undoubtably the worst I have ever tasted) along with other Basic Pizzas offered on your buffet. Don't worry about your Cheese Sause and the cost of placing your lit up signs around the city use your money and improve your Pizzas!. in asking other customers of yours their opinion, they agree you suck! You can be "The Best" again instead of cheapening your products!!

We were quickly greeted when we walked in. Our drinks came quick as did the food. The food…read moreportions are huge!! We even saw salads delivered to another table that were so huge 2 people could not eat them! The customers were even surprised and said they hope they have good to go boxes. The brisket was super tender and a very good portion! The grilled chicken with mushrooms and cheese had good flavored chicken and a nice amount of mushrooms. The ranch was good but very dilly! The bun on the chicken sandwich was way too big. This was a nice find as we drove through Martinsville on our way south.

My wife and I dined here for lunch on Thursday, July 23, 2026. Service was excellent. Environment…read morewas a surprise - when we walk through the doors we thought wow this is nice! Great food with reasonable pricing... We would recommend!

While my grandson was getting a haircut next door, I popped into this Papa John's to get the 9.99…read morecarryout special. The guy working behind the counter refused to take my order, saying I had to order online or pay the regular price...in other words, I would have to pay a penalty fee for having the audacity to order in person. I left and will NEVER come back. This is utterly ridiculous.

I really like their pizza, however when I pay for extra pepperoni, I expect more than 2 1/2 to 3…read morepieces on a slice, compared to Dominos it's sad, they really give you extra pepperoni

Been here three or four times. Was expecting an experience that I had when I visited their…read morerestaurants in high school, several hundred years ago. Unfortunately, this noble Romans did not maintain that same vibe. On most visits, the food was pretty good, service was adequate, but the salad bar and conditions of the restaurant seemed less than tidy.

Read on their web site weekends nights busy best to call ahead... called to make a reservation…read morederelict thought I wanted a room... if he can't function on the phone, hows he gonna take an order...

Only if you're a fan. Better pizza to be had in frozen food section at grocery. Pizza Hut is not…read morewhat it once used to be... it can go away now.

i earned enough points on the Pizza Hut app to get free breadsticks. I tried to redeem several…read moretimes and it continued to give me an error that would not let me redeem. very disappointed in false promises

I stopped in for a business meeting and let me just tell you if you love good barbecue or if you…read morelove Bourbon you need to check this place out. I didn't have a lot of time so I just got the brisket sandwich and it was amazing. I actually ask if they sold their barbecue sauce, but they don't yet. I've seen large whiskey collections but I've never seen one where you can order everything by the glass. It's incredible huge huge, huge selection and you can try anything. They also have a small retail section with very affordable prices.

Hidden Gem. Found this while at a baseball tournament and was blown away by the quality of bbq…read more Huge portions and great food.