Nietert Insurance

4.5 (2 reviews)

Home & Rental Insurance, Auto Insurance, Life Insurance

Closed • 8:30 am - 5:00 pm

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Services - Nietert Insurance

Homeowner or property

Car and truck insurance

Life insurance

Nietert Insurance Photos

Nietert Insurance - Home & Rental Insurance Near Me - New Haven, Indiana

+12

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Nietert Insurance

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Bill B.

5 months ago

I've been doing business with the Nietert's for over 40 years. First with Dick and Now with Matt. They are great people. I can highly recommend them. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Braxton H.

1 year ago

I called for a quote but their price didn't beat my current, but the agent there Sarah was fantastic and explained what she quoted for me very articulately read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Nietert Insurance

900 US Hwy 930
New Haven, IN 46774
Directions
(260) 749-9541
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.nietertinsurance.com

From the Business

Specialties

We have over 100 years combined experience helping our customers with all of their insurance needs. We pride ourselves in providing personal service and individual advice.

More Info

Hours

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Myers & Hayden Insurance

(6 reviews)

Kimberly and Owner Jill are amazing. They continually keep me updated and look for the best pricing…read moreand coverage!!

Kim Wilson was incredibly professional, helpful, and walked me through each step. She got me the…read morebest rates with great coverage, and did not try to oversell me. She was very respectful and I am excited to work with her!

Ovation Insurance

(1 review)

Honestly the BEST thing about Stoller Dunham is the willingness to communicate with me in a way…read morethat works for me. Previous agents have insisted on using traditional mail or phone calls to pass along important information. Unfortunately, that isn't the best for me. The ability to communicate through email and even text messages has been WONDERFUL. Also, you're very knowledgeable and helpful whenever I have questions. Always friendly, never impatient.

From the owner: Since 1961, we have delivered a broad range of competitively priced, custom-designed insurance…read moreplans to the families, individuals, businesses, and ministries of Indiana, Ohio, and Michigan.

Allstate Insurance Agent - Ben Bucher

(6 reviews)

Spoke to Gabby today, she was friendly and very helpful. I think in the future if I need help she…read morewill be a very good asset for your company.

Gabbi really helped me with my policies and is saving me over $5000 per year. Thanks Gabbi!read more

Allstate Insurance: Darren Vogt

(1 review)

Darren and his team insure 2 rental homes that I own. They are professional and responsive any time…read moreI contact them. Their prices are very competitive and the service is outstanding. A pleasure to work with. Kevin R.

From the owner: Contact my Agency to get a Quick,Personalized Insurance Quote Today! A great rate is just a call…read moreor click away. I am nearly a lifelong resident of Fort Wayne and enjoy being active in my community, especially working with youth programs. I enjoy coaching, spending time with my family, and making the community a better place to raise a family.

Amber Fiess Insurance Agency

(1 review)

Amber is amazing! She helped us navigate an overwhelming number of insurance options. She…read morelistened to our needs and concerns and then helped us eliminate dozens of plans right away. After selecting a few plans to delve into further, she outlined the pros and cons of each and we were able to confidently choose the right plan for us! Her professionalism, experience and candor were invaluable in the process! We HIGHLY recommend her services to everyone we know! Thank you Amber!

From the owner: Medicare/Major Medical/Dental/Vision/Supplemental and Liferead more

Nietert Insurance - homeinsurance - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of New Haven, Indiana Things to Do near Nietert Insurance

BEST of New Haven, Indiana Restaurants near Nietert Insurance

BEST of New Haven, Indiana Tax Services near Nietert Insurance

BEST of New Haven, Indiana Coffee near Nietert Insurance

BEST of New Haven, Indiana Furniture Stores near Nietert Insurance

BEST of New Haven, Indiana Banks & Credit Unions near Nietert Insurance

BEST of New Haven, Indiana Investing near Nietert Insurance

BEST of New Haven, Indiana Gyms near Nietert Insurance

BEST of New Haven, Indiana Pizza near Nietert Insurance

People found Nietert Insurance by searching for…

Insurance in New Haven, IN

Insurance Agent in New Haven, IN

State Farm Agents in New Haven, IN

Car Insurance in New Haven, IN

Insurance Broker in New Haven, IN

Homeowners Insurance in New Haven, IN

Insurance Companies in New Haven, IN

Commercial Insurance in New Haven, IN

Investing in New Haven, IN

Reviews in New Haven, IN

Business Insurance in New Haven, IN

Renters Insurance in New Haven, IN

Related Cost Guides

Auto Insurance

Currency Exchange

Financial Advising

Home and Rental Insurance

Insurance

Life Insurance

Tax Services

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Nietert Insurance also viewed

Myers & Hayden Insurance

5.0

(6 reviews)

Kimberly and Owner Jill are amazing. They continually keep me updated and look for the best pricing…read moreand coverage!!

Pat Bryan - State Farm Insurance Agent

3.7

(3 reviews)

I have nothing but appreciation for this office and their staff. We have been customers for many…read moreyears and we've been given attentive service and accurate quotes each time. They have been proactive in calling us when there's been an issue that needs our attention and they are always looking for ways to save us money, within reason. This isn't Esurance, folks, or Geico, and that's a GOOD thing, because I know my agent and his staff, they know me, and we have a good working relationship.

This is a scam…read more This is how the process works when purchasing an insurance policy from Pat Bryan. I can verify this happened to me multiple times before I caught on. 1) Get quote on vehicle 2) Pay quote in full 3) Months later (but way before policy renewal) get a letter from Pat demanding for more money 4) Contact Pat and he says "Sorry, can't help! Sorry your quote wasn't right! Pay me more money!" Unless I pay the extra, Pat threatens to cancel my policy early. This, ladies and gentlemen, is how a company baits and switches. Pat will learn word of mouth is essential to business! Treat your customers fairly and resolve problems in your error. I recommend Esurance.

Val White-Xayarath - State Farm Insurance Agent

5.0

(3 reviews)

Always available and always helpful with any question or concern. I have ben with this agency for…read moremany years and recommend them highly.

Val and her team and exceptionally hard working and knowledgeable. They go the extra mile to do…read morewhat is best for the client and are extremely honest, sincere and responsive. I would highly recommend them and in fact have referred her to my mom, brother, and several friends. Thank you for all that you do!

Jordan Klopfenstein - State Farm Insurance Agent

5.0

(1 review)

Jordan, Ethan, and Grace are amazing! The guys saved us almost $2k/ year (switching from American…read moreFamily)!! They are knowledgeable and patient, working up different quotes as needed and explaining everything. And Grace, the Customer Service Manager, was always available to answer questions and help with the account. She even personally helped us navigate the app!

Hoch Insurance

5.0

(1 review)

My wife and I were impressed with the level of service provided by Agent Doug Hoch. He went above…read moreand beyond to help us through the insurance process and his follow-through saved us a lot of stress when the insurance company made a mistake. He is thorough and knowledgeable - Very good at what he does!

Tom Steckler Agency

5.0

(1 review)

We've been with Steckler agency for more than 10 years. Both Tom and Adam Mitchell have proactively…read morehelped us get better coverage and better rates. Fully recommend them.

Global Kinnect Insurance

5.0

(1 review)

A flexible, responsive service that cares from starting the best insurance plans, to filing taxes,…read moreor creating a financial portfolio. I highly recommend Gus!

Edward Jones - Financial Advisor: Karen M Rupert

5.0

(1 review)

Love Karen Rupert, my financial advisor!!! She's very knowledgeable and curious about different…read morefinancial products.

Traxler Insurance Agency

5.0

(1 review)

We contacted Craig in a PANIC about our health coverage. First off I'll say this. He 100% cares. He…read morewasn't even sure he'd be able to do business with us. Helped us figure out the issue and it turned out we did purchase a policy through Craig. Very pleased with the policy and thrilled with Craig's service!

SourceOne Insurance

5.0

(1 review)

I cannot say enough about Joy DenHouter and staff at SourceOne Insurance. Joy has gone the extra…read moremile for my family and I during an extremely complicated situation. Her knowledge of the insurance world combined with being an attorney has made her an invaluable resource. We have felt more like family than customers. Highest recommendation possible.

Nietert Insurance

Services - Nietert Insurance