Justin Harkelroad

1.0 (2 reviews)

Home & Rental Insurance, Auto Insurance, Life Insurance

Add Review

Directions

Services - Justin Harkelroad

Homeowner or property

Car and truck insurance

Life insurance

Justin Harkelroad Photos

Justin Harkelroad - Home & Rental Insurance Near Me

Justin Harkelroad - Allstate Insurance - Home & Rental Insurance Near Me

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Justin Harkelroad

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

JM L.

103

9 years ago

Our service with this company has never been perfect but we are totally fed up with how My husband's car accident was handled. He was rear-ended in an accident this last march and all-state under-valued our car leaving us with a 1,600 debt owed. Our most recent letter from the claims department says they only collect money from the at fault carrier, but then tells me to Contact the at fault carrier and finally recommends we file a small claims suits. They are all over the the board pushing the responsibility back at us. WHAT AM I PAYING YOU TO DO...OBVIOUSLY NOTHING....think we will file small claims against our agent and all-state for not doing their job. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Heath D.

157

192

146

11 years ago

Garbage! I am so disappointed and upset with Matt at this company right now that it's not even funny. We switched all of our policies over to All State recently. Matt Hullinger was super helpful when we were shopping around and looking to switch from State Farm. We decided to switch all of our policies--two houses, rental insurance policy, 4 vehicles. A lot of coverage. He was suppose to take care of canceling the policy we currently had, transfer it over, etc. Nope. Didn't even follow up with our old policy holder. Someone from this office called us and that is how we found that out--that the old coverage had not been cancelled as they said it would. So that was the first...let down. State Farm cancellation was post dated from when it was suppose to be cancelled and switched to All State--so hats off to State Farm for that. No biggie. Unprofessional. But I'll survive. Now, nearly 3 months after we switched we are told we need a railing on our stoop at one of our rental properties. Ask Matt if this is necessary as we 1) didn't know about any concern about this initially, 2) it is a rental quite a distance away and thus is not feasible and 3) the money we would have in putting up a railing would negate any savings from the policy switch for at least a year, maybe two as it is a concrete stoop. Why would we do that! Matt never follows up. We get busy, we don't follow up as we got busy and forgot. We follow up with him again, and he said he's going to check into it. Never hear back from him. We forget again too. And then a couple weeks later we get a notice of cancellation policy! No handrail up before October and the policy will be cancelled. Now he decides to get back with us when we get back with him. Says it has to be done. I'm furious! We should've known about this, or at least the possibility that it might need done, beforehand. We know nothing about this, switch policies and then this comes up?! Wow. Shopping around again for a new Insurer as we speak. Wanted to warn others though about the seeming unprofessionalism and incompetence at this All State. Maybe others are better...I don't know. I know I won't be using them again. read more

Helpful 5

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

More info about Justin Harkelroad

Fort Wayne, IN 46815
Directions

From the Business

Specialties

Contact my Agency to get a Quick,Personalized Insurance Quote Today! A great rate is just a call or click away. I've gotten to know many local families as an Allstate agent in Fort Wayne. I enjoy being a part of the community, and building local relationships is one of the best parts of my job. I look forward to getting to know you and helping you to find the solutions that meet your needs. I'm committed to helping Fort Wayne residents assess their immediate and long-term needs and choose options that will help them achieve their goals. When you want to explore options for protecting your home, personal property, or financial future, I'm available to answer your questions. If you're already a customer, I'm ready to review your coverage so that you can make any necessary adjustments to fit your changing needs. Call, email, or visit my agency in Fort Wayne today.

History

Established in 1931.

We opened our doors in 2007, and with hard work and a customer-first philosophy, we have grown this agency into one of the top performing agencies in the region. We have done that by not sacrificing great customer service for sales only. Once you become part of this agency, you become family, and will be treated as such.

Meet the Business Owner: Justin Harkelroad E.

I became an Allstate Agent at the ripe age of 22. I was approached with an opportunity to work with people, save them money, and protect their familes...who could pass that up? I have been in Fort Wayne Indiana for most of my life. I was born in New Orleans, LA in 1984 and quickly moved up here as my family was starting a local pizza business. I grew up in the business world, learning the in's and outs. One thing I was told and it was hammered into my head: The Customer is the most important thing... No matter what!

Ask the Community - Justin Harkelroad

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Myers & Hayden Insurance

(6 reviews)

Kimberly and Owner Jill are amazing. They continually keep me updated and look for the best pricing…read moreand coverage!!

Kim Wilson was incredibly professional, helpful, and walked me through each step. She got me the…read morebest rates with great coverage, and did not try to oversell me. She was very respectful and I am excited to work with her!

Allstate Insurance: Darren Vogt

(1 review)

Darren and his team insure 2 rental homes that I own. They are professional and responsive any time…read moreI contact them. Their prices are very competitive and the service is outstanding. A pleasure to work with. Kevin R.

From the owner: Contact my Agency to get a Quick,Personalized Insurance Quote Today! A great rate is just a call…read moreor click away. I am nearly a lifelong resident of Fort Wayne and enjoy being active in my community, especially working with youth programs. I enjoy coaching, spending time with my family, and making the community a better place to raise a family.

Ovation Insurance

(1 review)

Honestly the BEST thing about Stoller Dunham is the willingness to communicate with me in a way…read morethat works for me. Previous agents have insisted on using traditional mail or phone calls to pass along important information. Unfortunately, that isn't the best for me. The ability to communicate through email and even text messages has been WONDERFUL. Also, you're very knowledgeable and helpful whenever I have questions. Always friendly, never impatient.

From the owner: Since 1961, we have delivered a broad range of competitively priced, custom-designed insurance…read moreplans to the families, individuals, businesses, and ministries of Indiana, Ohio, and Michigan.

Hoch Insurance

(1 review)

My wife and I were impressed with the level of service provided by Agent Doug Hoch. He went above…read moreand beyond to help us through the insurance process and his follow-through saved us a lot of stress when the insurance company made a mistake. He is thorough and knowledgeable - Very good at what he does!

From the owner: Hoch Insurance has always lived up to its name by being one step ahead of the insurance industry…read more We have been serving the Greater Fort Wayne Allen County and surrounding areas since 1967. We are always finding better ways to serve you with our new and personalized programs. Please call us now to get a quote.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jennifer H.

14 years ago

Justin and his team are always there when I need them. His office is 4 hours from me and I would rather deal with him as my agent than someone who is local to me because I have never found an agent more attentive. I've left for other insurance companies a time or two and always end up coming back. They respond quickly to email and phone at all hours of the day when I am in need of them. I highly recommend Harkelroad family insurance. You wont be disappointed! read more

Christine A.

12 years ago

Justin and his team are dedicated insurance professionals - they enjoy getting to know their customers, understanding their insurance needs, and making sure everyone takes advantage of all Allstate's discounts. As an Allstate agent in Manassas, VA (outside DC) we have customers that move outside our area frequently. I'm happy to have Justin and his team to recommend when they move to Indiana! read more

Sue O.

10 years ago

I cannot say enough about the great customer service at Harkelroad Insurance. We have had one claim concerning my son's auto accident. Everyone from the main office to the Harkelroad office was more than gracious. I am so happy I have chosen this agency for all my insurance needs. read more

Rex B.

10 years ago

great people and everyone needs insurance.why not them. rex brown

Justin Harkelroad - homeinsurance - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Justin Harkelroad also viewed

Allstate Insurance Agent - Ben Bucher

3.7

(6 reviews)

Spoke to Gabby today, she was friendly and very helpful. I think in the future if I need help she…read morewill be a very good asset for your company.

Gabbi really helped me with my policies and is saving me over $5000 per year. Thanks Gabbi!read more

Myers & Hayden Insurance

5.0

(6 reviews)

Kimberly and Owner Jill are amazing. They continually keep me updated and look for the best pricing…read moreand coverage!!

Traxler Insurance Agency

5.0

(1 review)

We contacted Craig in a PANIC about our health coverage. First off I'll say this. He 100% cares. He…read morewasn't even sure he'd be able to do business with us. Helped us figure out the issue and it turned out we did purchase a policy through Craig. Very pleased with the policy and thrilled with Craig's service!

Tisha Fast - State Farm Insurance Agent

5.0

(1 review)

I recently got life insurance from my agent Tisha. I can't explain how the customer service is…read morehere at State Farm. It's off the charts. Just moved here from california, and will be getting car insurance from here soon. Front desk lady is very welcoming, and Tisha offered coffee once I came in to sign some paperwork. Great job! Thank you! Brian G

Tom Steckler Agency

5.0

(1 review)

We've been with Steckler agency for more than 10 years. Both Tom and Adam Mitchell have proactively…read morehelped us get better coverage and better rates. Fully recommend them.

Marcus Elam - State Farm Insurance Agent

5.0

(1 review)

Moving from Michigan to Indiana, I had to change my insurance. Amber did such a good just…read moreexplaining the differences between the two states. She explained several policy options and helped me find something that fit my needs and my budget. She is always available to help in any situation. I would highly recommend her to anyone! -Katie

SourceOne Insurance

5.0

(1 review)

I cannot say enough about Joy DenHouter and staff at SourceOne Insurance. Joy has gone the extra…read moremile for my family and I during an extremely complicated situation. Her knowledge of the insurance world combined with being an attorney has made her an invaluable resource. We have felt more like family than customers. Highest recommendation possible.

Amber Fiess Insurance Agency

5.0

(1 review)

Amber is amazing! She helped us navigate an overwhelming number of insurance options. She…read morelistened to our needs and concerns and then helped us eliminate dozens of plans right away. After selecting a few plans to delve into further, she outlined the pros and cons of each and we were able to confidently choose the right plan for us! Her professionalism, experience and candor were invaluable in the process! We HIGHLY recommend her services to everyone we know! Thank you Amber!

Jackson Hewitt Tax Service

3.0

(2 reviews)

The associates are friendly, but neither appeared very knowledgeable. I only used this very…read moreexpensive service in hopes of getting a. early refund. Both early refund options were denied with no explanation. My latest appointment was almost an hour late and took another hour for what was meant to be "signing." If you have an uncomplicated return do NOT pay over $500 for this service you are not guaranteed any early refunds. And you could do it yourself online. Not worth the time or the $.

The service was excellent. The person who completed my taxes answered my questions to my…read moresatisfaction.

Brian Kinniry - Union Savings Bank

5.0

(1 review)

Brian was so great in our process to help us get a loan. He was really patient and really helped us…read moreas first time home buyers. We are so thankful to be in our home and thankful that Brian helped make that happen. Thanks Brian!

Justin Harkelroad

Services - Justin Harkelroad