Nico's in New Albany. Nico's is a great little spot in what I could only describe as quaint old town New Albany. You roll into town like you stepped back in time to the 1940's. A quaint row of old brick buildings lined the street on both sides. Absolutely love the old school vibe of this place. We entered Nico's and were immediately seated at a booth. Menus given and drink orders were taken quickly. We the. Ordered a Margherita pizza and thick bacon for an appetizer. For dinner, lasagna and chicken parm. The starters came and both the pizza and bacon were delicious. The pizza was hot and had a crisp crust and the bacon with the goat cheese was delicious. The main course came and both the lasagna and the chicken parm were cooked perfectly and also delicious. It was nice to get away from Oxford and the Oxford dinner prices at the square: Nico's has delicious food, a really cool old school bar and the pricing is a delight compared to Oxford. I would absolutely recommend Nico's and their great food and servers. I cannot wait to go back next month when I'm back in the area read more

See all

Was recommended to us to try and it did not disappoint. Food was excellent and so was the service! I will be back.

Such a wonderful place in downtown New Albany. Truly delicious Italian food. We enjoyed the atmosphere. Modern and inviting. Servers were very helpful and tried to accommodate our requests. The food was great! Very tasty and on par with high class Italian restaurants in larger markets. Way beyond your typical Olive Garden or Carrabbas. More on par with Amerigo, Maggiano's, and local Italian places. Much better than the places I ate in Rome, Venice, and Florence. Of course, Americanized versions are more flavorful in my opinion. I loved the shrimp scampi, chicken Marsala, loaded baked potato casserole, and linguini. Look forward to going back soon and trying their pizzas. read more

See all

Out in the 'country' for Mother's Day, we stopped in before the rush. Again, our fellow Yelpers reviews were right on target. We had Chicken Marsala - pronounced really good by my wife, and blackened redfish* - pronounced great by yours truly! * - Didn't not expect such quality outside of a major metropolitan area. Service was very good, and ambiance was of a typical classy (but not overly pricey) restaurant read more

Service and food is amazing!!!! Great spot to go for food and drinks... pizza was amazing!!!!! Spaghetti is also so good! Mozzarella sticks are freakn huge and so good! read more

See all

Food delicious. Very courteous employees. Clean. Family atmosphere. The food gets a top rating.

The pizza on Friday was so good! Great atmosphere, low noise . Service was fast and friendly! read more

Great service and excellent quality. The food is incredible delicious with great flavor. The price and quality is amazing. Great ambiance at the restaurant. read more

Nico's - Chicken pesto ravioli - Italian Near Me - New Albany, Mississippi

See all

Very nice restaurant. We went on a Monday night, ate at a high top in the bar area. Service was wonderful! Lighting is relaxing and the noise level was also nice and low, although it was busier than I expected for a Monday. For appetizers we ordered the fried mozzarella which I usually don't even like but it was excellent and calamari-little chewy, will try again bc it might have just been an off night. The hot honey pepperoni pizza was so good! My ribeye was flavorful but not over seasoned and cooked to perfection! Leftovers the next day were tender as well! You get two sides, I ordered the Ceaser salad which was great and asparagus. It was so good and seasoned nicely. I ordered a spicy margarita on the rocks and it was just okay. I felt like they used a mix which I don't like but whatever. Will try this restaurant again!! read more

Nico's - Strawberry salad add chicken - Italian Near Me - New Albany, Mississippi

See all

Food was awesome, service was the best I've had in a while. The vibe here was chill. Had great time with friends!

Amazing steak and lasagne! Wonderful, warm, historic atmosphere! Will definitely return on our next trip through read more

Our excellent experience at Nico's started with the warm, friendly service we received from Alyssa. We wanted a fairly light meal and ordered dinner salads. The salmon was deliciously seasoned and cooked to perfection. The grilled shrimp salad was equally delicious and also perfectly prepared. Alyssa was attentive, helpful and kept us smiling. We could not resist the tiramisu and it was perfect. We would definitely go to Nico's when we are in the area. read more

Food was great! Service was a bit sketchy. Seems like she just got sidetracked and sort of forgot about us! Love the look and feel of the place! read more

The food, service and ambiance were great. The Pecan crusted salmon was perfectly cooked, the bacon and the calamari appetizers were also great. read more

What a nice surprise in downtown New Albany. Great food, pizza is amassing! A friend ordered the ribeye and I can't wait go back and try it. Bartender knows how to make a great drink. Perfect for date night or girls night out. read more

Let me just start out by saying, this place is AmAzInG! The staff, the ambience, the decor, just overall AMAZING! The food was sooooo good, and top notch quality and hot. The bartender was our server since we sat in the bar area. His name was Coty (with a T). He was so nice, gave us recommendations of what to order, drinks, and etc. I can NOT and do NOT have a bad thing to say about this place. I HIGHLY recommend this place- and the prices soooooo good! 5 stars read more

See all

Another wonderful meal at Nico's! The halibut special was outstanding along with my favorite brussel sprouts and Mac and cheese! Wedge salad, Smoke salmon pizza was perfect! Fried shrimp and chicken Alfredo were excellent! read more

There is my favorite place in New Albany to eat! Great food and atmosphere! Service was outstanding read more

See all

The wait time was very short and the food was excellent. Family friendly atmosphere! We love the brick oven pizzas.

The food service is very good. our dinner was made with pride the bartender did an amazing job

The pizza and appetizer were good. We look forward to trying out some of their dinner offerings over the coming months.

We waited for over 5 minutes for someone to take our drink order,while 4 services stood 10 feet away chatting and ingoring us. Pizza was good but the lasagna was some of the worse I have had. read more

Great food, all four liked what we had. Was reasonable price too. Will definitely go back. Want to try their pizza. Heard it was great too. Service good too. Also could have some conservation, even though it was full. read more

Well. This place was recommended when we Googled dinner in New Albany. We thought, OK, Italian. We arrived at 8:00, two hours before closing. Six of us, in town after a football game. Pretty good wine list, so we ordered a bottle, $110, just so you know we are diners who appreciate a good experience; and a couple of us ordered a cocktail. Then we ordered two calamari appetizers and the fried pickles. Both were OK. We ordered dinner: 3 lasagnas, ravioli, chicken fettuccine and chicken Marsala. And Caesar salads, soup and a couple of sides. The Caesar salad came with giant packaged croutons, and the dressing was in a plastic cup on the side. Loads of shaved Parmesan on the Romaine, probably the best part. Just saying, a salad lightly tossed with dressing is a better presentation. The two people having soup said it was good. The lasagna was described as "fine"; not much flavor and no discernible meat in the sauce. The fettuccine was served with two chicken tenderloins on top, and was described as "Pretty good". The ravioli special was a large portion and also ""Good". The Chicken Marsala was a huge portion, and was served with a big portion of sautéed fresh vegetables, probably the highlight of our table! But really, here's the thing: We were not even close to finishing our dinners when our waiter asked if we wanted anything else, with our tab in hand, and another worker started sweeping the carpet around our table. This is an example of restaurant management not training their employees properly in customer service. And the food was good but not specially prepared or presented. We wanted to like this place but were not impressed. There are probably better choices for dinner in this area. read more

First time trying Nico's. It did not disappoint. My husband and I ordered the Fried Mozzarella for appetizer. They were delicious. We both had the Ribeye for entree. It was perfectly cooked and very tender. The service was amazing. We only had about a 15 minute wait. Everyone was very attentive. The manager came by and welcomed us as well. The ambiance was great. It's very open and welcoming. Everything looked new and clean. This will definitely be a new place on our favorites list. Try it out if you are ever in New Albany. read more

See all

Good food and service located in a nice town. I have the mozzarella sticks and pizza.

This place came recommended by our hotel and they were spot on. Stayed at Holiday inn Express and it's not far from there. Easy to park near the restaurant. Excellent service and delicious veggie pizza. We will be back. read more

Nico's always seems to do a good job. Food was good and service can be a bit spotty at times but overall recommend this place if eating in New Albany. read more

I don't live in New Albany where Nico's is located but I come through here pretty often. I have been here twice for dinner and it was great. The food, service and atmosphere is awesome. I plan on going back there. read more

Food was ok. Not as described on the menu but restaurant was too busy the night we were there to complain. Found better options for the following days of our visit read more

Great Food, large variety to choose from. Host staff was excellent and prices reasonable.