I ordered a pepperoni and mushroom for delivery via Grubhub. Smooth experience and the pizza is amazing! Good quality NY style, absolutely love it! Word of warning, the "small" is pretty darn big. And it's quite filling. Top notch experience. Would definitely eat here again! read more

Nick's Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom. - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

I stopped in at 8:00 with no order and asked for a medium cheese pizza . They made it fresh and was out the door in 15 minutes . Great place , very friendly , clean . The pizza was very tasty ! Good cheese , no complaints at all, in town for work or this would be my go to pizza place . read more

Nick's Pizza - Medium pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

I got a dozen hot wings char grilled. Lordy what a chicken wing. They don't make their own blue cheese, but they provide Ken's blue cheese (Buffalo classic) and Ken knows what he's doing. Crispy outside, perfect sauce, then char grilled. Don't hesitate, order these bad boys. I also got a calzone that was a size of the moon. Sauce is sweet, life is good. Sorry for only showing the half order of wings, too damn good to let sit read more

Nick's Pizza - Hot char grilled - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

See all

Service and Pizza is top notch. The store is like a little ma n pa shop, good spot, only downfall is theyre closed on weekends but i dont blame them there, good help is hard to find. read more

I went back to Nick's and asked them not to put olives in my ziti this time and they asked me incredulously what I was talking about so I showed them this review and they said, "Oh, those are green peppers." And I said, "Okay, who puts green peppers in a baked ziti?!" (Regardless, it tasted like olive.) And they said they make all their sauce with green peppers and suggested I was the weird one for not expecting green peppers in marinara. ‍ read more

Just stopped by for a slice as I was in that part of town for work. Despite it being busy staff was very friendly. Pizza was above average and reasonably priced. Not anything I would go out of my way for, but when in the area worth a stop! read more

Nick's Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

We stopped in this evening and was met with a very friendly and clean location. Before leaving, we were chatting with a lady at the restaurant and disclosed where we were staying. We then accidentally left before bringing our slices of pizza with us. To our wonderful surprise, she showed up at our location before we were barely even out of our cars. Wonderful service. Highly recommend. read more

I wanted to like this place. The sandwich would have been very good, but the green peppers in the sauce are a no go for me! This sauce said a very unique flavor. Some people may love it, but I was not one of those. read more

Food was excellent! Delicious. Excellent flavors and thin crispy pie Yelp recommended and it!! Was not disappointed Service great, very friendly!! Place is clean and bright. Bathroom clean and well kept Great place right off the thruway!! Highly recommend!!!! read more

Nick's Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

See all

solid slice here yelpers. I got two standard to go, one for yesterday, one cold tonight, pretty good both times and that's with my input on this place. near carrier circle for you road warriors living temporarily next block over, no issues here. can I peel myself away from wegmans enough to try other items?? read more

While staying East Syracuse, It was getting late on Monday night. I decided to order a pizza pie half pepperoni and cheese. It was delicious and made to perfection. The sauce and cheese were just the right amount . The crust was made to my liking. I ended up going back another day . Reasonable price & quick service. read more

I just got a dozen mild and a dozen garlic butter parmigiana wings and I have to say that they were delicious and I believe they were the best wings I've had in a long time definitely worth the price read more

Visited Syracuse for some family business. Yesterday I went to Nick's pizza. When I went in the pizza restaurant the cook was making a pizza that looked so good I asked for the exact same thing. Turns out it was a large meat lovers pizza. Got back to the hotel and the first taste of this pizza I knew it was golden. I went back to the pizza shop today asked for the cook and just thanked him because that pizza was fantastic. I also left him a tip and I'm just like everyone else,I left a tip in the bowl when I bought the pizza yesterday. Life is short so I decided to go back and directly give him a tip for making a fantastic pizza. He might even be the owner because his name is Nick. Great pizza Nick. Great, great pizza. read more

WE bought two specialty 16" pizzas (garlic with ham, Philly cheesesteak) and a house salad, our bill was $70 with tip. If the food delivered was memorable, I'd still be hesitant to order from them again, the food was very forgettable unfortunately. On the pizzas they had a ridiculously light hand with the proteins. The garlic pizza was topped with one slice of deli ham chopped up, the cheesesteak the steak was nearly non existent. Lastly a $12.00 house salad made with iceberg lettuce contained two small cherry tomatoes. This place is focused on profit, the pizzas weren't bad, weren't great. read more

Wow so Yummy . it was loaded , very generously topped on a fabulous crust .. delivered early and super friendly . Definitely a great choice . Thank u so much Room 315 Hotel Concord Steve and Karen read more

Delicious pizza dough & incredibly accommodating service. Definitely worth the try if you're a pizza lover!

I really hate leaving low scores for local restaurants, especially when I used to really enjoy when I worked in the area. Alas... I have to leave this review to call them out on the things that aren't cool. The first thing that knocked the star off right away it's freaking charge in a service charge. Yes times are tough but come on that's why you sell foods, they pay the bills... Tacking on a few percent milk a little more money is not cool. This is obviously being done because if they raise the price of the food they have to pay for the displays to be changed. The second issue that I had is that their bathroom isn't really handicap accessible. They may think it is with the two metal bars, but the sink vanity they have... Well see what happens with a wheelchair and a sink vanity. Also the spacing on the toilet as well. Lastly, I just didn't enjoy my pizza like I used to. It was very old when I came in and we all know how to tell what all pizza looks like. No amount of oven reheating will fix that. The flavors just weren't there at all, but I'm assuming that's because it was old. Sadly, I don't think I'll come back anymore. read more

See all

We ordered delivery from here to our hotel. We called around 8:30 and they said 45 minutes, but it took about an hour for it to be delivered. It was around $16 for a two topping 14-inch pizza. It was pretty greasy (but what pizza isn't?), a bit too salty and the dough was a little hard to rip. All in all, it was a fine pizza, especially after driving and only eating fried fast food for the past two days s read more

Nick's Pizza - Cheese Pizza w/ mushrooms and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

Way Above average pizza, Dave would have gave it a 7.9 maybe 8.2. Worth a 25 minute drive from the airport. Wings 9/10 read more

Nick's Pizza - 9/10 hot wings - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

Solid pepperoni slice! Closer to NYC style pizza than anything I can think of. The slices were large, around $2.50 and tasty. The person working the counter and oven was super friendly and I had my slice within 3 minutes. Would definitely come back here. read more

Have only ever had their pizza but it's always good. In my opinion, they're best by the slice, nicely crispy and thin as pizza should be.

Location was convenient to where I was staying off of Carrier Circle and was in the mood for some Italian food for dinner . I wanted something different and opted for the Chicken Parmesan dinner. It was very good and very healthy portion. Service was excellent for a take out order. Not only did I get notified through Yelp app that my dinner was ready, the restaurant called to make sure I knew. I'll be back to Nick's the next time I'm in the area because I appreciate good food and great service! read more

Food was perfect and fast. Salad was a ton! Ordering again tonight! Wish you all the best of luck. Keep up the good food! read more

Nick's Pizza - Antipasto and meat Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

Got to the hotel around 6 and didn't want to drive to get food. We ordered online to the Pizzeria down the street. They were so fast and the food was amazing! The Pizza crust was nice and crispy with light sauce and so was the wings. My 1st NY Pizza and I would say it was well worth the drive from CA. read more

Nick's Pizza - Mild Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

See all

I love pizza, was looking for a quick snack one evening while in Syracuse - low and behold nearby my hotel at Carrier Circle, I was introduced to Nick's, a traditional super NY thin crusted pie with tasty sauce, cheese and meat!! I dropped in for to go order, and just out of the oven was a fresh large pizza, 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 Italian sausage, looked great! Could've gotten the whole thing, but was way too much for 1 person, thus ordered by the slice, very reasonable. When I come back next time, will like to try ordering a whole pie with all the fixings I like. And they have plenty of other items such as salads, calzones etc. Check Nick's out if you have a pizza craving - it hit the spot for me and staff was super friendly too! read more

Nick's Pizza - Pizza slices that makes you hungry! - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

Great place to grab a slice for lunch. Pleasantly surprised.my style pizza by the slice or bigger.

So today I went and had lunch with the girl, and we were just looking for something quick and were just gonna grab some fast food burgers. Not everyone's favorite option but quick none the less. But she works in this area and knew of this pizzeria and it having seating and such since she's had lunch here before, and who doesn't like pizza. It's your typical walk in place where behind a sheet of glass a selection of pre made slices are sitting there and they grab and heat them up in the oven for you. Not my favorite method of pizza it's always better fresh I'm sure. So I got your basic two slices of cheese and a soda. She opted for pepperoni and sausage. Service was quick but I don't think I saw a single smile in the joint. But I imagine a summer in a pizza place isn't a magical thing as it's always incredibly hot behind those counters. So they were all probably hot and tired after a lunch rush. The pizza itself was a thinner crust. And easy to fold. Not my favorite but it has good flavor. The issue I take with most pizza places here is the same as most, the sauce. For one it was bland here. And sweet. They must add sugar to it and I like a zestier more robust and acidic pizza sauce. It was just kind of there. And the layer of cheese was so thin and when it was reheated you didn't get that ooey gooey cheesey love you get with a good slice of pie. All in all. Not to my taste and incredibly average. The reason I'd give this between 3-4 stars is the way they keep their restaurant. Most of these places are old tables old chairs and sort of dark and dingey. This place was impeccably kept. Super clean granite counters and table tops. Fresh paint and I couldn't see a single speck of dirt or fingerprints on anything. So while it might not be to my taste. It is obvious they have a lot of pride and care about the product they are putting out there. In consensus. I'd give them a second try. Prices were reasonable (about 13.50 for four slices and a soda to share), and service was quick even if not pleasant and i could tell how much they cared. I think next time I'd rather try a fresh pie and see if perhaps that makes the quality improve. read more

Nick's Pizza - Cheese slices - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

After a 10-hour day on the road, pizza from Nick was the perfect dinner for weary and hungry travelers! The pizza was delicious and the tables and dining area were super clean. Nicks has been added to my Contacts!! read more

Best pizza and eggplant in town! They get really busy so plan ahead and be patient, I think the food is worth it.

Great pizza and great establishment! I am surprised to say that I wouldn't change one thing about this place. It has solid pizza, solid wings, and the price is average. My family and I came here on a Friday looking for a good pizza/wing deal. We decided on a large pepperoni pizza and 24 wings (hot and honey barbecue) that came to $31.21 (with tax). They had a nice variety of pre-made pizzas sold by the slice up front. The interior was surprisingly pleasant and cleanly. My mother even commented that they had a cozy atmosphere and the bathroom was well kept. The place had a decent amount of tables with crushed red pepper and parmesan shakers decorating each table. It was about a 20 minute wait until a fresh pizza and wings arrived. As for the pizza, it's typical New York (very thin crust) style. So if that's what you're into, this pizza is for you. It was cooked perfectly. While the crust was quite thin, it did have good flavor. The sauce was equal in quality and unique in comparison to traditional pizza sauces; it was both garlicky and had a zing. The toppings were pretty standard, but satisfying. The wings were tasty as well. The hot were traditional red hot and butter, but they made them extra saucy just how I like them. The honey bbq hit the spot too. They were a little messy and sticky but that's what I expect from decent bbq.The wings were of quality as well, they were meaty and cooked to a perfect crisp. Overall, I will be back here. There pizza is good and the prices are average. To be honest, this was some of the best NY style pizza I have had in Syracuse in a while. Most other places have been dropping the ball with flavor and burning the crust. This place was just how I remember good NY style pizza. I would recommend this place to fellow pizza lovers. read more

Nick's Pizza - Honey BBQ and Hot Wings - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

See all

I am ordinarily a little hesitant to write about any initial experience that I have with pizza especially in the Syracuse area. My preference is to see if a good experience is reproducible. Sometimes if it is an especially poor experience, I would not consider spending my time, money or caloric intake on lousy pizza a second time. Nick's is just south of the Carrier Circle on Thompson Road next to a Dunkin Donuts so, nothing fancy is going on on the outside. Inside was surprisingly clean, updated and comfortable without being gaudy. They had a few nice and fresh looking pies on display and I opted for two slices: a plain and one with mushrooms since they looked to be fresh mushrooms. I paid, grabbed my fountain soda (refills are not free and cost 50 cents) and took a seat. A very short time later, my slices were delivered to my table. Service was very pleasant. The slices looked even better now that they were heated. The real reason I even tried this place is because another Yelper, Frank P. stated "Thin crunchy crust the way it's supposed to be." A good pizza crust is a rare commodity around here. Nick's has it ! The crust was fantastic, fresh, crispy and dense enough with some nice resistance in each bite. The cheese and sauce were good, although, I would like a bit more of an assertive flavor from both the cheese and sauce. This is just based on reheated slices so, perhaps I will be even more happily surprised if I order a personal pie to be freshly baked for me on my next visit. read more

See all

In my book, there are two kinds of pizza. Good pizza and Great pizza. Nick's kicks it up a notch....there is a new kind of pizza....as good as Nick's!! read more

First off I'm from Ohio so my opinion is definitely unbiased. I heard nothing but good things from the locals so figured I'd give it a try and I absolutely was not disappointed. I went with the Mediterranean pizza and it was one of the best I ever had. Delivery was really fast and professional. Nick deserves all 5 stars you run a great restaurant buddy read more

Nick's Pizza - Mediterranean pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

My family and I have been eating at Nicks for years. My Dad loves it. I enjoy it. Dad often stops by for their wings for dinner. I like the fact I can get deep fried cauliflower. The pizza is very good. And the location is convenient. It is in the little strip mall with Jreck Subs and Dunkin Donuts, just off Carrier Circle. read more

Great pie, good customer service, delivered right to our hotel room door! Would order again.

Excellent pizza! Excellent service! No complaints! The counter people are friendly and prices are good.

After ordering from this place probably a dozen times, they've decided that they're going to overcharge me, again. This isn't a review of their food. It's always good and I've yet to have a complaint. The delivery is prompt and friendly. I'm talking about simple credit card payments and now, for the second time, I was overcharged. It seems like they're using the contact free delivery and over the phone credit card orders and taking a little extra. It's called math, and the numbers don't add up. If there are extra charges, put them on your website! It'll take you all of 10 minutes to figure it out. So, after being a customer for a few years, I'm calling you out on whatever (extra) charges you're adding to orders. Ridiculous. I'll buy a 5 dollar frozen pizza before calling this place again. Way to lose a customer. AVOID. read more

Just about the best pizza I've had in the immediate area, priced right huge selection, and properly staffed so no huge wait even during lunch rush, kudos to the guys at Nick's for a job well done. read more

A tasty slice of pizza, New York style, just a few minutes off the thruway. Located in a little side plaza right down Thompson Rd, it's conveniently located for anyone staying on Carrier Circle or just passing through. Walking in, there were easily eight different kinds of pizza that were hot and ready to go. The crust was perfectly thin with just the right amount of crisp and chew to make a traveler think they had stopped off in NYC. The sauce was evenly distributed and not too sweet. I had added some garlic sprinkle out of habit but I'm no so sure I needed it. The only downside was that I could see was that the pepperoni slice was pretty greasy and the fountain drinks had a charge for refills which is a bit outlandish for the area, but it was certainly a great tasting experience. I would definitely stop by again if I was on that side of town again. read more

Nick's Pizza - Two of the many selections available to try! - Pizza Near Me - East Syracuse, New York

Closest pizza I've had to NYC. A coworker brought me the other day and I'm getting a pie for home tonight.