Cancel

Open app

Search

Nicholas Creamery Wall

3.5 (12 reviews)
Open • 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Order Nicholas Creamery Wall Takeout or Delivery

Nicholas Creamery Wall Photos

You might also consider

More like Nicholas Creamery Wall

Recommended Reviews - Nicholas Creamery Wall

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Flavors
Adam S.

First time trying Nicholas Creamery after having an awesome dinner at Lubrano's. Wasn't sure what to expect but there were people waiting outside. Would highly recommend the ice cream and shake options specifically the peanut butter option.

See all

2 months ago

Great ice cream with great ingredients. Owner does a lot for the community. I've been a patron for a long time!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of S M.
0
8
3

7 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Dan J.
4
116
49

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of D F.
0
9
0

1 year ago

customer service is nonexistent!! Cakes are 60$with no personalization or pre order!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Nicholas Creamery Wall

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Desserts 493 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Belvidere Baking Company - Butler's Pantry Belvidere Biscuits. Blueberry Whie Chocolate

The Belvidere Baking Company

5.0(1 review)
2.9 mi

This company had a booth at The Victorian Days event. I got to try a sample of their Belvidere…read moreBiscuits. These sweet biscuits are the best thing I have ever eaten! I bought three bags! Now I just call and order them. You can also order them through their website. I recently ordered a hostess tray of all eight of their flavors. My guests went crazy for them. Wanted to spread the word! These biscuits are addictive! They also have great gift baskets!

From the owner: We are online 24 hours a day, seven days a week. We are the Belvidere Baking Company, founded in…read more2013. Our products, Belvidere Biscuits, are a sinfully decadent sweet artisan dessert- a soft, rich, and dense biscuit. We have combined our 130-year-old recipe with Victorian-themed branding and have created what we believe is a singular dessert experience. Our biscuits are handmade, small batch, artisan baked goods. Each batch is created by hand, and all ingredients hand cut and mixed, and with no machinery, ensuring the integrity of each mouthwatering ingredient. This is why you'll see whole chocolate chips, and large chunks of fruit and nuts. We put no preservatives, no dyes, and no artificial flavoring into our product. We then slice them hot out of the oven. And, of course, every single batch is baked fresh and made to order. 19 Decadent Flavors!

Photos
The Belvidere Baking Company - Velvet Ladies Belvidere Biscuits. Double Chocolate Cherry Walnut

Velvet Ladies Belvidere Biscuits. Double Chocolate Cherry Walnut

The Belvidere Baking Company - Assorted Belvidere Biscuits

Assorted Belvidere Biscuits

The Belvidere Baking Company - Our newest flavor, Hyde Park. Orange Chocolate Macadamia.

See all

Our newest flavor, Hyde Park. Orange Chocolate Macadamia.

Sundaes The Ice Cream Place

Sundaes The Ice Cream Place

3.9(60 reviews)
1.2 mi
•$$

I have eaten ice cream throughout the entire state of New Jersey and New York. Sundays is by far…read morethe clearest Utkir entire state of New Jersey Over the decades, I have watched ice cream parlors reduce the quality of their product to frost bitten, overly aerated cheap low-grade artificially flavored baked cream. If I had to rank every ice cream parlor in the state, Sundays is so far out in first place that the second best ice cream parlor is in another galaxy. If you have not tried Sundays walk in and get their smallest cone just to sample it and see what I mean. It is genuine authentic ice cream with no frost, no cheap artificial flavors and you can tell that the owners really truly care about putting out a high-quality product. I have been to both locations at least 100 times and the quality of their product is always absolutely consistent and top-notch. I never write reviews for ice cream parlors if you look at my history but again I just had another incredible ice cream cone and they deserve this review. Good job Sundays keep up the great work and never change. Nobody comes close.

A solid choice for ice cream. Went on a rainy day and there was no wait. Fairly friendly staff who…read morequickly received ingredients in the flavors. Nice selection of ice creams and clean inside. Pricing was on par for ice cream. Ended up with a small Robert Brownie Jr. Overall, the experience and food was just okay - wouldn't seek it out again but wouldn't mind trying it again either.

Photos
Sundaes The Ice Cream Place - Ice cream is to die for

Ice cream is to die for

Sundaes The Ice Cream Place
Sundaes The Ice Cream Place

See all

Lexylicious - Oreo with Ice Cream

Lexylicious

4.5(68 reviews)
2.5 mi

I'm obsessed with Lexylicious! I decided to have them come for my daughter birthday party and it…read morewas perfect. It's so easy to book with them and then you literally don't have to do anything. They bring everything they need and start serving out of the window. Just make sure you book them after everyone eats. All of the kids at the party went crazy when the truck pulleThey bake the cookies the day of your event and stuff them with ice cream for your guests. They also have GIANT Oreos!! I've never seen them before. Each guest got to choose what type of flavor combination they wanted. The servers were sooo sweet and helpful. Everyone is still raving about the event and I can't wait to have them back this year too.

Do not book this company for an event. They are not capable of organizing a simple thing like…read moreparking or have the professionalism to properly communicate. My fiance has been emailing the owner to no avail and he was finally able to reach her by phone on the week of my wedding. She made my fiance call the town to try to obtain a permit and did not even attempt to call. I was planning to pay a decent amount for a wedding and she asked if the venue workers can scoop ice cream to my wedding coordinator. The business owner then told my fiance that the wedding coordinator told her to have my fiance call the town for a permit, which this is a blatant lie because my wedding coordinator called me with concerns as a vendor typically will deal with parking. They asked if me and my fiance can help during our wedding to guide them in or assist with parking and if they couldn't find parking it would eat into our paid time. We have other vendors where this is not a problem. The location was discussed when it was agreed upon. If I could give zero stars I would because my wedding is this week. She also charges my credit card without authorization as she did not finalize parking and did not email if she was coming to the event due to her complaining about the parking, mind you this is two days before the wedding Baked bear is amazing and I had more professionalism and organization in one phone call compared to this horrible experience.

Photos
Lexylicious - Funfetti with Unicorn Ice Cream

Funfetti with Unicorn Ice Cream

Lexylicious - Lexylicious Truck

Lexylicious Truck

Lexylicious - Funfetti with extra sprinkles

See all

Funfetti with extra sprinkles

Simona's Bakery - Cupcake with raspberry filling

Simona's Bakery

3.6(103 reviews)
1.3 mi
•$$

Simona's bakery has a great selection of cookies and other desserts. I really enjoy their large…read moreselection of biscotti's and different flavors as well as they have two different types of rainbow cookies, one with a apricot jelly and one with what I think is a traditional raspberry jelly. They also have a selection of butter cookies which are really great if you're bringing a box of something somewhere. The last time I came in I tend to be indecisive with so many selections and the woman behind the counter was very kind and patient with me waffling on what I wanted to get and how much of it I wanted to get. She even happily wrapped up the box because I was bringing it over to my sister's house. The shop is small but it does have a lot of items and to be honest if it was much bigger, I don't know if it would change much outside of having space for people to sit down which seems outside their business model. This seems like a great place place to stop if you were going to someone's house and needed to take a box of something or if it was the holidays and you wanted to get some desserts to bring. There is also the occasional self-indulgence and I really enjoyed the rainbow cookies.

Unprepared when they open the doors at 7 AM. Empty shelves and still baking stuff that should…read morealready be on display. Quality of bake goods is menza menza. Had to go back three times today for simple bread rolls that should have been out when they opened up an hour ago. Counter service is weak and slow which only adds to a negative experience here. Bottom line: NOT recommend! Muller's bakery of Bayhead eats their lunch all week long and then some. Go here instead, it's worth the drive..

Photos
Simona's Bakery
Simona's Bakery - 3 layered cake chocolate & vanilla with chocolate pudding and cannoli fillings, fresh whipped cream frosting.

3 layered cake chocolate & vanilla with chocolate pudding and cannoli fillings, fresh whipped cream frosting.

Simona's Bakery - My cookies

See all

My cookies

Sunburst Pie - Strawberry Shortcake Cream Pie; Vanilla custard, crumbled Vanilla Scone, Fresh Strawberries Fresh Whipped Cream!

Sunburst Pie

4.6(59 reviews)
1.6 mi
•$$

As we were on vacation at the NJ shore, took a long drive through various beach towns and noticed…read morethe Sunburst Bakery. After reading a lot of convincing reviews, decided to stop early on our way out of town for the peach scone (a bit of almond extract would elevate the fruit) and the artichoke, goat cheese, tomato and asparagus quiche. It was substantial and really creamy. And the pie crusts are homemade, tender and flaky. Added two small pies: the key lime was my absolute flavorite, creamy and just the right lime flavor without tasting too sour. Although it collapsed on the way home, it was just the right true lime taste without being bitter. I've had many versions of key lime pie, even in the Keys and this was my fave! The other banana chocolate features a pie crust lined in chocolate, loaded with layered bananas, crème topping and drizzled chocolate. Next trip, I'm trying more specialty treats! Thanks, Jay and staff for baking goodies!

Praise the LARD! Stumbled upon this place by seeing the words EMPANADAS on the window. Once I saw…read morethose words, I walked straight inside and ordered myself one. I did enjoy my breakfast empanada very much but the chicken one was definitely my favorite. It came with a chimichurri type sauce that just brought the already flavorful empanada to another level. The acid/garlic from the sauce was able to brighten up the heavier filling and crust. Let's talk about the crust for a second. It was so flaky, melt in your mouth texture! We did get to try the beef empanada as they gave it to us on accident instead of the chicken. All three were delicious and next time I would love to try their quiches or homemade soups!

Photos
Sunburst Pie
Sunburst Pie
Sunburst Pie - So good, he forgot he had a coffee. Great smile, Thanks Freddy!

See all

So good, he forgot he had a coffee. Great smile, Thanks Freddy!

Nicholas Creamery Wall - desserts - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...