This is my second visit here so far while visiting my boyfriend's sister. The pepperoni pizza was SO great the first time around. I was really eye balling the stuffed shells on the menu and the wings other people were eating so I had to come back! Turns out the stuffed shells are great and the wings are as good as they looked. This staff is very friendly and accommodating. Clean well kept place. If I don't make it a 3rd time before I leave, I'll look forward to coming back on my next return to Waterville! Thank you! read more

New York Pizzeria - Crispy wings! - Pizza Near Me - Waterville, New York

Excellent pizza and cooked perfectly. Sauce has a great flavor profile. Crust was spot on also Great friendly service at this rustic pizza joint. read more

See all

Best pizza for us ,frank n Rosa are the nicest people.great prices, great salads ,clean place read more

New York Pizzeria - a man sitting in a chair with a cat - Pizza Near Me - Waterville, New York

Love this pizza place, always good. Interior atmosphere is clean and nice. Staff is always friendly. You can tell they care for their business and customers and it shows. I was there when a customer dropped a big tray of food walking outside and they were kind and helped clean up and re made it for him. They made a crappy situation not any worse by their kindness. Really recommend read more

Amazing pizza and wings I have had good luck with these guys for months now. They are understaffed but somehow always gets pizza out at 30 minutes or less. Amazing job and cute area, wish it was in a bigger place but it's now my go to! read more

This is the real deal. Real Italian pizza, with home made crust- you can watch the owner making it through the front window! Probably the best pizza and crust I've had in years, anywhere. read more

Great! Family business feels like home Customer service outstanding the food is amazing.

always the best spot around for some great pizza. My earliest memory of this place was when I was about 7; I'm now 21 and the service and environment hasn't changed. Always welcoming and truly makes you feel at home. Friends I know who live in other counties come out to this small town to this big hearted pizza shop. read more

I ask my parents to buy a pizza, put it on dry ice, and overnight it to me in Ohio. It's really that good. They've never done it but I still have hope. read more

I posted some pictures of our dinners: chicken parmigiana, chicken riggies and lasagna. Can anyone say.........HUGE!!!! First off, they were sold out of fish frys by about 5:30pm. I found out why when I passed a couple eating them. The fish looks amazing and is a really good sized portion. I'll be back for that. Our meals were absolutely delicious. The prices are very reasonable and there is so much food that we had our leftovers today for lunch. Kids didn't even complain so you know the food is great!!! read more

See all

Best pizza on the planet. And I've had pizza on most every continent. I come home from CA for these slices of heaven.

I cant believe I am the first to write a review on this place! Better known to me and my family as Frank and Rosa's.... This place has literally the absolute undisputed best pizza, wings, pasta, garlic knots, salad, and chicken riggies on the face of planet earth! No place will ever compare or come close! I am now on a constant search for something remotely close here in SoCal. The best of the best, these people take time to get to know you and your family. We are greated by name and when the Paino family comes in, they have a tray of garlic knots ready for us! (We usually come with no less than 6 people... at least when the Cali clan is visiting!) read more

My family and I drive past multiple pizzerias and drive half an hour just to get your delicious pizza and wings! Best around and very consistent! read more

Their chicken riggies are excellent. I always ask them to make my pizza WELL DONE and it comes out crunchy and delicious. Their sauce is also phenomenal. The overall restaurant is small but it's really nice inside. Family owned and operated which is always a big plus. They know what they are doing here! Great local spot. read more

The only thing I've ever had from here are the chicken riggies. They're pretty good. They're always busy. One of the few places to eat in Waterville, NY. Small town Italian family local business. The owner, Frank, is always very friendly. Garlic knots are also good. People seem to like their pizza. Nice place to stop in and grab something quick. read more

New York Pizzeria - Family meal - Pizza Near Me - Waterville, New York

Amazing food, Whenever we travel back to Waterville we always stop by Frank and Rosa's New York Pizzeria. I don't get back to Waterville very often, so it's amazing to me that Frank and Rosa recognize me at all, it's a good feeling to be greeted by name and made to feel welcome. My family and I have to stop by at least 3 times per visit so we can sample all of the great food. I live near Denver, CO and haven't found any place that compares to the quality and value of this restaurant. -Robert Mayne- read more

My favorite pizza in CNY. Sweet sauce, great cheese! I'm usually a toppings person, but their plain pizza is perfection, so anything on top just doesn't compare!!! The garlic pizza with ricotta is also phenomenal. Try their riggies (I like them extra spicy) and chicken parmigiana- one dish easily feeds two people, but most of all, try the plain cheese pizza, it's absolute heaven! read more

"one picture is worth ten thousand words"-Fred R. Barnard good pizza despite the fact that this is what i saw when i opened it up. same thing with the 2nd pizza but it wasn't as bad as this read more

New York Pizzeria - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Waterville, New York

I've been here a million times and the food is always decent and never undercooked which is a big plus. However having a local business is about respecting the community that allows you to continue to operate and be profitable, not over time believe you are above the rules of the community. When you come to order food and you see one of the owners intentionally parking in a handicapped space numerous times you lose respect for the establishment as a whole because it reveals the true essence of the people behind it. Unfortunately I will not be going back and neither will my grandparents. read more

This place is my favorite place to get my pizza. The food is amazing and the staff is friendly and courteous. After a few times going in there you start to feel like your family every time after. Love the decor as well. read more

We loved the food the lasagna and raviolis were fantastic the tomato sauce was amazing .. frank and Rosa were very nice great people we will be back! Loved it! read more

I live more than 20 minutes from here and travel there as often as I can. My favorite Pizzaria, great pizza and wings, and very friendly staff! read more

Love this PLACE best pizza I've ever had we go here everytime we come to New York...the owners are great to very friendly people family owned business it's just great... read more

Great Italian sub. Just passing through this small town so I stopped for lunch. If I ever pass through again I would stop here for a meal. Clean and friendly. read more

We happened to be in Waterville at lunch time and luckily found New York Pizza. The pepperoni roll is to die for. Not only was it absolutely delicious, but it was also inexpensive. Service was quick and friendly. Don't miss this great spot! read more

awesome sauce. great service. family owned and operated. prices very reasonable. monster servings. a delight to eat there. delivery is fast! read more

Caring and Quality Family and Food!! A true and big blessing for a little town! Thanks for the Great Business you have built up!

This place is fantastic. The fact that I live on the Sauquoit/New Hartford border and drive to Waterville for my pizza proves that. There are a ton of other pizza joints closer to me than New York Pizzeria but unless we're in the mood for a upside down pizza from O'babys I take the drive to Waterville. Their style is N.Y tossed and not the typical set your dough out, let it rise, pat it down, and pour on the canned Don Pepino sauce pizza. New Yorks sauce is perfectly balanced with a hint of sweetness, the cheese is blended perfect, the toppings taste excellent, and they dont skimp on them either. Frank and Rosa (owners) treat their customers like family and despite many successful years in business Frank still chooses to work almost every day making the pizza. He always greets me with a smile and hello even when he isn't working the counter. My last order of 3 sub sandwiches was all screwed up but considering I've gone years without any issues that incident doesn't sour my opinion on their quality. Take the drive or when your in Waterville stop and try their food you won't be disappointed. read more

Tried to get to this restaurant several times lately only to find they are closed even when their on line hours say they will be open. Other times I tried to call to confirm they are open and no one answers the phone. Can only imagine someone in the family is sick to cause such disarray in regular business hours. This is a family run business so I can see how any disruption to regular routine would cause problems... read more