I'm giving this place 5 stars based on the fact that is it up in two harbors, if it were in a bigger city it would probably be only 4. However I think they deserve the extra star for offering and pulling off what they do in a more remote place where they could get away with much less, as their competition is really doing nothing noteworthy from what I've seen (and tasted).
Made a reservation here for a friday night for when we arrived up north. This was a very smart move as when we showed up there were about 15 people all waiting for tables and the wait was about 45 minutes. We got our table about 10 minutes after our reservation time, and they were really apologetic, couldn't believe how nice they were- 10 minutes waiting is no big deal.
Just looking at the menu made me hungry- everything looked awesome, and I rarely look at a menu and feel I could order anything happily. The waitress also told us of about 6 additional specials that all sounded amazing as well. You can't go wrong! We ended up ordering a fig appetizer special with gorgonzola and pecans. It was yummy, but the honey glaze the figs were cooked in was a bit sweet- I could eat it for dessert. For mains my hubby had a pork special wrapped in bacon with spinach. He loved it, and let me tell you that piece of pork was huge- took up the whole plate! I had a vegetarian lasagna, which was not like traditional lasagna with pasta sheets, but had grilled polenta layers with veggies, pesto, and some goat cheese. It was much lighter than traditional lasagna and WAY tastier. Now, usually, we're not big dessert people- especially after having the super sweet fig appetizer. However, their dessert menu looked so amazing, we had to order some dessert. Hubby had the goat cheese cake, which might have been the best cheesecake I"ve ever had, but I"m a huge goat cheese fan. I had the lemon tirimisu, which was the only mediocre thing either of us ate the entire meal. It was like a bad lemon sponge cake- really, I could only eat two bites and it just wasn't worth it to continue.
Despite the bad lemon dessert, I really loved the place, it had a cute cozy atmosphere, the staff were all really friendly, and the food was delicious, I 'd go back- in fact, I could happily eat here every day of a weekend away up North. Book ahead though. read more