Cathy's was a great time. I have been coming up to Cathy's for like ten years. Cathy's is a small…read morebuilding it is bright yellow and super cute. It has great hours so if you want a late night sweet you can get it. It closes at 10pm. It has plenty of different flavors. My favorite flavor is pirates bounty. It is caramel ice cream with chocolate, m and m's, and brownies pieces. It is mouth watering delicious. There is other flavors including After dinner mint, chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, raspberry truffle, sea salt, superman, blue moon, caramel nut, toasted almond fudge, mint bon bon, banana cream, cotton candy, sorbet, and other ones. You can order them in cones, cups, milk shakes, malts, and Sundaes. The place has a cute candy shop with a very wide variety of sweets. It has salitte wafers, gummy bears, chocolates, and a lot of other kinds of candy. They also sell these soft animal stuffed animals, perfect if you have little kids. Cathy's sells cool t-shirts. They have a couple seats inside, but outside they have a bunch of tables, benches, and picnic tables. It has great views just from your seat. The service is outstanding. It is usually a bunch of teenagers working. They are super kind and very friendly. They are personable and they get to know you. It makes me welcomed. Also it suitable for anyone to come here. If you are in a wheelchair they have a ramp to enter. If you can't eat gluten there is gluten free options for you to choose from. Overall I had a great experience at Cathy's. In my opinion it is the best ice cream shop in the northwoods.

I've been coming to Cathy's since I was a kid and it never disappoints. My brothers and I love the…read moreBlue Moon ice cream! There is indoor and outdoor seating, although the indoor seating is limited. They do have a small dock you can pull up to if you're coming from the lake, but it probably can't accommodate larger boats or multiple boats at once. The candy selection has decreased over the years but they do have a fun options of candy, chocolate and ice cream! It can get pretty busy in the evenings and on warm days, but the line moves quickly and the staff is always welcoming and efficient.

Loved this little shop! Lots of flavors to choose from. Staff were super nice also which definitely…read morehelps! Kids got hot fudge Sundays, hubby got the butchers block cookie, and I got the Carmel apple pie. We all loved our own. Mine was definitely a good mix of all the stuff inside. Definitely would come back next time we visit!

OMG fantastic, fabulous, are you kidding me good!!! Seriously, best ice cream I've tasted and that…read moreis saying something. So many flavors to choose from where do you start?? Let's cut to the chase - go with This Just Got Serious - seriously- and just keep going. Prices are reasonable and service is great! Enjoy!!

Hands down, this is the best place Up North to have a meal…read more This place outcooks, outserves and outvalues any bar or supper club in the north Wisconsin region. The only regret I have about this place is telling you how good it is, because that most likely means I'll be standing in line waiting to get in. Don't take my word for it, go try it out yourself. You won't be sorry.

What a great place! Their menu goes from cheese curds to burgers and pizza to braised beef shank…read moreand scallops. We went for the high end and couldn't have been more happy. It's just a roadside bar/ restaurant. We were there in the winter so a lot of snowmobiles had stopped to eat. The pan seared scallops seemed out of place but looked so good. I'm glad I went with it. I love celery root puree and the greens and bacon just brought it to a new level! My husband enjoyed the huge braised beef shank. I would highly recommend. Service was great as well and the prices were right.

The best experience in dining thanks to Jarrett! He was very informative, pleasant, and attentive!…read moreLoved our meals! We came in for 1st time on 10/11/2026 Sunday. My hubby had all u can eat broasted chicken with mashed and stuffing with gravy and coleslaw and homemade biscuit he absolutely cleaned his plate! I had a grilled chicken wrap with a special slaw, cheese bacon and a ranch side with kettle chips. Best wrap I ever had! Huge! We never waited for anything and Jarett checked on us frequently he is a fantastic waiter! We love him! We will definitely return! Just make sure you come at 4pm that's when they open ! Great experience!

Friday night fish fry. Rob cleared off a table to get us seated right away. We all ordered…read moredifferent fish dinners. All very tasty and we loved the potato pancakes. Great service and great food.

Who doesn't love ice cream!?!?!? This place was fantastic! I just wish I had more room to try the…read morecookie dough as well as the ice cream! I tried two delicious flavors in a cone and I was NOT disappointed!!! The flavor selection was outstanding, and every person in our group (there were 9 of us) found a flavor and serving method they loved! There are other ice cream establishments in town, but I just can't say they're better than Peanuts!

This shop is always a must when we are in Eagle River visiting. They offer popsicles, cookie dough,…read moreand tons of ice cream flavors (and they have dairy-free as well). This sh*t just got serious is one of the best flavors - if you love Carmel, fudge and sea salt. Friendly service each time and well worth the wait - they move quick!

Visited while up north on vacation…read more Fast service and huge scoops. Many flavors to choose from. I sampled a few flavors. The coconut joy was excellent. Ample room inside and out to talk. Short path to walk down for a lake view . Prices fair and pleasant service. We would definitely go back again.

Best ice cream i have ever had! Even though it's just Cedar Crest ice cream flavors, it seems to…read moretaste better in the north woods (: They are open until about 10 or so. It's very VERY popular! Love it!

Very nice ice cream shop with extremely friendly staffs. They gave the kids free stickers. Also,…read morethey made sure - triple checked- that a malt I order would cost more and came with a giant size. Also - we got an ice cream from another ice cream shop while walking around town and when we visited Kilwins, they saw we were holding other shop's ice cream and the staff said, if we toss the half ate ice cream, we will be rewarded with a double sized of our ice cream very healthy competition indeed and we of course got more ice

A favorite spot when we're in minocqua! Ice cream is delicious, staff is friendly - greeting us…read morewarmly, offering samples, making you feel very at home. We love having them in town!!!

Great little ice cream shop. They had Zanzibar Chocolate, so I was in heaven. Will definitely go…read moreagain.

The stars are for the employees. Very nice and quick service. Cleanliness very good…read more Pop10 ounce glass. Full of ice. Asked for small amount of ice. $2.0

This old-school drive-in sandwich and ice cream shop is divine. The food is always fresh and good,…read moreand the ice cream choices can keep you happy over many, many visits. However, the staff is exceptional. Always cheerful and welcoming, efficient and courteous. Sit outside at their tables, or in your car. Or play a round of mini-golf!

If you have not gone to the Ice Shanty and purchased a puppy chow flurry of the week. Go now…read moreimmediately! That is the greatest dessert of all time! The Ice shanty is a beacon of cheer and fun (albeit with a touch of mosquito flair), but this puppy chow situation has pushed them to the next level. The Northwoods is the greatest food Mecca in the world. Run, run, and get one before they sell out or I will secretly eat their whole stash!

ice cream was a tasty treat on a hot day! the 2 workers at the ice cream shop were friendly and…read morehelpful. The guy in the store was also pleasant, helpful, and friendly. there were only two containers of leaches so he quickly refilled fridge with fishing bait.thanks for being here!

Don't advertise dairy-free ice cream (not sorbet) and then give a bunch of excuses why you can't…read morescoop it. It's too hard or you can come back later. Dumb!