Cancel

Open app

Search

Nancy's On Main

4.7 (45 reviews)
Closed • Closed
Updated 3 months ago

Nancy's On Main Photos

Business Info

NANCY'S ON MAIN ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Good for kids
Good for groups

You might also consider

More like Nancy's On Main

Recommended Reviews - Nancy's On Main

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Gelato, vanilla bean (L) and strawberry cheesecake (R)
Judy W.

The decor was nice and the lighting was calming. Waiter was helpful & knowledgeable. I had grandkids with me and needed gelato that was free of red dye. They had vanilla bean that we felt was safe. They loved it! I ordered a chicken ranch with bacon wrap. It took awhile to get it, but was worth the wait. I'd like to try the pizza sometime. Parking was right in front of the entrance. I heard someone ask as we were leaving if they had pizza by the slice. They do not. They have scones on Friday mornings! Yummy!

Garlic Cheesy Bites
Hailey P.

One of the place's in Oklahoma I'll miss most! The Factory Pizza in Perkins will go down as my favorite hidden gem in Payne County. The owners are so friendly and welcoming. The food is delicious and had never skipped a beat. As always, we started off dinner with the garlic cheesy bites and the stuffed mushrooms. I didn't like mushrooms until coming here and now they're a staple in my life lol. The garlic cheesy bites are to die for and just thinking about them makes me crave them. For our main meals, we got the fettuccine Alfredo, the Herban Chicken Pizza , the pepperoni Pizza, and the build your own with hamburger, Canadian Bacon, and black olives. Everything was perfect as always. This will be my first stop when I get to come back to Payne County!

Patricia M.

Can I say again This place is AMAZING! I fell in love with the Flatbread, oil, and fig vinegar! So much so, I purchased a bottle of the fig vinegar for home! The food was fun, tasted amazing, and filling. The service was excellent, fun, and energetic! I cant wait to go back! I really pray they survive the small business changes COVID19 brings!

Garlic cheese bread

This was some of the best pizza I've ever eaten! The garlic bread was TO DIE FOR. seriously. And the prices were decent too. Only taking off a star because our food took over an hour and we had small children getting hungry and fussy. Even our appetizers took 45 minutes. That was on a Saturday at 6pm. They also have some amazing balsamic vinegars and olive oils and a small ice cream parlor with amazing desserts!

The old Eaton's Hardware store is now a Factory Pizza
Doug P.

I am going to write this knowing it's a very small town pizza joint. It was okay, I have had much worse. We ordered two pizzas, mozzarella sticks, stuffed mushrooms and flatbread all for $55.00 including tax and tip. The staff were very friendly and helpful as i had not been back in that area in a long time. The flatbread was amazing, especially when you dip it in the balsamic and oils. The mushrooms were not great at all and very small. The mozzarella sticks were...I dont know what they were. The pizza was okay but without a lot of flavor. My parents like it so we will be back but expectations are now set.

Amazingly, it tasted even better than it looked!

See all

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jo B.
0
41
3

8 years ago

Wow, the speciality balsamic's and olive oil are AMAZING, Pizza was Awesome, and OMG the salad unbelievable. Definitely 5 stars.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of M B.
0
10
1

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Nancy's On Main

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 258 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Cafe 33

Cafe 33

3.5(2 reviews)
3.2 mi

what an enjoyable visit! while we were out for a ride with a…read morefriend, he suggested Cafe 33 for lunch and we are so glad he did. First, there is plenty of good parking for cars and bikes alike, with lots of room to maneuver. Second, we were greeted by a friendly host and seated immediately. Our server was just as friendly and VERY efficient. The moment our drinks were nearing empty, she made sure to refresh them and she made sure everything extra that we asked for was brought out and on the table when our order arrived; she did not have to be reminded even once. our food was brought out quickly with no "heat lamp" taste and it was delicious! We all shared fried alligator bites to start and they were light, flaky, and came with a nice, slightly spicy dipping sauce. I had a regular cheeseburger with everything (including nice purple onion and extra pickles) and a side of fries that were crispy on the outside and tender on the inside like JoJo fries; the cheeseburger was the wonderful kind, cooked medium but still juicy with toppings on the side so I could put as little or as much on as I wanted. Hubby had a patty melt that had lightly buttered, perfectly crisp bread with rich, sautéed onions and a tender beef patty. He was so busy enjoying the patty melt that he was almost full before he dived into the in-house made crisps (chips) that were great (I tried one) and made even better with a bit of the alligator dipping sauce on it. Our friend had the cheesesteak sandwich that came on a soft but firm bun and was overflowing with filling that he thoroughly enjoyed along with a side of the crisps. This was a nice stop to enjoy good food and good friends! I highly recommend it as a day-ride destination or for anytime you want to have a relaxed, enjoyable date-night or family meal.

Was told to wait for seating when we got there as the only available table was "reserved". After…read morewaiting 15 minutes we were seated at that same "reserved" table because the waitress had made a mistake and it really wasn't reserved. Our favorite steak at this restaurant was the tenderloin...which now they don't offer. They charge that 18$ for the house cut now....which we ordered and it was just not as good and tender as the tenderloin. We were told by the waitress that their comparable steak was the filet... but it was $34 ...And it was the daily special for the night... so it won't be available all the time. I can go to Longhorn Steakhouse and get the Flo filet for $21.79 and save 12$ a steak. I am disappointed in the quality/selection/pricing of their steaks now. It's a shame as they had the best steak around.

Pickleman's - Stillwater

Pickleman's - Stillwater

3.8(39 reviews)
10.2 mi

this spot is going to be a place that no matter how many times i end up in stillwater, i'm going to…read morecheck out pickleman's. my partner & i were on the move while finishing up a graduation, we wanted something quick. we came here right on time because right after our order, it started getting busy! i went with the #12 aka the smokehouse stack, the 1 of 3 pulled pork sandwiches that are on the menu. i usually go the bbq route, i switched it up as this sandwich has (housemade) chipotle ranch, pulled pork, smoke bacon, provolone cheese & lettuce. you can make the sandwich the way it is on the menu or you can jazz it up & with that being said, i added pickles & cucumbers (no onions). i got a small, which was a pretty good size, & made it a combo. the sandwich simply got the job done. i got a good amount of everything that came with the sandwich (& of course what i added). the chips on deck were kettle chips (my favorite kind of chips) & i went with the hickory bbq (there were around 4-5 different flavors to choose from). to drink, they have a strawberry lemonade that tastes like candy, not in a bad way. i'd get it over & over again. all of the employees were super nice & friendly. they had me wanting a pizza (another thing they offer) while waiting on our orders & that's something i'd want to try next visit. you can add your phone number at the register to get rewards points. on top of that, as first visit, i had a $5 discount that went towards my order from adding my number. good experience all around.

Quick bite with great prices. The place is pretty clean for a college town sandwich shop. The…read morekids that run it were friendly. Definitely will be back sandwiches were great.

Photos
Pickleman's - Stillwater
Pickleman's - Stillwater
Pickleman's - Stillwater

See all

Nancy's On Main - pizza - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...