1. Mystic Pizza

0

Villa Grove, CO

Cancel

Open app

Search

Mystic Pizza

3.7 (3 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

Mystic Pizza Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Mystic Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Amy B.
238
47
30

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of L L.
0
7
0

5 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Mystic Pizza

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Pizza Rio - Hand Made NY Style Pizza

Pizza Rio

4.3(124 reviews)
20.1 mi
Locally owned & operated
Full bar

The things we look for in an establishment, quiet place that we can hear each other, the…read moreenvironment to be calming, and taking my allergies serious without getting irritated or giving false information. If I can walk away without my anxiety being triggered or my allergies triggered, we have found a gem to return to. Driving from Colorado Springs through Salida, Co to the Sand Dunes, we decided to stop for a later lunch. We stopped by The Boathouse and was rather loud along with no four top outside. The host referred us to Pizza Rio and said they had outdoor seating and it's usually quieter. Heading up the stairs, customers coming down said it's worth it. The host showed us the tables outside and indeed was very quiet and had a beautiful view of the river. When we sat down, the heaters were still on but the server turned them off for us and opened the shade screen. My husband got the Greek salad with a slice of pepperoni pizza. My son got the vodka penne pasta, my mom got the meatball grinder and I got the Greek salad with arugula and spinach and the spaghetti and meatballs. Everything on the menu said it was made in house including the dressings. And WOW!!!! The flavor these dishes had was top notch Italian and dishes were decent/big sized. Cost wasn't as high as we thought, and the server was extremely accommodating. I would recommend this place to anyone passing through. Great job to the cooks, amazing!!! Great service by Connor L, we appreciate all you did with my accommodations and that you were attentive even though you were the only server. We did not feel forgotten about

We are in town from Sunday to Thursday. I have been wanting to come back to Salida just for the…read morepizza. I checked Google hours yesterday and saw that they were only closed Mondays. However, today (Tuesday), I double checked again before leaving and I saw that their fall hours completely changed (only opening Thursday to Sunday). I wish they had updated their website, Google and Yelp with their upcoming fall opening days/hours as a heads up.

Photos
Pizza Rio - Pizza paired with a Salida Brewing Company Red Ale

Pizza paired with a Salida Brewing Company Red Ale

Pizza Rio - Fresh Homemade Bruschetta.

Fresh Homemade Bruschetta.

Pizza Rio - Chicken and Pasta

See all

Chicken and Pasta

Simple Eatery - Great space! Love the brick!

Simple Eatery

4.5(659 reviews)
42.2 mi
•$$
Locally owned & operated
Happy hour specials

My sister and I came here after a camping trip to Taylor reservoir. Its on main street in Buena…read moreVista and its definitely worth a stop! The bread here alone is super impressive, we ate a whole pretzel loaf as an appetizer and i don't regret it. The Mojo Pork Benedict was absolutely delicious! The pork was so tender and flavorful and the eggs were cooked perfectly. My sister's cinammon roll French toast was the best dessert breakfast! Overall this place is really impressive and is churning out delicious food in such a tiny space!

Simple Eatery, but holy moly talk about complex flavors…read more Stopped in for lunch, I got a Salted Pretzel with Beer Cheese, the Pesto Panini Breakfast Sandwich, and the Green Chile Cheddar Sourdough loaf from yesterday. I didn't even get to take a photo of the pretzel because I completely annihilated it. It was phenomenal. I came to my senses enough go photograph the sandwich, it was also amazingly good. I passed the loaf around to everyone at my table and we all really liked it. I also got a cute little mason jar for my drink which is so cool. The eatery is inside a little shop so the vibe is very granola in the best way. It smells incredible inside. The staff is also so incredibly nice and gave me several recommendations and made it all seem like incredible options. The price point is high, but i'm learning that's just Colorado in general. I had no issue spending my money here.

Photos
Simple Eatery - Local craft brews on tap

Local craft brews on tap

Simple Eatery - 3rd lb Angus Burger on homemade pretzel bun!

3rd lb Angus Burger on homemade pretzel bun!

Simple Eatery - Wild boar sausage, broccoli & cheddar!

See all

Wild boar sausage, broccoli & cheddar!

Crave - Pig & Fig

Crave

4.3(198 reviews)
42.2 mi
•$$

Needed refreshment and food after a day of rafting the Royal Gorge, recommend by the rafting guide…read moreand the great aroma from 2 day's prior we chose here. After a few cocktails, me Mountain Martini's my friend classic Margs we chose dinner. He had the Chicken Alfredo and wiped it out, he kept commenting how good it was and how much Chicken he was given. I had the Pig and Fig, unfortunately I was disappointed, not enough sauce or fig to my liking. The location has standing room only, we experienced on a Friday and Sunday night (We only fined in on Sunday). Modern interior, great bar, it all glows well and seems very open even when packed. Definitely with coming here to experience the great food and friendly atmosphere

We've been here at least 5+ times now and it's become one of our go-to spots anytime we're in Buena…read moreVista. We somehow always order the exact same thing too, gin and tonics, margarita pizzas, and Bee Stings. We can hear after our engagement pics this time around :) We had a small issue during our visit today, but the staff and managers were super attentive and quick to fix it. They were genuinely apologetic and made sure we were taken care of, which honestly means a lot. Definitely not something that would affect us coming back. If anything, it made us appreciate this place even more. We'll absolutely be back the next time we're in town!!

Photos
Crave - Inside view of dining area

Inside view of dining area

Crave - Pep Rally, Pig & Fig, Bee Sting

Pep Rally, Pig & Fig, Bee Sting

Crave - Inside

See all

Inside

Mystic Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...